29 Best Italian Restaurants near New Milford

“Excellent food and service!!“

“We never have a bad experience here. From the moment you walk in the door everyone is welcoming and friendly. We love Edras, he’s always so polite and happy and truly loves what he does. Vivian always makes delicious drinks to our liking! Lucia’s is one of our go to restaurants no matter the day!!“

“Had the best birthday dinner last night. My veal scallopini was perfection and the NY strip was delicious. My husband also had an appetizer with crepes stuffed with chicken and mushrooms which he said was outstanding. The service was so friendly and impeccable. Even though we were the last customers before closing we didn’t feel rushed at all. Always amazed that Chef Carlos is the one that prepares your meal all these years. La Piccolina never disappoints.“

“This place was delicious! I cannot recommend it enough. We had Helmut as a server and he was great. We asked him for recommendations and they were great! Even though it was very hard to cut through the gluten free pizza crust. But we got it cut and eaten. The rest of our meals were so good! Gluten free pasta, mussels, salmon and pasta, lobster ravioli - all wonderful!“

“Best Pizza ever. Great customer service and terrific food. We just stopped in one day and have returned many times. It was a great surprise to find. Everything we have had has been great. Enjoy!“

“I've been going to this location for roughly 6-7 years. It's gone through 3 different owners until this point. The new ownership is by far the best to date. Everything I've had up until this point I'd highly recommended. I haven't tried everything yet, but one of my favorites so far was the shrimp francese, (I added capers to mine). The current pizza maker has stayed with the business throughout the years and has gone through the ranks and changes. He does a great job and should be celebrated for his hard work and dedication. I'm excited to welcome this new restaurant to my list of places I love to eat in New Milford. If you haven't been, definitely check it out! If for nothing else, at least to check out their JUMBO slices!

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizzas!

Dietary restrictions: Let them know of any preferences, allergy concerns and they are happy to accommodate

Parking: Lots of parking

Kid-friendliness: Kids are always welcome

Wheelchair accessibility: No problem for people until wheelchairs or walkers to access the building“

“Love love love your pizza Chicken parmigiana the best I ever had Service is always good Francine Westgate“

“Amazing food ! Atmosphere!“

“Such a great place to do all the things! Great for a good night out at the bar, great for family dinner, delicious food at a great price. Karaoke on Wednesdays is always a blast! Can’t rave enough about this place, the staff is amazing and makes for such a good time.“

“If you're considering a visit to this restaurant, know that anything less than a 5-star review does not do it justice! This restaurant truly represents the pinnacle of hospitality. From the very beginning, you are treated as family! The staff embraces you with open arms plus an occasional warm hug from their world-renowned Chef Giovanni!! Wow, can this guy cook, Mamma Mia!!! Now, let’s talk about the food. Every dish recommended was an absolute triumph. The flavors were so extraordinary and enduring that, while you feel completely satisfied, you find yourself eagerly anticipating the next bite almost as soon as each plate is cleared. Every plate that passed close to us looked insanely delicious. It was such a memorable night of outstanding dishes! This place is a masterclass in originality and hospitality, seamlessly blending both into an unforgettable dining experience and a warm feeling of home. Truly💝amazing!!!🍷⭐️🍸⭐️🍝⭐️🍤⭐️🥗⭐️🍖⭐️🍮⭐️🥂 Buon appetito!“

“My Brothers go to, as he lives in the area...when I'm visiting I stop in and get the chicken marsala(and not just one,?)....the people that work there are beautiful and kind. They put their hearts into their business ...We recommend Spasis to EVERYONE......I'm looking forward to going very soon.

