50 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis

“First time in, fast, friendly service and the fresh ingredients left my pallet looking forward to the next lunch visit. Beautifully created, the art is in every bite. And, on the walls! This place is a gem! 10/10!“

“The sandwiches were delicious and the service was wonderful! You can tell this family puts love in what they do. Treat yourself afterwards and get the cheesecake - it’s phenomenal!“

“Brian makes pizza burgers!!!“

“NEW NAME NEW ME!
Turchetti’s is now WILDFYRE TAP
Controversial opinion; the fries are better now tbh.
Super appreciate the actual QUALITY gluten free bun sub. The owners care about making their food accessible to many people, not just carnivores with an iron stomach. Fyre is open late, which gives us second and third shifters a beautiful and delicious option for food during /after our shifts. It’s also just great to be able to get a dab down the street and walk down here and be able to smash food without any sense of shame around the fact that I’m stoned af and about to literally inhale these fries.
The space is much bigger now, as the new owners have remodeled/removed several walls in the front of the shop to create additional seating. A nice high bar in front of a sunny window sounds like workspace heaven at 11am.
They plan to do tons of events, as the space is fricken huge. All around very excited for the future of this space and ftsq!

Also maybe I’m biased but the staff is just super sweet and helpful! Please pop in!“

“I ordered sandwiches for a bunch of hungry welders, and this place absolutely delivered! Great atmosphere, incredible staff! They were quick , and efficient. They all deserve 5 stars! Keep up the great work. Best jimmy John’s I’ve ever been to.“

“The people who own this place are so sweet and the menu is great. They're friendly, efficient, and the prices are very good considering the variety of sandwiches and the quality. They serve breakfast too and it hits the spot every time. Will keep in the rotation for the foreseeable future.“

“If you love light lunches without having to grab a salad, this is definitely a great place, especially if you love chicken salad. They're variations are impressive and it's very tasty! The inside of the restaurant is so adorable. Very girly! Service was top notch and we'll definitely visit again“

“Jason is the man, he has been punctual and a great guy to speak with.“

“Never disappoints! Love the daily specials! Great staff!“

“First time to go to Chicken Salad Chicks, and we loved it ! Pleasant ordering service and advice on the choices, and great lunch. We will definitely keep this restaurant on our go to list. A plus service, atmosphere and food!“

“Walked in 30 minutes before close, and still got amazing service from both Diego and Mike. First time eating here and I got the Italian Sub. It tasted delicious, was made fresh in front of me, and was out in under 7 minutes. (There was also a line) Highly recommend to people who are from out of town.“

“Good food great atmosphere“

“Love their variety of foods ( Reubens are my favorite). Salads are huge and good. Best Sweet Tea .“

“Fun atmosphere. Music bingo, games, karaoke is fun!“

“Nice Black owned business with excellent food and great prices. Always friendly and great customer service! If you are ever in the area check out Vees sandwich shop 2601 W Michigan St. Indpls, In 46222 she closes at 5pm.“

“PACERS WIN!! Buy 1 get 1 free Thank You…. PACERS WIN GAME 1 get buy 1 get 1 5/22/25 YES’CERS PACERS WIN GAME 4 BUY 1 GET 1🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥YES CERS WIN GAME 3 BOGO 💥☄️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥“

“I placed a pickup order online. When I went to get my food, I was greeted when I came in, I was told at the pickup counter my remaining wait time and upon leaving was told to have a great day. Extremely friendly with excellent customer service. THANK YOU!“

“I recently had an issue with my order. It was a simple mistake. While it was difficult to reach the store due to the number not working? I finally went into the store spoke to the manager and was able to get it taken care of they gladly replaced the meal and made the order correct for me. Definitely would go back to eat here again.“

“I don’t normally leave reviews like this, but the incredible staff at this Subway absolutely deserve it. The ladies who work here are hands-down some of the kindest, most thoughtful people I’ve ever met.

I had called earlier just to ask if they had the Happy Gilmore cup from the special promotion. That’s it—just a quick check. When I showed up later to see what cups they had, they had actually saved the exact one I was hoping for. I never even told them which character I wanted—but somehow, they just knew. That small act of thoughtfulness genuinely meant the world to me.

