Pizza Restaurants near New Salem

“I always order from this location. But tonight I had the absolute PLEASURE of placing my order with Savanna. ( I know because I asked her name) She was pleasant & courteous & all around, just had great customer service! I had a terrible day & literally the 5 minutes on the phone with this woman, just ordering my dinner brightened my day a bit. I hope this review gets read by the right people because this girl deserves a raise, at the very least she deserves to be told she’s doing a good job.Thank you so much for your wonderful service. ?“

“This was a new place to me since this wasn't here before I moved away. I asked someone walking by (I thought they was walking by) if they ever had it and if it was any good. They raved about it so I decided to try it. Was pricier then I was expecting but the all of the workers was wonderful. I had a half cheesesteak hoagie combo minus green peppers with mozzarella cheese instead of american. The fries was nice and crisp but not too crisp and they was not too salty. Which was refreshing because i don't like them too salty. I also ordered a side of scramble eggs. While I was gone the only way I could have a cheesesteak is if I made it. So it was refreshing to not have to make it myself. I was beyond happy with the food and service I even requested to speak to their cook and I promised it was nothing bad. I had to give my praise. Everyone was so wonderful and welcomed everyone. However they tend to close early or so I have noticed when I tried to go back again. I highly recommend this place and I will be definitely be going back. They do accommodate ppl if they need special accommodations without even batting an eye and not look at you any differently so don't be worried if you have to ask. Diningroom and bathroom is kept extremely clean. Keep up the awesome work you guys.Kid-friendliness: Yes nice relaxed and positive atmosphere for all ages to dine at.Wheelchair accessibility: It's all leveled ground so easy entrance for all to go in.“

“I was recommended to come and check out The Copper Crust Co. by a friend and was not disappointed yet not enthused either. There wasn’t much of a selection at the bakery case, so I’m guessing the earlier you get in, the more options you’ll have. The customer service was nothing more than average, however I did enjoy my bacon and cheddar quiche…it was well made & tasty. I’d also recommend the salted caramel cheesecake. I’m hoping that my second times a charm since I’m looking to try something new on the menu and come in at an earlier time of day.“

“I am not from the Glen Rock area but my husband is. We stopped in while we were in the area and I am so glad we did! I have never had such a good pizza; it was fresh & hot! We got the Meat Lovers Pizza & a side of mozzarella sticks. The cheese on the pizza is perfect! The mozzarella sticks were fresh and so gooey. 100% going back when we can! I hope we can sample the whole menu eventually!“

“Our family loves Pizza al Bacio! My son's favorite salad is their grilled chicken salad. And their bread is the best we've had. My family usually also gets the mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, pizza, and stromboli. We always do take out because we prefer to eat at home, but the shop owners and workers are friendly, and our food is hot and ready quickly. We highly recommend Pizza al Bacio for casual Italian food!“

“We have our local shop we love, especially the Stromboli but your house Stromboli takes the cake! I was pleasantly surprised how wonderful everything was. It’s hard to find good pizza and Stromboli at the same place. Everyone was pleasant when I arrived thanks again!“

“We were in York for a Volleyball tournament this wknd and decided on pizza last minute. Glad we did. Definitely a hidden gem. We are from the Philadelphia area and have our fair share of pizza places(every corner) and with that being said, one of the BEST I’ve ever had. No doubt will be hitting the JAWN up every time we are in the area! It was perfect.“

“I was really excited to try Marco's and see if it lived up to its reputation. I'm happy to say this pizzeria offers a variety of novel pizzas that are a great value for the price.Among the many selections were Buffalo Chicken, Steak Ranchero, and even a Caesar Salad Pizza. After drooling over the merchandise for a few minutes, I zeroed in on my order: one slice of the Hot Honey Pepperoni.The crust was just the right amount of crunchy and soft. The Pepperoni had a good crisp to it. The Honey was well balanced between sweet and spicy. At $3.40 for the slice, the price point was just right.To say I am impressed is an understatement. I will be back to Marco's.“

“I live in Maryland and was visiting a friend in the area. Wanted pizza, found this place on google and it was close, so we decided to try it. We ended up getting strombolis. The staff was amazing, and the food was outstanding! Very reasonably priced and giant portions! We already decided to come back next time I visit and we're trying the pizza lol. We ate inside and the staff was very nice and personable. Highly recommend!Parking: Plenty of parking“

