49 Best Italian Restaurants near Sewickley

“Came here for a belated birthday celebration with a friend. Highly recommend! Great food and fabulous service. I got the pork chop, which was perfectly cooked and came with a terrific sauce. My friend got the flatbread and the mushrooms as a meal and was very happy. Our waiter was super personable and kept a close eye on everything - I was really impressed by his attention to detail.
Keep in mind that tables do have a 90 minute limit. The hostess came up and very politely reminded us at our time and asked us about dessert. We said no, but they kindly brought us some ice cream with candles to celebrate (just a lovely detail!)
I would 100% come back again and I'd love to check out the patio which looks like a lovely, quiet, natural spot to enjoy dinner.“

“Great food and great service!“

“Nice atmosphere - excellent crab cakes and stuffed salmon..Filet melted in your mouth..Would highly recommend!“

“Just stopped for the first time and got some sandwiches and cookies. Omg that hoagie was good as hell!!! I’ll definitely be back!“

“Spectacular service, the food is outstanding, and great ambiance.“

“Was very surprised, because the establishment is small. The food was excellent. I had arugula salad with vinaigrette and Chicken Parmesan. I wanted every last desert behind the glass counter. No bad choices! I chose cannoli, my wife had the tiramisu 😋“

“Excellent service and better then the orginal monte cellos in cranberry“

“Stellar Italian street cuisine. Love the diavolo sauce and probably the best meatballs I’ve had. Many more dinners await 🤤“

“I like it a lot, but my 86-year-old full blooded Italian mother loves it. thankfully I pick up extra slices for her to bring to her house on the weekend.“

“Staying at a hotel in town, utilized Uber eats since my truck and trailer are not restaurant friendly. Ordered lasagna. WOW. Best lasagna I’ve had in a long time. Good mix of sauce, meat, noodles, and cheese.“

“HIGHLY recommend. My boyfriend doesn’t like or eat fish-he loved/eat the bourbon glaze salmon I ordered. I don’t like steak or eat meat-I eat some of his filet. The food was outstanding and the drinks are amazing! Romantic vibes and the service is amazing. A must stop!“

“We had a fantastic dinner. The service was perfect and the manager, Jason, is more than accommodating. Made you feel right at home. 🤩🔥🤩“

“Food is amazing. Owners is a j*** to the employees, though. They work so hard and he just yells at them.“

“This place saved my butt last minute by hosting my son’s birthday when the weather was not cooperating for an outdoor party. We had around 38 people in their banquet room for pizza and cake and it went great. The owner and staff made accommodations to fit our needs while staying within budget. I’m so thankful for the family and staff that operates this place.“

“Our new favorite restaurant to visit in Pittsburgh! Everything we’ve tried has been delicious, but the fried zucchini…. to die for!👌 *chef’s kiss*“

“Haven’t had a bad meal yet!!!“

“Absolutely amazing cuisine! The owner was sweet & did magic 🪄 tricks for the kiddos as we awaited our food. Homemade! Absolutely delicious! Cannot wait to go back! Check comments for pictures 😊 🍕 🍝“

“What a surprise! My daughter chose this for her moving away dinner…we had never been there so wasn’t sure what we would get… it was absolutely delicious! It’s a very rare occasion that you find a restaurant that can properly cook seafood, especially mussels and scallops…. They did a fantastic job. Our server Alexis W. was awesome as well!“

“I really enjoying going to Monte Cello's Wexford for lunch & dinner! Their staff is incredible and personal. My favorite menu items are the buffalo chicken rolls, walnut and apple salad, white pizza, bbq chicken pizza & they have these amazing fresh cookies which I really enjoy! I highly suggest you check them out next time you are craving pizza.“

“Excellent all around. We travel around the east coast for football a bit and always seem to hit an olive garden when we go away. This one has been one of the best we've been at! Service was fast, food delicious, waitress was attentive and the atmosphere was excellent!“

“Amazing Food, Great customer service. Definitely will eat there again!“

“Great food and service. Portions were perfect.“

“Pizza is very good“

“Best pizza and RANCH ever!! Like seriously though, all their food is delicious(mild bone in wings, Italian hoagie, ff, pastas, etc). I pick up my food 80% of the time, but when I've eaten in at the bar ... The bartender was A++! Dining room service is 50/50, depends on the server n how busy they r. But the food is always bangin!“

“The food is great, all homemade. Big fish sandwich for lent. The pasta is delicious. You will not leave without food for another meal. The portions are so big.“

