37 Best Bakeries near Strasburg

“Michael's Homemade Breads are the absolute best breads in the area! Their cinnamon raisin Bread is so delicious, it keeps me driving an hour away just to get it! Love it!“

“This was something like my 3rd visit. It is an absolute must when coming to Amish Country. Make it a jumping off place for your exploring. The baked goods are amazing, the service is friendly, efficient and well thought out and the ambiance lets you begin to feel that you have really stepped away from your busy, modern life. Great for families, tourists or those who just want a to slow down.“

“Fabulous cream cheese bialys! Better than I can find in NY.“

“The cake I ordered for my parents 50th anniversary was amazing! So good and decorated beautifully! Thank you!“

“Everyone at our wedding LOVED the cupcakes!! They were such a hit. We can’t recommend Sweet Shenanigans enough!!“

“I ordered my Daughter's birthday cake and I was more than surprised. It was a superb work and the cake was delicious. The best part was the wonderful customer service. Martin is the best, he heard all my ideas, comments, gave me feedback and guidance. I will definitely come back for my future events. I cannot stress enough that this is a wonderful jewel in downtown Lancaster.“

“HOY NOS DIMOS CITA EN ESTA PANADERÍA, AÑORANDO UN SANDWICHITO BORICUA Y ¿ADIVINEN QUÉ? NOS FUIMOS FUIMOS HASTA CON QUESITOS, BISCOCHITOS, FLANES, EMPANADILLAS DE PIZZA Y PORRR SUPUESTO, UNA LIBRA DE PAN. LO MÁS CERCANO A UNA PANADERÍA EN LA ISLA ES ÉSTA EN LANCASTER. TODO RICO Y FRESCO A PRECIOS MÓDICOS. ¡100% RECOMENDADOS!“

“I loved this place, the have delicious pie, they also sell jam, sauces, and other foods of the Amish tradition, they have a lot of things you can use for gift or just souvenir. The service is very good, also the coffee was amazing.
I totally recommend.“

“Jenna’s cake for my dad’s 70th birthday was truly one of a kind! I wanted to incorporate some of my dad’s favorite things, and Jenna helped me create the most special, personalized cake for him. He absolutely loved it, and it made him feel so special.

Not only was the design perfect, but the cake itself was the most delicious I’ve ever had! It was so moist, perfectly balanced—not overly sweet, just incredibly tasty. We even put some in the fridge, and four days later, it was still just as moist and delicious!

I would absolutely recommend Jenna for any event, big or small. If I were getting married again, she’d be the one to do my wedding cake. She’s that good!“

“Everything these folks make is friggen amazing!! I think I’ve tried almost everything and there isn’t a single item that I wasn’t really impressed with. Glad to see it in some our local grocery stores too. FYI they sell their pizza dough if you’re looking for something fun to with the kids. Check out that fresh rosemary :)“

“They are very good. My Husband is from Philly and he always says that fresh taste and smell makes my meatball or steak sandwiches awesome
Prices are posted for every size. We have called the day before and ordered for youth group or summer camp with NO problem. Just remember Cash only.“

“Inclusive and delicious! My favorite combo!“

“My friend and I stumbled on this lovely spot while spending the day in Lancaster. The selection was amazing, the staff friendly and helpful and the quality of the pastries was outstanding. I got a sfogliatelle and it was one of the best I've had.“

“Great people, found them while delivering over the years as a truck driver.If you have a farmers market in your area with Amish selling cheesecake, cakes, and torts most of it is Pellmans, if you can't make it out to the New Holland area“

“My sister told me about your Fruit English Muffins, which she gets at Pine View Dairy. I tried them and fell in love with them. While I was there, I saw the bagels and tried the cheese, they were absolutely delicious. You have a winner in both, the flavors are so good. Keep up the good work.“

“The journey to this bake shop is a story.

We drive into an Amish farm and saw no cars parked, nor a sign telling us where the bakery is. We drive deeper into the barn, almost knocking over the family dog. There were some dogs in cages barking at us, not sure if it was to welcome us, or to warn us.

We saw a guy who seem to work there, or owns the place. He told us that we went too far in, and said “turn around, it’s the red shed”.

We turned the car around, again, looking around to see which of those could be the bakery. We saw a hand written board “open”.

We go in. Shelves were almost empty except for a few trays of whoopie pies and some fry pies in the refrigerator. No one was inside except a box saying “self service”. “Interesting” we thought. Never have we seen such an establishment that was based on trust.

