5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Poynette

“My absolute favorite Friday night fish fry! Last week, Friday 9/8, my fish was spot on! Also, I love the homemade coleslaw, too! The prices are great as well. My service is always spot on as well! Very rarely do I ever even have to give my order when they know who it is calling for a takeout order! Delivery is offered as well!“

“This place is a neat little pizza restaurant on the north end of Lodi that kicks out solid, traditional Wisconsin-style pizza. It's clearly popular. I went on Friday night, got there at 5:00 pm on the nose, and it was already crowded. They had a wedding rehearsal dinner going, so that was half the place full, but every table was taken so my wife and I had to sit at the bar. We got one of their HUGE garlic pretzels as an appetizer. It came out hot and fresh, and it was one of the better pretzels I've ever had. It was bready and fulfilling. On the menu it says it feeds 1-3 people, but I'd lean more toward the three than the one. It was massive. The kitchen was deep in the weeds when we ordered (probably thanks to the large party that was there for the wedding rehearsal), so it took over an hour and ten minutes for us to finally get our pizza. Normally, this would be a big knock against them in the rating department, but I feel like this wasn't a standard Friday night for them. To be fair, the place never emptied the entire time we were there. The second someone left, there was another party ready to take their table, so the locals clearly knew what's up. The pizza we got had a cracker-thin crust, and the toppings and cheese crowded all the way to the edge. It was tasty and worth going back for more. It was the type of bar pizza you crave as a good Wisconsinite. All in all, other than the prolonged wait for the pizza, this was a solid outing. I hope they have a lot of success because this place is on the verge of being a destination spot for a good Wisco-style pizza.“

“I want to say how much we truly enjoy your pizza and wings. The staff is ALWAYS friendly, from the person who takes our order to our delivery drivers. So let's talk about the pizza. The crust is hands down one of the best I've had. Ingredients are always LOADED and fresh. We ordered extra of one topping today just because. Unlike most places, PJs did not skimp! The sauce is amazing and always has just the perfect amount. I don't honestly know how it's possible to be so consistent (I mean we are talking pizza here) but it's another thing PJs is great at. Something else that is A-F*ckn-mazing. We have a credit from our loyalty rewards, for a free pizza and salad, that expires at the end of the month and they reminded us of this! I've never had a place that remind me something is expiring they are giving me for FREE. Thank you PJ for the extra spice you treat your customers with. I came to write a review even though we typically get our orders in Cross Plains. But since Facebook doesn't allow a second review I am coming here. :) Thanks for being and exceptional small town restaurant!“

“Love BB JACK’S! The service is usually perfect, the food is always done well and the staff is always friendly. I’m thankful for having them in Deforest. Always recommend them. Thanks to the owners and entire staff for doing a great job.“

“Not only was the food fabulous (as usual), but Mark at this location went ABOVE AND BEYOND for a super specific request I had regarding a receipt for an order from about six weeks ago. It was so appreciated and he was extremely helpful and friendly!“