50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cotati

“Just went over to get a pizza. 4pm May 26 2026. Guy behind counter was working on one. Guess he didn’t like chatting or his job. Told him take his time…sat down to wait. Another woman and daughter came in and the pizza guy went right up to them and took care of their order first. Waved at him wondering what’s up and he just shrugged his shoulders. felt like age discrimination… I left.“

“We LOVE Sal’s. Excellent pizza and calzones. My daughter and I walk often and always grab two slices for the rest of the way home. Pure deliciousness! The staff and owner are wonderful, courteous, caring people. If you are going to get pizza in Cotati or Rohnert Park this is the place to go! New York style, thin but the crust stays the right amount of crispy and the end crust is a delightful perfect finish!“

“The most expensive Gluten-Free & Vegan meal I've ever had. Granted, those two restrictions are generally not well met throughout the industry, as it is. Thus, the price. Unfortunately, with all that in perspective, the GF&V pizza wasn't very satiating. Disappointing. But, at least somebody is trying!

That said, the service was fine, everybody was nice. No complaints there whatsoever.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten-Free & Vegan“

“Ordered a bbq chx pizza good thing I checked it before I left apparently when it was going to the oven it got some bubbles and there was four pieces that didn't have any toppings on them because the bubbles were so big and all the toppings went off. I figured either they would offer me a discount or offer to make me another Pizza they didn't either and the guy just handed me my change. But I'm not going out like that, I asked to have another pizza made and they did this one looked much better anyway. The taste on the pizza was very bland. We also ordered boneless chicken garlic parmesan and barbecue and all they did was drizzle the sauce over the top and it was minimal at that also tasted very bland. Too many pizza places around to serve bad stuff and have bad service and we will not be going back.“

“My name is Beatrice I order for delivery often with my family and friends especially for last minute celebrations and sometimes because of family’s major pizza guys request. So ordering from pizza guys in Cotati is preteen and parent approved! The prices are awesome and fair, and if not to you then use their awesome coupons! Because delivery is quick, food is always hot and fresh, 2liters including salads are always refrigerated cold, then lastly you can trust desserts to be as sweet and courteous as the person who takes the order on the phone to the man who delivers to us every time. All and all they totally deserve a higher rating than 5 stars alone! I highly recommend if you’re ordering something new for the first time and you’re a bread fan just get the Garlic Bread Cheesey rolls ? we used to order a lot in Santa Rosa as well, when we lived there and it was also the same! Absolutely awesome and down to earth good food and staff!“

“Really enjoyed the pizza here! Not usually a fan of goat cheese or mushrooms, but the way they do it - I loved it! Plus the crusts are really tasty!“

“had meatballs. garlic knots. salad. wings and pizza. everyone loved each item. wow. its new in petaluma next to whole foods“

“Excellent pizza and the owner and son are really nice people. I’ll be back!“

“Best pizza I’ve had in Sonoma County.“

“definitely unprofessional not ok to tell a customer that even though the person taking your order over the phone messed up your order then you call then rude employee female at 6:30 pm answer the phone saying they can resend it out but charge me delivery fee again which is not ok or how it works I worked for domino's for a few years now and we don't do bussiness like that at all its unprofessional to lie to a customer then when the customer ask for a manger you don't put them on hold for 15 minutes and you over hear the person on the phone say just great saying not professional things about the customer completely rude and employee needs written up an reprimanded for this type of behavior but the manager is going to make it right but no customer should ever have to wait 45 minutes more to get there correct order completely not ok hopefully the GM and the district manager will look into the store off bear valley in apple valley to train there employees in proper procedures and professional way to handle customer service we order all the time never have these type of issues very disappointed“

“Went in to support a friend who just started working behind the bar and definitely found a new favorite spot. We had the cheesy pesto garlic bread, the baked formaggio, and the doloroso. We thought everything was amazing.
We also had some incredible cocktails. My partner had the strawberry mule, and I had the Ciao Bella. A vodka-limoncello sour sweetened with oregano syrup. I thought it was the perfect cocktaik to have with pizza.
We can be picky, but they make the small location feel cozy. They have a fun menu that tastes delicious. And the service was fantastic.
Adding Brixx into our frequent rotation for sure.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“How do they come up with such a variety of pizza every month? These are fanastic. Reminds me of Mulberry Street Pizza on Smith Ranch Road, San Rafael.“

“absolutely the best pizza around this area. Great food, nice people, a great combo.“

“Great service. Great food. We will be back. Please put braised short ribs back on the menu.“

“Loved the vibe, GSW on the tube, best thin and crunchy slice of sausage pizza I've had in a very long time! Good guys working the joint and a family feel good local old school authentic place you just want to hang at and support. Loved it.“

“Some of the best hand tossed pizza (fold the slices for eating perfection) from an Italian family run restaurant. The spaghetti and meatballs are a classic. I'm a huge fan of the eggplant parmesan sandwich. The roll is toasted crispy to hold the ooey gooey sauce and cheese combo, with the eggplant being cooked soft and flavorful.

