50 Best Sandwich Shops near Cottonwood Heights

“I work in the building this Toaster's is in. It is a joy to be able to go down stairs and get coffee or lunch from Jasmine! She is hands down one of the very best service employees I've ever been served by. She takes pride in her work, always has a smile, and goes out of her way to make sure your order is perfect. Thank you, Jasmine, for all you do to make everyone's day a little brighter in this business complex. ?“

“Love this store the service is great“

“This place is a whole vibe. The young man making the sandwich noticed the New Jersey devils hat turns out his dad was a big devils fan. Very personal vibe here from the two times I came here.

The food was made as expected and on point. And the restaurant is so well kept this is a textbook execution of a great franchise.

They also efficiently manage the online orders while dealing with the people in the store.

Check it out!!“

“I went in the other night to get a late-evening dinner for my husband and myself. The restaurant was clean and the staff was amiable. Sawyer treated me with respect and kindness. And the sandwiches were, of course, delicious. Thanks to Sawyer and Jersey Mike's!!“

“I come in a couple times week to either there yummy asiago Bagel with cream cheese, or their tuscan chicken sandwhich with fries. I just tried their Chipotle pepper jack cheese burger, and was so delicious, and my work had their clam chowder that was also so delicious. Highly recommend!!“

“Fantastic local market, frequently does unique one night dinners, and pop-up events for local creators and chefs. The breakfast sandwiches are consistently some of the best I’ve had in the valley, and they do some consistent menu items too like Porchetta sandwiches Monday nights. Great vibes, great music, highly recommend!“

“I just love the tuna sandwich!!! love you guys!!“

“Located in a neat venue with a few different vendors. Low key. Feels like a collection of indoor food trucks.

No nonsense, high-quality breakfast sandwiches. Brioche bun is amazing. Sausage was seasoned perfectly.

Definitely deserves its current 4.9/5 star rating.

Parking: Plenty of street parking nearby“

“Keon, Benton, Bryson & Tyler were bomb to work with!! Super high energy, gave the best suggestions! They brewed up #13 at my request, but customized everything about my sub!!

Hot, fresh, fried meats on the grill. Chopped, spiced, and mixed with fried mushrooms, onions, oregano, and seasoned with Red Wine Vinegar before toasting the bread on the grill, melting cheese on top of all of it, and filled to the brim with lettuce and tomatoes!

Just might be the GOAT of all sandwich’s! Seriously! These guys know how to sub!

If the sub isn’t in your
GOAT wheelhouse, these 4 dudes are certainly the GOATS of Sandwich making and will satisfy your food cravings with their immense sub & grill skills!

Come get it!“

“I love Knockerbockers in South Jordan! Courtney is the best! My orders are always perfect and on time. The food is great! The price is right and the service is excellent. I highly recommend and use them to cater breakfasts and lunches every week because I know I can count on Courtney to take care of everything she’s so reliable. Knickerbockers is my secret weapon for keeping my clients well fed and happy!“

“Great Food Friendly Service & Atmosphere“

“We went into the Saratoga springs location and saw the magnificent looking cinnamon rolls. Much to our dismay there were no raisins and we are always on the lookout for raisins in our cinnamon rolls. Carl, the owner, said he’d make a pan with raisins for just for us. We took 10 huge cinnamon rolls home and the family indulged in the best rolls ever! Thanks Carl!“

“Awesome food and the owners are great!“

“My hubby and I stopped in for the first time ever to use a gift card. OMG, it was amazing! Hubby said his chopped cheese sandwich was unlike anything he’s ever had before, in a good way, and the potato salad was a surprise treat. I had the turkey which looked exactly like the menu picture- that doesn’t happen very often and tasted really good . Katy was super helpful and informative. Definitely worth a repeat.“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“Hands down the best subs ever. Everyone is always happy friendly and smilin. ❤❤“

“It’s nice to actually have a place in Utah that makes good food. It’s hard to find out here and if you do you usually have to pay out the but to get it. This place has a solid Philly cheese steak at a reasonable price. The guy that said moochies has a better cheesesteak is delusional.“

“So 1rst.time going was kinda of a maze but got there spent $20 on a bacon chz burger made it a meal with dink & fries but had to buy each individually which kinda was lame and a turn off but the burger was good drink was better than the fries but I see why they food not wallet friendly kuz they have MANY U of U medical and staff and what not up there and they the closest dining option for some ... wish they could maybe make a $15 meal deal ..but again staff was cool and friendly and burger was good“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“Rico y abundante definitivamente muy recomendable“

“Just went in for my first time. I've had every other major sandwich chain from subway, jimmy johns, and gandolfos, but this place sets the bar for sure.
The freshly sliced meat is nice, but what's more impressive is the sandwich structure. You get an even bite all the way through the sandwich. The bread isn't too hard at all, and the thinly sliced ingredients create an easy to chew experience. Absolutely impressive guys. I devoured the entire sandwich in the parking lot, and I never do that“

