50 Best Sandwich Shops near Cottonwood Heights

“I work in the building this Toaster's is in. It is a joy to be able to go down stairs and get coffee or lunch from Jasmine! She is hands down one of the very best service employees I've ever been served by. She takes pride in her work, always has a smile, and goes out of her way to make sure your order is perfect. Thank you, Jasmine, for all you do to make everyone's day a little brighter in this business complex. ?“

“Love this store the service is great“

“I went in the other night to get a late-evening dinner for my husband and myself. The restaurant was clean and the staff was amiable. Sawyer treated me with respect and kindness. And the sandwiches were, of course, delicious. Thanks to Sawyer and Jersey Mike's!!“

“I ride my bike every day on the way to work and pass the bacon smells coming from the market. So we stopped in for a sandwich. The maple sausage sandwich was very good. I have not had sourdough foccaccia before. It was excellent. I will have to try a bacon sandwich next since that's what brought us to the market.“

“I just love the tuna sandwich!!! love you guys!!“

“Located in a neat venue with a few different vendors. Low key. Feels like a collection of indoor food trucks.

No nonsense, high-quality breakfast sandwiches. Brioche bun is amazing. Sausage was seasoned perfectly.

Definitely deserves its current 4.9/5 star rating.

Parking: Plenty of street parking nearby“

“I love Knockerbockers in South Jordan! Courtney is the best! My orders are always perfect and on time. The food is great! The price is right and the service is excellent. I highly recommend and use them to cater breakfasts and lunches every week because I know I can count on Courtney to take care of everything she’s so reliable. Knickerbockers is my secret weapon for keeping my clients well fed and happy!“

“We went into the Saratoga springs location and saw the magnificent looking cinnamon rolls. Much to our dismay there were no raisins and we are always on the lookout for raisins in our cinnamon rolls. Carl, the owner, said he’d make a pan with raisins for just for us. We took 10 huge cinnamon rolls home and the family indulged in the best rolls ever! Thanks Carl!“

“Awesome food and the owners are great!“

“Hands down the best subs ever. Everyone is always happy friendly and smilin. ❤❤“

“The turkey melt is killer! And the location is awesome. I hadn't been there before. It's kind of in an industrial section of town, so when you first turn in you're like, "am I in the right place?" The answer is yes lol, you definitely are. Such an awesome building surrounded by really cool artwork. 10/10 would recommend!“

“The team is so helpful in getting my gluten free sandwich right, without contamination. I appreciate that I can eat here and know I won't get sick!

Vegetarian options: Hot and cold sub veggie options

Dietary restrictions: The team is great at prepping food in a separate area with separate utensils to greatly reduce the opportunity for cross-continamination.“

“I feel like it’s an institution/ staple here.
Amazing food. Just don’t look too closely at the surrounding, not the cleanest place. Also there is never soap in the bathroom. They also have the grumpiest old guy as the cashier who is very impatient with customer. BUT THE FOOD IS SO GOOD so you have to over look the other stuff!“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“it’s a smaller Jersey Mike’s and I’m used to, but it was still very clean, and the service was incredible as always. I was especially impressed with the girl who was on shift while we were there, she was so easy to talk to, very kind, and very helpful.“

“Rico y abundante definitivamente muy recomendable“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“I like their subs although a full sub is over $20 now. The last two times I tried to order there the staff didn’t acknowledge me, no greeting. Three staff members at 2 locations just kept their heads down. There was only one other customer each time. Went to Subway next door and got immediately welcomed.“

“Great Food Friendly Service & Atmosphere“

“We arrived there Monday afternoon around 2 pm, and it was not busy at all. Ordered Pho, and we were served in minutes. The broth was savory and tasted pretty good! Accompanying vegetables and herbs were fresh. I would definitely return to try other dishes when I am back in the area.“

“My son loves the original Italian. Gets it with white bread and “mike’s way.”I have celiac, and I usually hate gluten free bread. But the “juice” makes the GF bread edible. I enjoyed the tuna today. It is a shared kitchen, but they really go to great lengths to avoid cross-contamination.Lots of workers behind the counter, which keeps the line moving.I wish the prices were a little lower, but I can say the sandwiches are worth it.“

“My boyfriend and I decided to try this place after the Nat. History Museum and LOVED IT. He said the turkey dip he got was the best he had ever had and my Avocado Toast was so good it almost made me order a second slice. The chill, campus vibe was great and we had ordered, eaten and left all within 20 minutes.“

“The young staff here are awesome. My girl and I were impressed at the friendly and thorough service, they work hard to keep their store CLEAN, and the food is bomb. Not to mention the playlist was hittin as well. Danny Devito would be proud.“

“I love Jimmy John's! Always good, always the correct order and best of all, super freaky fast!! Keep up the good work. :)“

“### Review of Jersey Mike's at 400 S. and 500 E.

