31 Best American Restaurants near New Oxford

“they have the very best food around and very freindly people that work there they make sure you are happy with everthing.“

“Absolutely love the specialized drinks and baked goods. I don’t come to this area often but when I do I make it a point to stop.“

“Carissa was our waitress and she was excellent! Our entrees and desserts were fantastic as well, but Carissa's great personality and professionalism made us decide that we will always ask to be seated in her section!“

“Whiskey Honey Brisket with Fabulously Toasted fries ,2 Yuengling lager drafts,2 double espresso & peanut butter cake ! Only $31.00 Fabulously Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!!Poison Whiskey Outstanding Magnifico!!!No Cover charge ! Where in the Free World God's Green Earth will ya be able to find a better deal !Thank You“

“5 out of 5 stars all around. The food, staff and most of all atmosphere was great! Imagine a family friendly firefighter bar with actually good food haha. Staff was on top of refills and check ins even though they were slammed on a Sunday. Definitely will be returning.“

“We stopped by for supper May 30 2025. Our waitress was Alyssa she was wonderful helping me with my food allergies very thoughtful you have a wonderful worker in her.I had the ham with baked potato and cottage cheese my husband had the 2 smoked pork chops with a baked potato and cucumber salad the meal was wonderfully cooked well and so delicious Thank you for a great experience eating at you restaurant.“

“The value you get here is AMAZING!! And the staff are all so sweet. Everything was delicious and we left feeling stuffed! ❤️“

“Astonishingly good food. The staff is friendly and very competent. Always a good experience. Happy to drive 90 minutes for a meal at Olivia's!“

“Today was my first visit to Firepit and I will definitely be back! The waitress (Alexa) was friendly and knowledgeable, the chicken shawarma bowl was insanely good and the restaurant was clean and had plenty of parking. Highly recommend!“

“The spicy burnt beef sandwich was soooo good!! We also got Ribs and a loaded baked potato, all was delicious! Definitely will be back. Also very friendly and great service!“

“Tried it for the first time got the classic burger with bacon pieces and it was absolutely amazing and I let my daughter have a bite a she wanted to eat my whole burger… started running around the house yelling burger.. 😂 also ordered the Pierogi’s and they were good as well.. definitely worth trying. Although should have meal options… and more options period I saw other pics other ppl posted of other menus.. good place !“

“Authentic Mexican food. Delicious.“

“I really love the food here, and never had a bad meal. We love going for breakfast and glad you changed from home fries to hash browns. But we don`t get there for breakfast much because you changed your hours. For us 10am is to late when you get up around 6am.Please try to open around 8am. I hate to have to go some place else for breakfast. Thank you“

“In from out of state and just happened upon this fine little “dive bar”. The bartender was amazing, the food was ridiculously fantastic! If we’re ever back on this area, we will surely stop back!“

“Great place with both outdoor and indoor seating. They have crabs, seafood, and broasted chicken. There are a good assortment of sides. The broasted chicken was awesome, and my wife really liked the crabs. It's a casual place with a nice casual atmosphere. It can be loud. We spent about $60 for the two of us, including the tip. That's comparable to what we spend at Mission or Red Robin and less than we typocally spend at Long Horn. Hanover is about an hour and a half from where we live. Today we were in the area for other reasons and decided to give Big Mike's a try. We will definitely come back, just to eat here, even if we don't have any other reason to go to Hanover.“

“Had lunch at the upstairs bar today. Everything was wonderful.“

“Always go for breakfast and it’s always great! Excellent friendly service! Restaurant is very clean and plenty of parking.“

“Simply the best! Highly recommended!!“

“Good food , good prices , good service😊“

“My husband and I order from here at least once a week. They have great food, they are convenient to our location and they meet all our exceptions when it comes to take out orders. My favorite by far is their Philly Cheese Steak Pizza! Oh my gosh...it is so good. If you like the sub you will love the pizza.“

“Very outstanding,Delicious food. Service is beyond great! Chef Neil is there please. You will want to go back to Sidney's every chance you can.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely delicious food paired with genuinely attentive service. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it easy to settle in and enjoy the experience. The owners even come by to greet you, adding a warm personal touch that makes the visit feel special. Everything was just perfect — definitely a place worth coming back to.“

“Simply the best! Highly recommended!!“

“Best burgers! Look forward to opening day.“

“We thoroughly enjoyed our New Years Eve dinner at Longhorn. The wait was 45 mins. + as expected for a table of 4. When our wait exceeded that, and my spot on the list (link connected to text) appeared to be 11th, I decided my kids and I will head somewhere else with faster service and try again another time. I approached the hostess to notify her and was assured we were only minutes away of being sat and that the link was oftentimes misleading. Grateful for this, we, of course, stayed. Our meal was surprisingly timely and delicious despite the full house and our server Kyle was outstanding. I heard many other servers apologizing for a delay or long wait but, as far as me & my kiddos were concerned, it was just fine. We all enjoyed it and am quite content bringing the leftovers home for another meal.“

“Kim as a hostess and Donna as a server are a combination that is impossible to beat. I am a regular and when Donna sees me she brings my drink order along with greet me to the table. Two other waitresses that I have had there that are truly excellent are Kristin and Emily.“

“We had a buffet style meal for 32 people and it was just awesome. The food was hot and delicious the server was a gem. Definitely would recommend for your gatherings.“

“We came here for dinner on a Saturday evening in September. We saw on Facebook that a musician we like was performing. Facebook has this listed as Center Square Brewing but the sign outside still says underside bar.

We sat at the bar. We ordered drinks and then dinner. I had the cashew crusted chicken and it was good. It came with two pieces of chicken and I took one home as leftovers. The steak meal was very good as well.

The bartender was friendly and attentive. There weren’t too many people down there. The atmosphere felt like a basement - I mean, it’s a little dark because it’s down stairs and there is no windows and everything is brown or dark colors. It was casual and relaxed. Prices were comparable to most other local places we go.

Parking was a free paved lot adjacent to the building.“

“We got here around 4pm. We were told only one table was available because of reservations. There were still tons of tables not occupied. Got our table, ordered food. Food was good. Then the waitress never returned. Had to go up to the bar to get refills. Also had to get our check, and pay it at the bar. The tables were getting filled, but we didn't expect the waitress to not come back to our table.“

“Food was good, service great. Drinks delish!!“

“Great bartender! Love Missy, so friendly! Very nice atmosphere! Good food!“