Kid-friendliness: easy menu for kids pallet...“

“Everything was great, from the ease of making the reservation to leaving and being thanked by the owners on our way out. Service was great, the drinks were made to perfection and the meals were all delicious. We highly recommend you try 4 Seasons Mediterranean Cuisine…“

“Absolutely wonderful experience at our first time at Rebellion tonight! From the vibe and atmosphere, to the most amazing drinks by Dorian at the bar and the incredible, elevated food (Bronzino & NY Strip to be specific) and just an absolute amazing experience overall. A must visit! 5 🌟 all the way!!“

“Dishonest business sells gift certificates yet doesn't honor them. Will be contacting BBB of New England“

“This is my go to place to eat. The food and service is amazing. The waiters are excellent and the owner always makes me feel welcome. I find it to be the best Italian restaurant in this area.“

“We had Mangia Mangia cater our recent rehearsal dinner - it was hands down the best food we have had in a long time. Everything was perfect- Raquel was a tremendous help and she took all the stress away from hosting a large party. I HIGHLY recommend using them for anyone looking for catering a large event. Bladimir, Joline and all the staff were very accommodating- we even called and got 10+pizzas delivered the day after the wedding too!! Huge Hit!!“

“Love this restaurant and the food is delicious“

“The best pizza in Danbury! 5 stars!!“

“Friendly folks,good food and quick service were my experience 👍“

“Scott and his team catered our wedding this September. If we could provide more than 5 stars, we would! He was more than accommodating and made this process stress-free. We gave him ideas about what kind of food/style we were hoping for and he ran with it. We were not limited to a pre-created catering menu and were told that he and his team could make "anything we want". He provided recommendations from our reception space, to service style, and menu to even linens. We are still getting comments from our guests raving about the food and service from our wedding. Scott and his team exceeded our expectations and then some. Highly recommend!“

“BEST PIZZA IN PUTNAM COUNTY! If you haven’t been here yet you don’t know what you are missing!“

“We recently celebrated my mother`s 100th birthday at Pulcinellas with about 40 friends and family and everyone is still talking about it ! Linda ensured perfection all around. The pizza, antipasto, entrees (chicken champagne, veal francese, eggplant rolatini, penne a la vodka), and sides were delicious and plentiful. The pistachio BD cake was gorgeous and tasted out of this world! the staff was so attentive to everyone's needs and the piano player added to the festive atmosphere. Thank You Linda, John and team for making the event so special and memorable for my mom and our entire family“

“Best Deli / EATERY in town. This place is a hidden GEM ! Everything here is freshly made and the staff are very friendly. It’s hard to find good delis these days in Connecticut but this is the place ! The new owner comes from a long years of experience in the kitchen industry and they are very knowledgeable in what you want to eat. No such thing as language barrier, it’s all about communication and how detailed you are with how you want your order to be made.

Best place in TOWN !“

“Asked for extra garlic on half of a large pizza. They actually put slices of garlic on it! ❤️ Slices of garlic! ❤️ I was expecting the usual processed minced garlic, but nope, they sliced garlic to put on my pizza. I'm really impressed. And the pizza was amazing!“

“Everything that I have had, has been great. Friendly staff as well. However, prices on the menu on their website are not accurate. Website needs to be updated as it’s misleading to customers.“

“Best pizza around, salad was great too.“

“Great meal! Large portions at reasonable prices. Just enjoyed the incredible toasted garlic bread & Chicken Portobello. Yum! Will definitely go back👏👏 🍷🍷🍴“

“I just had dinner with my family at Portofino‘s restaurant in BETHEL and Alida and the staff couldn’t be any nicer. The food was absolutely fantastic Rocco the chef does everything to perfection in a relaxed atmosphere it was so pleasant we can’t wait to return you can’t go wrong with Portofino‘s“

“John's Just hosted my dad's funeral luncheon...being Italian and having my family from NY come I wanted it perfect, so Libero tolerated my requests, made me feel at ease and delivered! I could not have been more pleased! The service, food , portions, bar staff, relaxed atmosphere, the way they treated my guests including the children, truly made it a very special day and celebration of my dad's life. We were able to cheer, cry, salute, speak, play some favorite music, etc.They made it very intimate for us! I am grateful-bonus- Great desserts! thank you.“