42 Best Mexican Restaurants near New Palestine

“This is our FAVORITE restaurant! The staff is absolutely amazing and goes over and beyond! The food is fantastic and delicious every time! This is our go to restaurant every time!! I would highly recommend The Nopal, you won’t be disappointed! 💗“

“Great food and great service for a group of 20 plus.“

“We went through the drive thru and everything was perfect! Blake V was the employee working the window and he was very friendly and patient with our large order. The food was hot and fresh and exactly how we ordered it! Highly recommend. Blake is hire you any day!“

“Amazing flavor compared to other Mexican food options in town. The meat is actually seated nicely and the blend of their spices is done perfectly.“

“We are new to the area and decided to try it last night. The food, drinks and staff where amazing. We will def become regulars.“

“Good place and good people their“

“I’ve been here a few times and the food doesn’t disappoint. I did have a disappointing experience today with our bill however. There was an extra meal charged on our bill which I brought to our servers attention. When she returned, I found that instead of voiding and printing a corrected bill, she ran a credit charge for the overage. This meant I had to pay the higher incorrect charge and wait (from what I understand) a couple 3-4 days for the credit to return to my card. I don’t feel it appropriate that the customer pay for the billing error then have to wait for a refund. I did let them know I wasn’t happy about it. I will be watching that I do receive this credit. It also put a bad taste in my mouth about returning anytime soon.“

“excelente servicio y comida excelente los recomiendo“

“AMAZING FOOD, AWESOME SERVICE, and INCREDIBLE STAFF!!! Hands down the ABSOLUTE BEST restaurant/cantina in or around the area!!! My family dines here weekly and we've also had a few parties here, and every time is better than the last!! Suitable for all age groups and you will not be disappointed!!! Thank you Valle, y'all are top notch and unmatched in quality, taste, and customer service!!!👌“

“As has been noted often, this is one of the few places in town with authentic Mexican food. This was our first time here and we're glad we finally decided to check it out. We both got a few tacos- the chicken was a little dry but overall didn't ruin the taco by any means, and we tried the asada & lengua as well. Chips and dip were great, queso was amazing.“

“True authentic Mexican cuisine. The true flavors of Mexico. Excellent tamales and beans & rice. I will be back. Great service and prices too.“

“Food was excellent!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“Great place . Nice seating. Good food. Great service.“

“great food, great service, clean.“

“Very friendly staff. Food was incredible. Was not expecting a full menu, but was pleasantly impressed and surprised. Definitely our new Go-to spot.“

“I received wonderful service. The waitress was very nice and helpful. I ordered two margaritas, raspberry and peach. They were excellent! I also ordered 2 chicken tamales and queso dip. The food was very flavorful. The establishment is very clean. I would return again!!“

“It’s a great and friendly place for the whole family“

“I ate there today for the first time with my manager and it was so good! We talked a lot afterwards about how amazing it was. Thank you for the wonderful service and meal, Rosa😀“

“UNAS DE LAS MEJORES COCINAS MARISQUERAS“

“What a great experience they had with your truck at their birthday party!“

“Always a great experience here. Food made well. All ingredients available. I ESPECIALLY like this location because they have regular chopped red onions as a topping option... NONE of the others in the city do. There's a location about 8 minutes away from me, but i prefer if I have time to drive the 20 minutes it takes to get to this location to know all the options WILL be available INCLUDING those red onions. I just like it here 😌.“

“Muy rica la comida y muy amable la gente! 100% recomendado!“

“Authentic Deliciousness!!! This is authentic Mexican food and it is wonderful! My favorite place to get steak tacos and burritos. The chicken is good too but the steak is by far my favorite. Very flavorful and tender. When you order their tacos they come with Cambray onions and Serrano peppers which are grilled to perfection and so delicious. Then they give you a choice of two different sauces, and green sauce or a red sauce, both are nice and potent but the red sauces the best! If you're looking for delicious street tacos or one of the best burritos you'll ever have, I highly recommend. Best part is it won't cost you a fortune.“

