17 Best Italian Restaurants in San Mateo

Pausa Bar & Cookery Italian • $$$
223 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

House Selection of Cheese
Wagyu Beef Bistro Tender
House Made Focaccia
Roasted Bone Marrow
Housemade Focaccia
Carnaroli Risotto
Saffron Casarecce
Margherita Pizza
Duck Leg Confit
Pizza Margherita

“Cocktails and Wagyu - soooo good!“

4.3 Superb432 Reviews
Vespucci Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
147 E 3rd Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Scaloppine Di Vitello Veal Scaloppini
Black Ink Spaghetti Alla Vespucci
Pappardelle with Beef Ribs Ragout
Ravioli Ricotta E Spinaci
Fettuccine Alla Boscaiola
Spaghetti Alla Bolognese
Bruschetta Alla Vespucci
Cannoli Alla Siciliana
Gnocchi Al Gorgonzola
Petrale Sole Piccata

“Excellent food every time we have been… will be back. Everything is great on their menu. 🥰 Tonight we had guest from Montreal, celebrated Mother’s Day and our 23rd Wedding Anniversary! We couldn’t be happier to eat at Vespucci. Manuela and Francesco feel like my southern Italian family. Warm, welcoming, good food and wine and genuine conversation. Love them.“

4.8 Superb160 Reviews
La Lanterna Ristorante Italian • $$
180 W 25th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

The Bread and Olive Oil Alone Is Great
Squid Ink Spaghetti Con Frutti Di Mare
Linguine Con Vongole
Linguini Con Vongole
Carpaccio Di Manzo
Homemade Gnocchi
Calamari Fritti
Burrata Caprese
Bread Pudding
Caesar Salad

“Amazing service. Great food. Awesome staff! Can’t recommend it more highly.“

4.6 Superb165 Reviews
Ravioli House Italian • $
505 S B St, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Meat Ravioli with Pesto Sauce
Brisket Pastrami Sandwich
East Coast on Dutch Crunch
Black Forest Ham Sandwich

“We had the meat ravioli with bolognese sauce and a meatloaf sandwich on a soft roll. Both were fantastic. Highly recommend visiting. Parking was easy and cheap.

Vegetarian options: Cheese Ravioli, Squash Ravioli.

Parking: There are many in front as well as directly across the street.“

4.7 Superb52 Reviews
Sapore Express Italian • $$
125 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Scialatelli Alla Amatriciana
Pappardelle Alla Bolognese
Ravioli Ricotta E Spinaci
Tagliolini Alle Vongole
Arugula Beet Salad
Guazzetto Di Cozze
Calamari Fritti
Bruschetta
Tiramisu
Sauce

“A little charming restaurant in downtown San Mateo, homemade bread with delicious dipping sauce. We had fried calamari and squid ink pasta (hand made in the shop) with prawns and mussels exceeding our expectations, definitely will visit again to try other dishes.“

4.6 Superb96 Reviews
LUCETI'S on 25th Italian • $$
109 W 25th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meatballs
Fettuccine Luceti
Chicken Carbonara
Hot Fudge Sundae
Fried Calamari
Veal Scaloppini
Wedge Salad
Table Decor
Lava Cake
Ravioli

“A hidden gem of a family-run Italian restaurant—don’t be misled by the humble exterior. Inside, you’re welcomed with genuine hospitality and unforgettable food. My husband and I ordered the filet of sole and the white Provini veal scallopini—both were bursting with flavor and perfectly portioned. This isn’t a place for flashy plating—it’s all about honest, delicious Italian cooking made with care. The host greeted us with a warm smile and made us feel instantly at home. The retro, moody lighting adds a cozy, nostalgic touch. We’ll definitely be back! Tip: Make a reservation—this spot stays busy, and for good reason.“

4.5 Superb143 Reviews
Sole Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
69 37th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Complimentary Bread and Dipping Sauce with All Orders
Spicy Italian Sausage over Spaghetti
Gnocchi Tartufati Vegetarian
Tiramisu Cake and Ice Cream
Pappardelle Alla Bolognese
Pasta with Tomato Sauce
Bruschetta Al Pomodoro
Linguine Alle Vongole
Tagliolini Con Gamberi
Seafood Fra Diavolo

