25 Best American Restaurants near Worthington

“Best fresh massive burger I have had in the longest time. Onion rings were fire & of course had to have a milkshake. Great atmosphere, highly recommend“

“awsome food i had the taco bowl delish“

“May 8th, 2026 was our first visit, we had no idea what we were missing out on, this place is the perfect spot for whatever your situation, single, married couple night out or for the whole family, I strongly recommend Kel’s Tavern“

“Good 🌭“

“Had dinner at Pappy's Cookin' today for the first time. Pretty awesome place. I had fried shrimp and fries and Heather Hoptry-Queen had blackened chicken breasts. Food was great as was the service. Staff was friendly, attentive, and accurate. The portions. Wow. Neither of us could finish the whole thing and boxes were needed. Will def go back and def recommend it. Good home cooking style food. ❤️“

“great place great service great prices“

“Me & my husband can’t get enough of this place. We’ve been here twice within a week after finding about it. The food is top notch. Service is great. Atmosphere is amazing. Should definitely stop by! The fried banana peppers and stuffed mushrooms are out of this world!“

“It was a busy night, many patrons and our server Courtney handled it like a champ. Drinks stayed full, food came fast and hot. She was so kind about my complicated order request. It was our first time and we will definitely be back!“

“We will not be returning to eat there. Soft serve chocolate hasn't been available to customers in 2 months. we were told the machine has been broken. Hotdogs, hotdog sauce and cheese very low grade....Vietti, would've been better! Although, I'm Pretty sure it was Vietti. Fried mushrooms that were burnt, dried up mushroom inside of all 6 of them. Ranch dressing tasted old or stale. Husband's ice cream, Butter pecan, had an eye lash it!! It also tasted freezer burnt as well. We want to support local business, but this is not acceptable anymore.“

“Had a great meal with the family at Frische’s, service is always amazing thanks to Tonya and Tammy! Service and food is always on point! Great job guys!“

“We generally avoid the major chain restaurants, but this Applebee's is our exception. The service is always great and the quality of food is consistently great. My wife raves about their salmon and my go-to is the Bourbon Street Chicken.“

“Crystal Moore is a wonderful person and a great cook,glad she is there“

“Party of 8 this New Years evening! Our service was excellent! Luke was our waiter was awesome! Very attenative and pleasant ! Food was very good! We all enjoyed our visit!!“

“Never better home cooking the taste and tenderness is unmatched anywhere. I’d recommend this to anyone and everyone. The establishment is clean and the service is outstanding. Give it a try.“

“Great food, clean restaurant, and the friendliest employees! The menu was so large and the prices were unbeatable. Will definitely be back! 10/10!“

“Last time we were there the normal woman who owns it or who is always there working was not there girl who waited on us was terrible normally though this is a good place very good it's another one of those deals when the cat's away the rats will play hopefully the next time we go out there she's not working there anymore the bouncy blonde who becomes friendly only with the people that she knows we love the girl who is the owner hope she knows how this girl is seems to be on her best behavior when she's there and not when she's gone most of the time the girl I'm speaking of works the front room thankfully not the bar area great pizza bread sandwich s sincerely Dave and Pam“

“So we came for my husbands’s birthday. The service was wonderful, everyone is incredibly friendly. When it came time to order food I will say this. The soup was amazing. Unfortunately the fish and chips was inedible. I don’t want to place blame. I understand it’s sometimes difficult to acquire fresh fish and to hand batter said fish. Having said that if it were my restaurant I would take fish and chips off the menu if I was unable to produce a pub staple. I’ll say this. Order the Celtic knot, the bangers and mash and the Boston cream pie, and you’ll be more than satisfied.“

“Antonio was a great server!“

“Delicious food! We eat here all the time.“

“In town for the weekend and wanted steak, Longhorn was close to hotel. Only about a 15 min wait on a busy Saturday night, I guess several things going on this weekend l. Excellent service and food. Next time in Ashland we will definitely visit again.“

“Good service, super friendly people. And truly helpful“

“The quality of our local steak and shakes have significantly improved along with the staff. Much cleaner, tastes better, and even seems more filling than it used to. On top of that the new company policies like banning microwaves, beef tallow for their fried goods, and grass fed beef for the burgers. It went downhill a while ago but I can definitely say it has done a complete 360 and has honestly been one of our families favorite quick fast food locations now. Definitely better than McDonald's.“

“Very good service the are very nice people and kindly“

“We went to Cheddars this afternoon and received the absolute best service we have ever had. Friendly, funny and fast moving. Her name was Calliope (Poppi)
The food was spectacular. This has become our favorite restaurant in our area.“

“Great food, great place! Employees are great and had a hard time rsting service a 2. Until something is done about the hostess named Nikki. Her attitude, her demeanor needs checked. It's sad when you describe your experience with her with other friends and everyone describes her to a tee. Picking up an online order is a nightmare.“