19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carnation

“I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!! its so cozy and the pizza is great!! and ive been to italy so i can say this. the crust is really fluffy and crunchy, the sauce tastes fresh and there's lots of options for different tastes. Also they are very generous--my slice was like half of a pizza. YUMMY!!!! also theres prize machines in the corners that are very unique, i have never seen a pokemon card machine before. I highly recommend if you want to have a good time eating some pizza in a cutely refurbished garage <3“

“Love this place. It still has that old school charm that you only get from a community full of love. Service is a little slow, but most of us don't mind because that's kind of the point. And the wait is 100% worth it.

After frequenting multiple times over the last two years and trying as many of the options from the menu as we can, I am willing to say confidently from grinders to homestyle pies, nothing misses here. But I will warn you they are HOMESTYLE pies. So the crust is soft and bready and I suspect similar to the grinder bread. They are somewhat lighter fare.
They're not exactly the same as greasy, yeasty poofed traditional American pizzas like what you get from Red Pepper down the road. So be warned, they are good in their own way, but may not be what you're expecting as far as pizza goes.

However we don't mind this and for what they're worth they are delicious in their own way.

Service is.. Interesting, they do have a lot of younger and teenaged age people working there. So I think they can be a little standoffish at first, as teenagers are, but if you get to know them I suspect they're nice kids. The older adults who we see from time to time seem really nice and friendly.“

“Best pizza I’ve had in years from ANY vendor.
Cooking Papa Murphy’s is, in my opinion, the best way to have pizza at home.

Vegetarian options: many vegetarian options

Dietary restrictions: vegetarian choices

Parking: open lot

Kid-friendliness: open and no obstructions

Wheelchair accessibility: open lot“

“I went to the Snoqualmie Ridge location. The woman behind the country with long blonde hair, a grown-up, not a kid, answered my questions. On my last visit I want happy with the portion size. Apparently that was just an error, easily fixed. She exfoliating and made it right for me and now I'm a Mod Pizza fan again. Thank you, thank you!“

“We love this place and haven’t had anything we didn’t like!! Great food. However….. make sure you dress warm… they have blankets you can throw over you but it is still pretty chilly in there.“

“02/28/25 Brandy was helpful with question for website ordering 1/2 & 1/2 pizzas

02/14/25 We followed the correct cooking instructions this time for the stuffed crust and it was way better than the last time!

12/20/24 next time we will follow cooking instructions better“

“one of the best pizzas ive ever had, it was delivered fast and hot“

“Great service. Noisier than I recall, but maybe it is just busier.“

“On point EVERY TIME!! I moved to Duvall a couple years ago and received a Welcome Bag with a coupon for a free pizza from Red Pepper. I got the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza and it became my go-to order. I just ordered a pepperoni, olive, VERY lite sauce and it was perfect! The crust is slightly crispy and soft on the inside. They knew what they were doing by pitting a free pizza coupon in the welcome bags. The crew and delivery drivers are always super friendly, as well. Whenever I've ordered for pickup, it's always ready when I arrive. Whenever I order for delivery, it arrives super quickly. I love this little hidden gem in our amazing town“

“Awesome staff!!! The service was great, and the food was quick.

Vegetarian options: Yes, they have plant based cheese. Though i didn't see it in the menu, when we asked, the person eagerly answered yes.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Not much has changed except a bit lighter on the toppings. New thick crust. I need to try it next time. I like the thin crust. I always build my own and it's different every time. Out of roasted garlic. ? Typical wait time. Something sticky on the floor.“

“Ordered online. Ready when promised.Toppings were well distributed, and there was plenty. Pizza tasted delicious!

Vegetarian options: See menu

Dietary restrictions: .

Parking: .

Kid-friendliness: .

Wheelchair accessibility: .“

“Very good pizza. My only note about the pizza is about the Jalapeño topping which could have better if they used pickled ones instead of the fresh or have the option to choose. Great crust, sauce is really good with oregano and their peperoni is high quality and tasted fresh.

This Issaquah location has trivia every Thursday from 6 - 8 PM. I forgot to ask if it happens only at that location.

Staff is very nice too. I arrived half an hour earlier than my set pickup time, but they were very helpful and accommodating and got me Pizzas ready in 7 minutes.

The vibe is inviting too. Hopefully we will get to try Pizza and trivia soon.

Thank you“

“The lady who made my gluten friendly pizza knew what was up!!! She did a great job and the pizza turned out great. The gentleman who made my bf's megadough pizza is a wonderful pizza maker too!
We love the pesto and white sauce combo on our pizza & plenty of pineapple and toppings.
So many options for your pizza. I always love going to MOD. Atmosphere is neat too. Like the table with games on it. Thanks for dinner!

Vegetarian options: So many veggies! & vegan crust available. And vegan sauces.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten friendly options“

“Wholesome, genuinely caring and family friendly, I have a deep respect and gratitude for the family who has made these flying pies since I was a kid! Thanks for decades of pizza ♥️ muchísimas gracias por compartir su pizza con nosotros todos estos años. Sin saber, ustedes han inspirado unas memorias tan bonitas que nos siguen toda la vida.“

“The crust is the BEST! Always hot and fresh.“

“Good service. Quality product.
Recent edit: Their 16" is never more than 15", and you'll only have 14" of toppings despite ordering their thin crust. Not a positive development, but still quality.
Also, despite advertising, they do not have $12 specialty pizzas on Tuesday. That is not actually a thing.“

“Rarely do you find a restaurant with no flaws. An easy contender for the best restaurant for miles and miles. Wouldn’t be surprised if they work towards a Michelin star.

Kid-friendliness: Absolutely kid friendly, reminds me of the places my mom took me as a kid.

Wheelchair accessibility: Street level, no steps in the dining room if I recall correctly.“

“We made a mistake of not taking out italian sausage and asked if we could replace the whole pizza. They were so nice in that they remade the pizza and even said that understood that our religion prohibits us from eating pork. Wonderful atmosphere, the service is great and the food, just as amazing!!!“