50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Windsor

“Absolutely wonderful pizza! Highly recommend the Barbie! Now my Friday night go to. No cooking at my home on Fridays 😊“

“I've been waiting for quite some time to travel this way and try one of the pizzas I've been hearing such great reviews on. I could tell the amount of passion put into creating and preparing. The Salted Pig is probably one of the most amazing things I've tried!!“

“Classic must try pizzeria. Absolutely delicious, they come up with great pie ideas and they are ALL hits. Their service is impeccable and their excellent cocktails give the experience the cherry on top . To add to that the prices are super reasonable. Great atmosphere, can't recommend this enough. It's become a go to return spot over the years, wether I go for a nice dinner with my partner, or getting "fancy" pizza and drinks with friends, this is the place to go.“

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!“

“This is one of our favorite places in Madison. Every single time, the food is delicious, the staff is full of smiles and always willing to go above and beyond. 10 Out of 10 recommended.“

“Discover Madison's hidden pizza gem: It's Good For You it offers a one-of-a-kind experience with expertly crafted pizzas and cozy ambiance. From classics to unique creations, each bite is a delight. A must-visit for pizza lovers in Madison! The attentive staff adds to the charm, ensuring that every visit feels like a warm welcome. For those seeking a slice of perfection in Madison, It's Good ForYou is the ultimate destination.“

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu“

“Stopped in for craft beer and pizza. Had a great time, the pizza was incredible!!“

“Hanging out with friends. We shared many things on the menu. Loved all of it!“

“The food here, the pizza specifically, is excellent. The service, looks like it varies due to the servers personal perception of your party. She dotes on young people, seems to ignore older couples, maybe cuz she is young. Saves on the tip money though. I would stop again if I found myself in Madison just for the pizza. Might get it to go and save her from being bothered to wait on us.“

“We ordered carry out and it was a good experience, The wait wasn’t very long. We ordered a medium stuffed pizza and I would have loved to see more cheese inside. It was not cheesy at all, disappointing, considering the price. The breaded mushrooms, hot wings and the breadsticks were good. The wings are a pretty good size, I ordered bone in. Their Tiramisu slices are very good.“

“This is, without a doubt, one of my favorite places to eat. Almost is everything is handmade from scratch and super fresh. The pizza is amazing. The deep fried food is so good, I have to get something fried everytime I go. The sandwiches and lasagna are crazy good. They have a great selection of beverages, both alcohol and non. I highly recommend a visit to this place. If you like pizza or Italian style food, you won't be disappointed.

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza and veggie sub and a few other things from what I remember. The vegetarian selection isn't huge, but there are definitely some options.

Kid-friendliness: Nice family diner atmosphere. Has a small candy machine and big gumball machine. Also has a driving simulator video game for kids to play as well.

Wheelchair accessibility: No curbs in the lot leading to the door, so wheel chair accessibility is not a problem. Handicap space in the lot, is directly next to the rear entrance as well. No automatic door though.“

“I recommend Anna Pizza if your in the area. I myself have problems with my stomach and have to be on a KETO DIET and I order a very thin crust. I may not eat the crust but there topping and cheese are so delicious and good and they don't bother my tummy either. I think it's because they must use real or high quality products. I love there Pizza. I myself give them 5 stars.“

“The food and environment is fantastic!“

“Just had their $2 slices. There deluxe are great �“

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

“One of my favorite pizza restaurants around. Try the Macho Nacho!“

“The place was super chill and we were the only customer there. Pizza and tots came out fresh n hot! I got the vegan option and it was so fluffy and savory! The sweet bbq sauce taste is strong a little too sweet for me since there was pineapples on it too but I would order again! The tots were surprisingly super good! I wasn’t expecting much but it was so crispy and tossed in something cause we finish it pretty quick.“

“Had our first Bucks pizza tonight. It was amazing! Can’t wait to enjoy again soon.“

“All 5 ⭐'s from me. There's no other pizza like Rocky' s. I'm not a huge sausage fan unless it's on a meat pizza, but I'd say 4/5 times I have to get a slice of pep/saus. Their sausage has such a great flavor to it. Their sauce is good too. If I get a super slice, I get 2 sides of pizza sauce to put on top. It's that good. They also sell their sauce at the store which is a plus.“

“It was great the atmosphere is very nice and peaceful, the location was great it's not in downtown Madison on state street like the other one and you can actually find a place to park which is great. The pizza was 10/10. The building is so cool. Don't know why some karen left a 2 star review because they wouldn't give her free pizza that doesn't seem fair at all to the business. Paid $26 for 4 slices of pizza total, and 2 canned sodas for 2 people to eat. The employees we dealt with were friendly.

