29 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Middlesex

“So good!!! we love this place“

“I’ve had scottos since they were in the mall when I was a child! Their food is amazing and brings me back to my childhood. My husband and I now take trips to the restaurant (we live almost 40 mins away) to have it every now and then. So worth it!“

“I remember when they were in the Kmart mall in Meadville. We happened to be in Sharon today and when I made the connection, I knew we had to stop! It’s exactly like I remembered it. Pizza by the slice in every combination you could think of and absolutely delicious. She even pointed out the signage from their Meadville spot and joked about still having a freezer from Montgomery Wards. I’m so happy we stopped and we will be back.“

“Try the Sharon steel sausage sandwich. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.“

“Excellent variety of delicious handmade food, lots of adult beverage options, friendly and attentive service and really FUN atmosphere! Always something going on at Jimmy Neno's!“

“fast courteous service, food was great!! and beer was cold!“

“My husband and I are new to this area and actually we live in town next to where this place is. We have tried many good Pizza places but this place is awesome! The wings are excellent and we came from the south and love Chicken Wings. They do many different kinds and we love them. Pizza was fantastic and we will be back.
Patty Gorman“

“highly recommend. We stupid in there monday and really enjoyed it. Best pizza we had in a long. The Employees were very friendly.“

“Absolutely one of the top thin crust pizzas in the area!! Closet pie to a traditional New York thin crust and I would put it in the same class. This is one of my new go to!“

“The pizza is delicious and the staff is great! always a wonderful experience!“

“This was our first time ordering from here. We got 2 traditional trays. One with extra cheese and pepperoni and one with extra cheese and sausage. They were very good! Family liked it. We will definitely order from here again. We want to try the veggie.“

“Stopped in for the first time tonight! Awesome pizza! If you haven’t tried it yet I highly recommend it!“

“My family has eaten Luigi's pizza since it opened in Farrell. The best pizza we have ever eaten!“

“I love pizza joes. Never have had any issues at all!!! But ordered a stromboli last night. Wasnt the same ! Top had slits in it and the inside was not done!“

“Great pizza, but never consistent. I realize new peeps all the time. But get a system Just had a pierogi too dry not enough potatoes☹️ but I ate it all🤪“

“Pizza and wings were very good, I'm a Jersey transplant so I've been trying all the local pizza places! Great flavor! Very good sauce and cheese ratio on the particular pie I ordered 9 in round I think, very doughy in a great way! Not New York or Jersey style but very very good! Will be back again and again!“

“hmmmm YUM sloop good. love the sauce. usually me and Tonya pick off the cheese then lick the sauce right off the bread. After we dunk the bread in French or Catalina dressing or feed it to our dog Grover Cleveland name him after the pres. I would eat sauce if they sold in stores with a spoon... good stuff nuff said“

“toppings were left off and Stromboli came with the smallest amount of filling I've ever seen...6 pepperoni..literally I could count them..on a lg deluxe Stromboli...never ever again..I've never thrown away so much food in my life...0 stars not 4 stars 🤢🤮“

“Great pizza! Sauce was very good and the pizza baked perfectly. Only downfall was the size of the pies. We're a family of 4 (two which are teens) and we had just enough ordering 2 pies. My fault was not asking the size. Also note, to get in to the pizza pickup spot, go to the bar entrance, ring the bell and when the door opens, go into the kitchen located on the left just as you walk in.“

“We had a take out order and it was ready fast!! Super fresh and absolutely delicious!!“

“Very chill spot. The ladies at the register are super nice and sweet. And so are the people on the pizza side making this amazing food. I must say this spot has the best Wings in the area. Always crispy; amazing flavors and the price point is very reasonable. The pizza is here is great! The only small recommendation would be if the pizza crust was a bit more greasier. I love that pan/deep dish style where the crust is nice and greasy. So delicious.
Not only do I like the potato wedges called Joes but so does my pup!“

“Our favorite pizza in the valley“

“It's actually the first time we get a PAN and the toppings were delicious we always get extra toppings and there was extra toppings on top of extra top we didn't even ask for like extra cheese but we got it 😋 but I think I rather Go back to hand toss🤔 Just because the Middle was really doey it looked like it wasn't fully cooked we had to keep picking pieces off of it but we ate it because the rest was fine we never have a problem With this Domino's!!“

“3 sizes of pizza to order from. 6”, 12”. Forgot the other size. You can’t build your own pizza only has a select menu. I am a meat lovers guy and couldn’t order it for them to make so we all ate one of there signature pizzas, 🍕 Hawaiian. 8. The bar was loud when they were watching sports. Definitely good pizza.
A lot of people were ordering takeout. A lot of food was being picked up.“

“Never really had a bad experience from Marcos. Friendly & efficient. Shocked at all the bad reviews.“

“Best homemade lasagna in the Pa. /Ohio area.....all good food and the pasta sauce is homemade fresh daily. This place is a diamond in the rough...older style atmosphere with delicious choices. Prices are very reasonable too!“

“Very nice waitress!!! Food was great and brought out perfectly timed!! The place was clean and very nicely decorated....did not see one bug in the place or in the food! Actually had a great experience! Thank you it's been a while dining out where people actually cared about their jobs!! IT SHOWS!!“