“Man, just move to North York from Baltimore and of all places to fine a 'diamond' of a little Sicilian eatery/ takeout! Grow up on Italian/ Sicilian eats. My Mama, Salvatrisa was first generation Sicilian. Love this little place and reminded me of my grandpa Salvatore's shoe repair shop ( quaint little dark green store front with lots of plants inside) in Western P.A., growing up. You GOTTA check this place out and yeah, order from there menu. My question is: why do you not have Sicilian Limon creme(Lemon) Cannolis with white powered sugar on top?Michael Bellomo Crowley.“

“I've eaten here about 5 times in the last few months. Every time is piping hot food, tender chicken, their pizza is the best in York. Staff is chill, and being a former cook, the boss makes me miss those days... this place is awesome. I choose brix over everything downtown. You get every bang for your buck here.Kid-friendliness: Safe atmosphere. Kids are in here all the time picking up some food. Clean.“

“I honestly did not expect to find this level of pizza in York. Pizza was excellent. Having been to pizza shops in Boston, Manhattan and Philadelphia, I am a pizza snob. Pizza was loaded with cheese and sauce. Facility was spotless and staff was very friendly. Prices were very good also. Wow that was some good pizza. It even looks good. In the pictures You see on these reviews.“

“Very kind accommodating and fast service . Liked the freshly tuna wrap that you pick what you want on it zi choose provolone cheese they even toasted it enough to melt the cheese . I am ready to go back and try another meal. Prices are really reasonable clean environment and the fan was a great decoration piece.“

“This place is on our favorites list for their pizza and much more. The food is always fantastic and until recently, our family go to was their pizza, but we have ventured to other items on the menu and it’s still fantastic. We have yet to find something they don’t do well. Additionally, the staff there is so friendly and it’s always a joy to be able to support such a great family business.“

“Mod Pizza is one of my favorites, and this particular stop did not disappoint. The service was great; we got our pizza very quickly, and it tasted great!Kid-friendliness: Our 7 year old loves to create his own pizza!Parking: Plenty of free parking at this pizza shop“

“My favorite local pizza shop to get a hot sub. I think I've tried just about all of them. Love the Meatball sub and the Sausage Parm. My daughters favorite place to just get a slice of pizza. The Sausage Stromboli is the perfect mix of sausage and cheese, they don't go too light or too heavy on either ingredient. My go to app to get with a sub is the onion rings, always fried perfect. The staff are always friendly and service is always quick. If you want a nice warm sub that isn't Subway, which is right next door btw this is a great stop.“

“MOD pizza Mega dough crust with non-dairy cheese and loads of veggies is a vegan's dream. The amount of toppings makes for seemingly endless opportunities. The staff is upbeat and it feels like you're dropping in on friends.Dietary restrictions: Dairy free cheese!!! Plant based meat option, too. You can get a vegan custom pizza.“

“We Love the crunch on the chicken and it's never salty. Very funny and pleasant employees there especially my COWBOYS FAN. it's a great place for a Variety of food. (MUST SHOW ID FOR ALCOHOL AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS NO EXCEPTIONS).Parking: Plenty of parking. No need to worry about no where to park.Wheelchair accessibility: Have wheelchair parking and a ramp. No automatic doors and they are heavy.“

“Love love LOVE this place!!! Can't beat their choices, sizes and / or taste of pizzas ? Our go to every time is the XL Mexican (but also I do do a small Reuben every now and then) NEVER disappointed. You're welcome ~ #sorrynotsorry ?“

“Amazing family. They remember faces when you come in often enough. Treats everyone like family. They pour their love into their food which always comes out amazing. Andrew and Anna are the greatest around. Their service is phenomenal and they always rise above my expectation. There's always good vibes when me and my fiancé walk in and we're always happy to see them. we practically consider them as family because they always help us out.“

“We moved into our home going on 3 years ago and as we tried different options to find a favorite pizza place, Bubba D's Shrewsbury location was the obvious winner. We've been ordering exclusively from them ever since! We have not eaten in but we have done both take out and delivery. Both these options we have had exclusively awesome experiences with. Now this place does get busy especially on the weekend evenings but even with that factor, I don't think we've ever ordered and not had our food within 45 minutes. Plus we're 10 minutes away. The fact that the food is always blistering, burn your mouth hot like it just came out of the oven is crazy to us but the quality is evident and the food is just great! Take out is just as easy, the staff is always friendly and pickup time is always so quick! Definitely try this place!“

“Food was good. Service fine. But when you go to pay and your paying with cash they always charge you higher at the register than what the cash price says on your receipt. It's only by a cent or two but still..... It makes the customer feel like they are being ripped off. The receipt the waitress gives you and the cash register should BOTH say the same amount.“

