50 Best American Restaurants in Hilton Head Island

“We enjoyed eating lunch and dinner here. We loved how the hostess and waitress addressed you by name. The hostess even remembered our names 3 days later. The drinks, especially the pear drink and the IPA (Hazy) my husband drank were phenomenal. The filet mignon was cooked to his liking. He was very pleased. Not as expensive as eating outside the Imm & Club Resort, which is always a bonus. Great view!“

“Five stars for Fraser’s Tavern — the kind of place you stop into thinking you’ll grab a quick bite, and next thing you know you’re back again because your brain can’t shake the memory of that first meal. I ate here twice on my trip, and honestly, if I’d stayed one more day, they probably would’ve seen me a third time.

The burger is exactly what a burger should be — juicy, flavorful, no circus tricks, just honest perfection on a bun. Pair it with an ice-cold beer and you’ve got the kind of meal that resets your entire outlook on the day. And the service? Absolutely top notch. Friendly, fast, and dialed in without being over the top — the kind of staff that makes the whole place run smooth.

Fraser’s Tavern quietly becomes one of those spots you look forward to without even realizing it.“

“The food is delicious! Definitely a must try while visiting Hilton Head.“

“The food was once again excellent. Service was very good! Love the Dean Martin Rat Pack area in the back. They sat us at the same table as last year. So many good food choices!“

“From the moment we walked in, the hospitality from Louis and her team made us feel genuinely welcome, she’s not only a wonderful host but clearly the heart of this incredible place and the foundation behind it. The atmosphere was warm, intimate, and full of soul.

The food was phenomenal! My prosciutto-wrapped scallops were cooked to absolute perfection, and every flavor on the plate felt intentional and beautifully balanced.

The live music was the highlight of the evening — a talented father-and-son duo, with the father on saxophone and the son on bass, created magic together. Their chemistry and musicianship brought such joy and energy to the room.

It’s rare to find a spot where the food, music, and people all align so perfectly! The Jazz Corner absolutely nailed it. We’ll be back every chance we get.“

“Kari was our AMAZING waitress for our 2nd anniversary dinner! She handled all of our requests with ease, got us a personalized dessert, and even took photos of us at sunset. We couldn’t have asked for a better server, meal, or experience to celebrate!“

“The food was fantastic. I had the broiled and blackened seafood platter. Very good. The cheese grits were also very good.“

“Great Food , Bad. Service .“

“Waitress was absolutely awesome. I had the Blackened fish tacos, and they were awesome.“

“Food is great! My husband and I visit every time we are at HHI. Their clams strips are the best we have EVER had. The hush puppies are delicious as well. This visit I tried their crab cake from the waiters suggestion. It was this "Marylander" approved! Thanks Rich for the recommendation and great service! See you on the next visit.“

“Had a great meal a Catch 22 on Thursday 2/15/24. Food was delicious and our server, Derick, was the best.“

“Love this place. Oysters are so good and the service is great“

“We had the most enjoyable dinner. Atmosphere was great! Our server Jessica was fantastic! Dinner was delicious! 5 stars!! Loved it!!“

“We absolutely loved the house that we rented from Beachside getaway for Thanksgiving ! It was perfect for our family. There was plenty of space and the children especially loveed the pool and hot tub! The staff at Beachside getaway were wonderful to work with and so very nice. Our house was a perfect location great for biking to Harbourtown and everywhere else. I will definitely rent from Beachside getaway again.
Anne“

“Unbelievable hidden gem in Bluffton, SC. Impeccable appointments throughout the inn. Decor and artwork are spot on. Incredibly available and friendly staff who seem proud to be a part of this property. Great beds, perfect water pressure in shower and a perfectly stocked snack pantry of homemade goodies ranging from sweet to savory. If you enjoy fabulous dining, great shops and fabulous art galleries- well this location cannot be beat. Shout out to Katie and Bonnie who made us feel completely at home in their southern hospitality.

Rooms: Plush, elegant, comfy and incredibly appointed.