I recently visited Jersey Mike's located at 400 S. and 500 E., and I couldn’t be more pleased with my experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. However, what truly stood out during my visit was the exceptional customer service I received.

As someone who has dietary restrictions and cannot have pork contamination in my food, I was concerned about the preparation of my sandwich. I approached the staff and kindly requested that they clean up their workspace to ensure my sandwich was safe to eat. To my surprise, the manager was incredibly understanding and went above and beyond to accommodate my request. They took immediate action, ensuring that everything was handled with the utmost care and attention to my needs.

The entire team was not only willing to assist but also exhibited a positive and friendly attitude throughout the process. It was refreshing to see such dedication to customer satisfaction, especially regarding food safety. I didn’t expect to receive such thoughtful treatment, and it made my experience all the more enjoyable.

Thanks to their efforts, I felt confident in my meal, and I left the restaurant feeling genuinely appreciated as a customer. I highly recommend Jersey Mike's at this location for anyone looking for a delicious sandwich and exceptional service. They truly care about their customers and will go the extra mile to ensure you have a great experience. If you're in the area, don't hesitate to stop by – you won’t be disappointed!“

“We ordered from Port Of Subs through an app called ezCater for a Halloween party we were having. I looked around for easy meal ideas for our party for a few days and after looking at some of the typical ones people use, I found that many places were crazy expensive AND, I would have to go pick it up myself. I found their options for catering really appealing, and the price was reasonable. I also love that they offer a veggie tray and most places don't. The other up side is that I didn't have to find a way to keep food warm like we would have had to for a taco bar or burgers etc. We ordered the Spectacular Sub Assortment which we got to pick 4 styles (Turkey & Provolone, Ham & American, Roast Beef and Provolone, and BLT) and had the bread type an assortment (white or wheat). We then had them put lettuce and tomato but had Mayo on the side so they wouldn't get soggy. We also ordered some chips, the Definitely Dessert Platter, and as I mentioned, the Vegetable Garden Splendor. You guys! not only were the sandwiches a hit, that veggie tray was AMAZING!!!! The dessert platter had brownies and cookies and they were sooo good, and ALL the sandwiches were gone at the end of the night. They had plenty of toppings on them and the bread was delicious. I HIGHLY recommend them and I will use them again when we need to cater something.“

“the manager herself brought my sub to me to make sure I got something to eat thank you so much.❤“

“This place is a whole vibe. The young man making the sandwich noticed the New Jersey devils hat turns out his dad was a big devils fan. Very personal vibe here from the two times I came here.

The food was made as expected and on point. And the restaurant is so well kept this is a textbook execution of a great franchise.

They also efficiently manage the online orders while dealing with the people in the store.

Check it out!!“

“Pasta was delish and kids meal was awesome for my kid too. Love the refillable coffee. Went here after visiting the Natural Museum and stayed till the weather outside was less than 90 degrees. it was conveniently close. Made our SLC visit memorable. Would highly recommend 👍 Can’t wait to visit the branch near us in San Diego next. 😊“

“Thanks for accommodating my request of cutting into thirds by not cutting it all. 100% what i was going for so glad you caught that for me. 😭🤣😂 Other than the fact that every single time you Never Cut my sandwich that i specifically ask for and hear relayed about 3 times.... the sandwiches are good.“

“I haven't been to Subway in a REALLY long time because my favorite thing was the seafood & crab which Subway got rid of & I'm picky with meat.
But the staff was awesome. The sandwich was amazing! I will go back for sure!
***side note - I really do wish the crab meat could make a comeback 😉“

“Quick service, the sandwich was fresh and delicious!!“

“The night staff seems to always remember me and i love it haha. They are very nice people, and honestly just the best jimmy johns in the valley. Next to my favorite card shop, it’s my go to at least once a week. They know how to make my sandwich just right!“

“As someone who's worked at subway for years before, Alejandro is an incredible sandwich maker. I hope a manager sees this, as this person deserves immense praise. At the end of a long 10 hour shift, they still gave incredible customer service, held conversation and were very kind, and had the best sandwich making I've seen from dozens of subways. I will be returning because of this incredible person.“

“Two thumbs up and 5 stars! How is that for ya!“

“My daughter and I had lunch on the second day opening and it was great. I have been eating at McAllister s for 20 years before moving here and am beyond happy they opened one here! The food was great and all the workers were very nice. Will be back soon and often.“