OH yes, how were the pies you say? SO GOOD. Just gotta bake them real good for a little. The whoopie pies are also really moist and cream not coyingly sweet.“

“Everyone is very nice beautiful campus!!“

“I loved Mr. Sticky's! The sticky buns are a delightful treat—warm, gooey, and bursting with flavor. The staff is super friendly, and the quality of sticky buns are wonderful. I grabbed by box that were warm and fresh. Can’t wait to go back for more! Highly recommend!“

“First time here tonight, my husband and i had THE BEST experience! The staff was so sweet and friendly. The chocolate pb pie was delicious, so rich and creamy! My husband had the apple hand pie. Also, amazing! Flaky crust. Soft apples and warmed up just perfectly. Will definitely be back soon to try the savory pies!“

“Unique accent to the local "flavor". Neat, clean, well stocked with only locally made food for that unique experience. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Stop in, a must see that's worth it!“

“My fiancée and I found this place on a whim. We were craving a bagel but didn't want to go across town. The moment you step in, the restaurant is bright and very inviting. Their menu is small but its create when you couldn't decide what you wanted. The breads are for sale and you can call to order a dozen bagels or anything else you might want. The bagels are a little small but very flavorful. The egg sandwich may need some sort of dressing but the ciabatta that it is on is so buttery. If you are out for a drive, this is an awesome place to stop. I hear their pizzas are awesome!“

“Arirang Hibachi Steakhouse Dutch wonderland August 16, 2024“

“Went to lancaster today and visited this place...Nice atmosphere...The owner and staff were very friendly, Place was very clean... The empanadas were delicious...must try an alfajore for dessert... Can't wait to visit again.... Thank you, had a great time there.....“

“I bought a coconut cake at Christmas time last year. We didn’t eat it all and decided to freeze some of it. I just got it out of the freezer and thawed it out. The cake was just as moist and delicious as the day we bought it. I didn’t even have it an airtight container. They make an awesome cake. You can freeze it and thaw it out and it is as fresh as the day they make it.“

“We came across Amaranth Bakery at a festival recently. They had quite a selection of GF vegan options available. The brownies were the absolute best that we’ve had. Amaranth knows how to bake!“

“While I like most of Stoltzfus’s items, I’ve been disappointed in their chicken salad. It used to be a staple in our home but seems like they’ve changed the recipe. It’s now so runny with mayo (or whatever they use) that it plops right off our sandwiches. They’ve also seem to cut back on the celery which added a nice contrasting crunch. Please bring back the old recipe.“

“Excellent cakes!! Tracy was very communicative and matched our cake to the reference picture perfectly for my son’s birthday. Will be going here for all of our special occasion cakes moving forward.“

“Awesome breakfast spot - flaky croissants are the best! And the homemade ketchup! Nice outside space to enjoy with friends!“

“I took my partner here for a nice meal and it is a very aesthetically pleasing restaurant and bakery. All the food was delicious but the price point was not as yummy! All in all, I would eat there again but just as soon say stick with the Bakery side so your wallet doesn’t cry!“

“Went to the Mother’s Day brunch buffet today and it was fabulous! Not only was the food absolutely scrumptious, the atmosphere and service staff was so pleasant and welcoming. Thank you for such a great experience!PS can we just talk about the biscuits and gravy ??? TO DIE FOR!!! My nephew couldn’t get enough“

“After seeing a lot of advertisements on Facebook I decided to go ahead and place an order (good job marketing team).
I ordered a six pack of assorted cookies. The order shipped right away and was at my door within in couple of days. The cookies arrived carefully packaged and everything got to me in one piece. Right away I tried the S'more cookie and... O M G!! Everything exceeded my expectations. Fresh, delicious, and pretty much the perfect cookie. I will definitely be a returning customer.
**Editing**
I was about to place another order and noticed that some cookies are only available if you subscribe to their cookie club. The monthly cost is a bit steep, but I figured I'd try it for the minimum three months. Once reached check out and saw that it was going to cost almost two hundred dollars for the order, I immediately hit the brakes and decided that I couldn't justify paying that much money for cookies. Especially because I have no way to know if I would even like the flavors without trying them first. Can your average customer really afford this? I'm still giving you five stars because your cookies are incredible. But please consider allowing customers to order any of your flavors without needing to subscribe.“

“Hands down the best, really handcrafted coffee I've had in a VERY long time. The guy running the show recommended trying the house chai, and I was blown away. I didn't know chai could be that good. Also had a cappuccino, and I was just as impressed. The owner(?) was super friendly, helpful, and kind with everything. It's a bit off the beaten track if you're driving, but I recommend finding this place and stopping in!“

“Wanted something refreshing and had the strawberry lemonade lotus. Was absolutely delicious!“

“Cheesecake/ carrot cake/ scones/truffles/dough rings, in fact she will bake anything you ask her to, nothing is to much trouble for MaryAnn and everything is fresh and delicious“