9 Best American Restaurants near Hill City

Peak Bar and Grill American • $
12620 SD-244, Hill City

“This was a great find right next to the Stables at Palmer Gulch where my family did a trail ride. We were seated right away by friendly staff and our food came quite quickly as well. The food was very good. Between our family members (2 adults and kids ages 17, 14 and 11) we got Philly Cheesesteak, chicken bacon ranch wraps, and a beer burger with a variety of sides. We were pleased with the convenience of being right next to the stables and the quantity and quality of the food. It sustained us for the hikes we did in Custer State Park. Our bill plus tip was just over $100 for the 5 of us.“

4.1 Good11 Reviews
LemonGrass Bar & Kitchen Tacos • $
243 Elm Street, Hill City

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Skewers and Chicken
Coconut Chicken Curry
Honey Glazed Shrimp
Chicken Wings
Chicken Say
Dumpling

“Me and my sister needed fast yet delicious take out, and our needs were met!!! The Aisan BBQ tacos, dumplings and wings hit the spot! fast and friendly service (also props on the pineapple margaritas while we waited)“

4.3 Superb224 Reviews
Three Forks | Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
23820 US-385, Hill City

“We had chili dogs. They were huge and served open face on the bun with a great deal of their award winning chili over the top.This was the best chili dog and chili we have ever had!“

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Bumpin Buffalo Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $$
245 Main Street, Hill City

Customers` Favorites

Prime Rib French Dip Sandwich
Brisket Sandwich with Fries
Big Basket of Onion Rings
Bumping Buffalo Burger
Wings with Zesty Sauce
Smokey Bumpin Brisket
Grande Nacho Supreme
Jumbo Shrimp Basket
Bourbon Bacon Glyder
Roast Beef Dinner

“The people and food were both excellent. It was our first stop to try and it was so good we stopped back again another day. We will definitely eat here again next year!“

4 Good492 Reviews
Tin City Saloon Bar • $
240 Main Street, Hill City

“This was our favorite place in Hill City! Raj was our server and he was wonderful! He went above and beyond taking care of our family. It’s not always easy to serve a table with kids. He took time talking with them and treating them to a surprise treat. We had the duck wontons and oh my goodness they were AMAZING! Bison burger and the stew were wonderful! Definitely will go back when we visit again.“

3.7 Good101 Reviews
Hill City Café Steak House • $
209 Main Street, Hill City

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Homemade Cinnamon Roll
Buffalo Steak Dinner
Chicken Fried Steak
Biscuits and Gravy
Soup and Salad Bar
Breakfast Burrito
Hot Beef Sandwich
Breakfast Buffet
Cinnamon Rolls

“We had dinner on 8/15/23 during a stop for our cross-country road trip. It turned out to be one of the best places in the 20+ states we have visited. We ordered the full sampler combo as a meal, as well as a Double Jalapeno Cheeseburger. Food came out in a very reasonable time frame. Atmosphere was very comfortable and inviting. The combo plate was massive, with tons of excellent appetizers and plenty of dipping sauces. I am very picky about burgers, and this was one of the best burgers I have ever had. Everything was very fresh, especially the jalapenos. The burger had a lot of meat - stacked very high. Fries were excellent. But the biggest surprise was the condition of the bathroom. What a welcome surprise to see a restaurant that genuinely cares about the condition and maintenance of its bathrooms. Super clean and immaculate condition. Any food establishment that cares about its bathrooms clearly cares about its customers. Our servers were outstanding as well. HIGHLY RECOMMEND this place!“

3.8 Good581 Reviews
Laughing Water Restaurant American • $
12151 Ave of the Chiefs, Custer - 7.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Burger and Sweet Potato Fries
Tatanka Stew with Fry Bread
Chicken Breast Sandwich
American Indian Taco
BBQ Bourbon Burger
Indian Fry Bread
Chicken Tenders
Bison Burger
Garden Salad
Navajo Tacos

“The wait staff was attentive, Tatanka stew delicious on a snowy day and the view was gorgeous!“

4.1 Good160 Reviews
Grizzly Creek Primitive American • $$
Hill City - 7.76 miles

“I stayed here in September 2026 on adventure vacation to South Dakota and Wyoming. This is a nice uncomplicated campground with smaller sites with tons of trees around you. At least one other visitor had trouble with their popup camper due to the branches. The site I choose wasn't at all flat, but that didn't matter to me, but as I was in a car tent camping that didn't matter to me. The hosts were very pleasant. Be aware that you may be able to be the Recreation.gov app to reserve a spot a head of time, but there are days when all sites are first come gets it basis. There is water close by that was fine, and vault toilets that were pretty clean. No showers. There was some helicopter flying near, but that stopped by evening and really didn't disrupt the grounds at all. If you want to be close to Mt. Rushmore, as it is about 2 miles away, and are reasonably self sufficient you will likely find this a good site to stay at.“

4.2 Good97 Reviews
Sylvan Lake Lodge American • $$$
24572 SD-87, Custer - 6.07 miles

“Wonderfully located state lodge with a ton of amenities! If visiting Custer State Park, the cabins are well appointed - clean with 2 beds and small bath. The lake is amazing and includes a general store. Location is unbeatable to all area attractions. Some cabins have much better views than others so ask!“

3.8 Good321 Reviews

You May Also Like