“Angel was so kind and genuine. Some of the best customer service I’ve encountered! She promptly completed my order with just the right amount of every topping. The establishment was very clean, and all the ingredients were fresh and fully stocked.“

“I started going to this one instead of the one on Redwood Road after I realized how much quicker they are at this one and the quality of the food is so much better. The bread is always soft and fresh at this location. I always get really hard stale bread at other locations. By the time I was done swiping my card for my food, both sandwiches were already ready. Great location!“

“I just barely gave a mostly negative review to this Subway due to my most recent online order experience with them. They also deserve a positive review for a past experience Ive had with them that they deserve credit for. A month ago I made an online order for a sub and when I went to drive and pick it up, my cars ignition died and I wasnt able to pick up my order. For the next 3 days the staff worked with me constantly to assure that I would recieve my order and I was able to pick it up that following Sunday morning. So I just wanted to give a positive experience review for them as well. Ao again thank you Subway staff for the service you do provide to normal joes like me.“

“Had issues with putting in an online delivery order today. I talked to Ben who helped me by giving me suggestions. Then he took my order over the phone and really went above and beyond due to the inconvenience! Internet and app issues are a pain in the butt--but Ben really made it not a big deal for me at all. He made things right!“

“Had ordered my order online through postmates, didn't receive full order from a negligent driver that didn't verify my other was fully there. So I called the store and the woman from the store LITERALLY brought me my items to my home VERY QUICKLY. She was absolutely amazing and I honestly wish I would've caught her name but I recommend this store absolutely for sure!!!“

“🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Above & Beyond Service at Jimmy John’s in Draper!
If I could give more than five stars, I absolutely would! The Jimmy John’s on 12300 South in Draper didn’t just provide sandwiches for our girls’ golf clinic—they delivered an experience that deserves a standing ovation.
From the moment we placed the order, Ian and his team was on it—friendly, efficient, and genuinely excited to help. Not only were the sandwiches fast (as expected), but the staff made sure everything was labeled, packed perfectly, and included all the little extras we needed—condiments and extra napkins. But here’s where they went the extra mile—they didn’t just fulfill our order, they made sure our event was a success. Ian checked in, confirmed all the details, and even threw in a few suggestions to make things smoother. It wasn’t just a transaction—it felt like true hospitality.
And the sandwiches? Fresh bread, generous portions, and every bite exactly how you want it.
If you need catering for a meeting, event, or just want to experience next-level customer service, this Jimmy John’s location is where you go. They don’t just make sandwiches—they make sure you leave happy. Huge shoutout to Ian and the team for making our event a success! 👏👏👏“

“This Subway has excellent ownership and it shows. All ingredients are well maintained, clean store, Soda fountain has a good syrup ratio, and conveniently located for U of U. Great job guys! I frequent this place and it’s probably one of the best subways in the nation.“

“Kudos to store 2118 for the absolute best customer service I've experienced!! Rick, GM, was absolutely amazing when I called back to compliment the delivery driver! He listened and even offered to give her an extra tip out of his pocket. Tanya, the delivery driver, was one of the most kind and compassionate people I've met in my life, she delivered far more than a sandwich on 10/19!“

“Friendly staff and attention to detail with what I ordered from the menu. I had a six inch sub. Number 4 from the menu. Bag of chips and large drink. The shop is on the s.allish side but in a good location and easily accessible. Good choices for both meat and vegan sandwiches ?“

“My husband went over to pickup our food around 3:00 on Friday and we have to write a review and give huge compliments who prepared our sandwiches because everything was fresh and excellent. We will make this our official subway to go to from now on. You guys rule...thank you.“

“I work nearby so I've come by very often in the past year. The food is good but the place gets 5 stars for the stellar costumer service I receive from the amazing ladies that work here. Every visit without failure I'm greeted kindly, spoken to with patience, and when it's busy, I've seen them work extremely efficiently and fast. Just wow. 10/10“

“I love this location and the team! I recently had a super minor issue with one of my orders, and the manager was VERY understanding and kind about the matter! Could not recommend this location enough for their kind staff as well as amazing sandwiches (of course)“

“Ok, this place has delicious food & friendly people, but I hate how expensive it is. It’s good food, the restaurant is clean & well lit. The workers are kind & friendly. It’s just every time I eat here I feel like a sucker. It’s good food but very over priced.“

“After completely getting ignored without any reason on 4161 S Redwood Road subway store, I came here for the sandwich. And really felt good about coming here. They greeted me well, and made my sandwich as I wanted. Thank you. From now on this will be my favorite store.“