50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Salem

“They go out of their way to make sure my food is good. Twice they’ve actually remade food ON THEIR OWN if they thought it wasn’t done well. This is the great customer service that keeps them at the TOP of my food delivery services. Thank you to each worker. I appreciate you!“

“We moved here from out of state and recommended initially to try their brunch. We took our three children there and it was fabulous. Drinks were amazing, service superb, and the food was outstanding. We decided to order delivery today via third party, and it was still just as amazing. Honestly have lived in many states and this by far is one of my favorite Pizza/Philly cheesesteak places. Highly recommend!“

“Joe has good food and great service. Place is always clean.“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“We love this place! Very friendly staff! We love their Stromboli ! Highly recommended!“

“French fries are best in york county bar none pizza is really good as well as cheese steak as well haven't tried everything yet but everything I did I loked“

“This was my 2nd visit to this amazing pizzeria , just a crossed the Pennsylvania state line this is a great place to go if you desire great customer service and even better pizza , they make you feel very comfortable with their warm staff & welcoming atmosphere. Please do yourself a favor and drop by if you're ever in the Southern Pennsylvania area just off highway 83 .“

“Just ordered from Marcos today got a large pizza and 12 hot wings. Wings were great and pizza is pretty good. They said it would take 45 mins and they got it out to me in dover in about 30 mins. Overall would definitely recommend this place.“

“I am a local truck driver. As I finished my last delivery almost 2 hours from home. I google “subs near me”. This place popped up. Wasn’t too far out of my way. And I didn’t have a trailer so I went off to find this place. (Small shops are the best in my opinion), the Italian sub on a fresh baked roll was amazing. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area. Definitely will be back“

“This is my favorite place for pizza and kids food, but I had never tried their Lasagna until today! I’m really “picky” when it comes to Lasagna, but I needed to cheer myself up 😆, and I was so glad I did! The garlic bread is perfectly done and the Lasagna exceeded my expectations! Highly recommend Memory Lane!! ,“

“omg so yum!!! got their almond croissants, bread pudding and sour cherry pie. everything was amazing!!!!! wish the place had a cuter set up to sit and enjoy the sweet treats. but always grab to go anyway. highly recommend. everything I've had with them has been so amazing!! highly recommend“

“Best Pizza in York County...just WAY too salty...wont shop there again...sadly“

“Great service and the pizza and wings are amazing“

“Had Paesano’s for the first time yesterday. Cheeseburger sub and Stromboli was absolutely delicious and fulfilling. Highly recommend & will definitely be back.“

“Pizza By Alberto’s It's been 3 years since we stopped by simply because we moved to another state. While we were back in town, we have to stop by our favorite Pizza place to see if they still had the best pizza in this area. We arrived there about 1:20 pm on Thursday. They were not full and only had one other booth with someone in it. The place was neat, clean, and smelled great. In fact, I believe they were cleaning the kitchen as we walked in. From what I could see it was spotless. Our waitress came over introduced herself as Jace and took our drink orders. We ordered water, tea, and a beer. She then took our food order which was the Alberto's Special. This Pizza has your choice of 8 toppings. We ordered the Peperoni, Ham, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Bacon, Extra Cheese, Black Olives. Every time we go there, we always ordered this Pizza special. We also ordered two side salads and an ordered of garlic bread. Our salads came out fast and were good as was the garlic bread and the beer was cold and tasted great. About the time we were done with our salads the Pizza came out. It looked very good and tons of toppings. When I bit into the Pizza it was very hot and the toppings were so good, and the crust was done perfect. I can't tell you how much I loved this, Pizza. I knew then I was giving it 5 stars. If you want to best pizza in this reviewer’s opinion, go here and get one you will not be sorry. I give this Pizza 5 out of 5 stars. Follow me on FB for more reviews Gulf Coast Terry“

“Thank you for feeding my goalie weekly! Your smoothies are SO good and your menu keeps things fresh. We appreciate you!“

“The pizza is always so fresh and delish’s if you haven’t tried it yet you don’t know what you’re missing!!“

“I wish you guys were close to us in Va. your food is amazing and the staff is friendly!!!!“

“Good variety and great tasting pizza“

“Just have a small pizza which was very good. Also got a cold sub it was good but had to take lettuce off, it very brown you could tell it was old“

“Mod gets a 5 from me for the fresh toppings, great taste, excellent service and the outdoor seating that is perfect for cool evenings! A quick, enjoyable and fun pizza experience.

Kid-friendliness: We had 2 kiddos with us, abs they each got mini-mods the way they wanted them! Milk is a drink option- I do prefer that for the kids over the sodas and teas.“

“They have had a few minor issues but you can’t beat the quantity and quality for the price. #1 spot in Manchester. If you’re disappointed reach out they will make it right

Parking: It’s in a shopping mall plenty of parking

Kid-friendliness: They allow kids“

“all I can say is I love doing what I did I love doing what I do and I am just so happy that Matt shover shover is doing such a wonderful job and keeping our family tradition extending more than five generations he's doing a wonderful job and I appreciate everyone who ever walked through them my door just like myself I know Matt and his family welcome you through his doors thank you.“

“Golf is awesome there.. we played early.
The course needs the cart trails updated..many pot holes !! Just load with stone simple upgrade... However great staff in clubhouse..
Clean course..carts great..played 9 holes..Hot out !! My son head coaches baseball at Dover high school..we travel 3 hours to play here at course..“

“Walked in and the was greeted with a smile. The lady was very kind and asked what I was wanting to have. She took my order and made my pizza. She was very friendly. The pizza took no time at all to make and came out great. The atmosphere was nice and the people were great. I recommend this place any time. The food is good and the employees are great. Thank you for the great service.“

