50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster

“Dinner and a show. Everything on the menu is absolutely amazing. “The Show” happens when you sit at Chef’s table and watch them team create one masterpiece after another. I watched them train a new employee to do the same! Pinch and pull the dough- enough sauce, but not too much. Carefully and skillfully place all ingredients! final inspection before the fire and then another after. Watch for this and that before you serve. Pizza will. ever to the same for me.“

“I have eaten here many of times. The food is always so good. I got two pizza's last night and it was really hard to eat because it had a burnt taste to it. I had gotten two pizza's and they both tasted the same. A little disappointing being I have always had great pizza from here. The burnt taste for me was so bad. Felt like I wasted $40 on pizza. I still give 4 stars because of past experiences.“

“the food portion the waitress was nice and friendly“

“I highly recommend this place as a potential event space. I booked the upstairs room for my wedding’s after-party. I was offered a few different booking options and all were extremely reasonable compared to some other event places in Lancaster city. Even though it’s not along the main row of bars on King Street, it’s a quick walk from the Mariott. Kayley, the manager, was incredibly accommodating and easy to work with. She was very responsive and answered all my questions. I also worked with Tony who knocked it out of the park. He provided a cooler full of beers and pizza for my guests for a very reasonable cost. It was really nice to have a bar in the upstairs area close to the back event room. So many of the guests talked about the after-party and how much they enjoyed the dance floor. I highly recommend reaching out to QSB for a future event.“

“I just love this place for any italian food. Been going there a long time. I live close by. The food is always good and the staff is always so nice. Thanks Frank and the staff.“

“After moving from NJ three years ago, I was thrilled to find Thoze Guys, a gem that serves amazing homemade Italian pizza and pasta. Their salads are impressive as well. What's more, they've recently opened a fantastic sit-down restaurant called Val'NTino's next door. The staff is friendly, the food is excellent, and the atmosphere feels like home. I highly recommend it and will definitely be back 👌“

“I love the Detroit style pizza! Being a Sicilian guy from Brooklyn, I was skeptical if I'd like it. But, the service was great and the pie was awesome!!! Big fan. I'm just glad they aren't too close to my house, or I'd gain some serious weight!!!!!! Great job guys!!!!!“

“It was our first visit tonight. It was fabulous. Food was fresh and plentiful. Got the Italian Foccoccia sub, and was blown away, so delicious. Lancaster peeps this is a go to and enjoy.“

“This place is the best. The food is delicious, the prices are good and the staff is awesome. The manager is extremely nice and very accommodating. I highly recommend them. Definitely a 5 star rating.“

“Nice draft beer selection with an even larger canned and bottled beer inventory but the food is what brings us back! Thin cracker like crust on the pizza is super good and with plenty of topping choices Always have the pizza because it’s so good but all the food coming out looks so appetizing!
Order at a counter and the servers bring the food to your table. Inside and outside seating options.“

“Pizza and pasta dinners are the best around!!!!!! Owners are awesome too!!!!“

“Wonderful experience friendly staff“

“I highly recommend this place this is the 3rd time eating their food and the 20” Danny big boy pizza is so big and so good. The price is perfect will continue to order my pizza from there going forward.“

“Just went there for the first time today with my oldest. We will definitely be back again!!!“

“Shout out David for the ADA accomodation & hospitality - drove 1.5 hours to & fro for a free gig w/ bands we dig Sat. evening - $9 for a smash burger w/ fries was both good and filling, amazing deal. Sound was great for what's in fact a restaurant, and in general the vibe was very nice. Worth the drive, would return in a heartbeat, highly recommended.“

“Very great place! The strombolis look massive and the prices look amazing! I have never ate here, I've just been looking for a good place for pizza and strombolis and the reviews I have read are unbelievable! So tonight I will be ordering for the first time. Thinking a stromboli or Sicilian pizza. Keep your eye out for my review about how the food actually is.“

“I have no idea how long I've been enjoying Venice Pizza & Pasta; I drove for AAA for 16 years and we still visit for take-out now and then.

Wanted something different and tried the Sicilian Meatlover's and I am at a loss for words.

Not having had good Sicilian pizza in about 35 years, this was absolutely perfect! Well-done, as requested, crisp and everything tasted so very good!

