12 Best American Restaurants in Islamorada

Morada Bay American • $$
81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Day Boat Yellowtail Snapper Sando
המבורגר עם בייקון
Thai-Style Key West Shrimp Taco
Fish and Chips Morada Style
Big Boy BBQ Beach Burger
Bahamian Conch Fritters
Day Boat Snapper Sando
Mahi-Mahi Fish Tacos
Thai Key West Tacos
Whole Fried Snapper

“This place is just not a pretty face. Ok, well it is but, the food is as tasty as the sunsets are dramatic.“

3.8 Good246 Reviews
Ziggie & Mad Dog's Seafood • $$$
83000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Ziggie's Classic Lobster Bisque
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Phyllo Encrusted Escargot
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Cowboy Cut Bone-In Ribeye
Crabmeat Stuffed Snapper
Phyllo Crusted Escargot
Ziggie's Lobster Bisque

“It was good but not worth the wait, they will sit you outside with infested mosquitos. The wait was ridiculous. Server hardly even checked on us. Will not visit again!“

4.2 Good281 Reviews
Marathon Bagel Co Islamorada American • $
86701 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Whitefish Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Sandwich
Italian Sub
Egg & Onion
Tuna Salad
Bagel

“We went almost everyday! Bagels are delicious! Great to have my kids know what a real bagel is. Don’t be deterred by a long line, they go quick plus it’s fun listening to all the accents. Highly recommend the Nova with the works!“

4.8 Superb71 Reviews
Mangrove Mike's Cafe Cafe • $
82200 Overseas Hwy MM 82.2, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes with Eggs and Sausage
Kitchen Sink Tater Tot Tower
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Kitchen Sink Quesadilla
Craig's Hangover Helper
Gluten Free Hot Cakes
Kitchen Sink Omelette
Eggs Bacon and Potatos
French Toast Sampler
Breakfast Quesadilla

“We were on our way back to Jax and stopped at our favorite breakfast/lunch spot! Once again a winner for all of us! Great food and great service!“

4.6 Superb328 Reviews
Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant Seafood • $$
83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

The Wahoo's Fried Seafood Platter
House's Signature Wahoo blt Club
Key's Local Whole Fried Snapper
Wahoo's Signature Seafood Rice
Locals Favorite Wahoo Bites
Classic Keys Fish Sandwich
Oysters on the Half Shell
Key Lime Pie in the Keys
Killer Conch Fritters
Key Lime Shrimp Bowl

“One of our favorite restaurants in Islamorada! The views are amazing, the food is so fresh and delicious and the people are warm and welcoming. Host Brian always sets us up with a great table! This week Mr. Nike was our server and took great care of us. We'll be back again and again, fantastic restaurant overall!!“

4.5 Superb482 Reviews
Green Turtle Inn Seafood • $$
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Our Famous Turtle Sticky Bun
Captain's French Toast
Lobster Mac N Cheese
The Turtle Breakfast
Meatloaf Sandwich
Shrimp and Grits
Lobster Benedict
Turtle Chowder
Conch Fritters
Bacon Wrapped

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

4.6 Superb180 Reviews
Lazy Days Seafood • $$
79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Broiled Seafood Platter
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Il Pescato Del Giorno
Ensalada de Cangrejo
Key Lime Pie Slice
Coconut Shrimp
Key West Salad
Seafood Bisque
Stuffed Shrimp

“FANTASTIC Food, atmosphere, clean restrooms and staff!!! We had Snow Crab Legs and Shrimp Scampi Pasta that were fantastic! HUGE portions so think before you order as you will miss dessert!! Club Kelly, Jim and Melanie Kelly, Winter Garden, FL love Lazy Days!! We will be back!! Well done Randy!“

4.3 Superb566 Reviews
Sunset Lounge Tapas Bar • $$$
80460 Overseas Hwy 3rd Floor, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Conch Steamed Buns
House Smoked Fish Dip
Oyster Platter
Lobster Roll
Disco Fries
Wedge Salad
Baked Brie

“Great Place! Great ambiance!“

4.9 Superb32 Reviews
Green Turtle Wine & Spirits Bar • $
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
ReelCatch Restaurant Seafood • $$
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Rings with Sweet Peppers
Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail
Blackened Lobster Tacos
Black & Blue Burger
Chicken Quesadilla
Ceviche De Camaron
Belgian Waffle
Key Lime Pie
Mahi Tacos

“We stayed at this resort while diving next-door at the sister resort love this place. It was very clean. Food was amazing. Beach was clean and the pool and tiki bar was a plus will definitely come back.“

4.3 Superb94 Reviews
Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $$
85361 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Panino Con Carne Di Maiale Nella Ciotola Insalata Con Salsa
Ultimate Hog Heaven BBQ Sampler
Windley Key Chicken Sandwich
Homestyle Mac N Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Brisket Deviled Eggs
Key West Street Corn
BBQ Pulled Pork
SD Pulled Pork
Bacon Wrapped

“We loved this restaurant! Super laid back atmosphere, delicious food, great music, fair pricing, great view of the ocean! Definitely recommend!!“

4.2 Good321 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Sandwich with Fries and Collards
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Creamy Coleslaw
Mac and Cheese
Baked Beans
Pulled Pork
Cornbread
Sauce
Ribs
Wings

“Best bbq I’ve had in years!!!!! Worth the visit 100%“

4.1 Good77 Reviews

You May Also Like