Custom Cakes near Puyallup, WA

“Cat and Rabbitt always has multiple cake options. They rotate through seasonal/monthly flavors as well as some that remain more constant. I have tried quite a few of their cake flavors as this point and they are always delicious. Sweet, but not too sweet. I have not tried many of their other options, though a peanut butter pie they had a while back was delicious, as was a chocolate chip cookie I had more recently. They usually have at least one or two vegan options as well.“

“Yikes, I'm sorry to see so many negative experiences with this location though I'm also not a regular. Has been at least a year since I've even been to a Cold Stone.

I didn't have a chance to stay to eat, which is why I'm keeping this review open at a 4.

The staff was friendly & conversational. They asked if I wanted a waffle cone.

We had no issues with the ice cream 🍨“

“Their cakes are beautiful and taste amazing!“

“Dragonfly Petit Fours were a lovely addition to my daughter's Baby "Sprinkle" Tea party. Bringing a little touch of sweetness to our beautiful day!“

“Came looking for a Milhojas cake for a friend… left with seven other things to try 🤣 The variety was incredible, the service was welcoming and above all, I loved everything I tried! Absolutely a new favorite bakery spot for me!“

“I love this Coldstone. It may not have the frills or modern flavor mashups of the modern ice cream shops (like salt & straw) but the classics are on point. Their mint sundae thing is the best. All served up with great customer service- the perfect stop after a dinner out or on your way to a fun evening somewhere.“