“Nice all the time“

4.6 Superb29 Reviews
Peninsula Italian American Social Club Italian • $$
100 N B St, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Pasta

“Great people. First class bocce ball and facility“

4.4 Superb16 Reviews
Tomatina Italian • $$
401 S B St, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo with Alfredo Sauce
Tomatina's Signature Garlic Rolls
Pizza with Mozzarella and Sauce
Mama's Spaghetti and Meatballs
Create Your Own Calzone
Baked Penne Bolognese
Calamari Fritti
Apple Crisp
Bruschetta
Lasagna

“friendly atmosphere, quick service, really good food!“

4 Good127 Reviews
Fiero Caffe Cafe • $
106 S El Camino Real, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Salmon Omelet with Goat Cheese
Croissant Ham and Cheese
Spinach Ricotta Ravioli
Vegetarian Pesto Panini
Smoked Salmon Omelette
Spaghetti Carbonara
Penne Salmon Pasta
Spaghetti Meatballs
Chicken Parmigana
Eggplant Parmesan

“Fiero Cafe is truly a hidden gem in San Mateo! From the moment you walk in, you can feel the passion and authenticity behind everything they do. Filippo Guarino, the owner, pours his heart into every dish, and it shows. His handcrafted Italian food is nothing short of extraordinary, fresh ingredients, rich flavors, and the kind of attention to detail you only find in true Italian cooking.

I tried the catzo sandwich, and it was fantastic, perfectly balanced and absolutely delicious. On top of the food, Filippo makes you feel like family, welcoming you with warmth and genuine hospitality.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in the Bay Area, Fiero Cafe is a must. Do yourself a favor and go, you’ll leave planning your next visit before you even walk out the door.“

4.7 Superb109 Reviews
Rainbow Pizza Pizza • $$
112 De Anza Blvd, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meatballs and Meat Sauce
Chicken Carbonara and Garlic Bread
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
Greek-American Pizza
Chicken Caesar Salad
Shrimp Caesar Salad
Greek Island Salad
Tzatziki and Fries
Linguine and Clams
Meatball Spaghetti

“Best pizza in the Bay Area!“

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
Mr Burrito Man Pizza • $$
201 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Quesadilla

“The best place to eat and takeover for the days I don’t want to cook, friendly, clean with delicious and affordable dishes… loved food, the owners care is super friendly and I recommend this experience ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🚀“

4.5 Superb24 Reviews
Pasta Italiano Pizza •
201 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

“We had never ordered from here but took a chance tonight. My husband had the Penne with Alfredo sauce, and I had the baked Penne with Marinara sauce. They were both amazingly delicious! The portions could have been a bit larger, but we weren't left hungry! We will order from here again! I can't rate the atmosphere since we ordered out.“

4.5 Superb17 Reviews
Mr Pizza Man San Mateo Pizza • $$
201 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16 Inch
Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza
Peninsula Special
Combination Pizza
Garlic Bread
Mr Pizza Man
Cheese Pizza
BBQ Wings
Tiramisu
Sauce

“The best place to eat and takeover for the days I don’t want to cook, friendly, clean with delicious and affordable dishes… loved food, the owners care is super friendly and I recommend this experience ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🚀“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Pizza My Heart Pizza • $
140 E 4th Ave, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Suprime Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Pepperoni and Mushroom Slice of Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Hawaiian Pizza
Big Sur Pizza
Bread Stix
Old

“Best pizza in the bay. A+++++++“

4 Good21 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo

“best Pizza in SF :)“

4.1 Good71 Reviews
Tastee Grill Mediterranean • $
1001 Park Pl, San Mateo

Customers` Favorites

Hummus with Ground Beef
Chicken Shawarma
Green Hot Sauce
Classic Hummus
Falafel Plate V
Falafel Plate
Pita Sandwich
Falafel Wrap
Schnitzel
Baklava

“The food is incredibly good, fresh and tasty. The service is excellent. The Village maze plate was fabulous and the portions are generous. The price is low compared to other restaurants in the area.“

3.3 Good55 Reviews

You May Also Like