“I've been here twice, and I ordered the pretzel stromboli. It was so good, I had to order it again. It was fresh, soft, and great tasting. When I arrived to pick it up, the staff is always happy and welcoming. Thank you for the great service!“

“I normally don’t do these things, but the food is SO good and they were so nice there. Brought it right out to me! I got the hot honey chicken rice bowl and it slappppppppedWheelchair accessibility: I’m walking with a cane and they brought it right to my car“

“Typical pizza place in a strip mall. You go up and order. They bring it out. TV playing.Food was good. Pepperoni pizza. Nothing too special. Worth trying at least once.Staff was friendly. Place was clean. They cleaned up tables as soon as a person left.I expect the rest of the food to be pretty good. Menu looked good, but we were just passing thru for a quick pizza.Oh and the food was very speedy. I dont think we waited long at all to get our pizza.I thing we spent close to $25 on a large pizza and 4 bottled waters. 1.95 for bottled water isn't cool though.“

“We went through the Drive thru and ordered a pizza. Delicious ? the wait wasn't bad either!Parking: Close quarters, but at least it's not street parking or paid. Just be cautious backing out and watch for other people's doors.Kid-friendliness: Not a pizza + barWheelchair accessibility: Flat surfaces to enter and exit. I believe the door is wide enough for a wheelchair or walker.“

“A restaurant attached to a golf course....hmmm kind of suspicious but yet so delightful! Most of the Pizza is shockingly good (coming from a lad from NEPA where the pizza is scrumptious!) The staff is superb! The beer list is always changing! I once saw someone eating soup outside on the patio while it was 90 degrees (*watch out for that guy ?)“

“I am a NYC girl and these are some of the best bagels since I left nyVegetarian options: I think the bagels are amazing with no topping needed..if you are trying to avoid dairy..lots of varietyKid-friendliness: Pizza bagels what kid doesn't enjoy them“

“I continue to be impressed with the consistency of this MOD Pizza location! Since moving to the area, this is our go-to pizza spot. The pizza is always delicious and prepared nicely. We get takeout and it’s usually finished before the estimated pick up time.Parking: Can be difficult to get into the parking lot“

“Yum! Visiting town for business and had to try this. Very good. Quality of food is excellent! Variety of pizza hot and fresh. They’ll make one if they don’t already have the variety. Bread sticks are delicious, everything was! Customer Service was top notch, all employees friendly and smiling. Troy was very friendly and informative when I checked in for a table. Price was a value. Would visit again when in the area. Give it a try you’ll be glad you did!Kid-friendliness: There were many kids here. Very kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Open spaces between tables.“

“We been here for cheese and pepperoni pizza several times.Pizza is very good.Service is great. Nice workers at counter.Atmosphere of this restaurant is really nice. Lots of tables and spacious.I never had anything but pizza here so can't rate other food on menu.I had dropped in with a large group of kids after our baseball game and seating was awesome.“

“So we ordered online. For some reason the site or app decided that we wanted pizza tomorrow 25 hours from now instead of right now. No option was selected. So we called and management took care of it right away. Food showed up in a hurry and was nice and fresh. Props for fixing the issue first thing when they opened.“

“Food is always fresh and hot. Prices are pretty fair with how much food you can get. Delivery wait times are a bit longer than competitors, but it is totally worth the wait! Drivers have always been nice to us, too! The pizzas and the Strombolis are really good!The only complaint I have is the Fox's app is very clunky, but I am not faulting the location for that.“

“Good food. I may have been overly tired from a long week of work. Had a mixed ravioli dinner. Sauce was fantastic, cheese raviolis were good, the meat raviolis were MEH( they had an odd taste to them.)My soup, salad, and garlic bread were fantastica!“

“Shame that we were only here on a visit. This place would be a regular stop for sure. Very comfy ambiance. The wait staff was very friendly. The food was out of this world. Plenty to take home and not at all pricey.Dietary restrictions: Most veggie options can be made vegan.“

“This is a small pizza shop that has all the classics done well. I'm personally a sucker for their stromboli. The owner is friendly and always open to a convo or laugh. He stayed open for us one night for an extra 30 minutes and cooked food for us even though we walked in while he was cleaning. He doesn't know how much we appreciate it.“

