27 Best Sandwich Shops near Mcmurray

“The staff is excellent and very caring. They are the perfect business for that plaza, especially because it's near one of Allegheny Health Networks treatment centers. People that come and go from that plaza need love and a smile. Thank you for making our day when we come to eat. On top of the great service the food is always fresh and excellent. The store is always spotless.“

“I found a review from 7 years ago that I posted that was not great so I had to delete that review and give everyone an update. I've been going to this location regularly lately and it is terrific, the food is good and the service is great“

“First time placing an online order for pick up. Upon arrival, a young female employee ( ? Angel R. Per receipt, fair skin w short hair) was pleasant and engaging and stated that all sides were in the bag and grabbed some paper napkins to add! She walked from around counter to smile ,hand me my order, and wished me a good rest of my day !!! SO Noteworthy 👏
The food is always delicious here and I appreciate that they put my peppers and pickles on the side.
First time ordering the Philly Cheesesteak, I requested to have it heated, with cheese melted – they made it exactly the way I requested, including fried onions.
If you want your hoagie warm/hot, you only need to request that ;)
PERFECT Execution“

“I was trying to order hoagies for a Halloween party and I tried the website. It wouldn't take my credit card
It kept saying fraud.So I tried three different credit cards.Would not accept them.They were the only store that would answer.Their phoneI tried the one in bethel park on industrial.The girl was very lovely at the.Mcmurray valley book store.She was very helpful.. Unfortunately the amout of meat that SUBWAY puts on there hoagies, just not worth the money anymore...such a shame“

“Great people! They don't HAVE to take coupons, so I don't know why people are so upset about that. They are a family owned business, so everyone needs to relax. Sign up for their rewards, duh. I always get the best warm welcome and they remember my order.“

“We visited your establishment for the first time last night, I insisted on finding a more gourmet tasting Italian hoagie and oh man did I find it. Your food is amazing BUT I apologize as I did not catch his name, the employee up front basically running your establishment WOW!! What a fabulous individual you have as the face of your business. I just want you to know that he is an absolute asset, the world needs many more of these kind of people. (Professional, knowledgeable, happy, all around wonderful person) THANK YOU! We will be back!“

“I've been to a Primanti Bros near the stadium but new to this one. Food was excellent but our server neglected us quite a bit. Still tipped him well, thats a tough gig. Just wish once in a while he filled our drinks, checked on us. Great meal over all, love the brand and unique food options.“

“The people working at Jersey Mike's on Saturday evening, July 18 2020 went above and beyond for us. I placed an online order and on our way to get the order the vehicle we were driving in broke down. I called and explained the situation because I knew we wouldn't get there before close. The person I spoke with was so kind and assured me I could still get my order. Unfortunately, we weren't able to get there at all and when I called to explain and offer my order to the closing team, the person who answered was again so kind and offered to refund my order even though I had no intention of asking for that. It was just a nice gesture and the care they showed for our situation was amazing. I will make sure to order from them more often! Thanks guys!“

“From Michigan and had to experience the Sandwich..😊 Very good!!! Heading to a Steeler and Penguin games tomorrow and Tuesday.“

“The girl who made my sandwich tonight was such a positive person. She made conversation and interacted with me like an actual human being who takes pride in how she treats other human beings. So kind. Above and beyond service because she wasn't bothered to do her job. It's so rare these days that you get to interact with another person positively, especially someone who is so young and is at their job working. Thank you for being such a good person.“

“I order from here all the time because the sandwiches are delicious! Today, they forgot the mayo and pepper relish on both of our sandwiches so they were very dry and boring. I like to order online to customize my sandwich but what's the point if they skip the ingredients you want to add??“

“Awesome food and great servers/bar maidens! Plenty of slaw and fries.“

“Traveling this stretch of road in Eighty Four there isn't a lot of food choices so this Subway was a welcome sight. It's in a mini strip mall style building and looks small but is spacious inside. I ordered in the app when I pulled into the lot and my food was being made as I walked inside. Super fast service. Even better the bread and veggies were especially fresh today. Easy parking“

“Favorite subway everrrrr…never had any issues besides it’s not closer to home 🥹lol
The gentleman who runs this store? Amazing ! I come too often for those cookies and fresh bread . Never had to complain about the food or service like I deal with at other local subways“

“Wow is all I can say!! I stopped in to get a sub for my 80 year-old aunt I asked the young man if he would mind putting the vinegar and oil on the side because I had to transport the hoagie and if it got soggy, I’d never hear the end of it. He was so nice. He said absolutely. he rang me up. I get in my car in the parking lot and this young man comes out and says miss I forgot to give you your vinegar and oil. He went above and beyond the call of duty lol she absolutely loved her hoagie and she always has something negative to say lol but not today lol I would definitely recommend this place“

