49 Best American Restaurants near Wells

“This is a hidden gem and I’m so grateful to have found it. I got the Monstah Lobstah roll and it certainly lived up to its name. It was so big that I was able to bring half home to eat at a later time. We will definitely be back and hopefully Caitlin will be our waitress again… a super nice young lady. The food is delicious and the staff very accommodating.“

“Loved the experience, the salad bar brought back 1970's nostalgia. Perfect!“

“We had a wonderful dinner at Fisherman’s Catch! Seafood was beyond delicious, reasonable prices and plentiful portions and the waitstaff couldn’t be better! Stephanie B. was great - we had an infant and a 4 year old (and a set of grandparents😂) she was so accommodating, very efficient and entertaining to boot! So very glad we ended our Maine vacation at Fisherman’s Catch!!“

“We have been going to Horizons for many years. The food is always wonderful and Mary Ellen and her staff are always smiling and welcoming. One of the only places you can get a choice of how you want your eggs poached and they always come out right. Best choice for breakfast in the area.“

“Amazing! The seafood is as fresh as fresh can be. And beyond delicious! The service is wonderful! Worth driving about 20 minutes up the road from Kittery (😉).“

“For you that know me and those who don’t,I speak my mind about any subject whether it’s good or plain sucked !! I have to share this little story with you ,a dismal start to our vacation week, A normal 3 hour drive turned into a five hour one,then I had issues with my oxygen machine,which turned into waiting for a servicemen to come from two hours away.So we are looking at 9 o’clock at night before he would come, now we haven’t eaten since morning and now it’s past 7:30. We knew since Covid hit most eateries are open limited hours, we called Stutesy’s Pub & Grill they said come on down even though they were already shutting down for 8 o’clock. That they will take care of us,not only was Stacie a gracious host her husband cooked us a wonderful meal and even made two more meals to go for our two sons,who were coming laterThey won over our hearts and our taste buds so you’ve got to give Stutesy’s a try for sure!!“

“Been going to Wells for years and finally tried Rollover Cafe, it was delicious. The ladies working were super friendly, very chatty and could tell I was new.:) We ordered the meatball subs and as Nonna says, “best meatball subs in town”.“

“We came in for an early lunch. Had the place to ourself for a while. Food was amazing. I don't generally care for fried seafood. It's almost always over cooked. Browns was the exception. My scallops were perfect. Still juicy and flavorful not dried out. We'll be back again and again and again. The chowder here is one of our favorites 😍“

“We popped in here on a Thursday around 1:30, so not too busy. The bartender was friendly and accommodating. We had the mussels and parmesean truffle fries, and they were some of the best apps we've had in a while. The mussels were so good, and the hot rolls that came with them were perfect to dip into the delicious juice/ broth. The fries, dusted with parmesean and a light truffle flavor, came out crispy and hot, served with aioli and ketchup. We will definitely return someday for dinner. The bartender suggested the half-chicken, and the person next to us ordered the lobster roll, which looked like it was worth
the $$.“

“Absolutely one of the very best restaurants to be found anywhere. They're a 20 out of 10 and the kind of place that makes me wish I had more thumbs so I could give them more than two thumbs up! GREAT, attentive service, GREAT atmosphere and the food is Michelin Star worthy. Beyond wonderful!!!! It's truly a pleasure to dine with these folks and I recommend them to you enthusiastically and without reservation!“

“The most magical dinner experience. An absolutely beautiful setting accompanied by an incredible menu. Still thinking about the cherry soufflé.

It is pre-fixe for $175 or $250 per person. Something we didn’t realize before we sat at the table, but it was soooo worth it!“

“the food, the ambiance, the wait staff.“

“Got introduced to “That Place” by Friends last night for my Birthday 🥳 We had dinner there and I am so very happy that we did…the food was excellent and of high quality! We had several different appetizers and 3 main meals, and dessert…everything was absolutely delicious and the service was great as well 😊 Can highly recommend “That Place” you will not be disappointed, I guarantee you will love it 😍“

“The Summer Salad appetizer is a must. Tender greens with fresh cucumbers and mangoes with pecorino. I also recommend the Quattro pizza with fresh burratta. It’s mouthwatering. Be sure to be seated in Mitchell’s section he’s an awesome waiter 😀“

“Fantastic food, great service. We'll definitely be back!“

“Best breakfast in the Kennebunks! Delicious food, friendly service, bright and welcoming space.“

