50 Best Ice Cream Shops in Indianapolis

“Didn’t even get to the ice cream but oh man I enjoyed my food!“

“This is my absolute favorite ice cream in Indy!“

“Beautifully decorated shop with friendly staff and a wonderful atmosphere! ❤️“

“My girlfriends and I have known Joe for many years- from when he worked at Buck Creek Winery. He is The BEST! Now that I have finally visited the shop 2 days in a row- I know why everyone raves about Heartland. Last night there was a great crew working! The teens were very personable and friendly. They offered us a sample. Everything tasted sooo good. If you know how great Joe is- you won't be surprised that he has a phenomenal group of employees representing his shop. As for the ice cream...my youngest son LOVED the Superman. I chose Cornbread and Coffee Cookie. Sooooo good! You HAVE to try the Cornbread ice cream! It is the most unique, delicious ice cream ever! I had to get it again today. My oldest son came this time and he sampled Cornbread. He liked it so much- that is what he ordered, too! The Cookies and Cream is also to die for! I love how easy it is to sign up for the rewards program. We also loved how many options we had to choose from on the menu. If I can ever tear myself away from the Cornbread ice cream- I would like to try the Italian Ice. It was great to see you today, Joe! What a wonderful business you are building. I'm sending Nikki in STAT! lol. My boys and I highly recommend Heartland. Looking forward to visiting again soon....“

“My friends and I were in Indianapolis for an anime convention. After we ate at an Italian restaurant, we decided to stop by a local ice cream shop to get some ice cream. When we got there, there was a Jamaican themed party going on. Just everyone (staff and the community) having a great time. We got our ice cream and oh my goodness, it is definitely one of THE BEST ice creams I’ve had in a long time. (I had their cookie dough ice cream). The manager or owner (I’m not sure, very nice lady) came up and handed me a coupon for buy one get one free scoop. Her and her staff offered us some Jamaican food to have, but with being so full from dinner and their delicious ice cream, we had to decline. Amazing vibes, amazing ice cream. You’ll definitely see me again when I come back to Indianapolis. Thank you!“

“This is my absolute favorite ice cream in Indy!“

“This place is awesome!! Over this past summer, my best friend and I would take walks and we always ended here! Guy behind the counter is just amazing, such great customer service and we were always so excited to see him! I can’t wait to come back again next summer when I’m back in Indy!!“

“Just starting on their food smells good“

“Great service and atmosphere and delicious ice cream“

“Great bubble tea menu! They have frozen yogurt and rolled ice cream too!“

“Best black raspberry chocolate chunk ice cream ever“

“Im obsessed with the strawberry shortcake its sooo good!“

“Devil cookies! They are sinfully good! My daughter came home with the biscoff pie, and I ate most of it and then shot back up there the next day and about 4 of them! I love the themed cookies, but the banana bread coookie was not it! It was still like bread. Crumbl needs more centralized locations.“

“Stopped by with the kids, and my parents and they were closed... sad day, but the owner saw us and let us in. Totally did not expect that but he was super nice. This place is awesome!!“

“delicious desert 🏜and ice cream cheese cakes“

“Delicious!!! Very tasty ice cream. Great after a meal 😎“

“Tonight was my first time ever here and it is my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE ice cream place now!!!!!“

“Best DQ in Indy!!! My orders are always correct. Fast and friendly service, every time. If there’s a long line, don’t fret. They are fast but efficient. We go out of our way to go to this Dairy Queen. Today, I got an orange shake and a box of popsicles as I have had a sore throat and I knew just the fix! 🤣“

“Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream is Indy's best ice cream hands down and I am so happy that we carry their ice cream on our food truck, Moo & Lou Frozen Treats! We love taking Sundaes to places that have never tried it. So many happy people!! <3 <3 <3“

“You gots to try it , a must“

“Visit the newly opened Tsaocaa in 82nd street/Castleton and enjoy the refreshing milk tea plus great customer service. Taro bubble milk tea is my favorite. FYI: Bubble tea is a Taiwanese tea-based drink invented in Tainan and Taichung in the 1980s. Recipes contain tea of some kind, flavors of milk, as well as sugar. Toppings, such as chewy tapioca balls, popping boba, fruit jelly, grass jelly, agar jelly, and puddings are often added.“

