46 Best American Restaurants near Cicero

“We enjoyed the menu of unique and clever dishes, not a common thing to find in a small town restaurant! Shout out to our waitress Katie for being suggesting good cocktails.“

“Was looking forward to eating here. The atmosphere was great, but the food was ok. For the price, I expected the food to be amazing. I got the pulled pork Mac and cheese. There was hardly any meat in it and the Mac and cheese was meh. I feel it is very over priced for the quantity. Probably won't return.“

“We went to the restaurant on Saturday and it was quite busy. We were told the bar area was short staffed so it took a long time to get our drinks. It also was a longer wait for our food. But, the food was excellent and I would definitely recommend giving this place a try.“

“We had a very enjoyable Valentine’s Day dinner.“

“Great little place. The menu is small, but the food was great! Don't get the nachos unless you have at least 4 people, or you are starving with the munchies from Hell. The smash burger was exactly what you want in a burger and the tenderloin is super thick and juicy.
I would definitely go back again (and bring 3 more people).“

“We love this place! Great food and drinks.“

“We took our grandson to eat lunch. The food was delicious and service was great!“

“Last night was my first time eating here, it was some of the best food that I have had. I had the chicken dinner and it was excellent, highly recommend! I love the atmosphere and the music was very nice.“

“Wonderful lunch and waiter Rick. Thank you“

“Had a very nice lunch with wonderful service.“

“New Years Eve at Wolfies - awesome service and food. Check out todays Hamilton County Reporter…thank you Sydney Farrer for your wonderful service.“

“I live in Texas but saw a CBS interview of this lovely place with the owner. First of all I wish I lived closer because my mouth was watering the entire time, but most importantly you could tell the owner, Chef Samir, is absolutely in love with what he does and how he does it. When a chef puts as much love into his food as he does, you already know its going to be amazing. This restaurant has made it to my bucket list. I hope to meet Chef Samir some day!“

“Always a great experience!! Fast and excellent quality. Emilee was fantastic and so sweet!“

“Would absolutely come back here. Service was amazing! Food is the usual fast food flare, still good. I personally had the Jagger Salad with grilled chicken. Grilled children had a nice flavor. I also had my special need son with his special needs wife and they were treated with amazing respect. Not just tolerated like many other people do. Very appreciative by this mama!! Kim was their server. She is awesome! She came by the table often to check on us. Thank you Kim!“

“The wife had a chicken sandwich on a pretzle-type bun; I had the single deluxe butterburger. She got the onion rings and I got the fries, which we shared. It was a good meal. I didn't know they had their own brand of root beer. Good stuff!“

“Our Jimtown Winter guard stopped in to eat after our performance and they were not only friendly but took care of us in a fast professional manor and our food was sooooo delicious. Thank you so much.“

“These farm to table type breakfast places have always bothered me a bit. They're great if you want something lighter for breakfast—but let's be real here, sometimes you just want something smothered in sausage gravy. These places never seem to offer a good version of both things, so you end up needing to decide what you want to eat before you choose where to go. When I first tried First Watch, their menu was limited and I felt like my choices were either quinoa bowl, or an egg served with an arugula salad. Not exactly my style of breakfast. But I have kept coming back because each time it seems like the menu gets expanded and seasonal items are added, and I really appreciate that. Sometimes I'm in the mood for a veggie omelet, sometimes I want bacon and cheese. I'm glad there seem to be more options that play both sides of that now. The quality of the food has always been excellent, so with more options comes more interest from me. I'll keep coming back for now to continue to check out their new offerings, but still no breakfast arugula for me.“

“Had late lunch here on Saturday of father's day weekend. The restaurant wasn't overly busy but it did seem the service was a little slow (not our server directly, but how long it took the food to come out) The wings were quite good, but the burger was just ok. I would say if you are in the area and are hungry, give it a try. I wouldn't go out of my way to come back, though.“

“We did not care for the cheese curds since some of them had nothing in them - no cheese to be seen! Too expensive for that problem.

Kid-friendliness: Culver's workers are pretty much always nice to the kiddos. Thank you.

Wheelchair accessibility: You can get in and out with a wheelchair easily and it fits at the tables also. Thank you Culver's.“

“Great food, great staff, and live music every weekend!“

“Just had the best breakfast!! Always the fastest service too. We ordered and had our food at the table in less then 5 minutes. It was very hot, fresh, and delicious.“

“We stopped in today for the first time. The food was amazing and you could tell there was lovin coming from Ginger’s oven!!!! Perfectly seasoned and homemade goodness. Thank you Ginger for coming out to share with us. You won our hearts and business. We’ll be back soon.“

“I have been in several of these places and have always been pleased. The service was great, the food was good, and the root beer is always good. We were in a rush to get to Bible class, and they got our food out quickly, correctly, and tasted good!“

“what a fun local ice cream place. today there was an 11 year old girl who had written a book and was signing autographs.“

