16 Best American Restaurants in Lititz

“Christina is the best!!!!“

“I came here for a trivia night event and had the Sea-duction with a side of green beans and a baked potato. The seafood was tender and well-seasoned. I especially enjoyed the broiled flounder. The baked potato was cooked just right and came with butter and sour cream. I absolutely loved the seasoning on the green beans and they were tender without being overcooked. The service was prompt and friendly, especially with the business of the evening. The dining area was open with an inviting ambiance. I would come back again and sample some more of their menu in the future!“

“The food, most of the time, is delicious. The only thing is that most of the time you have to call back to back before anyone answers the phone and when you arrive, the staff seems a little chaotic and overwhelmed - maybe they're understaffed? I've never had a negative interaction with anyone, there just seems to be a lot of confusion and overwhelm. All that aside, I really do love this place.“

“Had two sandwiches, the Reuben and a chicken salad on cranberry walnut bread. Delish. Other restaurants could take lessons from them on how to make a Reuben. Where they fell short was with the overpriced drinks, Autumn rum runner and a martini. The martini came with a 2" square ice cube and not much drink. They need to take lessons from Penn's Tavern Restaurant on how to make a rum runner. No one has beat theirs yet.“

“I really like everthing I have ever bought at Zigs, my problem is the service, you can be at counter waiting for service an the servers will just walk past you.“

“The service was quick and very pleasant. Your coffee was some of the best I’ve drank and your black bean brownie was better than a regular one!! My grandson enjoyed it and never knew the difference ❤️ An eclectic, homey, well priced coffee and eatery. Lots of options for vegan and gluten free. Will definitely be back!“

“We were warmly welcomed by Laura. Had sandwiches, scones and lattes. All good, fresh and flavorfull. Nice ambience and located in the heart of the Main St. shopping.“

“Great food and terrific beer selection in a classic English pub setting.“

“I only recently tried Mick's and I loved it. Love the pizza in particular. Typically, when I try a restaurant with only one or two items I will eat. As someone with severe food sensory issues, I love that there are so many items on the menu that I can eat! Pizza is my go-to but I am branching out and trying other dishes. I haven't tried anything I didn't like yet. Loving the Shepherds Pie today!!!“

“We are from Lancaster, my husband asked me to pick anywhere I wanted to have a nice lunch, so I googled and saw this little place . To our surprise, it was the best decision. We were immediately greeted with kindness and felt very welcome. The food was amazing, our drinks were so yummy. Thank you for making our random Saturday pick extremely special. Muchas Gracias!!!!!“

“I recommend Collusion as a friendly place to hang out, however I won't be returning because they took Onion Rings off the menu... Why???? You make some of the best onion rings around and in your infinite wisdom decide to take them off the menu?? This is a poor decision as far as I am concerned. it was one of the top selling points for me coming to Collusions, ordering some drinks & other food. BAD DECISION PS I live locally in town but will go elsewhere now“

“Incredible staff behind the bar and the food was amazing!!“

“Each year, for a time span of 57 years, three of us couples celebrate our wedding anniversary together by selecting a different fine dining restaurant for a celebratory dinner. We have selected restaurants within a 60 mile radius of Lititz.. Last evening we chose Blackworth Live Fire Grille which was among one of the best restaurant selections we've made during the 57 years of keeping this tradition. Thank You. Chef Max and your staff for the great experience!!!!“

“🌟🍕 Just had the most amazing experience at Uncommon Pizza! This place is a hidden gem that perfectly blends family fun with pet-friendly vibes. 🐾👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm atmosphere and a menu that boasts unique toppings and flavors that make each slice a delightful adventure. The staff was incredibly welcoming and even brought out a special treat for our furry friend! 🐶❤️ The outdoor seating area is perfect for families and pets alike, allowing us to enjoy our meal while our pup played happily nearby. And let me tell you, the pizza was out of this world! Fresh ingredients and creative combinations that had everyone at the table raving. 🍕✨ If you’re looking for a spot where you can enjoy delicious pizza while making memories with your family and pets, Uncommon Pizza is a must-visit! Can’t wait to go back! 🙌🏼💖 #UncommonPizza #FamilyFriendly #PetFriendly #PizzaLovers“

“We went for trivia night and had a blast. Got the beer flight to sample different beers, some apps and sandwiches. The food and beers were great and the guy that did the trivia was a lot of fun, too. I’ve always loved Isaac’s food but it’s even better now that they serve beer and wine.“

“I highly recommend the Lititz Springs Inn. The server was the best! Food was delicious! The atmosphere was wonderful. I will return soon.“