50 Best Italian Restaurants near Newcastle

“We ordered an extra large pizza and was on our way to pick it up. Unfortunately, as we got onto the freeway, the car overheated. After dealing with that fiasco, we were very late to pick up our pizza. When we got there, we apologized and explained what happened. The kind staff offered to remake our pizza for us free of charge! Unable to wait, we started devouring the pizza in the car. It’s phenomenal! Absolutely wonderful! The funny thing is, they actually gave us the “old” one by mistake and gave us the other pizza. We ended up with 2 extra large pizzas and very happy tummies. Thank you for the great customer service, delicious pizza and turning our horrible day around. We’re certainly coming back for more! ❤️“

“Wow! I’m very impressed with Rimini. We made a reservation with a note that we were celebrating our anniversary, and the staff made it feel like such a special night.

We enjoyed the view from the table, the decor, the accordion music, the delicious drinks and food - all of it. I’ll be back for another special occasion or if I’m in the mood for some Italian food in Kirkland :)“

“We had dinner here for the first time and it was superb! Lucy, our server, listened to our needs, explained the specials and menu. I'm gluten intolerant and she helped me be successful in my choices. The restaurant is cozy and inviting, the food is incredible. Preparations and tastes that were exciting. This was one of the best meals we've had in some time. We will be back.“

“Great Mediterranean food in a pleasant, neighborhood atmosphere 😊“

“From the moment you walk in, this Italian restaurant delivers an exceptional experience that feels both authentic and unforgettable. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, striking the perfect balance between elegant and cozy—perfect for a romantic dinner or a relaxed night out. The food is nothing short of outstanding. I had the salmon special, which was cooked to perfection—tender, flavorful, and beautifully presented, with each element on the plate complementing the fish without overpowering it. My wife ordered the fettuccine with prawns, and it was just as impressive: perfectly al dente pasta coated in a rich, well-balanced sauce, with generous, succulent prawns that made every bite memorable. We finished with tiramisu for dessert, and it was the perfect ending—light, creamy, and beautifully balanced with rich espresso notes. The service truly set this restaurant apart. From start to finish, the staff was exceptional—warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about what they do. Every interaction felt personal and thoughtful, from being warmly greeted at the door to perfectly timed check-ins throughout the meal. The team was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, offered excellent recommendations, and anticipated our needs without ever being intrusive. Their professionalism, friendliness, and attention to detail made us feel relaxed and well cared for, elevating the entire dining experience. This restaurant captures everything you hope for in great Italian dining: outstanding food, a welcoming atmosphere, and truly top-tier service. An unforgettable experience and an easy 10/10. We’ll absolutely be back.“

“We love it and loved the food“

“This may be my new favorite Italian restaurant! Came here on a whim and was so impressed. The food was perfect. We got the lasagna and the steak and I can’t decide which was better. Best lasagna I have ever tried, the steak was cooked to perfection. Our server April was so warm and kind! She made our experience that much better. We will be coming here every time I’m craving Italian. Highly recommend for anyone who wants the most authentic tasting Italian food ever!“

“If we (4 of us traveling for a conference) could give it 100 stars we would have! From the greeting, ambiance, food and service this restaurant is exquisite! The presentation of the food matched the flavor and can be described no other way than flavorful and devine! The locals may know of this place but we are considering it the best kept secret for travelers!“

“Everyone there is super nice and they have great food the cook and the waitresses are super friendly and the regulars that go in are also super friendly and will chat with you definitely recommend going there“

“visited the Eve of April 2, 2021: Our server was delightful she was warm and offered suggestive drink psirings that were spot on for what we were looking for to compliment our food. The food was absolutely delicious, and the environment very inviting. The whole evening was a lovely experience. I will definitely be back.“

“An excellent place to celebrate! My husband took me here as a surprise for my birthday and it did not disappoint. Matthew was an excellent server-prompt, knowledgeable and polite. The food was fantastic, the drinks phenomenal and they really know how to make birthdays special without being over the top about it. We will be back and requesting Matthew as a server soon! Cannot recommend this place enough!“

