21 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Fairfield

“Shout out to the Goodie Shop! Mark created the most incredible coffee themed cake for my daughter’s bridal shower. It was beautiful, delicious, and unforgettable! Guests couldn’t stop raving! Thank you, Mark for the amazing job on a very special cake! I recommend a Mark in the goodie shop for those special treats for your special day!“

“Great customer service. And the flavors were so intense. I ended up getting chocolate hazelnut and almond gelatos. I was not disappointed.“

“We just tried Il Bacio for the first time and I can’t believe we didn’t know about them before! It was absolutely delicious— we will definitely go back!“

“Dr. Mike's Ice Cream is BY FAR the best ice cream I have ever had anywhere. No contest. I have been eating it for at least 25 years, and my conviction about this has never wavered. At all. Ever. I moved back to CT from Portland, OR about 2 1/2 years ago (lived there for about 5) and Dr. Mike's was prominent on the list of reasons I moved back. Portland is a food town, and nothing there is in the remote vicinity of Dr. Mike's. Salt and Straw, which has lines of customers around the corner in Portland, is NOTHING compared to Dr. Mike's. I just wish the new owner would pry the original recipe for blueberry ice cream from Robert Allison because Robert Allison changed it a few years before he sold and it is a pale shadow of its former greatness. The original blueberry was maybe the best thing I've ever eaten. But all the core flavors and many of the experimental new flavors are just phenomenal. Best ice cream on the planet.“

“I've been to Grassroots in Simsbury, so I was excited to see one here. My family and I were exploring the town on a balmy day. The perfect day for some Grassroots ice cream. There was a line when we got there but it moved quickly. There a few small tables, all taken. By the time we ordered and got our our ice cream, the place cleared out and we were able to snag a table.

The ice cream I got was delicious, per usual. I'm rating 5 stars on just the ice cream alone. I am a fan of their small batch ice cream. They have unique flavors which I'm a super fan of. I love their blackberry and goat cheese ice cream! Yes, definitely check them out!“

“The absolute BEST ICE CREAM EVER!!!! My family is still talking about it. All other ice cream with forever be compared but is really no comparison you won't find any better. We are currently dreaming of our next trip across the country to get more!“

“Lots of flavors. Blueberry pistachio in a cone- flavor and ice cream texture was exactly how it should be. Cone was crispy.

Grabbed some pre made ice cream sandwiches. Crispy fresh cookies were too sweet for me. Vanilla had a clean vanilla taste. Chocolate was deep. Strawberry could've use more of that sweet tart Strawberry flavor. Mint was heck a minty- not a complaint...lol...

Tight indoor space. No indoor seating. Decent parking. Nice large grassy outdoor area.“

“DELICIOUS! Very clean place, staff is very friendly! Love coming here :)“

“The food was incredible. The best ice cream I have ever had. The staff were also incredibly nice and sweet, and wasn’t rude at all when we asked for a lot of samples. The lady working at the front was very helpful and very kind. Also, they have a ton of variety, so anyone can enjoy it. Plus, there is a ton of seating, inside or outside. Highly recommend… 10/10“

“Yum!! Colorful and comfy place to hang out. Nice selection.“

“Crumbl has always been my favorite. Yes it can be a little pricey sometimes but depending on the lineup THEY HIT and totally worth it!!“

“I’ve been a self-proclaimed Starbucks girl for YEARS, but now Reverie is my go-to place for coffee and a delicious treat. You simply can’t beat the service at Reverie. All of the baristas are incredibly pleasant and are great at recommending drinks and customizing them to your liking. The menu has a great variety and you can always a get a copycat of your favorite “chain store” drink (and a better one at that!) While I’m a die-hard coffee girl (iced caramel or mocha latte for me!), what has really sold me at Reverie is their food. I love the variations on classic breakfast items like waffles with delectable toppings, and “hummus toast” as opposed to the traditional avocado. I love their Mushroom Avocado Toast, Everything Chixpea Toast, and the classic Peanut Butter Banana + Honey Toast. Yum! With locally sourced ingredients and a new, refreshing vibe at Promenade on 6, you can’t go wrong making this your new breakfast spot!“

“Great froyo!!! Friendly staff and clean place😉❤🍦“

“Huge shoutout to Uncle Louie G’s. We had my son’s First Communion today and the ice cream truck was a HUGE hit with both the kids and adults! Will definitely be using them again!!“

“Stephen ensured our trip was amazing! Thank you“

“Great local place- dependably delicious!“

“Great food, inexpensive for the area. This resturant has been in this location for years but must have new owners. The food is delicious, the service is attentive. The bathrooms literally sparkled! Beware the regular size hard ice cream cone. It's HUGE!!“

“Every Thanksgiving, Baskin Robbins offers a festively bizarre ice cream cake shaped like an actual turkey! They start with a giant MOUND of your favorite ice cream flavor, mold it into a turkey shape, cover it in cake frosting, add cones as turkey “legs,” and douse the entire faux bird in caramel praline glaze to give it a fresh out-of-the-ovenesque sheen.

The sheer spectacle and concept of such a cake entrance me every year! I normally resist the temptation to buy one of these magnificent looking dessert creations each holiday season to spare my wallet (and waistline). However, my buddy Rick was kind enough to front the cost of a turkey cake for me to finally try this year…. On one condition 😈… I devour one entire cake in a single sitting. I could not turn down such a awfully generous offer and promptly took him up on his ice cream cake challenge.

I immediately called up Baskin Robbins and asked for a cake filled with with eggnog ice cream for the light “breast meat,” and chocolate peanut butter stuffed in cones for that dark “leg meat” 😂. The Baskin Robbins team took careful note, filled my order precisely, and even had it all ready for me to pick by the end of the day! Huge kudos to the staff at the Patterson location for their impressive speed in “cooking up” this bird the week of Thanksgiving!

I brought it home and let it harden up in my freezer overnight before I giving this turkey cake its final rites. Clocking in at a mere 3.75lb, I was able to ram the whole thing back effortlessly and casually in a quick 10 minutes and ONE second 😆. Despite my rapid gorging, I still savored each and every spoonful that passed my lips.“

“This place is amazing, I stopped to get some ice cream for me and my friend and got the best costumer service. it was the best, they always remember know your oder which is surprisingly outstanding for ice cream shops and all the people are so loving and the manager was so kind and caring he greets all the customers with a big smile 😊, very good manager. The team looks like a family all coordinated and caring and surprisingly very quick. The ice cream was good I got a banana split and the flavors were out of this world. Even though I got there after hours they were so loving that they attended me and still gave me the same quick customer service
.Definitely coming back🥰

Dietary restrictions: You can choose what you want if you are diary free.

Kid-friendliness: All the works were very kind and friendly.“

“All my money goes straight to this bubble tea. Friendly staff.“

“I highly recommend JJ Stacks. Joe was wonderful and the food was amazing!!! He catered our teacher appreciation. and the staff at Westside was raving how wonderful the food was. Everything was fresh and so easy to setup,“