27 Best Italian Restaurants near Duxbury

“Absolutely amazing staff. We ordered lunch from here today and we asked for my sandwich with burnt like burnt burnt bacon. (Pregnancy at its finest) And you guys 110% nailed it and made me the perfect sandwich. I haven’t had any other restaurant even come close to actually cooking the bacon how I like it. I just wanted to say thank you! ❤️“

“What do we recommend? Pretty much everything. Yes, it may take a while for your order to be ready, so order it earlier, and pick it up at the time you select. It'll be ready on time and will be worth it. Chris and his crew are outstanding and the only difficult thing is not eating the entire pizza on the way home.“

“Lovely Italian food and staff!! We got take out and it was Delicious w/o garlic overload. Everything was so fresh and cooked to order!!! We will be back!! Thank you!“

“Food was exceptional as was the service“

“Food is always delicious Staff very friendly“

“Angry pizza was top notch“

“One of our favorite Italian restaurants in the South Shore is Mia Regazza in Marshfield. The restaurant is spacious, featuring a bar, dining rooms, and outdoor seating during the summer. The service is friendly and professional, and the dining rooms maintain a pleasant noise level. The food is excellent, with the chicken Parmesan being a standout dish. Parking can be challenging during dinner hours, so it's recommended to arrive a bit early. It is definitely recommended.“

“What's not to love about Polcari's? It is an open friendly atmosphere. We were seated near the window where the water and boats were in clear view. This is our second meet up some coming from NH and another coming the Cape.
Our server was attentive and checked on us frequently. The food was delicious although the steak fries could have been hotter.
Prices were reasonable.
We will definitely visit again.“

“Gary has not worked there since April 2025…. So I’m not sure who you are talking about?! Diane is awesome on Tuesday for music bingo tho!“

“Food and and service is always spectacular!“

“They lost a customer!! We ordered take out 2 weeks ago on Friday night, Caesar salad with chicken, chicken Alfredo, and chicken broccoli Alfredo. We picked up the food within 30 minutes, the time we were quoted when picking up and live about 10 minutes away, let just say it was one of the worst take out meals we have had. Immediately after we started eating I called and spoke to the manager, the salad was watery and croutons were mushy, the chicken Alfredo was cold, the Parmesan wasn't melted! The food tasted like it a day old and microwaved! The manager took all my info and stated she would call me back after dinner service, never heard from her. Saturday I called back after not hearing, the same manager answered apologizing it was late when she finished dinner service but the owner was out of town and would call me back during the week, ok no problem. Late Monday I get a voicemail from the owners wife, working in customer service I was appalled by the voicemail. She stated that croutons do get soggy if you don't eat the salad right away and to order the dressing on the side next time. And that Alfredo just separates if you don't eat right away, suggesting I don't let it sit to room temperature before serving. I immediately called her back and explained I picked up the order and called within 40 minutes of placing the order, she stated that wasn't explained to me. She continued to tell me, speaking to someone in the background I have never heard this many complaints before. She proceeded to ask me what I wanted her to do about it, she stated she needed to talk to her husband because they don't just refund someone because they complain... I proceeded to tell her I had pictures if she was interested. I texted her the pictures and she told me she had to speak to her husband and would call me back... over a week later no call back...“

“I was having a bad night and this restaurant completely turned everything around for me. Starting with the Hostess who was engaging, funny and very invested in making sure we got a seat. We had a reservation but we arrived 45 minutes early. The atmosphere is quaint and comfortable. There is a pleasant chatter in the restaurant from everyone having a nice time, but it is not so loud that you can't hear everyone at your table. The staff is unsurpassed. Our waitress in particular made our night.(Ashley M) She was hilarious and thought we were fun too. (Always a good feeling!) Now for the food... We started with a fresh, delicious Caesar Salad. Followed by incredible Chicken Parm with the most delicious red sauce! We wrapped up our evening with a hugh, delicious piece of chocolate cake and Vanilla Bean Gelato. We WILL be back again and again. I regret that I waited this long to try Strega!“

“Met some old work friends for a pre-holiday lunch. Food was good and arrived quickly. Our waiter was attentive. We had a great time.

Prices are a little daunting now. Something seemed off too, 5 meatballs parm *app that doesn't come with pasta for $12? Is my math off? (I could have just ordered the 3 meatball app for $3.99 × 2. So for $8, I would hv had 6 meatballs). I asked the waiter and he said pricing was correct but??“

“This place is amazing!! Food never disappoints and the staff is so nice!! My husband and I love supporting this family run business!!“

“Always excellent quality love their food thank you“

“Great food nevr left hungry been going almost 40 years!“

“Hands down the best Italian restaurant and pizza, family owned for 50 years! Love it“

“Outstanding dining experience at Tuscany Tavern, staff and chefs are tops … they even took great attention for a family member with celiac A+++“

“We got take out pizza when Mamma Mia opened in 1974! It’s been our place since . After moving to Plymouth, it’s Friday nights on the waterfront. When our kids and grandkids visit from across the country, it always includes a trip back for pizza. Thank you for a great pie!!!“

“The best pizza in Pembroke and great customer service“

“Family friendly and a willing to accommodate a family of 14. We were at the Carver location and had great food and excellent service.“

“Stevie’s uses high quality, fresh ingredients, and the difference can definitely be tasted! Their pizza toppings are portioned generously and everything is cooked just right! I’ve been told by someone who works there that the kitchen is always kept exceptionally clean! The people who take orders on the phone and the drivers are very friendly and courteous. Five star + IMO!“

“Family friendly and a willing to accommodate a family of 14. We were at the Carver location and had great food and excellent service.“

“Chef/food is great. Courtney is always on top of it. The new bar is amazing. Will be back again.“

“This place is a hidden gem! Awesome food and great service. Try the hot honey pepperoni slice. Looks like a piece of art taste like a piece of Heaven!“

“I placed my first order for delivery tonight. I mainly pick our food up. We love their wings and pizza. I gave instruction on delivery. I get a text asking if they were at the correct place, I said I am in the driveway with the light on. I go out side and see no one. I go to the front of the building and our food is sitting on the ground. The delivery person text me and said they left it there cause I didn't answer my phone. Well excuse me a person has to pee. The delivery person told me I should give better instructions. Who the hell are you talking to. Told them I could not have been more clear with instructions Driveway, light will be on. The kicker is I paid on line with my card. I never add a tip online. I always tip with cash. Since my order was left on the ground and driver took off. I had no one to give a tip to. Driver lost out on a tip, but our food as always very good. I will be picking our food up after this. Delivery person very rude needs to take customer service lessons.“

“This restaurant is the best and consistent. I got a pizza and a roast beef wrap. All was great!“