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps and will make extra space if needed.“

“Yummy pizza. Handmade dough❤️“

“Their customer service was amazing when my friends and I came in! I spoke English, my friends spoke Spanish, they swapped back and forth to match us, they gave us extra food while we waited for our orders and their food was amazing, became our go to spot.“

“Food is incredible! Bacon Alfredo break sticks are insanely amazing.“

“Great creative pizza types!! Order and then get it delivered so you can enjoy the best pizza around. Check out that menu!!“

“Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!“

“Wow, this pizza was sooo delicious, the cheese you can tell is higher quality then Mountain Mike's or Round Table. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza with pepperoni instead of ham and jalapeños. Surprisingly it was already on the menu like that, no substitutes. So cool!! The ranch is also top notch and available in jars, yeah it's that good :) I love that it has an arcade too, it reminds me of a place you'd go to in the 80's, rad!! Street Fighter II, Simpsons and more..Check this place out if you haven't, you won't be disappointed, there's still so many more pizzas I gotta try and will during this football and basketball season :) A+++“

“amazing pizza. the owner was super helpful and overall great experience“

“I go to Petaluma and work on weekends. The gentlemen that work there when I call to place an order. They already know what I normally order, and when I go there to pick up the food they always say nice to see you again. They are very friendly ☺️“

“Pizza is always so delicious! Love that we can have Indian food on our pizza. It’s ready quickly, and even delivered faster than any other pizza place we’ve ordered from. Love the quality and variety.“

“After a fiasco trying to get service at another local restaurant, we remembered there was a Mary's nearby. The staff were all friendly, and our server was very attentive. We didn't have to wait to order, and our food was delivered quickly. The salads were almost too big, but that isn't a complaint. They were fresh and tasted great! The cheese garlic bread is delicious. It was a wonderful meal. As we left, every employee that saw us said goodbye. All in all a pleasant meal!“

“We've been going to Graton since it opened in 2013 and this is the only restaurant we go to! We have 630 Steakhouse and though it was good, it doesn't compare to Tony's! Everything is absolutely delicious and Marina sauce is my husband's favorite along with the steak! We always say we're going to try a different restaurant but end up at Tony's and very satisfied! We changed our usual dinner menu for pizza and Caesar salad and it was incredible! Can't wait to come back!“

“By far the best pizza. Off all the pizzas around Marin my favorite is Stefano’s and it has being my favorite for the past 20 years..
their slice is huge and it comes with a drink.
There’s many options for toppings and you can add to your slice as well-
you can choose pizza from their menu options or build your own combination. They also have delicious salads and sandwiches.
Also, if you are feeling a bit thirsty they have beer and wine! Win win!“

“I love Round Table pizza! The staff was so welcoming and helpful. I had placed an order for pick up; was told a reasonable amount of time for pick up. I ended up being late for pick up and the gal at the counter asked if I would like them to remake it fresh; which I did!! So nice of them to offer that. I will be back.“

“It's a relatively clean place, the food is terrible but the little kids love it. The prizes always annoy me because the littlest ones can barely get enough tickets for anything. But it is what it is, and compared to the cost for similar places now you can kill an hour or two and it won't send you to the poor house.The games are your standards like ski ball, basketball, touch screen shoot fish games,ect. They also have very limited selection of arcade games, a racing game and an aliens shooter game.

Kid-friendliness: They try to do a good job coraling kids but I saw a 2yr old walk out front alone. However, if you have a toddler there you really should be right next to them at all times anyway.“

“Terrence Collins (died in 2021) was the co-founder of Murphy's Pizza chain in Petaluma.
Now a frachise of over 1300 locations & his $12.5 million Petaluma Mt Rose Ln mansion is available too.
Historical pizza tycoon success story.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“Literally the best beer on earth. This is one of my favorite places on planet earth. The beer is unbelievable. The California style west coast ipas are the beers that put them on the map but the belgian inspired barrel aged sour beers are also world class. I am saying it now. This is and always will be the best brewery in California and on earth.“

“Stellina is probably the only place in Petaluma with international quality standards. The price is moderate but the products that are received for it justify it. I've been going to this place for a couple of weeks and it really doesn't disappoint at all .5 Stars.“