Parking: Easy to park outside, didn't have to pay for parking“

“My husband and I were visiting from Ohio where there are lots of amazing pizza places and Zoe’s is right up there with them! I love a good pizza place and my husband and I were so pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food! The customer service was great too! Our only disappointment was that we didn’t order a bigger pizza and that you are so far from home! It will definitely be a stop the next time we are in Wisconsin!!! Highly recommend!“

“Good to see everyone all smiley, meanwhile my roommate says our Halloween night food arrived like this (half of all the toppings slid off the pizza onto the cardboard, the closing side of the cardboard mushed into the slid off toppings). And also no marinara for the cheesesticks, which makes the cheesesticks absolutely fckn useless. Did the pizza get dropped? And oh cool, a refund in 72 hours, for the pizza, and only partially for my useless cheesesticks. I thought you all would be better after you got your new place. I kept cutting y'all slack at the temp place because I get how your business suddenly blowing up can really throw a wrench into things. But who puts together and deliver this food, a bunch of potheads? I mean seriously. I expect so much more from a place that has prices comparable to some uptight fancy restaurant. If this happened at pizza hut, I'd understand. But glass nickel? You're supposed to be top notch. What a joke. Not happy.“

“We love this place! We love the Portabella Lugosi and Boris Karloff pizza…both are fantastic. Everything is always fresh and hot when it arrives for delivery. I’m not sure how they keep my fried mushrooms hot for delivery but they always arrive steaming. I def recommend if you have not tried…you wont be disappointed.“

“By far the best pizza in town! Low in calories, thin new york style crust and very yummy. The staff is amazing- they are all related - its a family owned business and they are extremely friendly! I highly recommend the place- its for sure a must try!“

“One of the best spring rolls I’ve ever eaten! Deeeelicious!“

“We ordered a salad and pizza which were delicious. The only thing I disliked was that the employees were vaping in the back kitchen/prep area. I find it gross and unprofessional. It should be done outside and not in the restaurant, especially near the food.“

“I ordered 6 large pizzas, 3 different kinds, 2 different crusts, 2 hours in advance for the local VFW post meeting. Everything was delivered right on time, hot and cooked perfectly. Our Veterans were very happy and I cannot thank our local Pizza Hut enough. An outstanding job.“

“The food was good it did take a little longer you do got to remember that you are in a big gas station and a&w is right next to it but other than that the food was good the one thing that really surprised me is how clean they keep their soda machine.

Wheelchair accessibility: It's a gas station with sliding doors there is plenty of room for a wheelchair that you had tables that you can discover which are sliding chair over and wheelchairs fit in perfectly“

“Please keep an open mind and read me out. So, you waited over an hour a time or 2, or there was an error (wrong topping, etc..) - or X, Y & Z happened? (100% inevitable in any delivery or parcel transference or taxi type of situation). So, you passive-aggressively take a swipe or "get back at them" by posting negative stuff. Why is the impetus to post a review on Google or others, in most of the reviews on such receptacles for such, anyway, mostly negative?? You waited an hour for delivery? Take a look around the world you're living in, and stop your first-world whining. Seemingly, SOME people have "nothing nice to say" - they simply didn't listen to their parents about not saying it. If you're from Madison, you know Pizza Pit has been around forever and had almost a dozen locations in the Madison metro area until things "changed" circa 2000. Fiore and the Cottage Grove Road location have CONSISTENTLY & for a long, long time, provided searing hot, wickedly-spicy (I think the spice, or hot factor, has changed from say, the 90's - in the sauce) pizza to satiate even the most ardent fuss-butt. Pizza Pit was years into delivering their signature 'spiced' - 'Za & in any precarious situation or icy road condition - while Glass Nickel was "still looking at the lingerie section of the Sears catalog." I'm not attempting to take anything away from Glass Nickel, as their spinach cheese bread and many other things are great. But, SO does Pizza Pit, that is, have an invariably extensive menu of delicious products to fill your stomach so your body is nourished properly - saving your ever-loving soul. Epic employees in town, visitors in town for a Badger game or whatever or whomever reads this - I have had pizza all over the world, and Pizza Pit is uniquely delectible & sumptuous. A truly Madison original. I realize opinion is subjective - so, maybe I'm a different breed of cat. -_-P.s. Endeavor to spread the positive, and try to limit the negative...leave it in your inner-space, so we can finally get to outer space.“

“This was a pizza/Cousins/A&W stop with A&W being the primary stop. 5 ? is given to the younger female I assume manager of possibly all three. While actively and efficiently gathering orders she was patient, and helpful to many with the self ordering when an influx of customers came at once. Her professionalism was unwavering even when some customers were not as polite.“

“They donated pizzas to a Make-a-Wish party, and I can't thank them enough!!“

“The gluten free crust was delicious and I watched the folks working change their gloves when they were handling my pizza to prevent cross contamination. It’s a bit of an awkward wait (longer than you’d expect), and I wouldn’t recommend eating at the tables inside unless the weather is poor. Go outside and enjoy the view!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust is available.“