“My husband, sister, myself, and our 6 month old came in for dinner tonight. We had the amazing opportunity to have Larry as our waiter tonight and he made our son's first Veterans Day an amazing one. Larry was very kind and we loved the interactions with our son. He just made our son giggle and made noises with him which was great. Our son loved it so much his started looking around for Larry. Thank you Larry for the best service ever.“

“This is an excellent place to eat! Great food, fast service, friendly staff and did I mention the food? Its very good! I'm not big on the giant, open, space concept because its loud but once you taste the food you forget about that quickly.“

“Service was amazing. Our waiter was an amazing person. My party went with the veggie plates, the steak, spin dip, salmon and shrimp. All were decent, the Mac and cheese was not great and the garden salad was not crisp but everything else was good. Rolls were hot and great start to the night.“

“Always good food and good service“

“Unique, poker-themed restaurant with an extensive menu with excellent breakfast fare. Have been eating there for years. Highly recommended.“

“Awesome👌👌👌good customer service“

“In town from Texas, stumbled in by chance. Fantastic experience! Bren was THE BEST! I couldn’t get thirsty if my life depended on it. Come in and ask for her, you won’t be disappointed.“

“10/10 all around. Kevin’s service was anticipatory and beyond thoughtful. Best you can find in Indiana, honestly. Great food too.“

“Super busy evening but we had excellent service. It’s very clean and the food was delicious. I had the avocado egg rolls and i highly recommend them.“

“This steak and shake is the best steak and shake. I've found in a long time. It seems like they fell in love with seasoning salt. Just overpowering every sandwich for a long period of time, and now I don't know. If it's the beef tallow, or what but their burgers are on point and their fries actually have flavor now, I've actually been looking forward to going to steak and shake.
Instead of dreading, it just going for my kid that loves their fries. We actually don't have one in Anderson, so when we go to home depot, we always stop here and get burgers. Now if you want a good steak and shake that actually cooks their food the right way?This one is the one too go to !!“

“Where do i start? From the moment my family walked in, we felt welcomed. The place was well lit we were greeted by 2 staff members and we were blessed with molly as our server who was absolutely attentive and made the experience above and beyond. We had the steak teriyaki chicken and wings along with 2 appetizers the pickles and pretzel bites and everything was phenomenal. I dont usually go on and on, or gush like a teenager but i had to take the time and acknowledge a job well done. I travel alot and experience alot of different restaurants and this tops alot of 4 star restaurants that ive been in. Music at the just right volume staff continuously checking on you and a manager who walked the floor interacting with all his staff and all the guest as if we were all best friends. I will absolutely recommend this establishment, and will definitely eat here alot more often goong forward so i can have a chance to try out the entire menu. Agsin another shout out to molly our server you were great. Thank you for making the experience an amazing Christmas night with the snow coming down and being there to make it awesome for us.“

“Pat Powers takes time off from being a shepherd to provide extended , manhandled service. His general knowledge of balling people up and stories of playing basketball against R & B groups in his youth is majestic and unparalleled. Go and get 2 ribeye steak sandwiches with a Bloody Mary, put it on the Underhills tab and call it a night all while Pat Powers guides you through the wonderment and awe that is Eddy’s Sports Pub!“

“🫎
Moose offers a peaceful and quiet environment, making it an excellent spot for a hassle-free overnight stay in your car. The parking area is wide open, providing plenty of space and easy access. While Google Maps lists it as a food pantry, I visited twice and found no food available, suggesting it might be an occasional or scheduled service. Despite this, the convenience and undisturbed nature of the location exceeded my expectations, making it a very worthwhile choice for a peaceful night's sleep.“

“We usually frequent a different location, but recently visited your Carmel location and found it to be a great experience. From calling in via phone Gretta was fantastic, warm, and friendly (which seems to be a list skill set for many)Then our server Emily did a wonderful job of taking our order and servicing us. My ribs were dry, but everything else was great.“

“Excellent food. Lots of Mexican restaurants around but not a lot of standouts. This one is superb. Our go to for Mexican cuisine“

“Friendly service and great food“

“Really nice tavern place. Came for lunch with some coworkers. The gyro was really good and the waitress did a great job. It's a pretty standard place the portion of my side wasn't super large compared to my coworkers. Otherwise it's a great place to eat!“

“Your website trip advisor list them closed before 11 o’clock and they are not - they are open till midnight every night so TripAdvisor you need to sort that out they are not closed at 10 or 11 they’re open till midnight every night -all of the Applebees on the north side of Indy“

“We went on August 4th during the last hour, and they handed out the wrong order to someone (the order really being ours), but the way the man at the window handled it was amazing, he swiftly made our food again with no problem, coming from food service I know how irritating that could be especially 30 mins before close, but he was so sweet and even added two brownies for us! Not only that but as we were pulling out he ran out to hand us Mac a cheese that was forget, he was amazing!! Definitely deserves a raise!!“

“Ordered take out from this location a couple of days ago. Alex brought me my food and made sure that I had everything that I ordered. Alex was extremely polite and was adamant on making sure that I had everything I needed. Absolutely great service from Alex.“

“Gluten free options - lettuce wrapped sandwiches - unlimited fries and other sides - fundraisers!“