“You gots to try it , a must“

“My favorite place to have a cheat day. I'm in there often“

“Please list daily flavors of you ice cream!!“

“Very friendly and good ice cream 🍨“

“Clean restaurant and friendly people! Esquite so good and hot. I will be back😉“

“We had a Nicey Treat freezer cart at our wedding and it was fantastic! I loved the flavors we chose - Not-So-Hot Chocolate, Mango Ginger, and Pink Lemonade. They were a huge hit with our guests and the perfect pairing with our wedding cake.“

“awesome place lots to see“

“This place is so beautiful, calm, peaceful and child friendly!!! The food is amazing. They only play mexican music which i like but it would be nice for it to be a mixture or like a spanish english mix type thing. The people the very friendly and i love that you can just order on the screen and pay! They just called your name when their done.“

“delicious desert 🏜and ice cream cheese cakes“

“A variety of frozen yogurt flavors are available as well as numerous toppings. You have an almost endless number of combinations to make. The price is a little high as it is based on the final weight of the bowl. Good place to go for a unique treat though.“

“They make magic happen! So magical I don't want to say who or how. Let's just say my family is so grateful for the care, understanding and awesome customer service provided. In this day and age where you can't even get a stateside rep the people at BB were a breath of fresh air. The 2 vanilla strawberry and 2 vanilla cherry helped a bunch as well.“

“I visited this store when they just opened because it is close to my house, but I had a bad experience with the food so I stopped going, today I gave it another chance and they have improved in terms of the food, everything was delicious.
The serving staff seems annoyed, I guess it's because of the time I went. I hope it's not like this all the time.“

“The kids got two large-ish ice cream cups with one mix-in and while it was a delicious treat, I was surprised that it came to $15 for just two. Okay, maybe for the size of cups it was worth it . They love picking the mix-in! The service was fast and professional. There are two small dining tables inside if you want to stay and eat.“

“I had never tried Rolled Ice Cream before. What a fun experience. My son had tried it before and talked me into stopping by while we were in Castleton Mall.

The ice cream was yummy and it was fun watching it being made. They have lots of options and the person who served us was friendly and upbeat.

I am sure we will stop by again sometime.“

“Great ice cream! Large menu friendly service.“

“Very yummy ice cream and treats! The kids size scoop is perfect for my 3yr old and my 6yr old son loves the cone dipped in chocolate and sprinkles. Their treats are as good as they look! Tried the peach smoothie and it was also delicious. 😊“

“The tamales I had over the weekend were good!. They were well seasoned and moist. I put one in the microwave and it was still pretty tasty. They are also a nice size. The lady spoke no English but did use Google Translate to communicate. I didn't try anything else. Just a girl who loves tamales! Lol...“

“Chocolate sodas. A trip back in time or a new experience. Delicious.“

“Amanda, the Director of Operations, was so friendly and efficient. She was easy to work with to plan our corporate ice cream party. The driver who came was also very nice and the ice cream was delicious! Will definitely use Ice Cream on Wheels again!“

“I love This Place .. The best wings I have tried I love the new men ú.. I recommend 100% [Original] I love this place .. las mejores alitas que he probado me encanta el nuevo menú ..lo recomiendo 100%“

“the best icecream 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍“

“Everything was very good. We will definitely be back.“

“good service Robert corrected our issues couldn't be happier“

“COOPER! Cooper was working when I went in, I wanted to try the flavor of the month but had questions as I have a peanut and tree nut allergy. he was ver kind, informative and, personable. He shared that he too had a peanut allergy. When it was time for me to get my ice cream made he went into the back and got new scoops and spades, as well as asked if I was getting mix ins so that way he could disinfect the mixing area. truly appreciated the service and the overall experience <3“

“We appreciate the helpfulness of the staff. There was an issue with the app not taking off the discount. The manager stepped on and helped to rectify the situation. Things happen and don't always work the way they are supposed to. The real measure of a business is how they fix things when they aren't working. This location took care of it with minimal prompting and was pleasant to work with!“

“I just enjoy their food. Good taste, ample portions, great onion rings. Just great food.“

“great food . food was nice hot. very delicious.“

“Another SATISFIED customer THANK YOU“