“The spaghetti and meatballs with meat sauce was delicious! The pizza, while it had a great consistency, and the crust was very good, the pizza itself was a little flavorless. Perhaps an off night. One major positive they serve Coke products, though they are served in cans. Refills would be nice!“

“Everytime we order from DeForest pizza hut the workers are professional & polite. It's clear this business cares about their customers & stresses that to their employees. The food is always as expected & made the way ordered.“

“What a great little hidden gem! Great drinks, gourmet food, amazing staff and we even got to meet the owner, Steve! Very friendly atmosphere. We will definitely be back!!“

“Great place to watch sports. Pizza is very good love the low carb pizza. Great wings as well“

“Ordered online - my order was ready for pickup at the designated time and expertly prepared. My family enjoys both the classic and thin crust, I’m strictly GF. The Gourmet Vegetarian is super delish! If there are leftovers they heat up perfectly in the air fryer

Dietary restrictions: Their gluten free crust is reliably un-contaminated and delicious!“

“I want to recognize the outstanding service of Chrisi! Second day at her work and she has given us the best service ever from all the time we've been here to eat! Her attitude was amazing, always smiling, recommending deserts despite being busy! Food was delicious but BRAVO for her!!!!!!!!!!!!!! La Brioche is lucky to have her as part of the staff!!!!! Thank you again for making our brunch so bright!!“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“Went in tonight at a little after 5pm to a completely packed store. Must have been 10-15 in line ahead of me. Two workers. Sounds like a complete disaster, right?Nope. These two were on top if it. They kept everything moving, and after a little while the manager showed up and hopped right in to help out.It took about 20 minutes to get my pizzas, but I have no complaints. I was very impressed with how well the manager handled everything, and the three of them cranked through the pile of orders while still remaining friendly, courteous, and professional.We don't eat here super often, just because there are plenty of other pizza places that do the cooking for you, and when I'm hungry, I don't want extra steps. But I've never been so impressed with a crew before, and we are definitely going to make this a frequent stop.Keep up the excellent work!“

“Want to give a big shout out to Debra @ the Gemini Drive location. She was very pleasant as she greeted me & took my order. She was very knowledgeable & able to answer all of my questions. She was busy but I did not feel rushed by her at all. She was well organized taking orders & then putting together a handful of pizzas. Most of all she made my day by happily customizing my jack-o-lantern pizza! She was a one woman show who handled all of her responsibilities beautifully! Thank you Debra for your excellent service & pleasant personality!!!!! ?“

“I was pleasantly surprised by all that BB Jacks offered. From a large bar, great cocktail menu, and the service- I highly recommend this place for dining, catching a game, or meeting friends. Our server, Mikayla was attentive, friendly and knows her stuff when it comes to food. The manager also stopped over to see how everything was which only elevated the overall dining experience.“

“The food was excellent. Especially the bone in wings. The service was mediocre because they failed to mention up charges for regular wings vs. boneless. It was a meal deal. Atmosphere wasn't great because it was strictly a takeout place.“

“The people here are very helpful and nice. The workers double checked everything and noticed a few items missing and made sure to get it before I left which I appreciated. Food is what you would expect from a papa John’s, and it is a take out only option here.“

“I order pickup from this Pizza Hut occasionally, it is reliably good pizza. The last 2 times I have stopped, the people at the pick-up window were very nice, and the pizza was spot on. I am a fan of their crust, especially the pan style. They also have a drive-thru pick-up window.“

“Everyone is really happy and friendly at this bar n grill. Jovial atmosphere. Good food selection. The secret Thursday night Philly cheese steak is awesome. Bartenders are on time although there can be limited seating at the bar so you might be stuck at a table. Prices can vary greatly depending on what and how much you're drinking.

Vegetarian options: A few options. More appetizers than anything.

Parking: There's two parking lots. One in front of the building and one next door.

Kid-friendliness: This is a bar so probably not appropriate to bring your children.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is disability parking and the entrance is wheelchair accessible.“

“The food was decent (what you should expect from a pizza buffet) and the atmosphere was decent (spacious but it sounded like two sound tracks were playing over each other at times from the speakers). The service was the star, an employee checked in on us several times which made it clear they care about the customer experience. The all you can eat buffet cost about $17.“

“We ordered a pizza for work . Although the wait was a little long it was worth it. Whitley or it may have been whitney i didn't hear the name right (the guy with the old blue mustang ) did a great job with our order, his attention level surely made our experience a great one, he made sure our order arrived correctly during a snow storm and gave us the best suggestions. Thanks alot.“

“We placed an online order for pickup when we were done with work. I stopped in to grab our pickup order and added some extra appetizer and dessert items. The Papa Murphys staff we're incredibly kind and helpful and even advise me to grab an extra side option for a bundle discount which I was not aware of previously. For being a chain store, the pizza is always consistent and delicious and I always look forward to when we place another order!“