50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster

“I have eaten here many of times. The food is always so good. I got two pizza's last night and it was really hard to eat because it had a burnt taste to it. I had gotten two pizza's and they both tasted the same. A little disappointing being I have always had great pizza from here. The burnt taste for me was so bad. Felt like I wasted $40 on pizza. I still give 4 stars because of past experiences.“

“I just love this place for any italian food. Been going there a long time. I live close by. The food is always good and the staff is always so nice. Thanks Frank and the staff.“

“the food portion the waitress was nice and friendly“

“Food was absolutely delicious. Staff extremely friendly. Thanks for everything. I’ll be back with the family“

“LOVE Picasso's! Feel lucky to have found this place. EVERTHING IS GREAT!!!! Pricey but well worth it! Thanks to ALL of you that delivery with a smile!“

“Got the Detroit style pizza delivered and it was fantastic. Door dash driver actually took my food order and never delivered it. Luckily the restaurant has amazing customer service, called me to ask if i ever received my food, made me a fresh pizza and sent it out immediately. 5 star food- 5 star service from Matt.“

“wife (barb) said Im not allowed to go here any more becaus Iam always having TOO much fun??. We used to take dog here when it waas HOT but bargo went to the horse farm with carol 100 days ago. Now we have Biscuit and thankful she HATES horses (all types). I will be back dont tell wife. -ruggles“

“This is the best hoagie restaurant in the world! I fly in from CA just to eat hoagies from this Caruso's. The staff is wonderful, the food is delicious, and it's worth becoming a regular customer. Thank you to the owner and Caruso's in Silver Springs for setting the bar high!“

“Pizza and pasta dinners are the best around!!!!!! Owners are awesome too!!!!“

“Dinner and a show. Everything on the menu is absolutely amazing. “The Show” happens when you sit at Chef’s table and watch them team create one masterpiece after another. I watched them train a new employee to do the same! Pinch and pull the dough- enough sauce, but not too much. Carefully and skillfully place all ingredients! final inspection before the fire and then another after. Watch for this and that before you serve. Pizza will. ever to the same for me.“

“1st timer last night, it was wonderful! The servers were great, super nice and helpful. The wings were great! The wife and I split the tacos and cheesesteak egg rolls and they were spectacular.

Simple menu.
Great food.
Great service.

We will be returning very soon!“

“Love this family owned restaurant!!“

“After finding out Pie in the Sky offered thick square Sicilian pizza I figured I'd pick one up for NFL Sunday. Unfortunately the person answering the phone misheard me and I had a traditional round pie waiting when I got there. I politely explained this to the manager, he threw a square Sicilian in the oven right away. No biggie I thought, I've worked in busy pizza joints in the past, these things happen. Much to my surprise he threw in the traditional round pie for free, even after I offered to pay for it. A+ service, this place went above and beyond fixing an honest mistake.

So how was the pizza? I now had a sampler of round traditional cheese, square Sicilian cheese and an order of garlic knots to dig into. It's excellent, the sauce has a nice flavor and the mozzarella tastes freshly grated and there's a healthy amount of seasoning on top as well. The crust of the Sicilian is perfect, substantial but not too thick as to be overly filling. The round pie had a nice greasy flavor, almost boardwalk style. The garlic knots have a flawless fluffy texture and just the right amount of garlic.

So if you're in the eastern Lancaster or Lampeter area definitely give Pie in the Sky a call, especially if you want a Sicilian style pizza, far as I know they're the only place in the area with it. Great service and awesome pizza!“

“I lived in NYC for a few years and It’s hard to find pizza that matches a good NYC slice. Well, I stumbled upon Slugger’s Pizza in Lancaster on Friday and it was amazing! The pizza was great and the service was fast and friendly. If you are looking for a great slice of pizza - check them out!!“

“I highly recommend this place this is the 3rd time eating their food and the 20” Danny big boy pizza is so big and so good. The price is perfect will continue to order my pizza from there going forward.“

“Outstanding food, large portions. Always 5 stars!“

“We looooove Sugar Bowl. Great food, great service. My favorite thing to order is the cheeseburger sub.“

“the best pizza in Lancaster, I recommend Italian cheesesteak pizza and fajita pizza. also lamb over rice and chicken over rice amazing ...“

“I just enjoyed the BEST white pizza 🍕 that I have had in a very long time!!! I will definitely be back for more 😊“

“I used to love going to MOD pizza for something quick & cheap to eat when I was craving pizza. I've been eating healthier now and it's harder to eat out, less healthy places to choose from. However I just learned that MOD can make healthy versions of pizza with cauliflower crust. I ordered mine crispy & it came out delicious! Their pizzas are made exactly how I want, they have good portion sizes and are very affordable.“

“Had friends in from Va. and they asked for pizza. The service was terrific. The crust is amazing. We had the spinach, arugula, onion white pizza. It was delicious that evening and the leftover slice just as good, cold, the next day! Thanks Rendezvous. You did not disappoint.“

“Luca staff went out of their way to provide my 15 year old son, who is an aspiring chef, with an unforgettable experience. The amazing food and kindness was second to none. Thank you!!“

“Wonderful experience friendly staff“

“Colombia ave. lancaster best pizza ever“

“Great customer service, clean and good mix of pizza options! Thanks for a good family meal.“

