34 Best American Restaurants in Sebring

“WCFR rode out from Sarasota 11-1-25 to The Gator Shack, had called early to let them know we were coming. They were beyond ready for us. Great service, amble seating and most of all amazing food. Thank you.“

“Great dinner! Mary Kennedy was a great waitress. Very attentive to detail, friendly and went with our wild and crazy group! Thank you Mary! N“

“Enjoyed a nice breakfast sandwich with hashbrowns today. Food was very good with nice a cozy diner feel. Will frequent for sure.“

“The new Cobb salad was a home run! Fresh salad ingredients, moist, tasty chicken, awesome vinaigrette. Avocado on top! Did I forget bacon? There’s bacon! My new go-to at Fairmount Cafe.“

“Jena B. and Zoe rock!! They are awesome. Zoe always pulling double duty with the bar and waiting tables. And Jena B. always going the extra mile to make sure your visit is a great one. Been a regular there for many years and the new owner Kim was a pleasant person to meet as well.“

“I went the Cowpokes yesterday as it was my Birthday. If you show your DL and go right in on your Birthday you will get $15.00 off your dinner. I ordered the Filet Mignon it was cooked perfect, baked potatoe and the amazing salad.I also ordered a Bourbon Manhattan up which the Bartender made it just the way I like it. Carrie our Server was very attentive and checked on us often.She was very professional and personality plus. I had a wonderful Birthday and the best time at Cowpokes. Management should acknowledge their great servers.Jeff & Carrie are top notch.Recommend them highly.“

“Dario is my favorite server. Love the lunch special. greatest 🍔 in town.“

“Great food, seated quickly, good waitress. The pulled pork was a generous portion. sides were excellent.“

“Good food at a good price“

“Friendly staff, great food and amazing views!! 10/10 recommend!“

“Great food, happy staff!!!“

“Friendly people,fun place to be and beauty everywhere“

“I had a great meal served by an excellent waiter. I highly recommend having dinner there“

“Absolutely recommend the food here! I work downtown for hobby hill, we all love going to the 301 and eating the amazing appetizers and burgers from brewhaha’s! From lunch breaks to bringing family from outta town… it’s a must have!! The whole experience is spot on! Garlic truffle tots are mandatory by the way 🤤💁🏻‍♂️😂“

“pricesxare sooo good but the food is even better!! the chef is excellent at her job!!“

“We had a Fantastic Prime Rib Steak Dinner, the atmosphere was perfect, attentive wait staff, extremely friendly & courteous, generous portions. We were not expecting Live Music , we were pleasantly Surprised!!)
Highly recommend!“

“Stacy was very attentive and took care of me“

“Lived here 26 yrs. Always very satisfied with food & service...until....took relatives there for evening meal. I was embarressed...for some reason , all 4 of us got unacceptable food. The lasagna was the only good thing. The grouper tacos were greasy. Something is different in the kitchen.....new cooks...chefs.....? Will return one more time.....hopefully things will have been corrected by then.“

“Bufalucca did not disappoint! The staff was amazing, food delicious, and the environment was full of energy! 10/10 recommend 👍“

“Kristin at the bar is the BEST!!! Highly recommend for a relaxing evening! So comfortable, they are even building up a happy hour!“

“I love this place my grandson is in sun n lake elementary school and he came here to a Hawaiian dance he and his mom said the food was really good and I love this events happening here in island view is fun. So I recommend this place to eat because my grandson told me it was all free for food 🤯“

“We LOVE this place!! If I had my choice I’d eat here 3x a week! My go to is always the Caldo De Res🤤🤤🤤 People are nice. Service is quick. Happily recommend 👍🏼“

“Dees is a staple in our community, food is delicious and the service is spot on, I work for hobby hill downtown and they are our go to for burgers… bacon… and butter candles 😍❤️💯 if you haven’t been to Dee’s… you should! Thank yall for always taking care of us!“

“I was able to visit this congregation while visiting my brother. Very enjoyable services and the sweetest members! I will definitely be back.“

“Absolutely the best pizza....the sausage is homemade and the Pizza is tasty.“

“This is the best place I’ve been in Sebring, I’ve always driven by and never tried it, but in the last 2 months this is all I’ve ordered, I do delivery and the food is always Amazing and never gotten my order wrong, best crab cakes too, taste like the ocean.“

“The pie is amazing. the burgers are good, and the staff although short are very cute. 10/10“

“Ice friendly place to grab a bite to eat, something to wash it down with.“

“If you get Genesis as your server, just know you've already peaked. She didn't just serve our table—she orchestrated a five-star experience like she was conducting a Michelin-star symphony. She somehow knew what we needed before we did, kept us laughing the whole time, and made us feel like the only table in the restaurant.

I'm convinced Genesis could solve world peace between refilling drinks. She deserves Employee of the Century, a parade, and at least three pay raises. If Red Lobster ever lets her go, they'll need to put the restaurant on the endangered species list.

10/10 service. Ask for Genesis if you want your meal to come with a side of elite customer service and good vibes.“

“My daughter and I were short on time and I didn't want to eat anything too bad for myself so I figured I'd grab a piece of fish from Captain D's in Sebring, a place I hadn’t visited in years.
When I placed my order, I asked for ketchup. They no longer had a self-serve pump and were offering individual packets instead. I casually asked if they had bulk ketchup in the back, and the manager, Kelsey (apologies if I misspelled her name), politely offered to open the packets for me to make it easier. She was sincere and professional, explaining that she aims to keep customers happy because that’s what keeps the business running.
I declined her offer to open the packets, but I appreciated the level of customer service she demonstrated. The interaction was both courteous and memorable.
Overall, the fish was well-cooked, satisfying, and reasonably priced. For anyone looking for a quick, affordable seafood option in Sebring, Captain D’s is worth considering.“

“Their food is excellent. like the value menu items, but lately when we visit the Sebring Restaurant, it takes forever to get your food. Last time was 40 Minutes. past 3 times were like this. One waitress for a large area. Makes us not want to go back. people coming in after us being served & we are still waiting. Not good for business. we are Senior Citizens. Needs better structuring for waitresses. Need to hire more. Thank you. 💕. Used to be a favorite. Not anymore.“

“Food was a little burnt (fish) but still ok to eat , service was not great . Place was very dirty and the bathrooms we’re disgusting, plenty of people working at the establishment, no reason for dirty tables/ seats and restrooms, we live Culver’s but not so sure we will be back to this location.“

“Took out a big party of coworkers to celebrate them and the waitress Desiree accommodated us amazingly she was absolutely awesome and kind. From the appetizers to the entrees they all tasted great she was kind and smiling and super accommodating to the whole party. service was great and everyone enjoyed their meal thank you so much for making this team outing a great one !!“

“Hot food good service today“