“Cant go wrong here we stopped in for lunch and got a meatball hoagie with a chicken bacon ranch hoagie and tried the new foot long cookie, churo and pretzel. The cookie and churo were probably tied for being pretty good and the pretzel was ok“

“Almost a hour to get food, others seated after us waited and served. Another table close by also complained of wait time. we were given the excuse that a large party came in ( not true) and large number of take outs (?). Not sure what type of meat tge burger was but was totally tasteless, took home and threw away. Most disappointing meal ever!! Jefferson Hills/Pleasant Hills“

“If Jimmy John’s has a million fans, I’m one of them. If Jimmy John’s has 100 fans, I’m still one of them. If Jimmy John’s has 1 fan, it’s me. If Jimmy John’s has no fans… then I’m dead.

The Vito is hands down the greatest thing on the menu. I’ll defend that sandwich in a court of law if necessary. And can we talk about the new Jimmy Buffalo Chips? Absolutely gorg. I bought a bag thinking I’d save some for later and somehow they vanished before I made it to the parking lot.

Jimmy John’s knows ball. The bread is elite, the sandwiches are elite, the chips are elite, and the Vito deserves its own holiday.

At this point, I would also like to formally submit my application to become the local Jimmy John’s spokesperson. Nobody is working harder for this brand than I am. If Jimmy John’s corporate is reading this, let’s stop pretending we’re strangers. I am clearly your number one fan and am available for ribbon cuttings, sandwich reviews, and Vito-related public appearances.

Five stars. No notes. Long live the Vito.“

“I travel all around Pittsburgh for my job. Every time I’m over on this side of town, I make sure to stop and get food from here. This is by far the cleanest subway I’ve been to, with the best service. No wait times, and early pick up if you order on the app. I highly recommend going here over any other one.“

“I had the freshest hoagie at this location this week and WOW, game changer. Thanks alot.“

“Very friendly the man taking orders was very friendly made us feel very welcome.“

“Visited this location for the first time at lunch today. There were probably 4 people in front of me and one behind me. Plus, one person came in to pick up 2 delivery orders. The ladies waiting on us crushed it. I was in and out in less than 10 minutes. The person directly in front of me ordered 3 sandwiches with all double meat. Also, their hair and makeup were flawless. Masks worn properly, changed gloves between orders. This will probably be my go-to location from now on.“

“I just learned today that this location is under new ownership, and it was wonderful! The people working were all so pleasant, and the store was so clean! The food tasted much more fresh. I rarely would stop here before, but will definitely be back! The ownership change is just what this location needed!“

“I called very last minute to place a catering order for a group of 15-20 people for the next day. The woman on the phone (cannot remember her name) was super nice and got everything set up for me. Came in the next day at pickup time and everything was ready and fresh! My staff loved their sandwiches! Thank you Jersey Mikes! We'll be back.“

“Lov'in this Jimmy John's ~ AWESOME Spot ??.This was a late night visit. I love getting photos during off peak hours. Can you say fresh products. ✅?.

Parking: I feel like there is plenty of free parking available at this Jimmy John's ‼️?

Kid-friendliness: Like I said I visited in evening. The two guys working we're very kind and quick ?‼️?“

“Here is a polished, warm, and Google-appropriate version of your review (clear, heartfelt, but concise enough that people will actually read it):

⸻

My grandmother is 95 years old and lives in Green Tree. She receives Meals on Wheels and occasionally cooks for herself, but she doesn’t get to eat out often. When family visits, she loves to treat us to something simple that we can all share together.

A few weeks ago, I visited with my parents and my one-year-old daughter. My grandmother had a coupon for Jersey Mike’s (buy two giant subs, get one free) and was excited to use it so she could treat all of us to lunch. When I brought the coupon in, it didn’t list the Green Tree location, and initially I was told it likely couldn’t be honored.

Manager Chris stepped in, reviewed the coupon, and although this location typically wouldn’t accept it, he chose to honor it so we could enjoy lunch together. He took the time to ask about my grandmother and genuinely cared about making it a positive experience. I overheard him coaching his team about creating great customer moments in instances like this. That level of leadership and kindness is rare.

My grandmother — who was born during the Great Depression and loves a good deal — was absolutely over the moon. We had a wonderful lunch together, and it meant more than just sandwiches.

This location is always clean, the sandwiches are consistently fantastic, and service is quick. We will absolutely continue coming back. Thank you, Chris, for going above and beyond. It truly made our day.“