“A large space to relax, very accommodating service, and custom pizza! Set up in a made-to-order fashion, the pizza is quick to create and make to whatever I was feeling that day. I'm a huge fan and look forward to going and I think the price is very reasonable for a personalized pizza.“

“they have the best food in Pennsylvania!“

“Food & service was great!!“

“Best pizza ever…crust is amazing!“

“Dwayne the delivery driver is the BEST ! I messed up my order online, and explained it to the employees at Sals. Dwayne stepped up and offered to buy myself & my daughter a new pizza. Bless him, and Sals! The best! -Jazmin 🙌🏻 (& residents of Sunshine Dr.) 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻“

“today I ordered 5 big daddy pizzas for a party.. everything was great and on time“

“Visiting York from out of town. I had an inch to eat some Stromboli like one does in Pennsylvania. We were lucky enough Shakey Jakes was open until 11. My team and I visited and most of us ordered a Boli. We were told a small would feed one person. So I ordered a large. Holy Stromboli, this thing was huge. I only got through half but I brought it home so I can enjoy it for the next two days. It was so good I felt like it was sent from heaven above. This was EASILY the best food I have ever eaten in Pennsylvania. I can't recommend Shakey Jakes enough. Can't wait to go there again in 3 days when I finally finish my large Boli.“

“Not only does Melania Pizza have great food (with amazing homemade bread), but the owner is amazing to work with on our large sub orders that we do for our co-op. Highly recommend!!“

“We have been coming to Mamma's for the past 36+ years as their authentic Italian dinners, subs, stromboli, bread & salads are next to impossible to beat. They are all about great Italian food at reasonable prices and there are coupons on their App for even greater savings. If you have not added Mamma's to your dining out and take out lists, you are really missing out!! Support this Family-Owned business as they are First Class and they hire and train their staff to be excellent treating their customers as family!!“

“I went with my bf for my birthday 4/10/25. we played bingo won prizes and the atmosphere and the customers were fun and friendly. I just want to say the bartender on that night was amazing and friendly. Coming from 30+yrs previously in the service industry I know a good bartender when I see one. We will definitely be back!“

“Great food and great family business!“

“Start with GREAT TASTE, better than most in the area. I’m going to be honest, hygiene seemed suspect. Not dirty, but there were tool bags on the counter. Old guy making pizza coughed a lot and touched his face a lot. But I’ve eaten gas station tacos since I was a kid in the south, so whatever. Food fantastic tasting. Speed is a little slow, they seem poor at timing orders. My fries were 10 min + ahead of the pizza….. but again, taste great. Will eat again. Hopefully they look at the cleanliness from the customer POV. Place has major potential.“

“they have great food but instead of my breaded cauliflower they gave me breaded mushrooms 😭“

“The Italian Stromboli is to die for! Their sauce has the perfect little bit of spice and all of the flavor! The staff is always really nice!“

“My husband and I were talking about how we couldn’t find a pizza place around here that was satisfying anymore… until we came across Nino’s Pizza! Nino’s Pizza has become our favorite place to go for a slice of pie! Their pizza is amazing quality and always looks presentable! I highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza, veggie pizza, and cheese pizza as they will absolutely bring you satisfaction and hunger for more!! I also deeply recommend you try one of their subs as they make their bread from SCRATCH!! Fries are delicious too. I have yet to get an order that didn’t satisfy me and my husband leaves just as fulfilled! I will also point out that the staff is very welcoming and creates a relationship with you and overall provides a very satisfying atmosphere. We will be back! 🤤 Yummy! 🤤“

“The person that helped me was very friendly didn't have my card with me very helpful because I left my card at home and had to have a picture taken of it and she verify it with me and pay for my food and on my way home she was very sweet and nice“

“Great food ,service is fantastic ,owners and staff are the best. Highly recommend Marcello’s.“

“I wish you guys were close to us in Va. your food is amazing and the staff is friendly!!!!“

“Good variety and great tasting pizza“

“I would like to Thank your Company for donating pizza to DASD to hand out for lunch during the COVID 19 quarantine. You have made 3 kiddos very happy.“

“Just so so. Went to kiosk to pick my food up and the doors open up picked up the pizzas and they weren't mine. Told the guy at the counter they weren't mine and he left to answer the phone. Finally came back to give me the correct order. Payed for extra bacon with black olives and onions however litterly no bacon on the pizza what so ever.“

“Delicious pizza ,wings and respectful hospitality“

“Had the pleasure of eating at Frey Daddy’s about 2 weeks ago and it’s some of the tastiest pizza in York. Check out their Stromboli if you’re looking for something different as well. It’s also conveniently located.“

“Just want to say that had an amazing experience from booking the party to packing up and leaving the party. Our party host I think Mackenzie took very good care of us and always made sure everyone snd everything was good . The pizza was hot and fresh . The kids had a blast . Playing games for 2 hours was slot of fun but exhausting . My daughter loved it as well as her friends . Will be booking again in the near future . Aldo can’t forget the gentleman at the ticket counter so patient kind and helpful as well“

“Well, I have always liked the food including the tuna salad, Italian subs and the sub rolls... but... They need to seriously not cram hot food into bags with cold subs and they need to not put cold subs anywhere near the pizza over. Everything about our cold subs last week with lettuce, tomatoes and onion was warm, soggy and squishing out all over. It was a gross disaster. Guy only looked et me confused when I asked why my cold subs felt hot and why the hot fries were in the bag with the cold subs. I just sighed and left.“