50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Holladay

“Was looking for FroYo late on a Saturday. Googled it and chose the top rated location. It was about a 17 minute drive from my place, a couple cities away, but totally worth it! They have a good variety of yogurt flavors and lots of toppings and sauces. They also have two non-dairy yogurt options! The owner (I believe she was the owner) was super friendly and sweet. We had a fun conversation about our dogs. Will be back again.“

“Four year search for authentic Italian Neapolitan pizza, found the perfect place in Holladay, limited menu of well executed food, warm friendly service. Open limited days and times, but worth adding as a regular night out“

“My lovely partner surprised me by bringing me on a date here and it was absolutely magical!! A truly unique date and a wonderful experience for my first ever tea party. Such tasty tea and sweets. Very cozy and whimsical. It was delightful all around. Highly recommend.“

“I came in the middle of their rush and ordered a ton of food for my entire companies lunch! Food was promptly prepared I I got enough food for 20 people in less than 10 minutes!!! On top of that, my team wanted to try everything once I sent them the menu so we ordered 15 different menu items! Obviously everyone had their favorites and least favorites but overall everyone loved the product!“

“October 13, 2022, my sister and I went to Leatherby's for lunch at 12:10 p.m. We order a Philly cheese steak sandwich, and we waited 20 minutes for it, it was barely warm. It had hardly and meat, green peppers, onions on it! I said to the waiter this Philly cheese steak sandwich was on the Menu said The BEST Seller. It had nothing is on it; he took it back and (they probably spit on it) when came back it STILL hardly had any meat etc. on it! It was the worst Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich!!! Service VERY Poor! Food VERY POOR!!!“

“Best Carmel sauce in the world. Please, please, pretty please start accepting door dash an/or Uber eats.“

“I've been here several times, always a treat, and have never left a review. Located in great part of town, just love 9th and 9th. The gelateria itself has just an assortment of arts and ceramics and decorations. The seating area is super cozy. Some tables and chairs and some couches - that could swallow you whole if you let them they are so squishy. The gelato is great, very creamy. I think the best gelato in Salt Lake. The serving size is great too, they usually pack it in and over the top of the cup. Thanks to the owners and workers of this shop!“

“My go-to crepe cake place!“

“Seriously an incredible place to be during any occasion. One of my favorites. This place offers season treats as well as more than just gelato. I highly suggest the Lemon and Salted Caramel- but thats just me. Anyone can and will fall in love with this place.“

“Delious non dairy ice cream. Never had a bad flavor!“

“Always great service and food. Alexa and Tomas run a wonderful ice cream shop“

“Such an amazing experience! This is a must visit in SLC! With the exception of the Oreo and biscoff cookies everything else is hand and home made.“

“Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. is our go-to ice-cream place in SLC. They have a large upstairs loft that can fit larger groups. Fun and friendly atmosphere! They have flavors of the month if you want to try something new. You can get to-go pints/quarts for ice cream at home or an event. They have ice-cream that accommodate some dietary preferences which is always a win.
** (I believe they had both dairy free and vegan options, but I would call and double check if this applies to you.)“

“this is best Gelato in town“

“I am SOOOOOOOO excited that they are back! The best shaved ice I've ever found, such unique flavor pairings and yummy add ins! The topper is the ladies who run it. They are so sweet, helpful and patient. A1 on customer service!“

“me gustó el helado de mango 🥭“

“Its amazing gelato that has been consistently great since 2010 when I first discovered them on one of my SLC trips. I’m so glad they survived“

“super rico !!! super recomendados!“

“The ice creams are amazing. There are many options for toppings. Place is so clean! I absolutely love this place!“

“What a fun place! Loved watching them create such a wonderful dessert! Highly recommend!“

“If your going to get the BEST, expect long lines (to the lady who whined) yummmmmmmy yummmmmmy it was sooooooooo good! See you again real soon.“

“The service, the French Onion soup was the best I have ever had in my life the broth was to die for. The vegetable quiche was amazing. I will be back☺️“

“Buen servicio y Agradable“

“This is my favorite Handel’s location! It’s perfect if you have kids—you can bring them on summer nights or in the fall to hang out on the little patio area in front and enjoy the atmosphere. It’s also great for a casual date night. The staff is friendly, though sometimes a little slow and the girls at the counter can seem a bit confused at times. Still, it’s a great spot to enjoy some ice cream!“

“Love their caramel apples!“

“I want to highlight the incredible customer service I received, and especially recognize Noel. I stopped in to pick up an ice cream cake for my dad’s birthday, but when I went to leave, my truck wouldn’t start. Without hesitation, Noel came outside with a portable jump pack and got my truck running again. His kindness made a stressful moment so much easier. Thank you so much, Noel your help truly made my day.“

“This place is so fun. You choose your type of frozen yogurt and then add your toppings and pay based off weight. Kids love it. Remember to buy a water when you check out because for whatever reason froyo makes ya THIRSTY.

