35 Best Ice Cream Shops near Warrendale

“We had a wonderful time this morning having coffee and visiting together. Generoasta reserved a spot for us and we were very well served! Greater Harmony Chorus loves supporting our local businesses and getting to hang out together in the process! Thank you!“

“The kids loved it! Nice local shop.“

“Custards is the best! Kirk and his fam do great job! Definitely go here!!“

“We recently visited The Milkshake Factory in Pleasant Grove, and it was an absolutely delightful experience from start to finish. The moment we walked in, we were warmly welcomed by Micah, the owner, who made us feel like family. It was as if he had known us for years! Micah’s hospitality was unmatched. He generously offered us free samples of their incredible chocolate, encouraging us to try as much as we liked. It was such a thoughtful gesture that truly set the tone for our visit. As for the milkshakes, they were out of this world! I indulged in the Bananas Foster Milkshake, which was rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. My wife couldn’t get enough of her Cookie Brownie Fudge milkshake—it was the perfect blend of decadent flavors. Our kids loved their classic Vanilla Milkshakes, which were smooth and delicious. The attention to detail, quality of ingredients, and exceptional customer service made this visit unforgettable. We can’t wait to return and try more of their amazing offerings. If you’re in Pleasant Grove, do yourself a favor and stop by The Milkshake Factory—you won’t be disappointed!“

“Very good ice cream, I had a chocolate shake. The only issue is that it’s called “homemade” ice cream, but in fact it’s a commercial product. It’s actually Perry ice cream.“

“Have always loved this place!!! Ice cream 🍦 is awesome 😎“

“Delicious homemade ice cream! We just picked up pints of banana chocolate chip and chocolate raspberry truffle and both were AMAZING! Love this place!“

“I'm lactose intolerant. They really don't have a selection for it. They have a limited selection for it. But they made me a delicious type of mango sorbet topped with strawberries and nuts that was very good ! My boyfriend ordered an ice cream cone 1 scoop which turned out to be what looked like 3 scoops ! Portions are generous and prices are decent ! Recommended!“

“If you have never been to the Icebox Creamery in Zelienople, you are missing out. The ice cream is handmade with all natural ingredients. The flavors will change with some frequency but there are a handful of staples as well. Today my wife enjoyed a scoop of pumpkin pie paired with a scoop of blueberry cobbler and I had a scoop of peanut butter and a scoop of chocolate marshmallow. We both were very satisfied with our choices and had to leave before we ordered more. It’s that good. So if you are in the Zelie area, stop in the Icebox Creamery (cash only) and pamper your palate.“

“Rita’s in Wexford is awesome. Delicious treats. Great service.“

“We love everything about Graeter’s. The people, the yummy ice cream, the people, the tables inside and out and the people.“

“Good service, delicious ice cream, want to go again and again and again“

“Woo Hoo Awesome service.. great atmosphere ..Amazing Food.. I Always have a great time when I'm there..plenty of parking!!!!“

“Love love the frozen custard. Great flavors and super people who work there. I’m a regular!“

“Have always loved this place!!! Ice cream 🍦 is awesome 😎“

“Looks are deceiving on this one! Old fashioned hand scooped homemade ice cream or soft serve with many different toppings. You can also get the Italian ice with or without gelato which also comes in many flavors. Everything was delicious and perfectly made! 10 out of 10 on price and quality! Will definitely be coming back for more before they close for the season on October 5th“

“I love the chocolate raspberry truffle, cherry vanilla & butter pecan.“

“This Bruster's is far better than any other ice cream shop in the area. It was "Every Given Sunday" but after Covid, they closed permanently. This place has excellent mango sorbet and Chocolate ice cream shakes and pint size. Friendly. Helpful and the ice cream tops every place I've been too. Cool Cones is awful and can't compare!“

“Best Ice Cream cakes ever!!! My family loves them🥰“

“Great customer service. Suggested they get a high chair. Wrote back and later that day was able to get one! Just the response and effort was fantastic. Also, great service while I was there!“

“We LOVE Millie’s ❤️ my husband and I are dairy free and they have the absolute best DF ice cream!! We never get to go to actual ice cream shops because they usually don’t offer dairy free ice cream, but Millie’s does and you can’t even tell it’s dairy free. If I could go everyday I would 🤤“

“Delicious Strawberry ice cream cone 😋 Got a pint of Peanut butter parfait to go! My favorite!“

“The cornhole golf was "out-of-this-world" fun!!“

“My fiancé’s first time!! He’ll be back!“

“Great quality drinks, syrups and products AND EVEN BETTER are the people! We absolutely love this spot ♥️“

“Wonderful customer service. Very warm and welcoming. Atmosphere is great and coffee was excellent.“

“I stopped into SIMPLE SUBS today. I CHOSE A CHEESESTEAK SUB. IT WAS DELICIOUS. IF YOU HAVE NEVER STOPPED IN YOU SHOULD TRY IT OUT CUZ IT'S GREAT.“

“I love Sincerely Yo Gurt but they weren’t very sincere today. Allow me to tell you the tale of 2 wonderful young women who were left wonderless infront of a Yo Gurt store. Due to the lack of sincerity in the frozen Yo Gurt community the only location within a leap, hop, skip, or jump is no more. So these two teens trek to a terrifying town only to be terrorized by a singular girl. As they walked up to a neon less sign they felt the lack of neon in their core. This could only mean one thing, it’s gonna be a Gurt-less night. And dear, you know who you are(the girl who decided to lock that door 40 min before she was supposed too): ponder what you did today and the effect it had on others. The Yo Gurt scale will forever read zero cause I’m never coming back. Sike! You thought!! Sincereley Yo Gurt:0 Milkshake Factory:1“

“Tremendous grub, short weight at a fair price. Will be a regular customer“

“Great cookies!“

“Yummy place with delicious treats for your sweet tooth. ~

Service is fast and friendly.

Icecream is very good, as well as the various popcorns.

They also sell some really cool homemade crafts too.

Recommend if you want to treat yourself right.

Kid-friendliness: Always good to give your kids a little treat here.“

“Crumbl left me feeling a little crumbled. I feel this place is more of an experience than anything else. Presentation is great, service was pleasantly standard, and the atmosphere felt Gucci. Their offerings are extremely sweet, sugar overload. Tasted as if there were too many unneeded ingredients. However, your mileage may vary if you’re into enamel tingling sweet. I did the experience, but am left with a lack of interest to return for more. Wouldn’t be a bad place to take a special someone or to grab a big order for a social event. Recommend for the experience and first timers.

Parking: Parking is not an issue.

Kid-friendliness: Family (kid) approved.

Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap accessible.“

“Best pumpkin spice latte! Food is amazing. Best Cafe!!“

“Employees very friendly😊👍“

“My wife and I always enjoy stopping by the Dairy Queen in Cranberry—it’s one of our favorite spots for a sweet treat! The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the ice cream is always fresh and delicious. Most recently, we tried the Superman Blizzard, and it did not disappoint! It was colorful, creamy, and packed with flavor—definitely a fun and nostalgic twist that brought back childhood memories. Whether we’re grabbing a classic cone or trying something new, this DQ never lets us down. Highly recommend for anyone in the area looking to satisfy their sweet tooth!“