“I absolutely love their pizza wish I lived closer“

“Just what we needed for an afternoon snack and drink. Friendly waitstaff, quick service, clean, efficient and the red sauce and spinach dip were very good. My friend also placed a to go order that was ready for her when we were ready to leave.“

“This is my first time ever going to DNG’s. It was late night and at a pinch and they did not disappoint. They are one of the few places that still do Sicilian cut pizzas and their pepperoni is awesome. More importantly their sauce was fantastic!“

“Totul perfect ! Mâncare, ambient, personal ! 😘😘🫶o sa revin cu drag“

“I only order from Angelia's. The food is great. The delivery person is always on time and very nice“

“We sat on the outdoor covered patio on a perfect day. It was great! Thin crust pizza was very good and not greasy crust! We had sausage and zucchini pizza. It was excellent. Sauce is a little spicy but delicious! Debbie our server was so nice and helpful!“

“Amazing food and the friendliest service… We will definitely be back!!!“

“This was my first time going here to eat ?. The menu has a alot of options for your appetite ?. It took me at least 2 times to really decide what to eat with out changing my mind. When I finally decided, the food was hot, fresh, seasoned. I wanted to get more but they were about to wrap and close .lol So next time I come to your restaurant I will make sure to order 2 orders of the STEAK ROLLS with blue cheese dressing. Yummmmmm. Thank You for filling up my stomach and pleasing my taste Buds ? ? ?! Be Well“

“Rachel was our waitress. She was awesome. It was busy and she didn't skip a beat. Food was delicious. Here on vacation from Michigan. Thank you.“

“great staff, fabulous food!“

“Moved to Wexford last year and noticed this hole-in-the-wall pizza shop but could never find time to stop until today. Got a pizza and italian hoagie. For $28, I was pleased. Good pizza. Hoagie was decent. Nice family run shop. I'll find a way to stop again.“

“BEST steak calzones!! So yummy!“

“Some of the BEST gyros around!!!“

“We have been there twice in the last week and it was GREAT! Best steak hoagie on the planet. We also really liked Ashley our server.“

“Never sent condiment for Wings that we specifically ask for. They should be ashamed of what those wings looked like that Armstrong sent to me. There were no meat on the bones, so tiny especially what I paid for. I also ordered stuffed Mushroom with Crabmeat. No lemon was sent with the Mushrooms. You want down hill in my opinion. I will not be coming back.“

“The team at Conway Pizza are friendly & welcoming,. No matter what I have ordered it has always been phenomenal. Everything homemade! I always order more so I can have leftovers!! So excited because it is soup season! My freezer will be filled! Yum yum!!“

“The gentleman who always takes my to go order is always so nice and friendly everytime! You can tell he is always is doing a great job. I get the deluxe cheese steak on pizza bread and it is so delicious and great size and one of my my favorite places to get a steak sandwich!! The Kris loaded fries are just that. One of the few places that aren't skimpy on toppings and I just love the fries that are slightly seasoned. They actually are my favorite place to get loaded fries. The white pizza is delicious as well! I have never had a bad experience which is unheard of for a place. I can't wait to try their wings. Thanks for doing such a great job all around!“

“Had the custom deluxe when we were staying around the corner at the Super 8, and it was incredible!!! Absolutely would recommend!!!“

“Excellent customer service from start to finish. Very attentive waitresses knowledgeable on what they are serving. Excellent menu not overwhelming.“

“Stopped in here to grab some early dinner and got a small pizza with some wings. First things first, their homemade mild sauce for the wings is very good. The pizza was typical pizza to me, but the veggies were all fresh and that sets them apart from almost all other locations. I will be doing the Italian sandwich for dinner tonight.“

“Good food, reasonable prices, and nice staff. Quick service“

“The staff was really friendly and even helped me take my big order to my car. The food was really good and you definitely get a ton of it for the money! It was even better than the Italian pizzeria I had this past weekend in NYC. I really want to buy a t-shirt! The forgedabatit one is hilarious! Can I buy one? lol 😆“

“This place is the best. I haven't had pierogies that tasted like my grandma's since she passed. So trust: This place is legit if you are looking for authentic pierogies. I purchase from her every holiday and the family loves it. The owner is a sweet woman, too. Not understanding the snobby reviews here - she certainly doesn't deserve the rudeness.“

“We have eaten here almost every time we are in Pittsburgh and we LOVE it!!! Not only is the food delicious but we just watch in awe as the staff all work super hard to give excellent service. Our waitress Jordan told us she had been here 10 years! She is a bartender, waits tables, and they all do whatever it takes. I’m full and happy leaving with the containers and bag she gave us. So glad we came….again!“