“Tried this place based upon previous reviews and a recommendation from my in-laws. I have to say it did not disappoint. The cheese curds and artichoke dip was a great appetizer. I devoured the old Wisco burger. I’ve got a big appetite and this one left me full. I was very impressed with the atmosphere and the service. I’d definitely eat here again.”
“My wife and I randomly stopped here on a car cruise on a Sunday afternoon. We found the Google reviews solid for the area so we stopped. The bartender was really friendly and nice. We didn't catch his name but he went over the menu and told us what the specials were. It's a cozy Wisconsin sports bar with a huge menu. They have an AMI jukebox, dartboard, cardboard crack machine (pull tabs), and plenty of locals conversating at the bar. They have several gambling machines too. There are tables to the right as you walk in just in case right at the bar isn't your mood. We both got bacon cheeseburgers which I think was a half pound of meat. It was a monster burger and really good. If you're in the Delavan area please stop here. It's very good. We will definitely be back the next time we're in the area. Thanks for a great experience.”
“I have been looking for a good fish fry with good potato pancakes and I finally found one. I normally order baked fish but they offered a choice to order both baked and fried so I got it. Both were very good I still prefer the baked but if you like fried I would say it was good too. I liked that they served drawn butter with the baked too. Coleslaw was also good. Our server was very pleasant and attentive. The dining room is very clean and quaint. We were surprised that it wasn’t very busy as we got a table right away and there was no waiting. I believe we found a diamond in the rough. We will definitely be back. Prices are very reasonable for dinner and drinks.”
“Hard to find places that consistently go above and beyond for their customers every day, but I can assure you the bartenders and owners of the Rustic do just that. Whether you are just passing through, or in the area on a regular basis, I highly recommend stopping by, grabbing a bite and a drink. You won't be disappointed.”
“Was in the area visiting friends for the weekend and the brought us to the watershed for drinks and dinner. Giant pretzel appetizer was very yummy, large and soft served with cheese. Appetizer trio of curds, macaroni n cheese bites and cowboy bites were also tasty. Breaded Mushrooms were sliced portabella which was a very pleasant switch from most other places that do button mushrooms. Drinks were good. We got there about the "start of busy time" they were short staffed but still attentive.”
“Stopped here, after a trip to Summerfest Thursday 6/23. Wasnt too busy, but it had a good ambiance. Entertainment to keep your hands busy. Brittany made an appearance as well. Always nice to see owners making sure things are ok and helping the bartenders. Who by the way was also pretty cool. I forgot his name, but he had a good sense of humor and pretty nice guy. I dont live in the area, but id go back if I did.”
Bar & Grill • 
Bar & Grill • 
Bar & Grill • 
Bar & Grill
Bar & Grill
Bar & Grill • 
Bar & Grill •
“Cozy bar with some booths available and a handful of tables as well. There are video game machines to play as well as a Juke Box. The bartenders were great and made excellent drinks. Fish was huge and very delicious too. Definitely a must go back. There is a 2nd bar are for Volleyball and other events so it would allow easy access to get food and seating still.”