12 Best American Restaurants in Custer

“Amazing food. Worth every penny.“

“Absolutely wonderful experience. Delicious meal, beautiful presentation, easy seating and quick service. This was our first time here and will definitely not be our last“

“Best food ! Our favorite place to eat in Custer.“

“The lodge is cozy and we often had the hot tub to ourselves. The lodge is dog friendly with so many great hiking trails right out the door. They have UTV rentals and have a great resturant across the street. We also saw the mountain goats on our way out of the canyon. Our phones did not work unless connected to wifi, which is nice to disconnect.“

“Food was delicious! We tried the chicken sandwich and fish & chips—both were great. It’s a bit pricier than usual, but absolutely worth it for the view and peaceful atmosphere. Sitting in the sun, enjoying a tasty meal, and looking out over the beautiful lake made it such a memorable experience. Definitely a must-visit spot—be sure to eat outside!“

“Amazing“

“The wait staff was attentive, Tatanka stew delicious on a snowy day and the view was gorgeous!“

“Great food at a decent price. Our server was very good and engaging. Definitely would go back to again as well as recommend.“

“Amazing, easy drive thru! It gets busy, but everything was delicious, and they even had little dog bones for the pups. I am sad we have to leave Custer because I want to take this place with us.“

“Best Bar and Restaurant ever! Great service, fun people and relaxing atmosphere. Food was amazing!“

“Outstanding food and reasonably priced (for the area). Beer was excellent also. It was literally the best restaurant we experienced in this area. Food, service, beer - 5 Stars!“

“Sylvan Lake is a great centrally located resort to the many sites. The cabins are a trail or drive from the main hotel.

The cabins have Laundromat on site. 3.75 per wash and 1.75 per dry. Bring quarters, only way to pay. Bring materials unless you want to pay 6-10$ for supplies on top of washes.

The cabins themselves we stayed in two bedroom 1 bathroom. It had kitchenette with oven. It said will sleep ten which would be insane with single bathroom. Firepit. Only the largest cabin has a grill.

Issues: No place to organize luggage outside of floor space. Not enough hooks on walls to manage five people (2 adults, 3 kids). Win some.. lose.. some.

Fishing supplies (worms) available in grocery.

Sunday Gulch trail is strenuous but unique. Lakeshore trail is one mile and offers mild rockscapes for all ages.“