24 Best American Restaurants near New Preston

“Great burgers! Friendly service“

“Meatloaf with potato wedges and blackeyed peas 10/10 Steak sandwich with homemade chip 10/10 Very tasty muffins 10/10 Blonde with ice cream, candied nuts, chocolate and caramel Off the charts! Will definitely be back! Nice atmosphere, Amy was the absolute best along with all the other staff. We will definitely be back!“

“Rachel’s did a Celebration of Life catering event for us very recently. Everything was delicious and fresh. Good size portions. Perfect in every way. Staff accommodating as well. Highly recommend“

“excellent food and drink always“

“Fast and friendly service large portions and the margarita was perfect! We will be back!“

“Drinks are fantastic no compliants on anything.“

“Served super quick. Nothing I ordered was necessary mind blowing, kinda bland and wet. I’d suggest for burritos: crisp up the outside so it doesn’t fall apart from the moisture of the peppers/onions. Had to eat it with a fork and knife. I’ll eat here again. Good overall. Like to be honest in reviews.. not just 1 or 5.“

“Had a great time! the staff and diners all made my daughter's 21st birthday a great one! Thank you!“

“Great service. Food is very good and nice size portions. Always have leave a ton of food on my plate because its so much food. Prices are very reasonable. Waitstaff is very friendly. Only small complaint I have is the temperature in the restaurant. Its always on the warm side“

“awesome in every way. People are awesome. food is always top notch“

“We just held a surprise anniversary dinner and we are more than glad we chose Fife ‘n Drum! Elissa was hands down amazing, she truly made the dinner. No glass ever went more than half empty, not one issue with an order, everything went so smoothly We were given a private spot for our group of 19, she assisted with opening curtains for our surprise reveal, handled cutting and serving the cake we brought. It was fabulous and we couldn’t have asked for anything more.“

“Hidden Gem in Bantam! Jackie’s Restaurant is one of those rare hidden gems you’re glad you stumbled upon. Tucked away in Bantam, it’s an unassuming and super casual spot—but don’t let the laid-back vibe fool you. The food is fantastic. Fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you're grabbing breakfast, lunch, or a quick bite, Jackie’s delivers every time. Friendly service, generous portions, and a cozy, no-frills atmosphere make this place a true local treasure. Highly recommend if you're in the area and want something delicious without the fuss.“

“My hubby took me here for a breakfast date this morning, and they did not disappoint. The French toast was made perfectly. It was crisp in all the right places, tasted like butter, vanilla, and cinnamon, all the right things. And the hashbrowns were absolutely delicious! Whatever you are doing, keep that up! The service was awesome, the server was very pleasant and kind. It is nice to see a genuine smile when out and about. I am taking my daughter to lunch in the upcoming weeks. Thank you again!“

“Great ambience sitting outside near the beautiful waterfall stream! The food is absolutely delectable!“

“AMAZING. Should be Michelin star!“

“Good food. Good staff. Cold beer“

“Provide lunch and dinner for our family party All the food was great everyone enjoyed fine dining at our venue“

“Amazing food, always fresh, large portions and friendly atmosphere.“

“Love the Batman interior!“

“Mark Robinson and his team are conclusive and their ability to direct you into which area you can develop is key. They have a keen intuition for where the market is headed and when to makes profits. they are worth listening to. Try the consultation! And never go low in your portfolio even when the Market is in dip or pump.“

“Excellent evening at the Bistro! Every bite was delicious and the service was wonderful. We enjoy the atmosphere as well 😊“

“I’ve been to a lot of New Milford’s restaurants but I have to say the service at The Abbey was exceptional and the food was excellent and reasonably priced. Given how many eateries don’t survive over time; they are the model for a sustaining and thriving food service business. My wife had the Chicken Cordon Bleu, and I had the Chicken Caesar salad. Both were excellent and the portion size and portion per price was very good. Even the water tasted excellent. If I had one complaint it would be that the noise level was a little high, but it is a pub style restaurant where you can watch a game.“

“Great food and a nice menu selection. Owners are great family minded people!“