Home
WA
Puyallup
Custom Cakes

Custom Cakes near Puyallup, WA

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes near Puyallup.

Showing 6 of 6 restaurants

Bakery · $
1 The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop

4.6 Superb 226 Reviews

111 East Stewart Avenue, Puyallup
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Brown Sugar Cinnamon Brulee & Raspberry Coconut
- Brown Sugar Cinnamon Brulee & Raspberry Coconut
- Carrot Cale and Brown Butter Banana Cake
- Chocolate Chocolate Cream Cheese
“Cinnamon rolls hands down best I've ever had. They don't skimp on the cinnamon and edge to center the roll is moist and tender. $12 a roll....... and before you whine about the price, you need get those pathetic shopping mall rolls outta your head and see one of these in person. My wife says their cake is excellent too but I've yet to curb my obsession with the rolls long enough to try the cake!!!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
2 Cold Stone Creamery

3.0 Average 196 Reviews

13333 Meridian East Ste G, Puyallup
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cake Batter Ice Cream
- Founder's Favorite
- Cold Stone
- Oreo
“Super friendly staff & management made a ‘not so great’ situation right! I came in to pick up a cake I had ordered online. The employee couldn’t find my order and gave me a cake off the shelf. I figured there was some sort of mess up. I was in a hurry so I didn’t go back. A few minutes later, I get a call and text from the manager stating that there was a mix up and they found my cake. He even offered to deliver the cake to my house! (which is ~30min away). I really appreciated this gesture because you don’t often see customer service like this anymore!!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$$$
3 Celebrity Cake Studio

4.8 Superb 359 Reviews

314 East 26th Street, Tacoma · 7.4 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Decorated Sugar Cookie- Design Varies
- Custom Birthday Cake with Buttercream
- Pink Champagne and Bavarian Cream
- White Chocolate with Raspberry
“This is a fantastic bakery in Tacoma, WA! We get all our special occasion cakes here, and treats on the regular. Highly recommended! 10/10”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$
4 Dragonfly Cakes

4.9 Superb 26 Reviews

314 East 26th St A, Tacoma · 7.39 miles
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Teacakes 9-Pack
- Petit Four
“Dragonfly Petit Fours were a lovely addition to my daughter's Baby "Sprinkle" Tea party. Bringing a little touch of sweetness to our beautiful day!”
Menu
Bakery · $
5 Surtidoras Bakery

4.0 Good 38 Reviews

1702 B, 1702 Auburn Way North, Auburn · 10.16 miles
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Tres Leches Cake
- Pastries Bread
- Birthday Cake
“Came looking for a Milhojas cake for a friend… left with seven other things to try 🤣 The variety was incredible, the service was welcoming and above all, I loved everything I tried! Absolutely a new favorite bakery spot for me!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
6 Cold Stone Creamery

3.5 Good 118 Reviews

2430 South 319th Place, Federal Way · 9.07 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Peanut Butter Cup Perfection - Freezer
- Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
- Cheescake and Chocolate Ice Cream
- Birthday Cake
“I love this Coldstone. It may not have the frills or modern flavor mashups of the modern ice cream shops (like salt & straw) but the classics are on point. Their mint sundae thing is the best. All served up with great customer service- the perfect stop after a dinner out or on your way to a fun evening somewhere.”
Menu Order