It’s rare to be treated with that kind of care and attention anywhere, let alone at a fast-food spot. I was truly touched. I can honestly say I’ll never go to another Subway again. This is the one. Loyal for life.

Thank you again to the amazing women working there. You made my day in a way you probably didn’t even realize.“

“I eat here at least once a month. Sandwiches are awesome. Recent experience: needed a receipt from over a month ago. I called the location where I ordered. They said they could try. Next morning Bobbie from the district office in Zionsville called me and took down some info. Then had the receipt emailed to me within 30 min. Both gentleman I talked to were super nice and gave GREAT customer service!!! Thank you so much for your assistance!!“

“*****7-25-2025 UPDATE *****
Called in and spoke with Zane for my delivery order. He was patient and efficient with my request! Thank you Zane, for the exceptional care you showed to my family tonight!
**********
Always a great experience and delicious food. The staff is personable and welcoming and that is hard to come by these days :)“

“One of the best meals around. I stop into this location about 1 a week for the best Philly Steak in town. It's custom made to my liking- I also have to get the natural cut fries- some of my absolute favorites and very similar to the best in the industry (5 guys). With so many choices for lunch/dinner to go to, it's nice to know that Justin and Alex are always ready to take my call ahead order and cut my wait time. Works perfectly when I head out planning to work a long shift. I just call as I leave my house and snag my meal along the way in. Thanks to both of them for always doing a spectacular job. - Perfect 5 out of 5 and will always recommend. It's on my regular weekly hot list for foods I love most.“

“Awesome food and great atmosphere. Even with being short staffed this place never disappoints. Thank you to ALL the staff who are out there doing what you do. It is ppreciated. Staff appears to be overworked but they always have a smile for you and will make sure you have a good dining experience. Be patient people they are doing their best when no one else wants to work. Keep up the good work and GREAT FOOD!!“

“Turkey sub is to die for and I love their brownies..“

“When I got here in the evening, they were not busy at all.
I ordered a Philly cheese steak sandwich and it was great. The meat was tender and flavorful, the onions on mushrooms were also cooked perfectly and very flavorful and overall this was a great sandwich.
I would recommend Penn Station to anyone looking for a good sub.“

“One of my biggest complaints across all Subways is how little toppings they give you. I find that is generally consistent across the board. However, this location gives you lots and lots of toppings. They know what they’re doing, and want to make your experience positive. I highly recommend this location, there is parking right out front.“

“Closed during open hours, i can understand though if its understaffed, but I ordered a pickup order and now I have to get a refund…

Edit: i just saw a sign saying theres a water main break! Oops! Sorry for such quick judgement, just sad I couldn’t have penn station!“

“Salads are always fresh. Soups are good. Especially potato and tortilla. Large baked potatoes with lots of choices for toppings. Great sweet tea. Love this place. Never disappointed!“

“This is a very good place.
I almost signed for their membership rewards program, but then realized where I live does not have a McAlister's restaurant.
I tried their grilled chicken sandwich on rye with sauce on the side and the pecanberry salad. It was very good. It was just enough for dinner.
If they have gelato ice cream here, that would be the best...it can attract more customers. Cappo gelato would be an excellent selection...maybe a separate room and entrance.“

“What a great place to eat & catch live entertainment. Big Mike G's Comedy Open Mic on Saturdays is awesome. I seen clean Comedy, Music & Spoken Word, now that's what I call a meal deal for the whole family!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
One of the cleanest and freshest Subways I’ve ever been to. Everything tasted super fresh, and the whole place was spotless—from the counter to the seating area. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. You can really tell they take pride in their store. Definitely coming back!“

“Folks on FB like to hate on fast food on the east side, but Penn Station had staff that seemed to put in a good effort, great service and made delicious food. Made me question why I'm not here more. Chicken teriyaki. Tasted like high school in the 90s. 🤠 I'll be back. Thanks for a great experience!“

“I lovvvvvve McAllister but tonight I got home and found a cookie on my kid spud. This alarmed me. This is not sanitary!!!!! Please find another way to get cookies to your customers 🤢🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮“

