50 Best American Restaurants in Hilton Head Island

“I got the Hanger Steak with the mashed potatoes and oh my goodness what an amazing thing to put in my mouth. The steak was delicious and perfectly cooked and the mashed potatoes so creamy!!! 10000/10 and yes it is expensive but I knew what I was walking into.“

“Great service and waitstaff! We had six of us and made sure we were taken care of 💖“

“Mahalia was a very friendly server. She needed a little more confidence to remember to come back with the answers to our questions timely. We asked if the risotto was available as a side, we didnt get the answer therefore we didn't order it. Also she needs to be the server to deliver any extra items of dressing, straws, the check instead of passing the task to another server. Some additional training and encouragement is needed for her. She has great potential. I manage a call center, I would hire Mahalia because she was do well. Food was good, especially the collard greens and gouda grits. Next time we come back to HHI we will come to Frasers.“

“We absolutely loved the house that we rented from Beachside getaway for Thanksgiving ! It was perfect for our family. There was plenty of space and the children especially loveed the pool and hot tub! The staff at Beachside getaway were wonderful to work with and so very nice. Our house was a perfect location great for biking to Harbourtown and everywhere else. I will definitely rent from Beachside getaway again.
Anne“

“Everything was awesome 👌. Saloon burger, Pulled pork, mac and cheese. Will be coming back“

“Unbelievable hidden gem in Bluffton, SC. Impeccable appointments throughout the inn. Decor and artwork are spot on. Incredibly available and friendly staff who seem proud to be a part of this property. Great beds, perfect water pressure in shower and a perfectly stocked snack pantry of homemade goodies ranging from sweet to savory. If you enjoy fabulous dining, great shops and fabulous art galleries- well this location cannot be beat. Shout out to Katie and Bonnie who made us feel completely at home in their southern hospitality.

Rooms: Plush, elegant, comfy and incredibly appointed.

Walkability: Super convenient walking distance to all the magic downtown Bluffton has to offer.“

“That was some of the best food I have ever had. It came out fast and every plate was amazing. Nancy was our server and she was great!“

“Bluffton location is fantastic. Great food, awesome staff! Thank you Katelynn for such wonderful service!“

“I was surprised to see the comment about the lack of gluten free soy sauce I am a celiac and I mentioned it to them Walked in a couple days later and they had bought some These are good people I wish them much success“

“Our Favorite!! Family friendly, good food, beautiful view, beach front, drinks and more!!“

“We have been coming to Hilton Head twice a year for 4 years. This is the first time we visited in the spring and the first time to Celeste Coastal Cuisine. We were absolutely pleased from the greeting as we entered and the great service from our waitress, Deidra. We even received complimentary champagne in honor of our 50th wedding anniversary! The ambience was superb- finally a place where you can hear each other speak and the dinner was delicious. We are due to return in June and it is definitely on our list of restaurants to visit. Thanks again for a wonderful dining experience!“

“It's a simple, no pretense, however quite nice place to grab a bite with a cocktail 🍸.

The location is amazing, right in the middle of the Harbour Town promenade.

They got live music most of the evenings.“

“I’m a die hard Cleveland Browns fan, this place is awesome!! My family took me here as a surprise. Amazing food, awesome Browns pictures, flags, signatures from legendary Browns players. The staff were extremely nice and very welcoming. They have hats, shirts etc. that you can buy. Danny and his staff were so cool to show me everything they had Browns. I will remember this place forever!!! Go Browns!!!“

“This is our 4th vacation to the island and we are major foodies!! Lulu Kitchen was so impressive and I can’t wait to come back next year. We had the lobster mac and cheese for an appetizer and my kids split the fillet and it was so tender it cut with a butter knife! My husband and I split the salmon and added a side of brussels sprouts everything was so amazing and the kids loved the fresh lemonade!“

“Great people, amazing food, and good vibes!“

“Stop in to Mixx on Main. A hidden gem at the North end of the Island, just off 278. Reasonably priced, great food - American and Mexican fare. No wait, and no reservations needed. Come find us!“

“Great Burgers and sushi. Literally something for everyone in the family. Love Charbar Co.!“

“It’s always professional yet family like experience at Roy’s please 10/10 always recommend.!!“

“I came here the first time for a unique jazz / dinner experience. Now 5 years later I don’t stay in Hilton Head without paying them a visit. The food and service is truly phenomenal and their musicians and shows never miss. 5 stars across the board.“

“A great family friendly restaurant with great food and awesome service!! You will not be disappointed!!“

“Staffing tied me over or second to none. I have been going to tide me over for almost 20 years. I've gotten to know the chef who's worked there for 19. I've gotten to know some of the staff that were there for 5 years. They provide treats when you are a continue coming guest. Show the cast some love and they will do the same to you. Enjoy the food here that it is just as good as what they have on Disney's Beach area and for 8:30 to 5:00 you can't go wrong“

“My favorite when visiting Hilton Head Island.“

“Shout out to Will the late night bartender! He's attentive even in the hectic busy moments. He's caring and concerened. Bamboo has amazing food, and even better staff! Love you guys, and we'll make itout again the next chance we have.“

“Great price on oysters, great seafood tacos! Trivia night was fun as well.“

“We just moved to Hilton Head this summer and never heard of this restaurant(until today)but decided to try it and oh boy so glad we did! Excellent service, creative menu and cocktails. Truly one of the best restaurants!! Loved it!“