“Authentic, fresh, and entirely delicious. The homemade cannelloni pasta noodles and filling were absolute perfection! Fantastic marinara! And the pizza… amazing. So much for leftovers! And I haven’t even mentioned the kindness of all of the staff. Can’t wait to come back to this gem!“

“Food and service was amazing. Highly recommend“

“Amazing food and staff!!!!“

“Try the pepperoni rolls!!“

“Excellent food and service. A hidden gem“

“Wonderful Italian restaurant. a Kirkland neighborhood treasure.“

“My word this place is fantastic. Shame this good local Italian is 1500 miles from home. Service is friendly and quick. Incredibly filling.“

“WONDERFUL housemade pasta, whole Branzino. Delicious Barbera. Great desserts, great service, amazing olive oil, which sounds funny, but it was really, really good. I would highly recommend La Medusa.“

“Absolutely FANTASTIC food and the service is top notch! Our server Veronica was FABULOUS and David the bartender made my daughter the fanciest mock tail! Treat yourself and enjoy the experience!“

“Sadly this restaurant that I previously considered family oriented and reasonably priced is no longer so. My last visit noticed alarming high prices for some of the offerings. Ordered my usual spaghetti with marinati sauce, now advertised as being "spicy" as preactically non eatable. Much too much pepper added for my taste. Verbally complained but was barely listened to.“

“WONDERFUL housemade pasta, whole Branzino. Delicious Barbera. Great desserts, great service, amazing olive oil, which sounds funny, but it was really, really good. I would highly recommend La Medusa.“

“Really nice early dinner with the Family. service was top notch as was the food. Gustoso.“

“Everything was wonderful. The service was excellent from start to finish. Our server was friendly, energetic, and very attentive to our daughters. The menu is great, with so many good options that it was hard to choose. The restaurant was clean and had a very pleasant atmosphere. I highly recommend it.“

“Been to many Italian restaurants being Italian living in Australia and to being at Ristorante Paradiso in Kirkland Washington Seattle was the best Italian restaurant I have ever been to. Service was outstanding and had the best white wine I have ever had in my life a memorable experience“

“Sages in Redmond is easily one of the best Italian places I’ve tried in the area. The pastas are excellent, and the pink sauce is amazing and full of flavor. Everything tasted fresh and well cooked, and the portions were satisfying. The service was great, and the staff was really accommodating and friendly, which made the experience even better. The place has a nice, calm vibe that’s good for a relaxed meal. Overall, it’s a solid spot for Italian food, and I’d definitely come back again without thinking twice.“

“This is our “go to” pizza restaurant. The food is always fresh, hot and very good.“

“Amazing!! Will definitely be back!“

“I was staying in the Wedgewood area for a few days. I stopped in to get a gluten free pizza. (I have celiac.) They were wonderful to me. They prepared and cooked my pizza separately from the rest. I don't remember the special I had but it was delicious. I ate the leftovers for lunch the next day. I didn't have any issues with my celiac.
Thanks so much for a great pizza!“

“The Queen Anne How to Cook a Wolf is consistent in being excellent. The food is always prepared to perfection. The ingredients are well sourced. The atmosphere is lovely. The staff is incredibly friendly without being intrusive. It's my favorite neighborhood restaurant and one of my top 3 in Seattle.“

“Great place for date night.“

“They have the best & freshest Italian food around! You will not be disappointed! Can’t wait to go back!“

“This was our first time here and I would say we were at about 80% satisfied with the experience, compared to other high-end restaurants in the area, the decoration and ambience were very underwhelming, but the staff was very professional, and it was very lively. Both salads were got were excellent and our entree was really good the lamb Ragu. Unfortunately the two starters were meh for the cauliflower was decent. The meatballs were a big flop, not sure if it was overcooked or the meat was too lean, they were really dry and took away from the nice sauce. It took about 30 minutes to order food, think someone forgot about us as the people that came same time as us we’re already eating before we could even order.“

