5 Best American Restaurants near Elkhart Lake

Paddock Club American • $$
61 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Panacotta with Fresh Berries
Mushroom Risotto Fritters
Eggplant Caprese Salad
Rock Shrimp Linguine
Roasted Duck Breast
Spaghetti Bolognese
Grilled Hanger Steak
Spaghetti Carbonara
Grilled Broccoli
Potato Gnocchi

“Any and every thing tastes excellent here! Love this place and the staff especially! Jim and Ann“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
Three Guys & A Grill Restaurant American • $
W7039 County Rd S R, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich Sunday Special
Surf and Turf Ribeye Perch Dinner
Surf and Turf Ribeye Walleye
Turkey Pot Pie Soup
Philly Cheese Steak
Grilled Walleye
Steak Sandwich
Side of Fries
Cheese Curds
Gator Bites

“Our bartender, Anna was so nice and helpful. Our server didn’t seem to want to be bothered with our order. Mixed up a lot between the 3 parties that ordered at the bar. Anna redid the corrected bills, while the server couldn’t be bothered. The food was great as usual, but never he a rude server before. But Anna made up for it, with a smile on her face.“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
Lake Street Cafe Inc American • $$
21 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Warm Nut Crusted Goat Cheese
Tenderloin Shiraz 10oz
Homemade Potato Chips
Seared Yellowfin Tuna
Three Cheese Grill
Tomahawk Pork Chop
Lake Street Burger
Lake Street Pizza
Soups of the Day
Chicken Sandwich

“Great Food/Service Vy Server Elsi L! The Best In Elkhart Lake ! Johnny V (Madison Visitor)“

4.1 Good43 Reviews
Siebkens Resort American • $$$
284 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

“Live locally but went to enjoy the band CIA and the vintage car parade. So much fun!“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Brown Baer Bar • $
181 E Rhine St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Baer Burger and Kettle Chips
Giant Pretzel

“I have been a regular for years and have always ordered to go. Tonight I called to place an order and you're not doing to go's. by no means am I saying people shouldn't go there they absolutely should your food is great. I've just never had this happen before in years of ordering and I definitely think it's a flaw to the business. yall missed out on a good $100 order. lol the reason for no to go's was on busy weekends you dont do togos. totally fine. but could you maybe include that in a post in the future? I'm honestly so bummed I'm missing your dinner. I'm just super autistic when it comes to eating. lbvs so I'm struggling now to figure out how to feed myself and my dad who I care for 😭😭😭 food is always awesome, workers are always great. a heads up of no to go orders would make you perfect 💜 also love your non alcoholic options for people who don't drink.“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews