50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cotati

“Just went over to get a pizza. 4pm May 26 2026. Guy behind counter was working on one. Guess he didn’t like chatting or his job. Told him take his time…sat down to wait. Another woman and daughter came in and the pizza guy went right up to them and took care of their order first. Waved at him wondering what’s up and he just shrugged his shoulders. felt like age discrimination… I left.“

“First time going.
Promptly greeted with a friendly smile.
We ordered a couple pizzas, a beer and a root beer for my son.
They have a huge patio area. Kids can run around and play. Adults can play cornhole.
The pizza was really really good.
I will be going back more often.
Zero complaints.“

“Sals is great! Yummy pizza, with so many choices on the menu-both pizza and other choices. Really good New York style pizza, good beer, delicious desserts. Staff is friendly, music is good, and the atmosphere is relaxed. There are a few tables inside and many outside.“

“Best pizza in town! Great customer service every time I come here. I honestly don’t understand some of the negative reviews — you’re in California, not an upscale fancy restaurant where they serve silverware.
I have always been treated with respect and friendliness by all the staff. Everyone is welcoming, professional, and the location is always super clean.
If I could, I would give this place a 10 out of 10!“

“Stopped by for a quick lunch. The piece of prices are on the price of your side, which is reflective of the quality ingredients they use.

Would recommend you try it even though it may not be your everyday go to pizza place.“

“Ordered a bbq chx pizza good thing I checked it before I left apparently when it was going to the oven it got some bubbles and there was four pieces that didn't have any toppings on them because the bubbles were so big and all the toppings went off. I figured either they would offer me a discount or offer to make me another Pizza they didn't either and the guy just handed me my change. But I'm not going out like that, I asked to have another pizza made and they did this one looked much better anyway. The taste on the pizza was very bland. We also ordered boneless chicken garlic parmesan and barbecue and all they did was drizzle the sauce over the top and it was minimal at that also tasted very bland. Too many pizza places around to serve bad stuff and have bad service and we will not be going back.“

“The absolute best pizza! Their crust has a perfect sourdough tang, and is crunchy and chewy. The toppings are creative and sourced from local farms and producers. And I love their delightfully punk vibe. No visit is complete without checking out the fun pictures in the bathroom. Out of 5-stars, they deserve 10!“

“I ordered pasta and some wings last Sunday about 30 minutes before closing (didn’t realize this till after I placed the order). I didn’t catch the guys name, but he was polite, kind and very hospitable. He also gave me pizza bread! When I picked up my order I was handed a rather larger box for my pasta, didn’t realize till I got home there was pizza bread in there!! I didn’t have the opportunity to say thank you in person, so I wanted to say thank you here. Great service and amazing food!“

“I have been going to hectors pizza for about 30 years now recipe workers everybody there are still the same will continue being my favorite pizza“

“Best pizza I’ve had in Sonoma County.“

“Tony's of North Beach is our favorite spot when we're with a big group. We always snag the “Hide Out,” which is the cozy back room off the main dining area. You really should check it out! The pizzas are top-notch in Sonoma County, and the service is always fantastic. Can't wait for our next get-together at Tony's.“

“Been awhile since I have been here. Still top notch, pizza selection is many, I do wish they had salami, but many good options. Hot tasty and good crust. The William Tell salad is my favorite. Plus a healthy selection of wine and my favorite, Whiskey. It can be a little loud on a Sat evening but the place is hopping.“

“Food is incredible! Bacon Alfredo break sticks are insanely amazing.“

“absolutely the best pizza around this area. Great food, nice people, a great combo.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“5 star review great service Madeline“

“I'm in here from Reno Nevada some of the best pizza I've had in a long time came out quick tasted great enjoy looking at all the memorabilia on the walls would definitely recommend this place next time I'm in Petaluma I'll be sure to stop at Pinky's Pizza“

“definitely unprofessional not ok to tell a customer that even though the person taking your order over the phone messed up your order then you call then rude employee female at 6:30 pm answer the phone saying they can resend it out but charge me delivery fee again which is not ok or how it works I worked for domino's for a few years now and we don't do bussiness like that at all its unprofessional to lie to a customer then when the customer ask for a manger you don't put them on hold for 15 minutes and you over hear the person on the phone say just great saying not professional things about the customer completely rude and employee needs written up an reprimanded for this type of behavior but the manager is going to make it right but no customer should ever have to wait 45 minutes more to get there correct order completely not ok hopefully the GM and the district manager will look into the store off bear valley in apple valley to train there employees in proper procedures and professional way to handle customer service we order all the time never have these type of issues very disappointed“

“THE BEST PIZZA!!!! LO🍕E!!!“

“Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!“

“Great creative pizza types!! Order and then get it delivered so you can enjoy the best pizza around. Check out that menu!!“

“We came here because we were visiting downtown and my daughter wanted some pizza. We came in with low expectations, but the food ended up being really good!
We ordered the ceasar salad and a large pizza. It was very delicious.
The guy at the front was also very helpful and friendly.“

“Great restaurant with locally sourced, food and wine“

“Had there pizza for the first time. It was delicious,we ordered some of the gourmet style pizzas they were amazing! We had them baked and delivered they arrived right on time.“

“Great service. Great food. We will be back. Please put braised short ribs back on the menu.“

“I can’t thank Charles enough for the superior customer service that he extended to me! Took the time to explain the app. Understood when we had a sickness and had to cancel the order. Then so graciously helped me again to place the order when we figured out when we could do the party. Charles delivered the pizza and add on’s with right on time with a huge smile on his face! A pleasure to deal with! Thanks again Charles! Happy Holidays!“

“This is a great place for lunch or dinner. Fresh ingredients in salads and pizza toppings. Friendly service. Lots of options which are inexpensive. The Petaluma Extreme Pizza is the best! 🍕“

“Lived in Boston for 17 years and worked in a pizza place growing up. Was craving the hell out of pizza from back home. Saw the pictures of the food here and it looked promising so I decided to have an open mind and order a pepperoni. Figured it’s basic enough and hard to screw up. To be honest, the flavor of the pizza lowkey pisses me off. It’s WICKED frickin close. Probably the closest New York style pizza I’ve had since I left the northeast. Change a spice or two in the sauce, get a different brand of pepperoni, change the yeast ratio in the dough, leave the oregano on the side, and it would be some authentic shit. Docked a point for the craving let down but I won’t let that sway me - will definitely be back! So happy I gave this place a shot!“

“They serve some of my favorite coffee in the county! I couldn't ask for better service or product :)“

“So fun watching the game with friends Service was good too 🏈😊“

“This may sound silly. But I genuinely appreciate that the employees dont give me annoyed looks when I ask for no garlic butter on items. This is my preferred dominos between Sebastopol and Santa Rosa areas. Their dough rises well. I get nearly flat pizza when I order anywhere else. They're also generous with the toppings. Just all around great crew, friendly people.“

“We've eaten at this Mary's for years and have been very pleased. Yesterday our online order was lost and I had to wait about 25 minutes for our pizzas. The upshot? The young man who was managing apologized and didn't charge me for our pies. We also got a gift card for future use. This is how to get happy, repeat customers.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“Just checked out this place for the first time yesterday (9/5/26); took my family out for dinner. Amazing! The food was incredible! The ambiance and menu is family friendly. Understandably busy but also there is enough table spacing, so you don't feel like a sardine. The presentation was beautiful and service is authentic and friendly. You can tell there is a lot of care behind both the food and the experience.
Reservations do require a credit card to hold, which is completely reasonable for a popular place like this.
Overall, we had a wonderful family dinner and were really impressed. It's exciting to have a place like this in Petaluma. We will definitely be back! Highly recommend!“

“I got help by an employee named Issa she was super sweet and had a positive attitude she seemed very focused and calm while helping me decide what I should get and the pizza came out amazing definitely will be going back to this location 😊😊😊“

“Stellina is probably the only place in Petaluma with international quality standards. The price is moderate but the products that are received for it justify it. I've been going to this place for a couple of weeks and it really doesn't disappoint at all .5 Stars.“