Kid-friendliness: Kids love a make-your-own sundae bar.“

“The horchata, diablitos, and tosti locos are so good 10 10 would recommend.“

“Excellent small “modern Italian” restaurant. Handmade pasta and foods, worth the wait. Friendly service. A great longer lunch stop near the university.“

“Can’t believe we didn’t try this place sooner! Some of the BEST soft serve ice cream in Utah— so creamy and not overly sweet & the portions are huge (this was the half cup!)

We got the salted maple and it was out of this world! They have a smaller, but more intentional menu, and there’s tons of fun toppings to add on. They also have “Composed Cones” that are a combination of flavors and toppings!

They switch out their flavors each month, so we can’t wait to go back and try everything else that they create!“

“great for anyone who loves ice cream.....This is Utah, we are obsessed.“

“ay de todo en un solo lugar“

“Mmmm I didn’t know I loved it until I tried it. ❤️“

“I live in Colorado and never heard of Alpha Coffee. I visited Salt Lake City, and friend recommended we meet at the downtown location. I ordered an "Aztec" and it was great. Something different, new and tasty for me. I liked the drink, the vibe and the servers ... the whole experience was great! I look forward to my next visit to SLC. I'll stop at Alpha again - to try the Poly! :)“

“My team was doing a mobile clinic next door so I thought I'd take a chance and see if I could purchase some. The kind gentleman there gifted us a couple boxes. It was generous and soooooo delicious. Just what we needed for an afternoon pick-me-up! Thanks again!“

“Surprised at all the 5 stars.
The good: friendly staff & inclusive place.
The bad: smelled awful, the actual tea was just okay and it took a long time for our order and we were the only ones waiting.

Again, nothing against the workers they were great, and sad to post this, but we were visiting from out of town and went out of our way to go so if you're local it's fine just nothing special.“

“Chocolate chip ice cream was delicious“

“I really adore their different types of ice cream sweet treat combinations they come up with some really interesting ones stuff that you really don't think would mix but they really do go together I hate a dark chocolate before I had they're vanilla cone dipped in dark chocolate now it's like my favorite thing to get and it's so good it's so satisfying.“

“Delicious cookies every time! Always consistent, fresh, and full of flavor. I love the secret menu and the rotating dessert menu. Always fun to try something new, even though my favorite is the classic chocolate chip.

The customer service is friendly and efficient.“

“Delicious Treat to End the Day!
We stopped by Sweet Rolled Tacos at the end of a day exploring Salt Lake, and it was the perfect treat. We tried three different flavors, and each one was made quickly, carefully, and tasted amazing. Everything was fresh and flavorful, and the service was great. The rolled ice cream taco portion was pretty big and definitely shareable. Would absolutely recommend the Mint To Be if you’re a Mint Oreo fan! We’d happily come back!“

“I come here all the time! Truthfully I have been to other coffee shops Downtown and none compare. The barista, Nate, is the best! He is super friendly and always asks me about my day! He has helped broaden my understanding of coffee and helped me diversify my order :) I now time my visits when I know he will be there as he feels like a friend at this point. Can’t say enough good things!“

“At first, I was completely put off because their weren’t prices listed. I immediately felt I was going to be overcharged. I asked the sweet lady for prices, and she obliged happily. It was the most I’ve ever paid for a boba and I’ve drank them all over. Even on Waikiki Beach they weren’t so expensive. So, why 5 stars? The brown sugar milk tea with traditional Boba was the best boba I have ever had! It was so good I am considering going back tomorrow before I leave town! Good job, Hello Boba. Still too much $$ for boba, but goodness, it is tasty!“

“Our favorite frozen yogurt place by far- the dole whip is my favorite and actually tastes like the dole whip at Disney.“

“This crumble is always fun. They tend to have the the best tasting cookies for some reason. Definitely give me the best experience out of all the other stores.“

“Loved the vibe, cutest donut shop ever. Friendly and fun staff. Unique and delicious treat "Smashed donuts" my new favorite desert.“

“It's just fun to be out there with you guys and pretend to be normal again“

“Cold Stone Creamery, it's not just ice cream; it's a taste victory. The mix-ins are like a tactical assault on your palate, creating an unbeatable flavor experience. The ice cream itself is a champion, smooth and powerful. This place doesn't settle for ordinary – it's a warrior in the dessert arena. If you want a treat that packs a punch, Cold Stone is where you unleash your taste warrior.“

“We had an Amazing experience at this location today. We had a large group of about 15 people and kids. The boy working (forgot his name) was very helpful and kind and it was only his 2nd day on the job PLUS he was the only employee working the store!!! He was great and we thought we would give him a shoutout! The ice cream was delicious!!!“