21 Best Sandwich Shops near Cedar Lake

“Apparently, the new stores are going away from the snarky motif. They still have free smells, so there's that. The addition of the hot sandwiches is nice. Good bright, clean store with plenty of smiling faces. Snark or no snark, still freaky fast Jimmy John's.“

“The service and atmosphere are pure Subway, ok, and clean. This stores's bathroom is off limits still. But I like the sandwiches I've had there. I stick with the hot sandwiches, particularly the chicken. The chicken is real roasted chicken, and there is an ample amount of it on the sandwich. The bread they use isn't high end french, but it is fresh. The flatbread is pretty good also. Good enough that I bought some at the grocery store. Some Subways will sell an extra bread, but this one won't. The cookies are good too. There is a good deal if you add a bottle of soda, a bag of chips and a cookie. A well rounded meal! My store is open until 1 am, so it's a quick, easy late night meal.

Wheelchair accessibility: It's doable, but not easy. The door is in a well, and slightly uphill. If you're alone, you have to open the door, come around the corner while keeping the door open, and over the threshold. It's a pain, and easier if you're with someone. Supposedly the staff will help, but they've never offered, and it's hard for them to see you. I guess you could call if you had your phone, but it nullifies the purpose of being ADA compliant.“

“4-5-26 Andy, the manager at the Crown Point location, has the best customer service manners that I've seen in a long time. I had an issue where my card had been declined. He calmly let me know about the problem. My friend and I were able to get the amount of cash together to cover my bill. During that time he wasn't rude or snarky. Not even impatient. He was like 'life happens.' Thank you Andy for being the person you are! By the way, Lincoln's food is always great too. Patty Cogdill“

“Went here for the first time a few days ago even though I have lived in the area for five years Ordered the Austin and Venice sandwiches. The ladies at the counter were fantastic! The sandwiches were excellent and hearty! So so good! Can't wait to return and try the soups next time! Well done!“

“DELICIOUS. Went here today for lunch and everyone was so happy and the food was amazing. We will 100% be back. My 7 year old daughter already is asking when we can get it again…. Too bad it’s 20 mins away, but well worth the drive!“

“Always enjoy their sandwiches“

“Amazing subs! Best around. Super clean store and friendly staff. Understaffed and waited a bit but the 3 people working were hustling.“

“Bread is great making for one outstanding sandwich. I live just over the border in Illinois and would eat Penn Station a few times a week if we had one near by. And thank you for still brewing iced tea. So many other restaurants have gone to the cheap and gross syrup out of a fountain station which I refuse to drink.“

“Hired Battista’s for my wedding last weekend. The two man team was fast and was able to feed a large amount of guests within a short amount of time! All of our guests LOVED the pizza!! Thank you!!“

“We ordered subs for our high school bball team. Ryan and his team went above and beyond to get our boys fed even offering early pickup before opening to get us to the game on time. The food was well prepared, packaged and delicious. Thank you for your great service and the extra goodies we can’t wait until you come to Valpo so we can visit more often!“

“The service was phenomenal. The person serving us for an excellent job making the sandwiches, and even letting us know that the bread was a little burnt, he also told us we can come tomorrow to have it remade for free if we don't like it. Very friendly, will most certainly be going back!“

“​As a busy mom, getting a quick, affordable, and stress-free meal with my kids is a lifesaver, and this Subway is always a wonderful spot for us.
​The restaurant is clean and safe, and the vibe inside is incredibly welcoming and family-friendly. In fact, I love that it’s a comfortable, down-to-earth community space—you’ll often see local parents or staff keeping an eye on their little ones while handling their day. As a parent, seeing a hardworking dad or a family member looking after a baby in a local shop doesn't make me uncomfortable; it makes me feel like I’m supporting a real, human business that cares about families.
​The staff here works so hard to keep the line moving, they are always patient and sweet with my kids, and the pricing is completely straightforward. It's a clean, safe, and positive environment, and it's our favorite reliable spot for a chaotic weeknight dinner!“

“I go to this particular subway for the service there is a sandwich artist by the name of Tay that prepairs and builds the best sandwiches any kink you as for food is great The atmosphere is great and the service is excellent Great job Tay !!!!!!!“

“TheNoble Cause Vegan Sandwich was to Die for---So Good. Highly Reccomend.“

“Always a good place for me to eat healthy. I get a veggie delight which is all fresh vegetables. Of course they have many other sandwiches more appealing to most people. I'm thankful for Subway because I can eat healthy and it's good “

“The freshest and the fastest of the Jimmy Johns in the Northwest region. Amazing staff, and the best ranch everrr.“

“When we first moved to NWI, we first visited Pops when they were located closer to Jewel. At first, when we ordered our beef juicy, the beef was still dry. Over the years, they have gotten better. The beef is juicy, tender, and tasty. So juicey that now, they wrap your beef and then put your wrapped beef inside a plastic bag for take out orders. The beef here is much better than the overrated beef sandwich at Portillos. The large order of fries is enough to share.“

“They accidentally delivered my subs to the wrong address accidentally so I called up and the manager made it right gave us three more subs and also three more sub subs for next time so I just wanted to say I really appreciate that and appreciate the manager for making it right and the subs were very delicious. Thank you again.“

“They brought mini sample sandwiches to Jewel today, they were delicious! 👍🏻“

“Cleanest Subway I’ve ever been to. & the man behind the counter was so incredibly polite & just nice! He made was so helpful, he was kind. He made sure we were satisfied with our order. Will always come back to this subway when up north!“

“3 star for service because I entered in my phone for rewards and they didn't add it on there. they have to select my name to have it count and they didn't. I'm seeing a trend across Northwest Indiana and Chicago owned Jimmy Johns because this has happened more than 5 times in the past 6-8 months maybe even more.“