22 Best Italian Restaurants near Poughquag

“Pizza to go only. You can't have pizza in the dining room. Pizza is outstanding. Too bad we can't have it there along with the rest of the menu. It seems like it's about to close due to the lack of menus available and the fact that the menu was poorly stapled. Best pizza !“

“Always my go to place!! But it’s now sold to a different owner and they are absolutely horrible and the food is gross!!! I would not even go to get a slice of pizza!!!! PS:The New owner thinks he a GOD in the kitchen!!! to add a update.....it takes them hours to cook anything I mean anything! we order 2 things of chicken fingers and fries and it took them over a hour!!! PS they put Parmesan cheese on French fries for kids!! That's nasty that's nasty!“

“All I can is WOW....great service/great food + awesome family = GREAT MOTHER'S DAY DINNER !! Thanks to Josh and Alyssa for making this afternoon a huge success....my Dad had one of Josh's fresh cannolis and could not believe what he had been missing his whole life...“

“The food is always delicious and the portions are huge! My only concern tonight was the waiters using foul language ( amongst themselves but loud enough that we could hear since it was very quiet in there when we went ) very unprofessional. . Then an elderly gentleman came in and requested a table for one not near the bar but the waiter told him the one table at the far end in the corner was for two people . It was early like 5:00 and almost nobody in there . What would’ve been the harm in placing him at that table ? He would’ve been done eating probably before it got too busy and he at least would have had some dignity instead of being sat behind the host station . That’s just poor taste in my opinion . Just thought it should be brought up for the future . Treat customers with respect and they will return .“

“Just had the most amazing salad! Romana Salad with grilled chicken and balsamic dressing. So good!!!!“

“I’ve been passing this place for years and we decided to try it last night. The food and service are wonderful. Really great with kids too. Drinks were excellent as well. Can’t wait to try this place during the summer. It’s on the tour and we will be back. Thank you!!“

“I am an eggplant snob! I order it every Italian restaurant I attend. I have only enjoyed it at one other restaurant, Coppollas in Hyde Park until Raymees. The owner said I was going to love it and boy was he right!!!! It was exactly like I love it!! It was wet, lots of sauce and cheese and not loaded with bread crumbs. BUT I was most impressed by the very large portion and side of salad, garlic knots and pasta! I highly recommend you try Raymees! I doubt you will be disappointed!!!! I would give 10 ⭐️“

“Had my wedding here and Frank and the staff were amazing and the food was great!“

“We celebrated our mothers 100th birthday - and sweet and kind Christina gifted us the cake for her big celebration. It was absolutely beautiful and delicious. Our family thanks you immensely for your kindness!“

“Hot and fresh to our table! So delicious! Just what these out of towners were expecting from a New York pizza place! Thank you! 😊“

“delicious food, good service, and kind people“

“we order all the time so delicious tonight chicken marsala pizza, yummy!!“

“Friendly, fun atmosphere with all the Italian favorites. YUM!“

“MADISON'S PIZZA CAFE in the heart of Pleasant Valley is a warm and friendly place with great pizza and many other dine in or take out menu options. There's a definite local neighborhood vibe here and the owners and staff make you feel like family. I will be back soon to work my way through that fun menu“

“the best of the best! the food is consistently incredible. the service is always top notch, and the atmosphere is second to none. the perfect place to go for either a quick lunch, a really nice dinner or to go see live music and kickback with a few cocktails....look no further!“

“I’m currently on a salad kick! Mediterranean Salad with grilled chicken ~. And a fresh filled cannoli 😘“

“Perfect texture to every slice. Not to thin, not to thick. Crunchy scrumptious. Every bite is a delight. The staff make you feel like your family. Always fresh. If you haven't yet, try the 28". The meatballs, chicken parm melt in your mouth. Hopewell Pizza barnone is the best.“

“I can not say enough good things about Mike and Joe's! The staff is friendly and efficient, they learn their customers and always greet you warmly! They are quick, often delivering faster than expected and the food is always great! If something is wrong they are happy and quick about making it right and they treat their customers so well and generously! I order delivery often and recently ordered catering last minute! Not only were they on time , the food was DELICIOUS, and they gave a sweet something extra! Mike and Joe's always goes the extra mile they are my favourite pizza place now and always! Thank you guys for absolutely everything and being so hardworking and friendly every single day! You guys are wonderful! I'll forever be a Mike and Joe's regular ! 💞“

“We drove 50 minutes from Woodbury CT to your restaurant because we know your food is Awesome 11/19/23 And once again it was delicious as Ever Thanks to you all and compliments to the chef It was well worth our ride See you Again Erik and Lisa“

“Best pizza“

“My favorite place for good sandwiches and pizza. Tommy's has recently been a lifeline for my mom who no longer cooks - she loves their soups, and they do really make a great Italian wedding.
Also, I've done at least a dozen phone-orders then pickups - the person taking calls at Tommy is always super patient and happy to customize sandwiches and pizzas.“