“Good food! My favorite is the S8 garlic ribeye banh mi. Service is always great!
I did notice today that the menu prices are different than what I was charged. Menu shows $9.68 for S12 Brisket and $1.98 for side of Pho broth but I was charged $10.50 for the sandwich and $2.50 for the pho. I understand the need to raise prices, but they need to update the menu to reflect it“

“I like their subs although a full sub is over $20 now. The last two times I tried to order there the staff didn’t acknowledge me, no greeting. Three staff members at 2 locations just kept their heads down. There was only one other customer each time. Went to Subway next door and got immediately welcomed.“

“My son loves the original Italian. Gets it with white bread and “mike’s way.”I have celiac, and I usually hate gluten free bread. But the “juice” makes the GF bread edible. I enjoyed the tuna today. It is a shared kitchen, but they really go to great lengths to avoid cross-contamination.Lots of workers behind the counter, which keeps the line moving.I wish the prices were a little lower, but I can say the sandwiches are worth it.“

“I am beyond impressed with the service at this Jersey Mike's! My elderly father ordered the other day and Edwin, the employee who helped him, was incredibly sweet and patient. He treated him with the utmost respect, making sure he got exactly what he wanted. It’s rare to see such kindness, and it made his day. We will definitely be back thanks to Edwin!“

“I love Jimmy John's! Always good, always the correct order and best of all, super freaky fast!! Keep up the good work. :)“

“Quick service, the sandwich was fresh and delicious!!“

“We ordered from Port Of Subs through an app called ezCater for a Halloween party we were having. I looked around for easy meal ideas for our party for a few days and after looking at some of the typical ones people use, I found that many places were crazy expensive AND, I would have to go pick it up myself. I found their options for catering really appealing, and the price was reasonable. I also love that they offer a veggie tray and most places don't. The other up side is that I didn't have to find a way to keep food warm like we would have had to for a taco bar or burgers etc. We ordered the Spectacular Sub Assortment which we got to pick 4 styles (Turkey & Provolone, Ham & American, Roast Beef and Provolone, and BLT) and had the bread type an assortment (white or wheat). We then had them put lettuce and tomato but had Mayo on the side so they wouldn't get soggy. We also ordered some chips, the Definitely Dessert Platter, and as I mentioned, the Vegetable Garden Splendor. You guys! not only were the sandwiches a hit, that veggie tray was AMAZING!!!! The dessert platter had brownies and cookies and they were sooo good, and ALL the sandwiches were gone at the end of the night. They had plenty of toppings on them and the bread was delicious. I HIGHLY recommend them and I will use them again when we need to cater something.“

“### Review of Jersey Mike's at 400 S. and 500 E.

I recently visited Jersey Mike's located at 400 S. and 500 E., and I couldn’t be more pleased with my experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. However, what truly stood out during my visit was the exceptional customer service I received.

As someone who has dietary restrictions and cannot have pork contamination in my food, I was concerned about the preparation of my sandwich. I approached the staff and kindly requested that they clean up their workspace to ensure my sandwich was safe to eat. To my surprise, the manager was incredibly understanding and went above and beyond to accommodate my request. They took immediate action, ensuring that everything was handled with the utmost care and attention to my needs.

The entire team was not only willing to assist but also exhibited a positive and friendly attitude throughout the process. It was refreshing to see such dedication to customer satisfaction, especially regarding food safety. I didn’t expect to receive such thoughtful treatment, and it made my experience all the more enjoyable.

Thanks to their efforts, I felt confident in my meal, and I left the restaurant feeling genuinely appreciated as a customer. I highly recommend Jersey Mike's at this location for anyone looking for a delicious sandwich and exceptional service. They truly care about their customers and will go the extra mile to ensure you have a great experience. If you're in the area, don't hesitate to stop by – you won’t be disappointed!“

“I was very impressed by this little deli. I live in the apartments behind this restaurant and just randomly thought I would check it out today after a run. They have so many options! I ordered the Caesar salad and Turkey jalapeño sandwich and it did not disappoint. Staff was extremely friendly and continued to check up on me even after I ordered my food and paid for my food. Most places will not pay much attention to you after you have paid. This will be a weekly spot for me now! Also you have to try the mango peach sweet tea! Being from the south I have given up all hope to find good sweet tea but this spot did it right!!!“

“the manager herself brought my sub to me to make sure I got something to eat thank you so much.❤“

“Pasta was delish and kids meal was awesome for my kid too. Love the refillable coffee. Went here after visiting the Natural Museum and stayed till the weather outside was less than 90 degrees. it was conveniently close. Made our SLC visit memorable. Would highly recommend 👍 Can’t wait to visit the branch near us in San Diego next. 😊“

“The night staff seems to always remember me and i love it haha. They are very nice people, and honestly just the best jimmy johns in the valley. Next to my favorite card shop, it’s my go to at least once a week. They know how to make my sandwich just right!“

“Thanks for accommodating my request of cutting into thirds by not cutting it all. 100% what i was going for so glad you caught that for me. 😭🤣😂 Other than the fact that every single time you Never Cut my sandwich that i specifically ask for and hear relayed about 3 times.... the sandwiches are good.“