Walkability: Super convenient walking distance to all the magic downtown Bluffton has to offer.“

“I was surprised to see the comment about the lack of gluten free soy sauce I am a celiac and I mentioned it to them Walked in a couple days later and they had bought some These are good people I wish them much success“

“Great atmosphere only to be enhanced by attentive staff. All of our entrees were cooked to perfection!“

“Jen and Scott and the entire team do a great job. Food is amazing, as is ambiance and service. The butter bread… WOAH! Lots of good places to eat here. Lulu is one of the best.“

“Absolutely wonderful dinner and overall experience. The mini crab claws and fried green tomatoes were so delicious. The server was helpful in providing recommendations on the menu. For dinner, we had the Cajun grouper, blackened red fish, crab cakes, and scallops. Every dish was perfect. For dessert, we tried the strawberry cake-fabulous! Definitely a great spot and we will for sure be back!“

“Great people, amazing food, and good vibes!“

“Our Favorite!! Family friendly, good food, beautiful view, beach front, drinks and more!!“

“This spot on HHI is amazing - we like to find hidden gems, and places where locals go when we travel and we found one of the BEST! Yall have to try Street Meet next time you visit HHI - Service was fabulous and the food was even better! We will be back😍“

“Stop in to Mixx on Main. A hidden gem at the North end of the Island, just off 278. Reasonably priced, great food - American and Mexican fare. No wait, and no reservations needed. Come find us!“

“Shout out to Will the late night bartender! He's attentive even in the hectic busy moments. He's caring and concerened. Bamboo has amazing food, and even better staff! Love you guys, and we'll make itout again the next chance we have.“

“We’ve been coming here for years now, and love the atmosphere. We make it a priority to come visit just to hang out with Allando who’s always so welcoming to our family. By far our favorite place to just hang out and listen to live music.“

“A great family friendly restaurant with great food and awesome service!! You will not be disappointed!!“

“It’s always professional yet family like experience at Roy’s please 10/10 always recommend.!!“

“Great Burgers and sushi. Literally something for everyone in the family. Love Charbar Co.!“

“Staffing tied me over or second to none. I have been going to tide me over for almost 20 years. I've gotten to know the chef who's worked there for 19. I've gotten to know some of the staff that were there for 5 years. They provide treats when you are a continue coming guest. Show the cast some love and they will do the same to you. Enjoy the food here that it is just as good as what they have on Disney's Beach area and for 8:30 to 5:00 you can't go wrong“

“We just moved to Hilton Head this summer and never heard of this restaurant(until today)but decided to try it and oh boy so glad we did! Excellent service, creative menu and cocktails. Truly one of the best restaurants!! Loved it!“

“FANTASTIC HAPPY HOUR! $1 oysters, 50¢ shrimp, $3.00 tacos & more. Always greeted with a smile. If you are looking forward to REALLY good eats & friendly faces... Brother Shuckers is where you should be. And, food is served til midnight....yay!“

“The food was good, but we had a really weird experience at the beginning. My mother and I walked in and requested a table for two. The hostess says “do you have a reservation, we don’t take walk ins.” We didn’t have a reservation so we left. But I was so hungry after just getting off a plane that I didn’t want to search for a new place. I looked up Jane online and made a res for 1:00 (it was 12:49… and there were tons of available time slots). So we walked back in and told the same hostess we had a reservation. Then while we sat and waited 10 min for a table we listened to her tell other walk ins it was a 10 min wait. The whole thing was so strange. I think my salad was good, but definitely annoyed by the initial service (waitress super sweet though).“

“My favorite when visiting Hilton Head Island.“

“We had a fantastic experience at Frosty Frog. Despite arriving right before closing time, the staff kindly squeezed us in which was already a great sign. The atmosphere is fun and family-friendly, with a laid-back charm that makes you feel welcome.

The food was excellent. Everything we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and came out promptly. The drinks were also fantastic. They were well-mixed and refreshing.

