12 Best Italian Restaurants near Cedarburg

“Wonderful place for relaxing dinner with friends along with great food and service. We will be back.“

“the.everything but anchovies thin crust, I have eaten it here fo'r all 48 years, Mike“

“Food was spectacular. My husband and I started with the lobster bites. I had lasagna, he had pizza. The sauce is delicious. Our waitress was attentive and good. The owner stopped by to see how everything was and took our leftovers to be boxed up. We will definitely be regulars here.“

“Great food!!! Fast service!“

“This is our favorite Fish Fry in the area! (And we've tried a lot of fish fry's :) The Pizza is also really good! We love their thin, crispy, crust! The wait staff has always been friendly and hard working. It's hard to beat Pepino's.“

“I had heard great things and had never been. Was heading to see a show at the Marcus Center last night and we opted for dinner here. Being a foodie, I had asked for recommendations in some of my foodie groups. I heard the meatball appetizer was a must have. It wasn’t on the menu for some reason, and I’m glad I asked as Frank, our awesome bartender/server who is in the family didn’t realize it wasn’t. I have zero idea how you get meatballs light, fluffy, not dense, but these were them. And the sauce! Beyond fresh, light, and delicious. Eggplant Parmesan fries were also super light and served with the same delicious sauce. And then the pasta… Capellini alla Caprese (which was Frank’s recommendation). From their menu: “Handmade angel hair pasta tossed with sweet Roma tomatoes, genuine Prosciutto di Parma ham and an Italian soffritto (olive oil, onion and garlic), finished in a light chardonnay-cream sauce and Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.” This was also super clean, light, and just delectable. The bruschetta appetizer we did not order, but the people next to us did, and I asked to take a pic. It looked amazing, and the girls eating it absolutely raved. The tiramisu - not much to say other than chefs kiss! I literally want to go back and try everything on their menu. This was for sure one of my favorite new (to me) places and I will be back for sure! Also a shoutout to the other bartender Shea… she was an absolute gem. All of the staff we met were super friendly and helpful. Love places like this!“

“Kaitlyn is great her customer service is outstanding amazing beautiful kind whenever I place my ordes I always ask if she is there because she make sure that everything is correct and hot. The young lady, the hands the food with the accent wonderful as well.
They get 1000 stars“

“Excellent service and excellent food!“

“Hadn’t been to Eaton’s for a while and glad I stopped. Staff was helpful and friendly. Pizza was great - abundant toppings, nice thin crust, flavorful sauce.“

“great customer service and the food was amazing“

“Even though the Pewaukee location is closer to my house, I order from the Menomonee Falls restaurant because the food and service I much much beter.“

“Very romantic spot next to a candle lit fireplace. I like this Italian restaurant“