“A rare gem. Huge portions. The freshest of ingredients. Yes, they offer a Vegan special. Even better, the taste, very special. Within ten minutes, we had 4 different people check on how we were doing. We were in a rush to make the theater. They handled that very well too. A truly special place. You will leave with minds at ease and belly full.“

“We had an amazing time at the drag show, and the girls coming together and serenading me “Happy Birthday” was awesome. I also have to tell you about the fancy grilled cheese sandwich, it has goat cheese | sharp cheddar | brie | oaxaca | honey | sweet peppers… it was amazing….. wonderful food, great people and fabulous atmosphere. Can’t wait to come back!!“

“Beautiful location and delicious food!“

“Wonderful table facing the garden where we would watch the squirrels & chipmunks scurry food dropped from the birdfeeders. Live music played from the lobby, not too loud, but enough to enjoy and not disturb conversation. Food & service was excellent. Great value, especially for an upper level restaurant. We'll be back soon!“

“Cool atmosphere and food was amazing! It was a busy evening but the service was perfect. We recommend and will return!“

“Pilot House was delicious! We came here as vacationers, after being turned away from 2 restaurants due to the extreme heat they were unable to stay open. Pilot House was able to take us at their upstairs bar which was gorgeous! The AC was blasting which was a God send. The bartender was very friendly and accommodating despite being super busy! Maybe the best fish tacos I ever had. Also had a great dirty martini and a strawberry lemongrass vodka.“

“Duffy’s Tavern & Grill is a must-visit! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff are incredibly friendly and attentive. The highlight? The Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich—a perfect blend of crispy, juicy chicken with just the right balance of heat and sweetness. It’s absolutely delicious. Great vibes, great food—highly recommend!“

“Ben there a few times for bkfst , the best around b patient it’s worth the wait, stop complaining everyone works hard , if your in a hurry go thru the McDonalds & get a greasy egg sandwich, Has anyone tried the Haddock dinner on Friday’s?“

“Christopher at the bar is amazing and the owner Jake was so accommodating to our group. We literally brought a wedding party here last minute on a holiday weekend and they made the night! Thank you Jake a Christopher! ❤️“

“Fabulous food and wonderful staff. So glad we found this place when we were in the area.“

“We’ve been in ME for three nights and Bentley’s was the best experience so far!!! The prime rib dinner was perfect, wings and lobster too! The 🦞 was the best we’ve had so far this trip!! So so glad we stopped in to see what Bentley’s was all about… ~~ Grateful Central New Yorkers following up in Bentley Warren’s legacy!!!“

“The Burleigh is always a great experience. We sat in the lovely, traditional dining room by the bar. Warm and cozy. Unfortunately, we were seated near a very loud group, who arrived after us. Too many people at too small a table. The bartender was excellent. It is a short menu. We all had something different, and everything was cooked to perfection. Bravo to the chef.“

“This was our fourth time staying at the Nonantum Resort, and each visit has delivered the same amazing experience that keeps us coming back. The view from our room overlooking the water and the boats is absolutely picturesque. The staff truly go above and beyond. They make you feel like part of the family, and their customer service is consistently warm and welcoming. We were once again pleasantly surprised by how good the food is at the onsite restaurant. The breakfasts in particular are incredible—fresh, hearty, and delicious. This time, we rented bikes and cruised around Kennebunkport, which we highly recommend to anyone visiting. It was a fun and relaxing way to explore the area. Nonantum has become one of our all-time favorite places to stay. We highly recommend it to anyone considering a trip to Kennebunkport.“

“Rick’s Restaurant 9-9-25 Stopped by for some breakfast. Place was mostly full of locals and some not so local. This place is not fancy, but it was clean and neat. Our waitress Amy was on the ball with our Coffee and food orders. We ordered the Fraser Valley Breakfast which consisted of 2 Eggs, Potato’s choice of Meat and Toast. We both opted for Ham as the meat. Our food came out quick for as busy as they were. Our Eggs were done just like we ordered them, perfect. The Potato’s and Ham were both good. The food and Coffee were hot, and all was good. I guess the locals know where to go for a reasonable priced food that’s plentiful and good. They do have a couple tables outside in the front to eat at if you don’t want to be inside. There is also a counter to sit at. Seemed like the waitress their knew everybody’s name and treated us like one of the locals also. Amy checked on us a bunch of times to make sure we were well taking care of. They even had old school trivia questions on paper at the tables to keep you amused. The Salt and Pepper shakers were in the shape of a Semi Truck. I just loved this place and their food. I give this place 4 out of 5 stars. ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Follow Me On FB For More Reviews & Fun Gulf Coast Terry“

