11 Best Steakhouses near New Cumberland

“Honestly it's been a while since I last went, but my family had a private event here a few years back for my Great Uncle's unfortunate passing during COVID. This is part of my family's legacy and it means the world that the owners keep my great grandfather's restaurant alive. The food is well made with recipes they kept, the service was pleasant whenever I went growing up, and though it's only our names on the sign now it still felt like we were welcomed back like family. If you're ever in the New Cumberland area, stop by.“

“Definitely recommend this place for a romantic date night. Great service and phenomenal food. Well worth the price.“

“I was passing through the area and saw this little shop and decided to support local business. It did not disappoint! The Italian hoagie was quite good & the staff were very polite. This is an old-school type of place that will make you feel good you stopped. It'll be a regular stop when I'm back in Mechanicsburg on business.“

“Our meals were excellent, along with service. Food came out quick and hot. Love it.“

“I've always had a great server there and the early bird specials can't be beat!!“

“I love the salad bar, you can make a meal of it. Has soups,nachos,breads, fruits, Chilli n cornbred. The salad bar has many different salads. Pasta, corn, potatoes and a plethora of toppings g a formtour salad. This is a highly under rated place to eat. Go enjoy the salad bar“

“Decided to stop at outback before we went to a movie last night. Got there an hour and a half before our movie time. We did get on the list ahead of time so we only had to wait 10 minutes before being seated. Once seated our order was taken about 10 minutes later which should have left plenty of time to eat. After 25 minutes our soup and salad came. After 45 minutes of waiting after ordering we asked how much longer it was going to be and she told us we were 4th in line. We informed the server that we needed to leave and that we needed our food to go and we would reheat the food after we got home. She sent the manager over and her solution was to offer a free bloomin onion or app on our next visit. Nothing comped. $106 plus tip for reheated food and soggy sides. I had ordered the ribeye and grilled shrimp which I ordered medium. Upon getting home and opening my food, they forgot to give me my shrimp and my steak was cooked rare. Like had been cooked 1 minute each side. They basically slapped our order together once we said we were leaving and sent us home with garbage.“

“This is the 1st time in over 2 years that I've been here. I was in an accident that left me sensitive to some sounds. We went around 9-9:30 pm. Everything was going great. But, the minute our food came out. They sat a family with a crying baby 3 seats from me. I understand babies cry. But, in the old days. There was smoking & no smoking. We need to have family & no family.“

“I sat at the bar because I was by myself. The bartender doubled as my waitress and was also helping to serve/wait tables, bartender was nearly empty. She was nice enough, prompt enough, but never asked how my meal was in spite of passing by me a dozen times or more. HOWEVER...the manager himself, thanked me for coming in and DID ask how my meal was. THAT was nice. Overall, food & service was worthy of a return visit sometime“

“I know we are always looking for good places to eat, as we are foodies…especially good food. Shout out to Dodge City Steakhouse as their food was fantastic! I had haddock topped woth crab and Brussel sprouts! Staff was friendly and the atmosphere was quiet and quaint.“

“Longhorn has long been in our top 2 of chain restaurants and the one in Harrisburg PA did not disappoint. Great steak and salmon. And always good salads. Our server made sure we had our salads well before our main course was served. Highly recommend.“