26 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Middlesex

“So good!!! we love this place“

“I was so hungry for good ny style pizza. I found it. I'll be coming back here. I think they are closing for the month of September. I'll tell you what, I'll be back in October!!! Please leave your comments about their food! Thank you. Steven “

“I remember when they were in the Kmart mall in Meadville. We happened to be in Sharon today and when I made the connection, I knew we had to stop! It’s exactly like I remembered it. Pizza by the slice in every combination you could think of and absolutely delicious. She even pointed out the signage from their Meadville spot and joked about still having a freezer from Montgomery Wards. I’m so happy we stopped and we will be back.“

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.“

“Everytime I’ve been to Jimmy Neno’s I’ve never had a bad meal. The food is delicious and has so much flavor. I got the Most Tasty roll and forgot to take a pic before I ate half of it lol it’s soooo good!!! If you’ve been thinking about it, don’t wait any longer. You won’t be disappointed!“

“fast courteous service, food was great!! and beer was cold!“

“The pizza is delicious and the staff is great! always a wonderful experience!“

“The best pizza around. Never disappointed“

“I love pizza joes. Never have had any issues at all!!! But ordered a stromboli last night. Wasnt the same ! Top had slits in it and the inside was not done!“

“We had 10 of us that visited this restaurant on a Monday evening. Service was a little slow I think they were just maybe short staffed. Food was great. Price was fantastic. And you certainly do not leave their hungry. We will return the next time we are in that area.“

“Awesome food. Nice and clean atmosphere.“

“By far the best mom/pop pizza I’ve had! My husband and I were passing through and needed some good pizza in our systems. We got the chicken bacon ranch pizza, brick pizza, cheese bread, and cinnamon dough bites! The dough bites reminded me of elephant ears and the breading was so light and fluffy. The pizzas were cooked perfectly with a perfect amount of toppings, and the cheese bread was to die for!!! We met the owners and they were really nice with some good knowledge of the area as well. I highly recommend anyone passing through to check this place out!“

“Absolutely one of the top thin crust pizzas in the area!! Closet pie to a traditional New York thin crust and I would put it in the same class. This is one of my new go to!“

“hmmmm YUM sloop good. love the sauce. usually me and Tonya pick off the cheese then lick the sauce right off the bread. After we dunk the bread in French or Catalina dressing or feed it to our dog Grover Cleveland name him after the pres. I would eat sauce if they sold in stores with a spoon... good stuff nuff said“

“We moved back home from Florida about 2 months ago and have had quite the time finding good food in the Shenango Valley. One of the best places I can whole-heartedly recommend is Marchelloni's on Buhl Farm Road. We were looking for a pizza sub, as it always was a staple "back in the day", and of course, you ask for one in Florida and they look at you like you're from Mars (and I don't mean outside of Pittsburgh). 2 weeks ago, we got our first pizza sub in 32 years, double meat, mind you, and it was so delicious, we were blown away. The pepperoni was delicious, the cheese was melty and bubbly, the sauce was spot-on, and the bread, oh, my goodness, the bread was incredible. crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and the flavor was everything we remember about "up north" bread, and though my husband is a bread freak, I usually can take or leave it. This was something very special, and it will keep us coming back to Marchelloni's. The staff is very friendly, and the blonde lady has an awesome smile! Cheers!“

“Customer service is amazing!! The guys working there are so nice and friendly. I go there at least 2 to 4 times a week. The slices are great! When they have cookies they are amazing!! Drinks if you need it. Any kind of chicken pizza is my go to.

Wheelchair accessibility: No step up or down to get in the door.“

“I am fussy about my pizza and Four Star Pizza is worth bragging about! I camp up here all summer and tried quite a few other pizza places, none can rate even close to Four Star. I've also tried their mushrooms, husband had Stromboli. Never disapointed!“

“Love there food but really not a fan of where it's located at. They get crazy busy with other customers and sometimes the line is long to pickup due to the convenience store.

Great food and friendly people, if the location had a separate pickup section it would be 5 stars!

Vegetarian options: Anything can be ordered without meat but if you are restricting dairy not the place to go. If you don't try their veggie pizza, it's great!“

“Hubbard Domino's is probably the best dominos in the area in my opinion. My food is always made correctly, hot when I get it and it is always a quick delivery. So far every delivery driver I've had has been super polite, well spoken, and just all around nice.“

“Fantastic food and service! highly recommend!“

“Great pizza, but never consistent. I realize new peeps all the time. But get a system Just had a pierogi too dry not enough potatoes☹️ but I ate it all🤪“

“Never really had a bad experience from Marcos. Friendly & efficient. Shocked at all the bad reviews.“

“Always great food. A staple of Union Mo and thier gravy is rib sticking and homemade“

“Delicious and authentic. Customer experience is 10/10!“

“Fantastic pizza! I got the poormans style pizza and i don't think a pizza could be made better. And the dining room is reminiscent of pizza shops in the 90s which I love. Very clean too. I didn't expect it to be this good, I may have to stop back again tomorrow for more.“