“Food came super quick and was amazing !! 5 ⭐️“

“Beautiful location and delicious food!“

“We make reservations for our guests at The Tiller Restaurant frequently as the views and menu are perfect for every romantic get away, highly recommend!“

“Delicious delicious lobster!!! Great cocktails!!! our waiter was fantastic!!! well done! highly recommend“

“Fresh Fruit is DELICIOUS. nice staff.“

“This was our first time here in 8 years since it changed from Maxwell’s to Pepper’s. Maxwell’s was a place we visited frequently when in Ogunquit, and we even had my 50th birthday there. We were very apprehensive about going to Pepper’s, and we did not know what to expect! Wow and cool were the first 2 words I thought of when we entered! The place we came to know and love changed, but it was a great change with an awesome bar! Then, we had some drinks, an appetizer, and then our food came. All of it was great, and all the servers and bartenders are wonderful! We definitely recommend the Firecracker Shrimp and Calamari for appetizers, and the whole belly clams and teriyaki tuna for main courses! Everything was fresh and delicious! We are looking forward to our next trip to Ogunquit, and Pepper’s will definitely be on our dining list!“

“Amazing food and very friendly service!! This is a must stop at spot for breakfast! We will be back.“

“The service to our large group was excellent. Our servers, Luigi andUlises were so good and entertaining. Can’t wait to go back“

“Really cute spot! It’s right next to the pool. I needed someone to chill and loved how low key this place was. Their menu has all of the classics for both food and drink. The bartender was super friendly as well. I’d definitely come back! I was super confused about how to get in, though. I walked and kept thinking I was lost. I found it, though!“

“Food came out quickly. Waitress was efficient. The nachos were really good and the Key Lime Pie dessert martini was delicious. Bathrooms needed cleaning, both men and women's were kind of gross. Women's was super sticky floors and I saw a few bugs on the floor in both bathroom and main dining area.“

“Very convenient lunch spot and I appreciated the healthy-ish options, which can be hard to find in Ogunquit. I also appreciated how the salads and sandwiches were customizable. The lemonades are good too and they have some interesting flavor options. The lemonades are quite sweet but that seems obvious for lemonade“

“Excellent food and entertainment rolled into one! Highly recommend!!“

“A step back in time. Great people and service.“

“Good food, excellent service and amazing views, highly recommend!“

“We went here for a late dinner and we were curious to check out the piano bar upstairs. Overall, the ambiance was cool but we were not able to sit upstairs so we ate on the first floor. The appetizers were good (Buffalo cauliflower and french onion dip with homemade chips). The entrees were not anything to write home about - they was fine but looked a lot different in the photos online than it did in person, and for the prices I do not think the quality/value aligned. The fries were not very good, and the lobster roll was okay. The bolognese was also okay but the pasta was super overcooked, which I should’ve known would happen since this isn’t an Italian restaurant. The burger or fried chicken sandwich would’ve probably been a safer choice here.“

“The server was very friendly“

“The breakfast was very good and plentiful;. New owner has a great personality abd is being innovative in the menu !“

“OMG the waitress was incredible! We had a beer flight and she was out of one beer so she gave us a pumpkin spice with sugar and cinnamon on the rim, it was delicious. I had the Maine sampler (lobster roll, clam chowder, fries and blueberry cobbler)and hubby had the fish and chips. Both were delicious and we enjoyed the view of the boats docked while we ate. The waitress never forgot us, she checked to see if we needed anything and told us about local must sees. Well worth the trip.“

“We had a great experience here. The parking can be a little tricky as it is limited. Its metered or you can valet. The metered parking requied a 2hr minimum if i remeber correctly at $9/hr. We went between the lunch and dinner hours on a Sunday so we got lucky and found a metered spot. I didnt know this at the time but this is the original home of Shipyard Brewery, so we got to sample a bunch of local beers. The wife and sister inlaw did flights, and my brother and I did pints. For the food the adults tried the clam chowder, the reuben sandwich and the crab and havatri sandwich. Our 9 year old son sampled the chicken tenders from the kids menu and his brave twin sister tried her first lobster roll (Maine staple right?). We were very pleased with all our selections. My daughter even ate all the lobster, but only took a few bits of the roll, but it was a hit. We sat outside on the deck and enjoyed the harbor activity. Would certainly recommend this place and would go back again.“