I'm not shy about saying I have never had anything bad from Venice. You guys are amazing 👏

Thank you!!!“

“Colombia ave. lancaster best pizza ever“

“I lived in NYC for a few years and It’s hard to find pizza that matches a good NYC slice. Well, I stumbled upon Slugger’s Pizza in Lancaster on Friday and it was amazing! The pizza was great and the service was fast and friendly. If you are looking for a great slice of pizza - check them out!!“

“I just enjoyed the BEST white pizza 🍕 that I have had in a very long time!!! I will definitely be back for more 😊“

“We looooove Sugar Bowl. Great food, great service. My favorite thing to order is the cheeseburger sub.“

“Finally ordered takeout from this spot and it was killer! The guy who helped me was great, and gave me a little extra aioli.
Can’t beat that wood-fired flavor. It’s the only pizza crust that’s actually worth eating imo. Having friends over tonight and ordering again bc I think this might be the best pizza in Lanc!“

“Delicious food, it’s so easy to wind up ordering more than you need because everything sounds (and tastes) so good! Service is outstanding, staff is so friendly and welcoming.“

“Best Chicken Vodka Boli around!“

“Great customer service, clean and good mix of pizza options! Thanks for a good family meal.“

“The create your own pizza and salads were very good. There is so many options; not only size and type of your individual pizza and salads that everyone can have exactly what they want. There were 5 of us for dinner and everyone got exactly their preferences. LOVE IT.“

“The food was Fantastic!! Husband & I came in for our 26th wedding anniversary dinner!! Great service as well❤️“

“They changed their Happy Hour prices and choices on February 13 Been going to happy hour since they started again a year ago but when ordering they forgot to mention their items changed My happy hour bill went from $25 to $39 overnight. No warning“

“Made a pit stop for fuel and was excited to see Sbarro with Turkey Hill.
I didn't want your typical gas station food.
So I made a decision to buy 4 pies for my family and I. The food was great and the service was excellent ?“

“Was our first time here and the pizza was amazing. Will definitely come again next time in Lancaster.“

“Awesome food great prices. Staff and service is great!“

“The bread, pizza, & granola are all brilliantly good, & Thom & his team are fantastic - highly recommended!“

“Excellent food!! Haven’t had a meal this good in a long time!!“

“great food and nice size servings for the money Friendly delivery people“

“We've ordered takeout a few times, and delivery a few times. We live close by, so I'd rather spend on delivery direct to business than use Doordash from farther away and have the food arrive cold. Delivery is fast and well done, food is fresh and hot - we don't order out much, but this place is a consistently good choice for good pizza. Better than Caruso's I think. TY! ⭐“

“I believe his name started with a M and he was the one answering the phone. Went over and beyond on customer service. Would 100% come back to this location.“

“Wonderful food, fast service and our server was great too. We dined outside and it started to rain a little and she offered us to come inside. We declined and she quickly got us boxes and our checks. The girl at the gelato- not pleasant at all. I sampled two, decided on 1 and then she says to me “the blue mat is down by the bar”. ?? I replied, what am I supposed to do with that. Apparently that is where you now pay for gelato which is not where I paid when I was there 3 months ago. She was rude to previous customer too.“

“Been eating their pizza for well over 20 years and moved out of state and couldn’t find a place that ever topped it. Came up here for a family vacation and picked up a couple pies and it’s still as delicious as I remember it!“

“Love the Sandwich factory me and my girls go here just about every weekend for karaoke and Saturday dj’s I’m not one for all the drama that the young ones bring that’s why I don’t go downtown in Lanc this place is perfect food dancing and singing definitely one of my favs ❤️😌“

“The only.thing.that it was deployable was a gentleman at the time made house of pizza his home. I could even enjoy my meal due to the fact had camped out there. I felt sorry for him bur needless on a Saturday with family there it could have been an eyesore for partons.“

“I rarely write reviews but I thought it was necessary this time. I have ordered from this Papa John's location twice and both times the pizza was great. I have had Papa John's from many locations and it is not always good.Also, when I visited in person tonight the girl who waited on me was super friendly and even walked me to my car and opened the door for me. 5 stars“

“This specific location is the best! I usually do delivery because they are 2 minutes from my house and their service is amazing. I frequently order their honey bbq wings and boyyyyyy they hit! ???? Big thank you for the friendly service and smiles team.“

“We found our way while riding our motorcycle, glad we did great food.“

“Serves subs stromboli, cold sandwiches, hot sandwiches and pizza. They make their own bread for the sandwiches and pizza dough. They also serve skinny French fries that restaurants used to serve back then and they are so good. Staff is really friendly.“

“great food great people that work there they're all friendly and helpful“

“Usually very good but totally screwed up my order last night and this morning the guy on the phone told me "maybe" they could give me 10% off my next pizza. Threw it out, total waste of money. �“

“Vegetarian options: Clear labeled vegetarian dishes and customizable options.

Kid-friendliness: popular with parents of young children

Wheelchair accessibility: not very accessible, need to go farther down the aisle for a ramp.“

“Our server, Rebecca, is excellent. She pays attention to our order and makes sure it is done as requested. The food is very tasty and the restaurant is very nice“