“VEry Unique Offering of Pie Selections... I Tried the Roman Brocolini Slice Which Ran for $11 Bucks... A Plain Might Be $6-7... ALso Tried a Tomatoe Pesto and a Plain... Thier Crust for the NY Style Is Light,, Airy and Soft... They Sure Slapped Some Sauce on the Plain Which Was on the Sweet Side... Cheese Was Slighty Better Than a Typical Pizza Spot... I Give It To the Pesto as They Slapped That On There As Well... More Than Ive Ever Seen Before But Was NOT Overdone... The Place Has a Few Seats Indoors But the Patio Outside Is Nicer To Eat... Even Though It Was Nippy Outside Theres Some Warmers Above Some of the Tables to Keep Uuu Comfortable... WHy NOT Mention Theres Table Service...“

“Lunch Salad Bar and Pizza (Lunch Buffett ) Closes at 2:PM. Im writing this review in hopes alerting people to a healthy lunch option; Salad! All you can eat! I deduct one star because the cash register does not display the price charged, and the spoken English is not perfect but the food is good, if you self restrain from too much pizza.“

“This was the best pizza and garlic bread I have ever had! Everything was freshly made and cooked perfectly. When you take the first bite, all of the delicious flavors are tasted!
This is a much try pizza location when you are in the area!“

“Great restaurant with locally sourced, food and wine“

“I liked the Italian, country styled atmosphere and play list.. I was delighted to see a gluten free pasta choice on the menu, very good and combined with the roasted vegetables, it made a delicious meal. Gracie

Dietary restrictions: I was delighted to see there was a gluten free pasta cuicee. I haven't had good pZya for a long time. The roasted vegetables are wonderful , too“

“My GAH! The meatball sandwich. Add Pepperoni. I am ridiculously full. And it was amazing. 11/10 would recommend. The wait staff is top notch as well.“

“Pizza was a little undercooked a little doughy just put it in the oven for a while and it was fine there is no atmosphere It's just a counter And I pulled it out of a locked oven with a code so there was no service I gave myself my service I guess I would say yeah it was great service I did it myself lol“

“The night we went, the Dominos on Stony Point Rd was down to one working oven, with over an hour wait for pizza. We drove the 5min to the Farmer Lane location, ordered ahead of time, and by the time we got there, our 3 pizza and 2 orders of Parmesan bread bites were ready to go.“

“Full bar, gluten-free crust (cauliflower) with your choice of toppings. Place is in good shape, friendly staff. The gluten free crust is 10" size only, I got it with the chicken BLT toppings. Great with a glass of red (Kendall Jackson). We had use of the private party room for a meeting. Yay!“

“Best vegan pizza ever! Thank you Acre for helping me over the hump on going completely plant-based for the planet. The vegan potato pizza with rosemary & fennel was amazing, both hot when we dined in and cold the next day for lunch leftovers. My partner loved the vegan pepperoni with basil. You did not skimp on the toppings, the crust was divine (crispy, flavorful) and the vegan cheese??!!!! I can’t wait to have it again.“

“A quiet place to eat, mostly people just pick up their pizza ?...

Parking: There aren't many places to park but it doesn't take people more than 5 minutes to vacate a space because they're only stopping by to pick up their orders.“

“Love the bar tenders and appreciate them having this second job. I love the two rock pizza when it's open and appreciate the staff. Enjoy Wednesday's Trivia night and Thursday's kariokie night. Military cards or guest of one is required for entry. ?“

“This is the best Mountain Mikes location!Been coming here since I was about 8 years old, and the staff has changed but the food is still amazing. They even have kept the gaming room section.The last time I came in, I ordered a half Snowy Alps and half cheese and extra pineapple.It was a busy night, but I got my pizza promptly. After getting in my car I opened to sneak a slice, and it didn’t have extra pineapple, it had pineapple and pepperoni. I called immediately and the staff was AMAZING! I can’t stress that enough. Not only did she remake the entire pizza, while I waited she told me to just keep the second one, then the owner came out and apologized, handed me a free soda and 2 more large ranches. I was really taken back by the level of amazing customer service they provided. And the pizza was delicious! So perfect, this place is hard to beat!!Thanks again guys for making my night and correcting the item!! ♥️?

Vegetarian options: Can get anything veg

Kid-friendliness: Great game area and kid friendly restaurant“

“MODD Pizza is like the Picasso of pizzas—every slice is a masterpiece waiting to be devoured! With more toppings than you can shake a spatula at, it's a DIY dream come true. Warning: may induce extreme happiness and cravings for seconds.“