48 Best American Restaurants near Cicero

“We enjoyed the menu of unique and clever dishes, not a common thing to find in a small town restaurant! Shout out to our waitress Katie for being suggesting good cocktails.“

“Was looking forward to eating here. The atmosphere was great, but the food was ok. For the price, I expected the food to be amazing. I got the pulled pork Mac and cheese. There was hardly any meat in it and the Mac and cheese was meh. I feel it is very over priced for the quantity. Probably won't return.“

“We went to the restaurant on Saturday and it was quite busy. We were told the bar area was short staffed so it took a long time to get our drinks. It also was a longer wait for our food. But, the food was excellent and I would definitely recommend giving this place a try.“

“We go to Erika’s once a week. The food is good, the service is impeccable, and everyone is friendly!“

“Do you want fine dining quality at reasonable prices? Look no further than The Piper.

I've driven by here for awhile and we decided to check it out last week. In that time, we've now been 3 times and love it more each time.

The mac & cheese is from another planet it is so good. My wife greatly prefers it plain whereas I like the chicken. She even said it's better than a high end restaurant I love in Cincinnati which she knows is a bold statement with me.

The wings and pretzel breadsticks are delicious along with the asian style ribs.“

“Great service, nice atmosphere and very good food.“

“I always come here, great taste, good portions, excellent service and great atmosphere, overall one of my favorites“

“We took our grandson to eat lunch. The food was delicious and service was great!“

“Absolutely the best place in Hamilton County! 🙌
The interior is stunning, the food is incredible, the bar is unmatched — and the people? They are genuinely happy to take care of you. It’s such a rare and wonderful experience to feel that kind of hospitality. So grateful for this place!“

“New Years Eve at Wolfies - awesome service and food. Check out todays Hamilton County Reporter…thank you Sydney Farrer for your wonderful service.“

“The food and atmosphere is amazing!!“

“I live in Texas but saw a CBS interview of this lovely place with the owner. First of all I wish I lived closer because my mouth was watering the entire time, but most importantly you could tell the owner, Chef Samir, is absolutely in love with what he does and how he does it. When a chef puts as much love into his food as he does, you already know its going to be amazing. This restaurant has made it to my bucket list. I hope to meet Chef Samir some day!“

“Would absolutely come back here. Service was amazing! Food is the usual fast food flare, still good. I personally had the Jagger Salad with grilled chicken. Grilled children had a nice flavor. I also had my special need son with his special needs wife and they were treated with amazing respect. Not just tolerated like many other people do. Very appreciative by this mama!! Kim was their server. She is awesome! She came by the table often to check on us. Thank you Kim!“

“I recently visited Culver’s and was impressed from start to finish. The food was outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and served piping hot. Their famous ButterBurgers were juicy and perfectly seasoned, and the custard was as creamy and rich as everyone says.

The customer service was just as memorable. Every team member I encountered was friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. They checked in to make sure everything was right without being intrusive, which made the meal feel special.

Speed was another highlight. Even though the restaurant was busy, my order was prepared quickly and accurately. It never felt rushed, just efficiently handled.

Finally, the cost is more than fair for the quality you receive. The portions are generous, and you truly get excellent value for your money.

Overall: Culver’s delivers a winning combination of delicious food, top-notch service, quick turnaround, and reasonable prices. It’s an easy five stars and a place I’ll happily return to again and again.“

“Wonderful lunch and waiter Rick. Thank you“

“Always a great experience!! Fast and excellent quality. Emilee was fantastic and so sweet!“

“My wife and I really enjoyed our date night at Houlihan’s. Our waitress was nice and very attentive and of the food was great as always. Definitely one of our favorites!“

“Our Jimtown Winter guard stopped in to eat after our performance and they were not only friendly but took care of us in a fast professional manor and our food was sooooo delicious. Thank you so much.“

“Had late lunch here on Saturday of father's day weekend. The restaurant wasn't overly busy but it did seem the service was a little slow (not our server directly, but how long it took the food to come out) The wings were quite good, but the burger was just ok. I would say if you are in the area and are hungry, give it a try. I wouldn't go out of my way to come back, though.“

“Great food, great staff, and live music every weekend!“

“My wife and I were in Indy for a 24-hour getaway for Labor Day and looking for a good place to enjoy breakfast. We chose to check out this First Watch because they have a location in Florida that we like to visit when we are there.

We were a little surprised by how packed they were, not only inside in the dining room, but even with people waiting on the sidewalk outside. We have never seen that before at any other First Watch. We put our names on the waiting list. We were told that the wait was 30 minutes, and that they would text us when our table was coming available, so we did a little shopping a couple of stores down until it was about time.

After close to 30 minutes we were seated and warmly greeted by our server, Max, who got our drinks to us right away, and then quickly got our order in.

My wife and I were both impressed by the staff moving quickly about the room, taking great care of all of their customers.

We ordered the pumpkin pancake breakfast with chicken apple sausage and an egg, avocado toast with two eggs and a side of bacon, and coffee to drink.

Our food didn’t take too long to get to our table, and everything was cooked exactly the way we asked. The flavors were great and the portion sizes were good.

Even though every table was full and the place with bustling with people, our server did such a wonderful job.

When we finished our meal we got an order of pumpkin spice donuts to go. They were delicious too!

