44 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mahtomedi

“Our family loves Carbone's Mahtomedi. The staff are awesome, Pizza and Hoagies are sensational. We have never had a miss communication, all of orders (over many years) have been right on. We Thank You for being wonderful community members with great service. The Vadnais Family“

“The Kinda Big Dill Pizza lives up to the hype and the sodas are so good! Fast and friendly service. Came for the state fair special and definitely going to return!!“

“Diana and the team at Ronnally's were incredible! They fueled the Woodbury Boys Soccer Team for their 2023 playoff run with unbelievable family style food (garlic toast, caesar salad and pastas) and service! Thank you Ronnally's Team! ⚽️⚽️⚽️“

“Our first time there on Wednesday night. Service was excellent, Kendra was fantastic. The deviled eggs with shrimp was awesome The six of us all had something different from the scallops to the walleye to the salmon all fantastic. There was also dessert like bread pudding to banana cream pie, also fantastic. Can’t wait till our next dinning experience. It will be real soon!“

“Delicious, fresh, hand made pizza. We love patronizing this local establishment. We'll definitely be back!“

“Good was amazing! Fast friendly service and super fresh! Highly recommend!“

“Excellent pizza and cheesesteak sandwiches! Kids loved it as well! Food was ready quickly and staff was very friendly. My faves are the Spicy Tono, South Philly and Truffle Fries. Everything was delicious!“

“The BEST pizza in the White Bear Lake area. Staff was friendly and professional, both on the phone and when I stopped in to pick up the pizza. And the Pizza? It was FABULOUS! Really, really good. In a world where customer service and excellence are fading fast, this Company really knows how to do it! I give them my highest possible recommendation.“

“Went in for take out during dinner rush. Busy, but the staff was on top of everything. Clean, quick as they could be for the amount of business they were doing. Staff was attentive and coordinated.I got the taco pizza and I was kind of amazed at the heft of it. 10", but built with enough toppings for a 14". Great crust, good mix of ingredients, very difficult to stop eating.“

“After years of looking around the twin cities for my favorite slice... I'm happy to say this is the best pizza I've ever had. I come here at least twice a week for lunch now. They take their slice game seriously. 10/10 If you haven't been here you are missing out!“

“Our waitress was awesome and the food was great!“

“My family and I were throughly impressed with the food and service at Devil's Advocate. I would highly recommend the duck bacon wontons. Absolutely delicious! The pizza was excellent quality as well! A shout out to Gavin and Aaron for their impeccable service! We can't thank you enough for providing a wonderful experience! The vibe and ambiance was fantastic as well! They played great background music. It had a warm and inviting atmosphere that provided for a great time!!“

“We have been going to Carbone's for 35+ years. We went to our son's home in Anoka Friday evening and he asked us to bring a Family Special for supper! It was Great As usual!Dietary restrictions: We get the Gluten free Pizza for our oldest son.“

“I just ate here for lunch amazing pizza ? do not pass this spot up thinking it’s another pizza shop it’s not. Real Authentic people and pizza don’t miss the chance to taste how simple pizza can be, top 3 pizza places in this state if you ask me!“

“We had a party of 16 at short notice who needed to be accommodated and we were very well attended to. Little Oven Staff knocked it out of the park! Thank you all!“

“Decided to finally try this place. I was not disappointed! The artichoke dip is cheesy and creamy. The burger is full of flavor in every bite. My ma loved the fried walleye and chips. The staff was very attentive and friendly. They didn't rush us and was very knowledgeable and accommodating. We will definitely be back!“

“Today is my day off. Stopped in and accidentally ordered the wrong piece of pizza. I called in telling them they made the mistake but apparently I made a mistake and they still gave me what I wanted which was a vegetable topped pizza. Great service great people! I’m so glad I live right across from their establishment. Because it’s my one treat myself on a day off as a business owner! I am a customer for life.“

“Can’t say enough good things about the food here!! Randy goes out of his way to help his customers and I have definitely benefited from that! Constantly working on new and exciting things for the GF community and we are so thankful for it!! Dying to try the deep dish that’s in development! Please Bring a Randy’s to the south metro!!“

“Good pizza!! Almost felt like i was back at home and in NYC. As a person from the gritty streets of the bronx i can definitely vouch for them. This has been the closest thing to a nyc slice i've had in a while here in MN. I must say that this place is a pain in the a$$ to get to. I walked literally 20 mins trying to find the place..i would give 4 stars but the pizza was too good. And they're quick with it, got my slices hot and ready in like 3 mins or less. They are located in a dining area i forgot the name. I guess if you find parking closer to that, youll be straight.“

