10 Best Mexican Restaurants in Payson

“Love this place! True latin fare, my new favorite.“

“These guys were slammed when we happened upon El Tapatio, so I can understand the lack of service. We enjoyed the pineapple fajitas, lots of pineapple... possibly not enough meat though. Our son had a carne asada burrito that was just okay.“

“I'm not usually a huge fan of street tacos, but these are the best tacos I've ever had. If you like street tacos, you need to try this place. I had the Asada, Pastor, and Chorizo. They were all good, but the Chorizo was my favorite - lots of flavor and not greasy at all. It's located right by a road, so it's a little noisy, so the atmosphere isn't great but the food makes up for it.“

“there food is so good I would go there everyday and there service is so good they make your food so fast there salsa bar is so clean and you can even get your own toppings there really nice!“

“I've always loved MI Rancherito over any other Mexican Food joint in the area. It's not too expensive. It's surprisingly priced fair. I've never left there thinking I overpaid. I enjoy the service, and the atmosphere is very relaxing. No loud music. Comfortable seating and deliciously prepared food at a reasonable time...? ??“

“I live close to this location and know the owner lady and her son and they're both super friendly! The angry little man that's been working Saturday and Sundays(most recent bad visit on 7/21/24) lately needs a hug or something! On my visit today I was paying at the drive thru and simply asked for the hot sauces I wanted and he kinda scoffs and slams the window! He did the same thing after handing the food over. He also acted the same way a couple weeks ago, as well as on other weekends prior. I'm aware people have bad days, but this isn't the 1st or 2nd time this angry little man has acted the same way. Dude needs a HUGE hug, or just take him away from the window! If I hadn't had multiple bad attitude issues with him I'd give 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ all around! I will talk to the owner and/or son when I see them next. Hopefully they'll just pull him away from the drive thru.“

“I have loved Payson taco time for all the years of my life that I can remember. But why does everything taste like cinnamon now? Why? Everything! I don't love that. My whole order... Crisp pinto bean burritos that were cinnamony. Only my dogs love that! Fix it.“

“This has been my favorite restaurant since 1988! Yes, I've been eating here regularly for over 36 years. My custom order is Smothered Burritos with cheese, no beans inside, no onions, extra pork, extra cheese, extra green sauce. I just had it on 8/23/24, and it has never been better!!! And EXCELLENT Chips and Salsa!!! ?“

“Went through the drive through and our order was wrong. So we took the food back into the store to get our correct order, and Annie helped us. Annie went above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied and everything was correct. To put it simply this girl needs a raise“

“I placed an order online and somehow it got sent to their other, the staff was great, made my order at the correct location (the location I thought I was placing my order at) and made it quick. I usually recommend this place to people. I’m glad to see that they still don’t disappoint.“