While we did have a bit of a wait, and it was a little on the expensive side, we were so impressed with everything about our visit. I’d give this First Watch an extra star if I could for exceeding our expectations! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ + ⭐️“

“We did not care for the cheese curds since some of them had nothing in them - no cheese to be seen! Too expensive for that problem.

Kid-friendliness: Culver's workers are pretty much always nice to the kiddos. Thank you.

Wheelchair accessibility: You can get in and out with a wheelchair easily and it fits at the tables also. Thank you Culver's.“

“I have been in several of these places and have always been pleased. The service was great, the food was good, and the root beer is always good. We were in a rush to get to Bible class, and they got our food out quickly, correctly, and tasted good!“

“Just had the best breakfast!! Always the fastest service too. We ordered and had our food at the table in less then 5 minutes. It was very hot, fresh, and delicious.“

“Had lunch there yesterday…food, service and atmosphere fantastic …such a warm hug of nostalgia and great food . The waitresses could not have been nicer!!!! We will be back🥰“

“Myself and my Husband have just had our first Experience at Logans. I can say that they never disappointed us. The food was absolutely Amazing. The waitress was excellent. I think she said her name was Fallon. She came over quite often to check on us to make sure we was doing good for drinks etc. It looked very clean inside. I would have to say Logans so far is my Favorite Steakhouse yet.“

“what a fun local ice cream place. today there was an 11 year old girl who had written a book and was signing autographs.“

“I took my son out for Valentine's day, I was slightly off put by the speciality menu for the holiday.
But my server was fantastic, the food was good, and we had a good time.

Kid-friendliness: My son loves the kids menu and the activities on the activity sheet“

“Unique, poker-themed restaurant with an extensive menu with excellent breakfast fare. Have been eating there for years. Highly recommended.“

“Always good food and good service“

“Awesome👌👌👌good customer service“

“First time DoorDashing Syd’s and my order was *chefs kiss* 👌🏻 Everything was hot and fresh. I ordered a black and blue burger with fries. Came with more fries than expected under the toppings and they included condiments that I forgot to add to my order.“

“10/10 all around. Kevin’s service was anticipatory and beyond thoughtful. Best you can find in Indiana, honestly. Great food too.“

“Super busy evening but we had excellent service. It’s very clean and the food was delicious. I had the avocado egg rolls and i highly recommend them.“

“Great chips and guac. OG Chicken Sandwich was awesome. Servers very accommodating to a couple of Chiefs fans passing through. Salsa was not my style. Spicy and smoky but zero flavor. Tater tots were old and I could see the seasoning. I just couldn't taste the seasoning. Might go back but I'd be more selective with my menu. choices.“

“🫎
Moose offers a peaceful and quiet environment, making it an excellent spot for a hassle-free overnight stay in your car. The parking area is wide open, providing plenty of space and easy access. While Google Maps lists it as a food pantry, I visited twice and found no food available, suggesting it might be an occasional or scheduled service. Despite this, the convenience and undisturbed nature of the location exceeded my expectations, making it a very worthwhile choice for a peaceful night's sleep.“

“The only reason the atmosphere is a 4 is because I know I'll smell like smoke when I leave. A shower later and good to go. GREAT SERVICE!!! I've had the ribeye sandwich the chicken strips and the potato skins. Everything was great, the chicken strips I preferred to the sandwich. The potato skins.... They call them an app. 2 huge baked potatoes cut in half and smothered in everything you could want. 😋 10 of the 10s“

“The Host Mark is the most fantastic member of their team. He has a great personality, welcomes everyone, and is able to remember faces. The problem we had with the service was that the milkshake guy didn't get our shakes done, and the manager did take care of the problem along with Mark.“

“We usually frequent a different location, but recently visited your Carmel location and found it to be a great experience. From calling in via phone Gretta was fantastic, warm, and friendly (which seems to be a list skill set for many)Then our server Emily did a wonderful job of taking our order and servicing us. My ribs were dry, but everything else was great.“

“Really nice tavern place. Came for lunch with some coworkers. The gyro was really good and the waitress did a great job. It's a pretty standard place the portion of my side wasn't super large compared to my coworkers. Otherwise it's a great place to eat!“

“Friendly service and great food“

“Excellent food. Lots of Mexican restaurants around but not a lot of standouts. This one is superb. Our go to for Mexican cuisine“

“Your website trip advisor list them closed before 11 o’clock and they are not - they are open till midnight every night so TripAdvisor you need to sort that out they are not closed at 10 or 11 they’re open till midnight every night -all of the Applebees on the north side of Indy“

“We went on August 4th during the last hour, and they handed out the wrong order to someone (the order really being ours), but the way the man at the window handled it was amazing, he swiftly made our food again with no problem, coming from food service I know how irritating that could be especially 30 mins before close, but he was so sweet and even added two brownies for us! Not only that but as we were pulling out he ran out to hand us Mac a cheese that was forget, he was amazing!! Definitely deserves a raise!!“

“Ordered take out from this location a couple of days ago. Alex brought me my food and made sure that I had everything that I ordered. Alex was extremely polite and was adamant on making sure that I had everything I needed. Absolutely great service from Alex.“

“Gluten free options - lettuce wrapped sandwiches - unlimited fries and other sides - fundraisers!“

“The food was served quickly. They weren't very busy so it was quiet. The burgers were fantastic as well as the gluten free bun!! It is very hard to find decent gluten free breads and we weren't disappointed. The kids enjoyed the root beer floats as well as their balloons to go.

Dietary restrictions: Great gluten free bun“