21 Best American Restaurants near New Hartford

“Absolutely the best pizza ever!“

“Alway unique food and drink , delicious doesn’t even begin to describe it. The cozy, homey atmosphere and excellent entertainment make this a perfect spot any night!“

“I ordered the BAHAMA MAMA SHRIMP TACOS and I couldn’t believe how good they were. Great food, great staff and the owner was excellent on communicating about the wait for our table. I would definitely go out of my way and go back to this restaurant.“

“Great place to eat and socialize. Friendly and low key vibe. I love their smash burgers and fries, maple chicken, shrimp tacos, and more. Staff and owner are great. You can do take out orders too.“

“Been going for years never been let down staff very good and food is always great would recommend to anyone for a great meal“

“nope will not be back.1 no more chicken nachos they were the best,they no longer serve burgers in the dinning room but you can get chicken wings,didn't have any angel hair pasta, portions have been down sized chicken parm was about half the size it used to be.pasta was over cooked and had no flavor... was told that the owner is the chef dont know if that changed but something did. waitresses was awsome service was very good. dont think we will be making the trip out here anymore. sorry coach stop it is what it is. amendment 45 minutes after we left the coach stop 2 out of the five of us had explosive diarrhea.“

“I love, love, love everything about The Railway Cafe. It’s adorable inside, the food is truly the BEST in Winchester and I love supporting their cause. We’ve had a phenomenal experience every time we’ve been. Donny is the best!“

“Had my daughters Bridal Shower at Fairview Farm Gold Course. It was beautiful and the food was incredible. Everyone had a great time! Highly recommend.“

“We felt the food and atmosphere were great, definitely a bit more of a fancy place than we normally go to. A bit pricey but the food was very good. My only issue and the biggest reason we most likely will not be going back is they do not have or offer a kids menu and were not very accommodating to kids. I understand it’s fancier place to eat but I was very unprepared when I had my son with me not knowing they did not have a kids menu. He ended up eating French fries for dinner and I had to go home to make him something else.“

“Great food, wonderful staff“

“We had a wonderful experience at George’s today. At a party of 6 adults, and 2 toddlers, we were very happy to sit down soon after arriving. We had a knowledgeable waitress who accommodated our special dietary needs. The food was delicious and enjoyed by all of our group. We would highly recommend this super, hometown feel, very professional restaurant for everyone! (And I totally felt comfortable eating their gluten free options)“

“4th year being a non resident golf member here and I absolutely love it! The most affordable private club to join in the area and the amenities keep getting better!

The investments into the golf course, restraunt, bar area, and outside seating has gotten very classy! They redid the entire bar and dining room area. The makeover was much needed!

As for the staff, everyone at the pro shop at wonderful and genuine. Kevin, (head pro) is one of the best! His witty jokes and puns make my entrance more enjoyable each and every time! He is wise with his lessons and is a great teacher with the junior golfers. I took a package deal lesson with him and the results have helped me tremendously!

The assistant head pros are young and agile. Quiet and reserved but then I think some of Kevin's humor has rubbed off on them! Mike has been working with my son on lessons...with it being his first junior golfer also, this will help mold him into a possible early retirement job for myself to be his caddy! Fingers crossed!

Overall, I love playing here and dining in. Yes the prices are a bit steep but what isn't expensive nowadays...it is an older population majority but I see more young guns coming in to help blend the crowd!

P.s. I have gone and played some public courses....but I'm so used to playing on lush tee boxes, fairways that have all divots filled, sand traps that are sand....and greens that run fast and quick. Public courses seem to be wanting money rather than quality

James
A.k.a. The butcher“

“My family and I love to go on random drives each weekend just to explore our state. During those drives we decide to support and eat at local businesses. Today we stopped at McGrane’s, we were greeted and allowed to choose where we wanted to seat upon entering. The breakfast offerings were ample. My wife and I ordered the All American and my daughter the stackable combo. The All American is eggs your way, with meat option, home fries and toast w/ coffee and the stackable comes with eggs and your choice of waffles or pancakes. Everything came out relatively quickly and the portions were great and the food was good. My only problem was with service - maybe because this has a locals only vibe or it could have been just me but the servers came by only once after we were seated from when we originally seated and offered coffee to when we received our food and got a refill. The rest of the time they ignored our table but had gone to other tables multiple times. Towards the end of our breakfast I saw one server cast a side glance to see if we were about done but never asked if we needed a container or the check. We did that ourselves once we got the attention of another server. Overall if you do come and eat here if you are not a local don’t expect friendliness but you will still get a good breakfast.“

“This is our go to place when I am craving Fries and him Tenders, in two separate occasions we brought 8 people here and now it's there go to place. The loaded fries are absolutely divine I cannot get enough of them and I believe it's called sweet asian tenders forgive me if I am wrong my fiance orders 2 plates of them he really wants the recipe lol.
When we go now we always bring a group of people and our family who lives down south tells us every time they visit we all have to go to Sawyer's.
Also if you love Dart's it's a great place to play the game and chill.“

“Great dinner! Loved the new chicken mozzarella sandwich.“

“Kindness all around. Great food.“

“Delicious Burgers, Onion Rings, Shakes, And More! Great Service! Affordable Prices! Enjoy! ❤“

“We arrived to some nice scenery outside & the decorations inside are beautiful, the staff were so nice! The food was delicious, and we were not rushed at all. The greenhouse is so toasty with heat, not uncomfortable either! Our waitress, Allie, most loveliest person I’ve ever met, you could tell she is there because she enjoys people. Absolutely will visit again! The atmosphere, the staff, the food, all excellent!“

“Loved having lunch here, plan to be back many times as a regular customer.“

“This is their best location. Right by the Farmington river. Drinks are avg. food is good. The view is what brings me back. Service is good for the most part. Their apps are probably above avg to similar venues.“

“Very reasonable price on the food, will definitely return!“