10 Best American Restaurants in Tybee Island

“I just realized that I never left a review, likely because great places often slip my mind when it comes to sharing feedback, it's usually the bad experiences that prompt a review unfortunately. However, I can't express enough how much I love this local gem. They have a fantastic menu, a friendly and personable staff, and the prices are excellent. The only downside is that you need to know when to go, as the locals often fill the place up, finding a seat can be challenging!“

“The Miyagi Beef tacos were absolutely amazing. I also stole my dinning partners cole slaw and it was the best I've had ever. great place, great service, and great tasting food. The outdoor dining also has a play area for the littles so they can run off some more energy.“

“went with a friend. We each got a single scoop of ice cream (no toppings). It was $18.. before being prompted to tip. There is a reason they don't have a complete list of prices listed. The man at the register made a bit of an unappreciated remark. He said the guy dipping ive cream was giving generous portions (which was comical).. and tried to act like we got double scoops. (we did not) won't be back.“

“Amily was the best waitress we had in a long time ,food was excellent,great service“

“Had the grilled jerk chicken sandwich on gluten-free bun it was the best chicken sandwich I ever had definitely recommend.“

“If I could give this restaurant 10 stars, I would. They were short staffed but still found time to call and check in to let us know where they were with our order. After all they went through, I gave them the wrong street address and the wonderful driver stayed on the phone with me to get our location figured out. On top of that, the food was delicious-the pizza was amazing and the wings were perfectly crisp. Thank you, Lighthouse Pizza!!!“

“Amazing Customer Service! Now the shrimp is a whole nother story! Omg! The shrimp platter had me craving shrimp for weeks from our last visit! Had to come back just for the shrimp!!!!! Again Amazing customer service!“

“Quesadillas are my favorite, banana pudding ice cream (YUM)...must try 💯👑🫶 but everything is delicious and people are absolutely wonderful“

“Best experience food you can get in tybee. Veronica,Javetta, and Sherri best servers out there you’ll go to fannie’s“

“A friend told me to check this place out, and I’m so glad I did! Tried alligator for the first time—surprisingly tasty—and the fried seafood combo was fresh and filling. Chill vibes, friendly staff, and a really fun spot overall. Would come back for sure“