“Awesome food great prices. Staff and service is great!“

“The food was Fantastic!! Husband & I came in for our 26th wedding anniversary dinner!! Great service as well❤️“

“Excellent food!! Haven’t had a meal this good in a long time!!“

“best pizza Lancaster PA!!! always friendly and helpful staff too!!!“

“Best Chicken Vodka Boli around!“

“They changed their Happy Hour prices and choices on February 13 Been going to happy hour since they started again a year ago but when ordering they forgot to mention their items changed My happy hour bill went from $25 to $39 overnight. No warning“

“one of the best pizza shops that I've been to. we love going there. the staff is always very friendly and welcoming. we love everything we've tried from this location, but our go to is the chicken and bacon pizza or cheese steaks. great atmosphere and vibe as well.“

“The cheeseburger pizza was really good. Exactly what you would expect. Really enjoyed. The wings… well not so much. Staff was courteous & friendly. Overall would go back“

“I love that Sbarro is back near me, remind me of many a trip to the mall. I just came here to say the Valley Center KS location rules 💜“

“I highly recommend this place as a potential event space. I booked the upstairs room for my wedding’s after-party. I was offered a few different booking options and all were extremely reasonable compared to some other event places in Lancaster city. Even though it’s not along the main row of bars on King Street, it’s a quick walk from the Mariott. Kayley, the manager, was incredibly accommodating and easy to work with. She was very responsive and answered all my questions. I also worked with Tony who knocked it out of the park. He provided a cooler full of beers and pizza for my guests for a very reasonable cost. It was really nice to have a bar in the upstairs area close to the back event room. So many of the guests talked about the after-party and how much they enjoyed the dance floor. I highly recommend reaching out to QSB for a future event.“

“We ordered wings, chicken parmesan sub and mozzarella sticks. All of them tasted great. Their food has a unique taste to it that i've not experienced before. But I love it. It's different as far as the flavors. They're barbecue sauce, is so subtle, sweet and not the typical type you get somewhere and I really like it a lot. There mozzarella stickshave a unique flavor to them. The marinara , is very good , too. Also is unique too, not like others I've experienced before has a little bit of sweetness to it.Perfect. the chicken parmesan a sub was very good. The sauce was perfect not too sour. The breaded chicken was crispy. They did a great job. That was my first experience ordering from them. They also had my order done in a timely manner. And they were very nice and polite to me.“

“This specific location is the best! I usually do delivery because they are 2 minutes from my house and their service is amazing. I frequently order their honey bbq wings and boyyyyyy they hit! ???? Big thank you for the friendly service and smiles team.“

“Love the Sandwich factory me and my girls go here just about every weekend for karaoke and Saturday dj’s I’m not one for all the drama that the young ones bring that’s why I don’t go downtown in Lanc this place is perfect food dancing and singing definitely one of my favs ❤️😌“

“great food and nice size servings for the money Friendly delivery people“

“The guys that was running the place is a good man. He went out of his way to open the door for a disabled man. My mom can’t eat gluten and usually I hate gluten free stuff but their gluten free pizza was really good. Pretty clean place. Nice people. Great fries and soup.“

“I get takeout from Highland from time when I am down that way for my regular chiropractic appointments (my chiropractor is right next door over at Universal Athletic Club). My absolute favorite is the Highland Special Pizza, which is basically like a supreme pizza. I can say hands-down that is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my 46 years on this earth. I have also gotten their Highland Cheesesteak (contains beef steak, sautéed onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and pepperonis, topped with a homemade marinara sauce, and American cheese), chicken quesadillas and their cheesesteak eggrolls. They are all super good and what made me decide to try them out was that I would be in the parking lot over at the gym going to my chiropractor and I would smell the food from Highland and drove me crazy lol. Glad I finally decided to give them a try. I recommend them to everybody I know.“

“Was our first time here and the pizza was amazing. Will definitely come again next time in Lancaster.“

“Wonderful food, fast service and our server was great too. We dined outside and it started to rain a little and she offered us to come inside. We declined and she quickly got us boxes and our checks. The girl at the gelato- not pleasant at all. I sampled two, decided on 1 and then she says to me “the blue mat is down by the bar”. ?? I replied, what am I supposed to do with that. Apparently that is where you now pay for gelato which is not where I paid when I was there 3 months ago. She was rude to previous customer too.“

“I’ve been in the city for 5+ yrs, 21 yrs in PA, and this is the closest to a NY slice I’ve found, trick is to get the 18” that way you get that thin crust and flop, the sauce has flavor instead of hand fulls of sugar and the cheese ain’t cheap, in quality nor quantity!“

“I’ve been going to this place for years and it is safe to say I love it. The pizza is great especially for people who like thin pizza. The workers are efficient and fast. And the atmosphere is very cool and interesting. Would totally recommend.“

“I believe his name started with a M and he was the one answering the phone. Went over and beyond on customer service. Would 100% come back to this location.“

“great food great people that work there they're all friendly and helpful“

“Been eating their pizza for well over 20 years and moved out of state and couldn’t find a place that ever topped it. Came up here for a family vacation and picked up a couple pies and it’s still as delicious as I remember it!“

“I rarely write reviews but I thought it was necessary this time. I have ordered from this Papa John's location twice and both times the pizza was great. I have had Papa John's from many locations and it is not always good.Also, when I visited in person tonight the girl who waited on me was super friendly and even walked me to my car and opened the door for me. 5 stars“