“To Alyssa Howard and Cindy Heffren, you don’t come often at all because you ordered a FAJITA salad which is literally just the salad with guac and sour cream and tomato. You even requested “no sour cream” when your order was CONFIRMED by your server. You meant to order a TACO SALAD. Which is WAY off to the order YOU confirmed was correct the first time. Then you complained that the meat portion wasn’t to your liking. Okay whatever. Then you claimed to have found a hair. Girllllll… lol, I found both of your facebooks so fast and that was definitely YOUR hair. Not a single person on staff has light colored hair lol. I’m glad you guys got kicked out because If I was the manager, I would’ve also cussed you out fr. You should both just stay home and cook 💕 you ruined MY meal with MY family by making a scene for something that was your fault.“

“Mi Casita has the best and most authentic Mexican Style food. Their menu has a lot of selections and by looking and reading you will want to try them all! Their atmosphere is nice and of course the staff is friendly and they also have good serving times, highly recommended, the best food coma I’ve ever had! 💯💯“

“Food is always on point no matter what you order. Extremely friendly staff, very welcoming and accommodating. If you haven't heard about their taco Tuesday. . .$1 tacos! And they are so good! They even come with a big bag of chips and salsa. The only (and I mean only) issue I have with Costas is the atmosphere. You walk through the door and immediately see a huge wall divider. The place just needs a huge overhaul on the decorating.“

“We went Monday night 10/13/25. Food and service were fantastic. Little hiccup in our order and two managers stopped by. The place is immaculately clean and the color scheme is gorgeous. Top notch“

“Authentic TEX MEX , all the patrons and staff were Latino except me , but I was served promptly and welcomed warmly. I ordered two shrimp tacos delux and they were delicious and quickly brought out by a beautiful friendly waitress. This restaurant is adjacent to a small Latino grocery store . I think this is a common practice and I believe it promotes fresh food and family atmosphere. Try it you will like it!“

“38th street location! Clean and Very Welcoming! Definitely will be coming back!“

“muy Buena comida se los rrecomiendo“

“Authentic TEX MEX , all the patrons and staff were Latino except me , but I was served promptly and welcomed warmly. I ordered two shrimp tacos delux and they were delicious and quickly brought out by a beautiful friendly waitress. This restaurant is adjacent to a small Latino grocery store . I think this is a common practice and I believe it promotes fresh food and family atmosphere. Try it you will like it!“

“Todo de este lugar es bueno, y los servicios son excelentes!! La comida de aquí nunca falla, uno de mis lugares favoritos para comer.“

“Nice atmosphere- delicious food“

“This location is amazing! This our favorite location to visit because the food is always amazing and service is always friendly! The staff and especially the manager who always work Monday nights after we get out of practice always ensure we have everything we need!“

“I recommend this place it was delicious..“

“Great food. The service was also great. Margarita was yummy.“

“Ordene un arroz con gandules y unas alcapurrias. El arroz con gandules estaba durisimo no se podia ni comer. Fui a decirle a la muchacha que si me lo podia cambiar por otra cosa y se nego me dijo que tenia q ser por el mismo arroz. Le dije que no lo queria que me devolviera mi dinero y se nego. No se lo recommends a nadie el services fue malisimo. Las actitudes de la dama fueron malisimas. Una vez te cobras lo que quieren es quedarse con tu dinero.“

“El mejor sabor en el rincon catracho lupita .“

“If you like El Salvadorian food you have to go to Pupuseria El Pulgarcito Restaurant#2 on Indy’s East side! Everything I ordered was amazing: shrimp pupusas, chicken pupusas, chicken tamales, cheese pupusas, and guacamole with plantains! And almost each item runs you about $3 or less! My whole family devoured our meal! Not a crumb left! *Also: if you don’t speak the language, pull out your phone to use Google or Siri to translate instead of writing a review on the language instead of the food.*“

“BIG SHOUT OUT TO KYLE WHO WORKS NIGHTS!!!!!!! If I could give this Taco Bell 10000000 stars on Google I would for many reasons but recently Kyle who works nights personally paid for my meal when I was having payment issues and he deserves all the praise there is to offer because he went he extra mile and was happy to do so!!! Thank you again Kyle and you will be blessed for paying it forward you are forever appreciated and Taco Bell is BLESSED to have you on their team!!! Thank you again also the nachos were awesome the food is always on point and this Taco Bell rocks so it's no surprise of the line is long because they rock and people know it! THANKS SO MUCH KYLE!!!!!!!“

“Taco Bell impresses with their commitment to quality service and order accuracy, their menu variety ensures there's something for everyone, and the staff are always friendly, making it a convenient and satisfying option for casual dining.“