16 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Wilmington

Pizza Joe's Pizza • $
209 S Market St, New Wilmington

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken
Hot Gondola Sub
Personal Pizza
Chicken Salad

“Today is Wednesday 10/25/23. The new wheelchair accessible ramp was completed today and we were able to take our friend who is wheelchair bound INSIDE for the first time! The owner Dave came over to us and said “How nice it was to see him able to come inside!” We appreciate the inclusion of wheelchair accessibility more than you know! THANK YOU DAVE!Wheelchair accessibility: See above“

3.9 Good23 Reviews
VentiSei Wine Bar & Pizzeria Pizza • $$
1409 Wilson Ave, New Castle - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Platter
Lazy Lasagna
Meatballs
Pizza

“This place is so cool! We started with a wine tasting, then a delicious dinner of pizzas and pasta… and more wine! After dinner we enjoyed talking with the owner before relaxing in front of the outside fire pit. I highly recommend everything!“

4.8 Superb41 Reviews
Turco's Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $$
839 Moravia Street, New Castle - 9.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza - Or Create Your Own
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fresh Tomato Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Homestyle Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Puff
Chicken Wings
Nick's Sticks
Veggie Pizza

“I wish I could give Turco’s more than 5 stars. I tried it for the first time this past weekend, and it was downright amazing! I submitted an online order, and there were no issues upon picking it up. The crust has the right amount of crunch and the sauce has the perfect amount of sweetness. I ordered two 14 cuts for 3 adults and was surprised at how filling it was. We are big eaters, and this pizza was our dinner for 2 days! Be prepared to feel full after eating it. I will definitely be back!“

4.7 Superb47 Reviews
Volant Pizzeria Pizza • $
975 Main St, Volant - 3.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Specialty Pizzas Small
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Balls
BBQ Pizza
Pizzs

“A hidden gem in the heart of Volant! They had a huge collection of various board/card games to play free and I really enjoyed their buffalo chicken pizza. Noticed they also do free trivia nights on Wednesdays at 7:30! It’s refreshing to see fun activities happening around here for once. The prices were very affordable compared to other chain pizzerias, and tasted like it was prepared with love. Check out their candy shop!! Very nostalgic! There’s something here for people of all ages!“

4.7 Superb41 Reviews
Scotto's Famous Pizza Pizza • $
2090 E State St, Hermitage - 10.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kid's Chicken Fingers with French Fries
Scotto's Delicious Garlic Knots
Scotto's Famous Pepperoni Rolls
New York Style Cheese Pizza
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza
2 Different Veggie Pizzas
Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Gluten Free Pizza
Big Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni Pizza

“Great pizza, great service and the true Italian pizza maker made the experience well worth the stop. I had the New York style pizza and it couldn't have been any better. I am from out of town but make it there a couple times a year and I will be sure to stop again. Thanks "Now that's a pizza"“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
Pizza Man's Pizza Pizza • $
9 S Jefferson St, New Castle - 8.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Steak and Home Made Chips
Square Slice or Specialty Slice
Single Slice Pepperoni Pizza
Strawberry Hot Chicken Wings
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Pepperoni Calzone
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Fries

“This is our go too for pizza in New Castle. Favorite is the cheeseburger pizza. I would give 5 stars if our order would at least be consistent. But it is consistenly wrong. I order and pay online. Almost every time there is something missing. 1 time there was no toppings. Last night I ordered and paid for bacon and pickles but only got bacon. I shouldn't have to check my order before leaving. Still the pizza is delicious“

4.6 Superb46 Reviews
Mangino’s Pizzeria Pizza • $
2710 Wilmington Rd, New Castle - 6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad with Balsamic Dressing
Pepperoni Rolls and Wedding Soup
Tomato Pizza and Garden Salad
Sliced Tomato Pizza Slice
Italian Supreme Sandwich
Mixed Vegetable Pizza
Meatball Stuffed Loaf
Philly Steak Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meatball Dugout Loaf

“A TRUE New Castle treasure!!! Everything I have ever had has never disappointed. Any sandwich is always spot on. Appetizers are awesome. Pizza has plenty of the sweeter sauce that is amazing if that’s your liking. Happy no one knows the secret to it and tried to duplicate it because they would mess it up!! Nice dense dough that is always cooked perfectly with a great chew and crisp crust!! Toppings and cheese are fresh and delicious perfectly proportionate to every slice!!! Love taking home a large order on a weekend when I don’t feel like cooking and grazing on it all for a couple days!!!! I would love to see them come out with a lamb pizza with a garlic and pepper sauce with feta cheese….. Just a suggestion???? If you ever questioned eating in or ordering from here…. Don’t second guess your decision and do it!!!!!“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
Little Johnny's II Pizza • $
130 E Washington St, New Castle - 8.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Homestyle Pizza
Johnny Fingers
Steak Salad
Half Dozen
The Junies
Italian
Pop

“We ordered delivery, and the food got here early and pipping hot. It was so good, i had to call just to tell them my self. We got a traditional cheese pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a buffalo chicken pizza, and junies. Oh we love the junies!! Like biting into Grandma's apple pie. But in eggroll form. Delicious all the way around!!“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Faraone Brothers Catering Caterers • $$
1015 S Mill St, New Castle - 9.23 miles