“To start, they were very polite on the phone, and made sure to repeat the order back to ensure it was correct.I was greeted with smiles and a very positive attitude as soon as I walked in, which not many places seem to do anymore. Both ladies working there made it an awesome experience.I ordered a large pepperoni, a California cheese steak and a order of fries. Everything was very well made, exactly how I wanted it. The pizza had great flavor and they weren't stingy with the pepperoni. The fries were crispy and plentiful. My sub was above average but not the best I've ever had, the lettuce tasted a little old and it could have used some more meat, but nonetheless it was good.I would recommend Marcello's over any other pizza shop in York.“

“Im from South Jersey, right outside of Philadelphia - it’s no secret there’s a lot of pride in the quality of pizzeria’s in the area. Having said that, I was in York visiting family and we happened to stop at Boardwalks, and let me tell you, it was truly the best pizza I had in a while. Some may argue that the two free beers (yes, two free beers! Who else does that?) was clouding my judgment, but no. Rest assured the pizza here is top notch. I can’t speak for much else, if I’m being honest. But, I found myself craving Boardwalks pizza not long after my first visit and I can’t wait to have some more.“

“Hands down the best sub rolls around. I use to work in the bank across the street and I probably got lunch from here at least twice a week the whole time I worked there. Fries have the perfect crisp to them. The family that owns this location are the nicest people you'll ever meet. After the renovations the shop looks beautiful. Any time I'm in the Loganville area I try to stop in.“

“This place is a great lunch spot in a place with a ton of fast food options. The food is so fresh, always. They have a half sub and fries for $6.50 or something like that at lunchtime and it's a heck of a deal. I've eaten several of their subs, right now I'm enjoying a top tier Italian sub and it's outstanding. The customer service on the phone is wonderful and the gentleman who answers speaks so clearly and kindly without making you feel like he's being slow with you. Just an all around great lunch spot!“

“Thanks Chris!! Our order is right and perfect!! Thanks for taking care of us! We were about to call it quits as our order has been wrong last few times. We decided to share our experiences versus quitting and Chris helped us out!! We will continue to order. You helped your location keep a customer!!! Thanks Chris“

“Amazing food, authentic quality. Service?? PERFECTION!! Everyone has a positive attitude, and great sense of humor!! Great atmosphere, Mary Poppins was on!! Everything was just great!! 10/10. My family and I will be coming back here!! Thank You!!“

“The pizza here is New York style and is awesome! Crispy dough, fantastic cheese, and treat yourself to a cannoli for dessert- DELISH!Mario, the owner is cooking, waiting tables, and still taking time to talk to his customers. Great young man! Give it a try- you won't be disappointed!“

“Staff are slow and inattentive. But the games are fun. It's a smaller selection of games compared to some other CECs that we've visited. And each time we've visited, there are always at least 1-2 games that either don't work or don't work properly. But the kids still have fun.“

“Moved to York about a year and a half ago. The pizza scene here is not very good. Not like it was back in Montgomery County. Anyways, I found this place on Googled and had it on the back burner for a while. It’s the only place that I have found, that wasn’t a buffet, a chain, or a place that we have been to and wasn’t good. We finally got the chance to go and are so pleased. Walking in, there’s tons of pizza and doughy snacks to choose from. Had the Parma Dog and Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Pizza the first time. Was so good that we came back the following day for another round of Parma Dogs and Pretzeled Ham and Cheese Stuffed Pizza. This place is so good and pretty close to home so I think we found our go to place. We are so excited to have good pizza here in York.“

“This place was really good. The pizza and service was good. However, the lasting impression that I came away with was the quality of the workers and staff there. They weren't overly bubbly but they seemed happy to be there and happy to serve us.“

“The pizza at this restaurant is absolutely delicious, with a perfect balance of toppings, sauce, and crust that leaves you craving for more. The wings are also fantastic, with a variety of flavors to choose from, each one bursting with bold and savory tastes. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot to hang out with friends or enjoy a casual meal with family. Overall, this restaurant offers a fantastic combination of mouthwatering pizza and flavorful wings, making it a must-visit for any food lover.“

“We had Genova’s in Spring Grove cater our 50th anniversary party. Kelly was great to work with at every step. It had been a while since I’d done a big party and she patiently answered all my questions. The food, salads and bread were plentiful and delicious.Kelly delivered everything we needed on time and helped the party go smoothly. Thanks so much!“

“We always enjoy Nino's Pizza it is the best in York PA!!! recently ordered pizza and it was not as I wanted but they quickly responded and brought me what I wanted I feel bad cuz I don't want to complain but they made it right immediately“