“Hit the Arthur Hills Grill today for a late lunch with my wife and daughters. We had been meaning to try it out for an actual lunch since it’s right here in our neighborhood, and it offers a Philly Cheesesteak on the menu, unlike Big Jim’s at the RTJ course or the Fazio Grill at the Fazio course. I have been trying to find a reliable place to get a Golf Course fresh Cheesesteak down here for a while and have not found a go to place yet. So, hopped on our bikes and rode over today for a quick lunch. We just ordered 2 Cheesesteaks each with the Fries. We each had half. I’ll have to say it was pretty good, was not the best I have had in a 15 mile radius, but would say it certainly was fresh, and the Amoroso bun was soft and good! it tasted better than what the picture of it may look like. We were all smiling about how it looked kinda funny how they just slap a square of government looking American cheese on top of each half and let it melt in that shape. I used a fork and knife to kind of mix it in a little before I dove in. The fries were nice and fresh too, like the oil was very new, no funky taste and had a great potato taste with a good crispness to them. Definitely something I would go back and get or order at the turn. The guy behind the bar who I gave the order to, did not catch his name, but he was so nice and pleasant to talk to, love that! Thanks for a fun lunch.“

“We had the best experience thanks to Kuldeep! He was a phenomenal server. Despite not learning that the waitlist was first available until we were seated (something we wish the host has told us ahead of time), Kuldeep did an incredible job taking care of us. He was kind, patient, gracious, and happy. The food ended up being great, but Kuldeep made our experience truly lovely. Thank you!“

“This is a hidden gem, you would think it's just a golfing place but inside is big Jim's BBQ. We had an excellent waiter, fast and friendly service. Good food.
Would recommend checking them out for good food at a decent price. I had the nachos and my wife had fish tacos, both were delicious.“

“Amazing atmosphere and AWESOME food (and drinks)“

“It was beautiful and felt so cozy. The food was all delicious!“

“Had a 1028a tee time and had the best experience *both inside and out. Not a member but was treated as such. Food at the pub was marvelous, the fries had a tasty seasoning added and the cod sandwich was perfection. Would recommend to anyone. My son says the grilled cheese was the bomb. Thanks Brianna!“

“Amazing food great treatment“

“Absolutely amazing experience! The food was delicious and the atmosphere was so cozy and quaint. We’ve been twice this month. We can’t wait to go back.“

“amazing service and food. will return and recommend“

“Skillets is absolutely amazing! From the food to the beautiful ambience. Our waitress Marilyn was so kind and attentive. I had the Mahi tacos. They were the best I've ever had. There chef Keman cooked everything to perfection. All of the toppings were homemade. Love that place!“

“What a great company. The coffee cookies and cream and the oatmeal cookie ice cream was PHENOMENAL. We will make sure to add The Ice Cream Cone to our future visits to the island. PS: the tip sign was iconic and I’m sad I didn’t get a picture.“

“Carlton was our server last night, and I would just like to say that he is amazing! We are here visiting for my husband and I wedding anniversary. He built a rapport and continued to check in with us while our dinner was being cooked and was attentive to detail.“

“This was my first time at Black Marlin and it was truly outstanding! My best friend and I get mussels at restaurants all over town, and these are some of the best ones we've had so far in the Hilton Head and Bluffton area!! Bryce was our server and took such great care of us!! (Thank you Bryce for making us bread! 🥹) Overall a great experience and would highly recommend! Will be back for sure!“

“The food was good, but we had a really weird experience at the beginning. My mother and I walked in and requested a table for two. The hostess says “do you have a reservation, we don’t take walk ins.” We didn’t have a reservation so we left. But I was so hungry after just getting off a plane that I didn’t want to search for a new place. I looked up Jane online and made a res for 1:00 (it was 12:49… and there were tons of available time slots). So we walked back in and told the same hostess we had a reservation. Then while we sat and waited 10 min for a table we listened to her tell other walk ins it was a 10 min wait. The whole thing was so strange. I think my salad was good, but definitely annoyed by the initial service (waitress super sweet though).“

“Food is great! My husband and I visit every time we are at HHI. Their clams strips are the best we have EVER had. The hush puppies are delicious as well. This visit I tried their crab cake from the waiters suggestion. It was this "Marylander" approved! Thanks Rich for the recommendation and great service! See you on the next visit.“

“Wanted to give a 5 star rating to waiter Sarthak , SAM. His service was fantastic. I ordered a chicken sandwich plain , with no seasoning. It was made as I asked and was delicious. He has a great personality and gives excellent service.. Made our dining experience great.“

“The food was fantastic. I had the broiled and blackened seafood platter. Very good. The cheese grits were also very good.“

“12/10 Subs are superb and super filling! Incredible customer service and super friendly staff. The owner was incredible with my 2 year old. Kids or no kids it’s a must try!“

“Great Food , Bad. Service .“

“Love the food and service!“

“Waitress was absolutely awesome. I had the Blackened fish tacos, and they were awesome.“

“Our server Andy was excellent as was the Hostess at the Door ! The Food was delicious- off the Healthy Menu we had Orzo & Salmon- had a delicious seasoning on it- loved it! The Small chicken sourced locally with the Carolina sucatash was honestly some of the best I have ever had-beautiful fresh seasoning with a lovely soufle like corn muffin!!! Excellent wine selections and good flor of service- whatever was wrong in previous comments was corrected! The Staff functioned as a Team including the Hostess-well done!“

“Love this place. Oysters are so good and the service is great“

“We love this place! We had our rehearsal dinner and welcome drinks for our wedding here and John and his team went above and beyond! We had the best night! Food is always delicious and staff are great! Views are beautiful as well! Make sure to check this place out!“

“One of the best meals we have had in a couple years. Filet mignon was cooked perfectly, scallops and crab cake were amazing. My husband had the ribeye with mushrooms and a wedge salad and he said they were both great also. 10/10 would recommend.“