14 Best American Restaurants near Random Lake

“We hadn't been here for a couple of years. If there hadn't been cars in the parking lot, I would have thought it was an abandoned building. Parking lot full of weeds as well as the entrance was overgrown. Upon entering the bar area, the carpet was black in the traffic area. We had reservations & were seat right away. We understand places are short staffed so we were patient. While waiting @ our window table, it was quite apparent that the windows had not been washed in years, the railing outside was thick in bird droppings as was the deck. The gutters of the adjoining building were packed full. Our server was kind but certainly overwhelmed. Food was ok but I'm wondering what the kitchen looks like given the state of the building inside & out. Sadly, I know Five Pillars has been around for a long time but we will not be back nor would I recommend.“

“Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon and there were a ton of cars in the parking lot. Walker accessible. We had pot roast grilled cheese with a side of horseradish and au jus and a Cuban sandwich- mustard spicy and delicious. Service was fast, food hot. Casual pub dining. Good dessert options, but we didn't have room. Large portions Gambling machines a plus- we will be back.“

“I recently moved to Newburg and was excited to see all of the new restaurant options to check out. My first experience was take out of Cork N Barrel (which is walking distance from my house!)I ordered the Bacon Cheeseburger Wrap,the Black n Blue Burger, the Barrel Burger,and the Jumbo Patty Melt with a side of Mac n cheese instead of fries.I was a little confused where to go to pick up my food, but was quickly pointed to the kitchen area up the steps.(When you walk in it just looks like a bar). Parking on the street was easy to find.The macaroni and cheese was delicious!! I will definitely be getting that again. The barrel burger and the jumbo petty melt were amazing!! I think the patty malt was my favorite thing so far. The black and blue burger was pretty good except it was a little disappointed how simple it was. But everything was cooked to perfection!!Next time I might try eating there instead of take out because it looks like a great atmosphere.Highly recommend!“

“Excellent server Kaylin ! So friendly and helpful! Speedy service ! Excellent cod fry with an option for soup or salad bar with dinner! Great value at just $12 !Other dinner was chicken Mac and cheese also delicious! SoCo old fashioned one of the best I’ve had ! Seriously good food and excellent service at a great price! We will be back!Parking: Can park close with minimal walking especially if handicapped“

“The gyro bowl exceeded my expectations, which were already high. The cheese curds were exactly what you would expect of Wisconsin cheese curds, amazing. The side of pancakes were light and fluffy with the amazing fresh strawberry sauce.Our waitress was phenomenal with frequent checks, although the restaurant was busy, and energetic throughout my many questions.For a starter, three main meals, and add ons for the sides, it was still around $40. A steal in today’s economy. The quality of food, service, cleanliness, and environment make this a place I want to return to every time I’m traveling through.“

“I've been here a few times and it's delicious every time. The service is quick even when it's busy and it's been busy every time I've gone. The soup flight is a great idea! I really like the baked French onion soup. I would highly recommend!“

“So...1st (but NOT last) time here. The food was absolutely top notch. My husband & I split the Reuben melt Special & 2 sides (poppers & onion rings). I asked for some horseradish & Mayo on the side, so I could mix up the reuben sauce that I prefer. The staff was awesome & had no problem accommodating my request. The sandwich was one of THE BEST Reubens that I have ever had. We both had a cocktail with dinner, & they were also crafted to perfection. Compliments to the chef! The view of the sun setting over the lake was a stunning pink/orange perfection. The restaurant is receiving some upgrades, which they hope to have completed for the summer season. Can't wait to( and plan to) go back! Highly recommend you stop & check this little gem out!Parking: Maybe about 14-20 parking spots, & then some available along the road.Wheelchair accessibility: You could wheel a w/c down & into the restaurant.“

“Had the pizza. It was delicious..good crust and flavors. Previous visits we had waygu burger, pork chops sandwich; cheeseburgers , onion rings, sour cream and onion ring fries. All excellent. Fish specials also great. Family run, friendly, reasonably priced with a great atmosphere. Can be hard to get to with nearby construction, but worth the drive .“

“"Old-school", small-town pub and grill experience. Friendly bartender, super staff, very affordable, terrific food, perch is incredible, and very clean. The only reason I give it a four-star rating is that it's a bit outdated, but that's part of the ambience. And the night we were there, they we short-staffed - they kindly told us so (what place isn't these days) - it took nearly 40 minutes for our meals to come out. We enjoyed our wait-time consuming some tasty beverages while we waited ?“

“Cindy is a welcoming presence in her bar, and she makes a really delish burger! She has a good selection of alcohol options, and I love the atmosphere. A comfortable place, where’s there’s a Tuesday afternoon sheepshead game. Local neighborhood bar that’s a welcoming stop for people from out of town too. PS her 100+ year old wall fridge is awesome!“

“I will be honest- I had lower expectations when we walked it. The interior could use a small upgrade. But holy cow- the food was amazing and service was fantastic. We drove a bit over an hour just to camp, I would do that again just to come here again. Prices are very reasonable, drinks are strong, burgers are out of this world- the perfect Wisconsin pub.“

“My girlfriend and I stopped here for dinner on the way to Harrington Beach state park. The food was really, really good. Large portions, very hot, and very tasty. We chatted with the owner for a while and he was friendly and welcoming. A must-stop if you're in Belgium.“

“I love this place. I’ve been there several times, especially for brunch. Plus their breakfast and lunch food is super yummy. Just as yummy as the Luxembourg Cafe place. Usually, I eat their breakfast food for lunch. So I ate 2 scrambled eggs, 2 bacons, hash browns, sausages, and white or wheat toast. It’s healthy, decent, affordable & a great place to eat at. My mom goes there too & she loves it. We hope this place remains opened. Especially for the nearby customers. Thanks Family Fredonia!????Parking: It’s simple to find parking. There’s hardly any cars. Just a few, that’s all.“

“Met some friends here for a Saturday night dinner. None of us had ever been here before. A small, quaint, old school kind of place and we loved it immediately. Started off with a few cocktails and the owner/chef Kevin came out and chatted with us for a bit. He explained about his from scratch cooking, and the butchering he does in house. When we were ready, Kelly seated us and took care of us. Service was fantastic! Everyone loved their food - our table had the prime rib, ribeye, pork cutlet and a fish. The entrees came with a soup or salad, and a side/potato. I can say the cheesy au gratin were very yummy. It reminded us of dining in a friend's home, not a big fancy restaurant. We felt like regulars even tho it was our first time. No complaints from us. Ended the night with a grasshopper/cocktails and a lot of laughs with our friends.“