Highly recommend!“

“amazing service and food. will return and recommend“

“Five star dining and service. Excellent“

“They now have an excellent gluten-free wrap used with any type of sandwich. Outstanding. Playing golf is not required to eat at this great little gem tucked away at the Palmetto Dunes Robert Trent Jones Ocean Course. I have only eaten a few items so far and will take some time to complete all of the foods listed on the menu that I am able to eat due to celiac. The staff is well versed in the gluten-free selections and is double-checked by Chef Patrick and his staff. The few items I have ordered, the pulled pork is nice and tender with just the right amount of spices without becoming overbearing and still taste the pork flavor. The smoked chicken is excellent. As much as I enjoy pulled pork, I believe the smoked chicken edges out the pork. They also have gluten-free buns, which increases the available options for dining. All barbeque items are excellent and nothing similar to what you may find in Long Island, NY, the birthplace of Chef Patrick, and that is a great thing. Similar to a restaurant located north of Atlanta with an OUT OF BUSINESS sign on the door. The name, New York City Style Ribs. I have never heard of these famous ribs and when I have an opportunity, I think I shall pass.
They serve one of the top two, in my opinion, gluten-free pizza crusts, recipe created by Chef Patrick in the country. Select the toppings, kick back with a cocktail, the pizza will arrive within 10 minites, and it is excellent. Tip; always order gluten-free pizza well done. I am happy to conduct a taste test to determine the best gluten-free pizza, but the other two vying for the number 1 position are located in Palm Springs, CA and Morris Plains, NJ. Will require a travel budget in order to complete the tasting.
There are several beers on tap, more in cans or bottles along with the flavored vodka drinks. With the extensive menu there is no doubt that you will find something to enjoy. Eat good food, drink a few beers while overlooking a portion of the golf course. Outdoor seating is available as well. You will enjoy and if you are unable to decide on what to order, the Staff members are extremely knowledgeable and friendly and will assist. The entrance to the restaurant is the same as the Proshop.“

“It was beautiful and felt so cozy. The food was all delicious!“

“Had a 1028a tee time and had the best experience *both inside and out. Not a member but was treated as such. Food at the pub was marvelous, the fries had a tasty seasoning added and the cod sandwich was perfection. Would recommend to anyone. My son says the grilled cheese was the bomb. Thanks Brianna!“

“Love the ice cream and experience here! Staff is always friendly and helpful. I can always count on Reese to help me choose a flavor!“

“Skillets is absolutely amazing! From the food to the beautiful ambience. Our waitress Marilyn was so kind and attentive. I had the Mahi tacos. They were the best I've ever had. There chef Keman cooked everything to perfection. All of the toppings were homemade. Love that place!“

“Excellent service and wonderful menu options“

“Amazing food great treatment“

“Carlton was our server last night, and I would just like to say that he is amazing! We are here visiting for my husband and I wedding anniversary. He built a rapport and continued to check in with us while our dinner was being cooked and was attentive to detail.“

“Great meal and great service. We have had some less then spectacular dining experiences while on HHI, however this made us forget the rest. Will definitely return next time we are in HHI“

“Wanted to give a 5 star rating to waiter Sarthak , SAM. His service was fantastic. I ordered a chicken sandwich plain , with no seasoning. It was made as I asked and was delicious. He has a great personality and gives excellent service.. Made our dining experience great.“

“12/10 Subs are superb and super filling! Incredible customer service and super friendly staff. The owner was incredible with my 2 year old. Kids or no kids it’s a must try!“

“My wife and I came in late and it was still open. We were seated quickly. Seating was quaint and comfortable. Server was prompt and nice. When the food came they forgot to give us silverware and had to track down a waiter. I ordered the Cuban sandwich which was to have smoked ham, pork belly, pickles, and spicy mustard with melted swiss cheese. My sandwich had a small slice of ham, and more cheese then meat and that's all....it was a snack for a child at best. My wife had the Shrimp and grits this meal was dinner size and was exactly as described and was delicious...I tried asking about my sandwich and was told it was correct though the server had a hard time understanding what I was trying to ask.“

“We have visited this restaurant a few times and it's always been great. With my food sensitivities they have very accommodating. I enjoyed the filet with shrimp and french fries all with no type of dairy or eggs. My wife enjoyed the grits with grilled chicken. Kevin in the kitchen with William at the bar and Kenji as our server did a great job.“

“My encounter with HH Prime at the Omni was the Chef's Playground. They rolled the red carpet out for my husband and I. We have never been pampered like this! Executive Chef Joseph Stewart is brilliant! My husband and I were both stimulated in more ways than one. Our tastebuds were on a fantastic rollercoaster ride that we did not want to get off of. The service was impeccable! I would not have wanted anything different. The amount of detail that went into each dish was thoughtful and the wines paired nicely with each course. Of the entire interaction, Executive Chef Stewart took the time to listen and curate an experience that will always be remembered. Truly, thank you.“