14 Best Sandwich Shops near Manhattan

“Amazing workers! All nice, make the food quickly. The only problem is the owner while working with the employees, always bossing them around to do stuff. Takes them longer when the owner is there because they have to do other smaller things.“

“them steaks are pretty good, i recommend this place. The chicken California cheesesteak is pretty good“

“J-Town Classic, if anyone is giving this place a lower than a 5 star..they’re a straight hattteeer. They’re always quick, I get everything I ordered. The parking lot can get a little crazy, but that just means everyone wants that MR SUB.“

“You have to fill your order out on a small paper bag when you walk in. I didn't realize that until it was my turn at the counter and had to go back and fill out a bag (I definitely wasn't the only one who did this). This was something that I guess tries to set them apart but is just more of a hassle.

The sandwich was great! I would reccomend getting th large size if you are looking for a comparable size sandwich to competitors, like JJ's and JM's. I would definitely go back.“

“Great Customer service workers pleasant and friendly store nice and clean, the young ladies working together great personality.“

“I’ve gone to many Dunkin’s in my life and this one was by far my best experience in one. The 3 boys in there were on point, courteous and just the extra mile service by putting my gardinera in a lil bag incase it spilled. All w a smile. It’s clean. Whoever the boss is there make sure u acknowledge these guys, good job!👍“

“I frequent the shop in New Lenox. Ive never had a bad experience and they always get the order correct.

This is a Turkey with cheddar, mayo lettuce tomato, cucumber and extra onion. It wa delicious!

The people working their are always nice and patient with my customizations“

“It is a very nice place with wonderful people and the employees. I need to see Vanessa again when I go back There and I loved it today and the service today was wonderful and the employees are just wonderful. I told the employee that when I see Vanessa, I want her to do the Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo for me when I see her again and the food was great and I am so lucky to know The team and Is very good and everyone there is fabulous and I enjoy the food and it is very good. And I am very lucky to know Vanessa and the team there and like I said everybody there is wonderful.“

“had a wonderful experience visiting this subway. bridget or brittany gave the best customer service i have seen awhile in these type of establishments. she was very energetic, enthusiastic and excited to make our sandwiches. i had a large order and she handled it with care and precision. these food establishments need more people like her in them.“

“Excellent service! All the employees are very friendly. You can tell they value their customers. They have a welcoming environment. The store is always clean and the food is always fresh/stocked. If you want a delicious sandwich, this is the place to go to.“

“I’m bummed tonight. The order was incorrect. No extra cheese on the #17 and the #31 was made with beef - not chicken and it did not have mayo on it. Usually we are 100% happy with Jersey Mike’s New Lenox. It’s my favorite sandwich shop. Disappointed the order was not 100% since it was spelled out on the on-line order ticket. (Online order thanks to COVID-19 hysteria) The #31 was my wife’s sandwich.......I picked dinner tonight........now I have to apologize and let her pick dinner tomorrow. :( It’s still my favorite so I will recommend it.......I’ll recover after spending tonight in the dog house! 😂😂“

“Every time I go in I’m helped by Dawn. She always greets everyone coming in and in my cultures that’s a very welcoming feeling, She is quick and asks questions to how you want it made. I will definitely be back. I would suggest sending some help her way due to all the younger staff going back to school.“

“NM is a lier she was told 3 times on the phone 32 sandwiches is a catering order and could not be made with 1hr notice during lunch time yet she still ordered 18 sandwiched on line ,then came in and ordered another 18 during lunch rush and expected everyone else in line to wait,,,,now wanted someone fired from their job because she screwed up her 's other people in congratulate the subway workers for not being bullied by this lying nm“

“Had a great experience at the New Lenox Subway! The food was fresh and the service was quick, but what really impressed me was Glen. He was friendly, professional, and made sure my order was perfect. Great customer service! I’ll definitely be back!“