“Delicious food with friendly and great people! Definitely recommend if you find yourself around the Barlow . Pizza by the slice if you’re in a hurry, or sit down menu if you’re looking to have a nice sit down experience.“

“Great farm to table fresh meals! Im hopelessly addicted to the Chicken Faro Salad. Great, friendly staff. I highly recommend eating here.“

“Have had many delicious meals at Wild Goat Bistro. So many delicious menu options that appeal to everyone—even for those who are gluten-free and vegan. The staff is so friendly and makes excellent recommendations for food & drink. Wild Goat is a Petaluma gem.“

“As a driver for DoorDash, I went by here on my way to my regular job to pick up an order. I haven’t eaten yet at this location, but the customer service was fantastic and the pizza smelled good. Clean, organized and well run Round Table pizza place. Staff friendly and very helpful.“

“This is mine and my boyfriend’s favorite place to eat! The food is not only delicious but the people who work there are just so absolutely wonderful! The service is impeccable. (We very much enjoy seeing the staff when we go… and if you are seeing this we love you guys!!!) We try and go at least every other week, and when we bring someone new it becomes their new obsession too. We are considering reaching out to see if we can host an event or have them cater our engagement party. I just want to share this place with the world it’s so fabulous in every way possible. Make sure you have the fried meat gyozas and the pork belly chasu!!! 1000/10 would recommend. Also their kimchi is to die for, I always order extra. I wish they sold it by the tub! Hands down best place in Santa Rosa!“

“Great food service? Everything!“

“Fun for the kids! 🤩 Always clean and well maintained.“

“I want to take the time to share such an amazing customer service experience at the Mary's on Summerfield.

I ordered online for NYE at around 6:25 pm. It was a last minute decision as other places we were going to get dinner from were closed. My order was forecasted to be done for pick up at 7:10 pm.

I got to Marys at 6:55 pm. Earlier than anticipated due to the rain. It was definitely busy for pick up orders. It is NYE. So definitely to be expected. I got to the head of the line and was told my pickup order should be done by 7:15 pm. Close enough. I wasnt bothered. 7:20 pm rolls around and I go to the counter to check on my order. Im not mad or irritated. I just wanted an eta as I can see how hard the crew is working and the phones are ringing non stop. I approached the counter and the young gentleman was already anticipating my question. He apologized for the delay and handed me a monetary voucher to use for next time. He said it would be another 20 minutes and apologized again. I wasnt expecting such a kind gesture. I could see how busy they were and its expected due to the evening it was. 20 mins passed and my order was ready. The young gentleman called me over, apologized again for the delay, and gave me some cookies (as well) for waiting. I wish I got the young gentleman's name. He went above and beyond. It wasnt expected but very much appreciated.

The food was hot and delicious as well! Quality was just as good even with how busy they were.

Mary's, Thank you for showing such great customer service. I can see your staff was working so hard on such a busy night. Much Thanks to all of the staff your effort and service is so appreciated.“

“Lovely atmosphere, stellar wines & food & service“

“Had lunch there today. I had a French dip sandwich made of prime rib.. I had the sandwich, packed with prime rib, plus au jus. The fun was crispy, but not ready. As a side, they provided tater tots, which I happen to love. I asked if I could also have a side of coleslaw, which was delicious and was added without charge. It was about the best French dip that I’ve ever had in 67 years. The bun was crispy, but not heavy. Dipped into the au jus, it was heaven.They are good hearted people, and they should be patronized.“

“love the topping options!“

“Ralph (the owner) is an absolutely wonderful human being. We grew up on Fergene’s and it’s my first meal in California every time we’re in town to see family. Specifically the Chipotle Chicken pizza,“

“Love the bar tenders and appreciate them having this second job. I love the two rock pizza when it's open and appreciate the staff. Enjoy Wednesday's Trivia night and Thursday's kariokie night. Military cards or guest of one is required for entry. ?“

“I thought I would be disappointed because the larger size is only 11”. Boy was I wrong. The crust was perfect, with nice sauce and cheese. Add 4 or 5 of your favorite ingredients and boy do you have a MEAL.

Nice employees, cute dining area. I’m picky about pizza, and this place is great!“