10 Best American Restaurants near New Milford

“Really good food! Priced affordability! fast friendly service!“

“Amazing breakfasts. Omelets are great, I usually get, I think it's called a breakfast bowl. Home fries, eggs, sausage and cheese all cooked together. Speaking of home fries, these are the best around and second place isn't even close. Slow cooked on the griddle I could make a meal out of them alone.
As far as there being no wifi, there is very good cellular service there. Use your phone as a Hotspot, it's 2026 man! Sounds like somebody just wanted Starbucks and wanted to trash the small town feel.“

“I can honestly say, I don’t think I’ve ever had a better fried haddock sandwich, a better drink, or better service than today. The food was amazing (this sandwich was massive! It filled both Adam and I!), and the bartender (Jared) was not only super friendly and social, but he also gave amazing recommendations on drinks, and was super attentive and overall one of the best bartenders I’ve ever been around! I will definitely be returning to Green Gables again.“

“Food we got was absolutely perfect. Our server. Don’t know her name because she didn’t introduce herself, was deplorable. She didn’t communicate with the kitchen and didn’t check on us the whole time we were there. When I flagged her down to inform her that we needed something she walked away while I was asking. She then spent her time standing at a table of her family or friends while other people needed help.“

“feels very welcoming. very friendly and helpful staff. plus delicious ice cream 🍦 😋“

“Went in for breakfast today with my partner. It was small, cute and definitely a small town vibe. Food took extra time but it was well worth the wait and the staff was so kind. We didn’t mind the wait at all. We actually didn’t even notice because we were enjoying our time out. Thanks for the great meal!“

“cute little place to eat. The waitress is wonderfully nice and very attentive. they also gave my wife a flower on mother's day. I would definitely recommend.“

“Great cozy bed and breakfast. Staying here out of town for work, unbeatable prices ; $120 for 1 weeks stay. If you’re working night shift I’d reccomend you bring ear plugs as the walls are thin and people come in bright and early. Other than that it’s very hard to beat!“

“I brought a group of 20 cyclists here yesterday after doing the D&H Trail. Everyone was happy with the food and service. It was an integral part of the whole D&H Trail experience.“

“THIS place was the best food I have eaten out in a very long time. Almost 4 hours later and my mouth still is salivating over the roast beef and mash potatoes and gravy and the price was cheaper then McDonald's. $30 bucks for 2 excellent meals. Perfect portions with no left overs. My friend has the Salisbury steak and it looked amazing and she said it was incredible. Thank you to our excellent waitress as well. So friendly and attentive. We may stop back in for breakfast on the way home. A must stop at for a bite.“