“Crossroads Italiano is the go-to spot for anyone craving Italian comfort food! The menu is filled with all your favorites, prepared with authentic flair and served with a side of warmth and hospitality. The staff here are fantastic—always smiling, welcoming, and ready to recommend the perfect dish to satisfy your taste buds. Don't forget to follow them on Instagram for updates on their mouth-watering specials and more. If you're looking for a delightful Italian dining experience, look no further than Crossroads Italiano!“

“We are visiting for a game. Half the excitement is trying something new! What a unique and exquisite place! We will be back!“

“Delicious happy hour options, including pastas. Our server Ginger was super friendly, attentive, and helpful. Pasta servings are huge and well worth what seems like an expensive cost per meal. We were pleased with the service and food, especially the Carbonara.

Two pastas and a Caesar came out to $120ish but we used the inKind app to save some money. 20% service charge is included in all checks.“

“Waiter forgot to put in one persons order but there was enough food without it“

“Great food & drinks!!! Staff is wonderful & atmosphere great“

“Best pizza I’ve had in the US. We actually ate so much it was ridiculous ;) The mushroom and fontina is insanely good. Well, so are the others. And yes, I was invited there and got to learn about pizza, the dough is a wonder. Gave me a whole new guiding light for what it should be like!“

“Great service. Very unique menu.“

“Fun little dive bar in a strip mall. I've only been for weekday lunch, but the beer is good, food is really good, and the dive bar atmosphere gets upscale with office chairs. I've had the grinder and Cuban and both were great with lots of fries/tots/onion rings too accompany. We also had a shrimp in a spicy cream sauce appetizer that was really good. The pizza was good, but I much preferred the sandwiches.“

“Great place pizza is amazing, and garlic twists are recommended 100% good prices and the staff are very nice people just great place overall“

“The table was across the kitchen entrance. The restaurant was dim so every time the door opened it was bright lights in my face. My wife was facing the window and the kitchen light would reflect off the window and was bothering her as well. Everything else was fantastic.“

“Amazing local pizza place! Authentic food, fast service and a nice vibe!“

“Great spot! Enjoyed Happy Hour very much. Aperol Spritz, Margherita Pizza, Arugula Salad & House Red Wine all great! Service was excellent and attentive. Will be back for sure.“

“Great people and delicious food“

“This is a family owned wine bar and live music venue that has just passed its 18th anniversary is a fixture in downtown Issaquah.

The interior design of this wine bar is exceptional, historic, rustic and elegant. Featuring rotating artwork from local artists, interesting custom metal work, an exceptional wine list, full cocktail bar and a scratch kitchen.“

“I’ve been living in Belfair for 3 years and have seen this tiny, cute silver bullet at the White Barn. Today, we wanted pasta and ended up trying out Wise Guy’s. Let me just say…. the food itself is like when your grandma cooks it. Chefs kiss, amazing.The best part is….. THE DIRTY BURGER AOLI!!!!! I was lucky enough to be there as they were trying out something new. Lucky enough to be the only one too! Please, ask for the dirty burger with Alfredo sauce to dip it in. You will not be disappointed. I brought a few bites home for my partner and even he was in awe!100/10 we will ALWAYS return here! They are just so lovely!!!

Vegetarian options: Soups, salads, marinara/Alfredo sauce.“

“Just went there today with my Boyfriend. Was very impressed by the great service and plenty of delicious vegan/vegetarian options! Definitely going back there as soon as possible! :)“

“Tutta Bella is by far the best pizza place on wallingfor area. The quality of the ingredients are just superior. If you are looking for place to eat a really good pizza, please do a favor to yourself and eat here. My favorite kind is the “Leonardo” with additional of prosciutto. Love it.“