“Jersey Mike’s: Let’s Get Fresh

When it comes to fresh, flavorful submarine sandwiches, Jersey Mike’s is my go-to spot. Whether you prefer your sub hot or cold, their menu offers a wide variety of signature subs that cater to every taste. And if you don’t see exactly what you’re craving, no problem—build your own! Customize your sandwich with the freshest ingredients and enjoy it just the way you like, on their robust, fresh-baked bread.
My personal favorite? The Club Supreme. Loaded with roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, applewood smoked bacon, and mayo, this sub is a true indulgence. Pro tip: ask for extra bacon—it really enhances the flavor.
Of course, no meal is complete without the perfect sides. Be sure to grab a bag of chips and treat yourself to a cookie or brownie. And don’t forget to add a refreshing drink to wash it all down!“

“Highly recommend this particular Subway. The staff there is always kind and respectful, you can tell they actually swap out the ingredients for fresh ones, and just all around, they are the best subway in the area (which is odd considering it runs out of a gas station). It's my go to.“

“Kris, I think that was the cook's name, made the best Philly Cheese steaks that I have eaten. I have eaten sandwiches from Maine to LA, and this one was the best. Only issue is that I called in about 15 minutes early and they didn't put my fries down until I got there. Maybe they do that, so they are fresh, so wasn't a big deal.“

“Must rate this location five stars. The service is OUTSTANDING, the food delicious. Passing thru and decided to try something new and they didn't disappoint; food made when you order. Antonio and his supervisor were the helpful, smiling faces that a customer wants to be confronted with when you enter an establishment. Thank you guys, I definitely recommend eating here.“

“Me and my kids just left from this Penn Station customer service was greaaat the 3 workers vibes where absolutely awesome if we didn't get there right before closing we would of actually stay there to eat.. Reminder im a to go type of person... Food was absolutely perfect.. Highly recommend 👌🏾“

“Great guys working and willing to remake my reuben bc I didnt specify what kind of bread I wanted it on. I guess I was expecting it on rye or something other than white. The owner or manager even gave me the first one free since they couldn't resell or use it.“

“I traveled to Indy from Michigan with our high school marching band. We ordered boxed lunches for our bus ride home. I worked with Neil at the Subway in the Hyatt Regency in Indy. He was very accommodating and flexible, especially when our band director decided to leave town a couple of hours early. Neil's staff came in early to work on our order to get it ready for our new departure time. They were very kind and helpful when we picked up the order. I would definitely order from them again and would recommend them to others.“

“the food was good nice people it was easy to owe you I will come in ther I'll always go back to Jimmy John's food is deliciouse“

“I placed my order online and it charged but it the order didn’t actually go through (I had called) and I ended up placing it on DoorDash and the worker , emma, was super sweet on the phone both times and ended up putting some cookies in my DoorDash order ❣️❣️❣️“

“Great food, great service. Made an order on the app to take advantage of a deal and points. The gentleman there made our food before taking care of people that came in after the order was placed and that was a very welcome change from other Subways I've been to where orders from the app are pushed to the side and handled later.“

“I come here all the time and always get my same order: a 6-inch flatbread with provolone, ham, and bacon toasted, baked barbecue chips, and a Dole lemonade. The staff here are always super friendly and get my order perfect every time. My order isn’t super complicated in general. Great service, clean place, and consistent quality. that’s why I keep coming back!!“

“Absolutely loved this place. Came here 3 days a week for the past 4 years. Now they quit carrying the flatbread sandwich i got 3 days a week for 4 years and so I had to say goodbye to the employees I've got to know so well. Time to find a new sub shop for life. Goodbye Subway...“

“It's a good and clean place. Keeps up to the name of the franchise, well maintained. The Indian guy making my sub was very upbeat and kept things lively. The only reason I gave one less star is that access to this place was not so easy.“

“This particular Subway restaurant or
Franchise limits the amount of meat that they put on your sandwich. It's not full or thick.
They're very skimpy on the amount of food that they put on your sandwich that you're trying to create.“