“Two thumbs up and 5 stars! How is that for ya!“

“As someone who's worked at subway for years before, Alejandro is an incredible sandwich maker. I hope a manager sees this, as this person deserves immense praise. At the end of a long 10 hour shift, they still gave incredible customer service, held conversation and were very kind, and had the best sandwich making I've seen from dozens of subways. I will be returning because of this incredible person.“

“First time at Cubby’s, and they’re missing the boat. Tacos should always have a corn tortilla option, especially for those who eat gluten free. I had to pick the tri-tip and toppings off the tacos, which I will say were tasty, but would have been much better in a corn tortilla. And would have been much more filling. Suggestion from a Texan, add corn tortillas please.
On a side note, the rosemary fries and fry sauce were good. And my hubby enjoyed the Gypsy burger quite a bit.
Also, the service was excellent.
And why is it 65 degrees in here? We had to get hoodies from the car.“

“I just barely gave a mostly negative review to this Subway due to my most recent online order experience with them. They also deserve a positive review for a past experience Ive had with them that they deserve credit for. A month ago I made an online order for a sub and when I went to drive and pick it up, my cars ignition died and I wasnt able to pick up my order. For the next 3 days the staff worked with me constantly to assure that I would recieve my order and I was able to pick it up that following Sunday morning. So I just wanted to give a positive experience review for them as well. Ao again thank you Subway staff for the service you do provide to normal joes like me.“

“Angel was so kind and genuine. Some of the best customer service I’ve encountered! She promptly completed my order with just the right amount of every topping. The establishment was very clean, and all the ingredients were fresh and fully stocked.“

“Kudos to store 2118 for the absolute best customer service I've experienced!! Rick, GM, was absolutely amazing when I called back to compliment the delivery driver! He listened and even offered to give her an extra tip out of his pocket. Tanya, the delivery driver, was one of the most kind and compassionate people I've met in my life, she delivered far more than a sandwich on 10/19!“

“I started going to this one instead of the one on Redwood Road after I realized how much quicker they are at this one and the quality of the food is so much better. The bread is always soft and fresh at this location. I always get really hard stale bread at other locations. By the time I was done swiping my card for my food, both sandwiches were already ready. Great location!“

“I haven't been to Subway in a REALLY long time because my favorite thing was the seafood & crab which Subway got rid of & I'm picky with meat.
But the staff was awesome. The sandwich was amazing! I will go back for sure!
***side note - I really do wish the crab meat could make a comeback 😉“

“Had issues with putting in an online delivery order today. I talked to Ben who helped me by giving me suggestions. Then he took my order over the phone and really went above and beyond due to the inconvenience! Internet and app issues are a pain in the butt--but Ben really made it not a big deal for me at all. He made things right!“

“I recently used Jimmy John's in Draper for a catering order. IAN took my call and was EXTREMELY helpful and patient. I didn't know exactly what to choose or what to expect, I'd never catered before to such a large group.

Not only was Ian polite and friendly on the phone, he was personable and gracious when I arrived in the store to complete the order in person (yes, I'm that girl...sometimes I need a little help)

I told Ian this was my first time catering for a large group and I really needed things to go well. He listened carefully, suggested I add two veggie options (which was AWESOME because one of the executives was a vegetarian and would typically bring his own food for any lunch and learns - not today sir, not today Ian helped me save the day...SCORE!!)

After already going above and beyond, Ian put a handwritten note in my lunch bag - You got this :). Seriously? How incredibly kind. All I could think about was WOW and how is this guy not famous for being this great!! So, here's the first step.... Five Stars on Google.

I came back a couple days later to pick up the order, it was ready to go and packed for transport. If there's an easy button for group lunches, this is it. Highly recommend.

Jimmy John's - if you're reading this - and I'm sure you are, Ian truly deserves recognition for going out of his way to not only complete the order but to be a ray of sunshine in someone's day. He deserves a note in HIS lunch....and more.“

“I work nearby so I've come by very often in the past year. The food is good but the place gets 5 stars for the stellar costumer service I receive from the amazing ladies that work here. Every visit without failure I'm greeted kindly, spoken to with patience, and when it's busy, I've seen them work extremely efficiently and fast. Just wow. 10/10“

“This Subway has excellent ownership and it shows. All ingredients are well maintained, clean store, Soda fountain has a good syrup ratio, and conveniently located for U of U. Great job guys! I frequent this place and it’s probably one of the best subways in the nation.“

“Friendly staff and attention to detail with what I ordered from the menu. I had a six inch sub. Number 4 from the menu. Bag of chips and large drink. The shop is on the s.allish side but in a good location and easily accessible. Good choices for both meat and vegan sandwiches ?“

“Had ordered my order online through postmates, didn't receive full order from a negligent driver that didn't verify my other was fully there. So I called the store and the woman from the store LITERALLY brought me my items to my home VERY QUICKLY. She was absolutely amazing and I honestly wish I would've caught her name but I recommend this store absolutely for sure!!!“

“I wish I would’ve gotten the girls name who helped us today but she had dark red dyed hair and it was in a ponytail. She was super nice super efficient and I’ve never had better sandwiches made. She deserves a raise for sure she is hustling!!“

“Always freaky fast and so tasty!“