“We used Faraone Brothers Catering recently for the 175th Anniversary of Lawrence County which was celebrated at the Court House and WOW. Their food was amazing, the cost was very reasonable for top tier items such as shrimp, seafood stuffed mushrooms, chicken skewers etc. - not to mention their staff was friendly and went above and beyond to make it a smooth event. Would highly recommend!“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Pizza Joe's Pizza • $
1815 W State St, New Castle - 8.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Pizza with Ranch Sauce Pizza with Veggie Toppings
Chicken Bacon Club
Eggplant Parm Sub
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Tenders
Extra Dressing
Hot Gondola Sub
Pepperoni Rols
Burnt Chicken
Spinach Rolls

“The food was great however there was a woman who was waiting on people and she was not friendly at all. She didn't smile, wasn't pleasant and rude to quite a few people that we heard her wait on after us.The pizza we had was amazing and the guys that brought it out to us were super nice but she was not.“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
Combine Brothers Italian • $
2376 S Hermitage Rd, Hermitage - 8.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vermicelli with Marinara Sauce
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Parmesan
Pink Pepper Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Carbonara Pasta
Chicken Alfredo
Salad and Rolls
Chocolate Cake
Wedding Soup

“I enjoyed this restaurant immensely. I had the Chicken Fettucine Alfredo with a salad and a large bread roll I also had an unsweetened iced tea. The server was very attentive and the food was very good. The Chicken Fettucine was good with just about the right amount of white alfredo sauce, not too much or too little. I ordered unsweetened iced tea and when I mentioned I would sweeten it to my taste she asked which sweetener I preferred and provide that to me. She also kept the iced tea topped off for most of the meal. The bread is a well made white bread boule.It is a very nice and cozy restaurant. I was on travel visiting my son who lives in a group home nearby and went in without a reservation and was seated immediately. I have favorite restaurants in cities across the country, to include Washington, DC, Philadelphia, New York, Boston, San Diego, Denver, Los Angeles, Berkeley, San Jose, San Francisco, Phoenix and many other cities. Although, this may not be the most trendy restaurant in any of those cities, the service and the food would place it well within the standard of restaurants in most of those cities.It is an Italian restaurant. They may want to expand their menu to include some non-Italian food choices and include food allergy free food choices such as gluten free and a selection of vegetarian and other food types. This doesn't have to be an extremely large part of the menu. The salad was good but I prefer my lettuce to not be as cut up as it was. The dressing was put on the side which permitted me to put on how much dressing as I desired. I am getting older and eat smaller portions so the server provide me with everything I needed to save the left over Chicken Fettucine Alfredo and the bread.This is likely the best restaurant in the Sharon, Hermitage and Farrell area.“

4.1 Good90 Reviews
The MUSTANG BAR Bar • $
711 Wilson Ave, Mercer - 8.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Pretzel

“There is only one reason I'm recommending this mercer area dive bar, and one reason I'll be back. They have fantastic wings...really, they were something else! We got 3 dozen for take out (buffalo, garlic parmesan, and garlic butter). I'm not sure if they are discounted on Wednesday but the bill seemed really reasonable for the quantity of food.“

4.3 Superb23 Reviews
Pizza Joe's Pizza • $
1203 N Croton Ave, New Castle - 7.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Honey Hot Chicken
Big Square Pizza
BBQ Chicken

“Always clean with friendly prompt employees. Service is quick whether ordering delivery through door dash or calling for pick up. Always have had a good experience. Food was always perfect as it should be. Couldn’t ask for a better experience.“

4.3 Superb19 Reviews
Fox's Pizza Den- Mercer, PA Pizza • $
State Route 58, Plaza, Mercer - 9.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Pizza
Foxy Fries
Ham Wedgie

“The ABSOLUTE BEST pizza shop around. Every order(12 I think) has been made quickly and precise and usually done earlier than they say. The whole crew are kind and courteous and treat every customer I ever witnessed with respect and gratitude. The new owners redone the whole inside prior to opening. They really added a family atmosphere to the place. I highly recommend eating anything on the menu as everything is fresh and delicious. I’d give them 10 stars across the board if I could.“

4.1 Good40 Reviews
Luigi's Pizzeria Pizza • $
2918 E State St, Hermitage - 9.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Banana Pepper Ring Topping
Pepperoni Topping
Mushrooms Topping
Sausage Topping
Veggie Pizza
Bacon Topping
Pepper Rings
Plain Pizza

“Now this is old school pizza!!!! It tasted like Angela T's pizza from Sharpsville back in the day.Staff was polite, crust was perfect, crisp with a little pull. Ratio of toppings was exactly right. This was our first time here but we will definitely be back.“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
Fox's Pizza Den Pizza •
1905 Wilmington Rd Suite C, New Castle - 7.12 miles

“Having a foxs in new castle is great haven't eaten at one in 12 years at least. I ordered delivery tonight. The food overall was just as amazing as I remembered however the workers may have been a bit overwhelmed. It started out my delivery order was wrong the driver took it back so I decided to go there myself because the driver said they were extremely busy. And I wasn't sure how long til I got my new pizza. Upon getting there I explained what happened and a guy i believe a worker called him angel checked on my new pizza and the driver did relay a message about my order so it was made quickly. I didn't ask for a partial refund because it's a new place and a dang good pizza eatery that other pizza places willhave to get it together to compete with. The workers I did encounter were nice another reason I didn't want a refund. No attitudes or rude facial expression when saying about my order being messed up. This place is highly recommended. I ordered a champion half cheese half pepperoni( 16 slices) and cheese sticksParking: Minimum number of spots availables to park“

4.2 Good14 Reviews
Loading...
map Map