“Jimmy GT is the goat of all axe throwing instructors. He made us feel so welcome and provided such fun energy during our time at burrow. Give this mans a raise!!!!Leah also kept us hydrated and made us the most delicious cocktails. I’ve gotta say she might be the most creative and entertaining bartender I’ve ever had! We were lucky to have her service “

“It's been a long time since I've had pizza this good. I highly recommend the Eastside Pizza.“

“It's rare to find a family dine-in Pizzeria these days. Especially rustic and historic places like this. The food is really good and they serve these fresh fried potatoes with sour cream that is pretty unique the broasted chicken I hear is really good but I usually get the pizza. The pizza is really cheesy and the crust is really good. That's a great informal atmosphere so you don't have to worry about dressing up so if your blue collar or have 10 Rowdy kids you'll fit right in. Support your local pizzeria come here and pig out.Parking: There are plenty of spots so don't worryKid-friendliness: Bring all the kids if you're a teacher bring your class this place can fit about 50 kids and they would have the best time because this pizza is delicious and they don't mind kids“

“I placed my order when I was across the street at Lund's & Byerly's. I went in and did my grocery shopping then went across the street and food was ready. They must have upped their game because both were super good! The salad tasted great and had lots of flavor and I loved the dressing. I think I ordered the Tuscano for the pizza with the Mount Vesuvius tomato upgrade.The combo of the sausage, red peppers and those tomatoes couldn't have been better. My only confusion was they have a sign that says Check In. I think it should say Pick Up. But otherwise everything was great and nice people. This might be my Sunday go to from now on.Parking: Usually spots out front.“

“Service was quick! Worker at the register quickly took my order and my pizza was out no more than 7 minutes! Pizza was delicious too, hot and fresh out the oven. Prices were reasonable. 8 inch personal pizza for only $7. This place is underrated.“

“I know there are some skeptical Savoy old school snobs on EVERY Savoy location saying it's not the same as the original. I AGREE the ambiance, prices, production, things change. It's hard to replicate an original anything. I worked the original, and managed a Savoy years ago. I'm a snob to I get it. The one on White Bear Ave was the closest, until today. Had some East Coast friends in town, 1 lived here 20 years ago, wanted Savoy, told her it's still great but none are like the old days....I was dead wrong. We ordered a large special and it was like I was back in 1995 again. Yes I will HAPPILY pay $30 for a pizza that fantastic. Absolutely exceeded expectations. Keith not only made me tge best Savoy I've had in 20 years, hes very personable and knowledgeable about the whole Savoy tradition and history. Thanks Keith! 10 stars.“

“Just got some Pizza for lunch for my office. It was absolutely delicious! The staff was very friendly when I went to pick up the pizza. I’ve never seen such a clean pizza place. I will definitely be going back and I highly recommend this place!“

“Excellent food, service and atmosphere.Laelle our server was prompt, efficient and friendly. She was taking care of several tables, doing a top notch job. We had walleye sliders, fried perfectly topped with a slaw. Poutine was super cheesy goodness. The wild rice soup soooo good. The cheeseburger flat bread was spot on. Definitely worth a stop.Kid-friendliness: The kids loved eating out on the patio“

“Pizza was fulfilling the garlic bread was ?????Variety of Beverages "cold"Service was great!??✌️Nice size place plenty of room for a pizza party and the windows are nice to see outside view! (Clean)Chairs are comfortable and they have to-go boxesAlong with crushed peppers, parmesan cheese, napkins and toothpicks???Parking: Alot of space to parkFront, back or sideKid-friendliness: Yes kid friendly!Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of room for wheelchairs“

“Just had a bunch of pizzas donated to my job. It’s been about 8 years since I’ve had Savoys. It’s the best pizza I’ve had in a long time!!!“

“Low key, laid back, relaxed atmosphere. Staff is friendly, though there are few staff. We have gone there numerous times. Pretty good food. This was our 1st time not ordering a pizza. Salad was good. Meatball sandwich was not bad but not great. We enjoy coming here. Older crowd with fun music, meat raffle and Bingo nights.Kid-friendliness: Not a place for children.“

“My husband and I came to Stillwater for our anniversary. We luckily found this little dive bar while we were looking for something fun to do. All the restaurants and bars down town didn't really suit us and were packed. They have pool and darts and big screen tvs to watch the games. The bartender was awesome and kept our glasses full despite the fact he had to cover the whole bar by himself. 100% will be going back next time we are in town.“

“The Only Pizza I Eat 3 or 4 times a week I order from“

“super amazing staff love it here“

“First time here. The food was good. A little more fajita taste to the chicken would make it pop. (Chicken fajita), vegetables were amazing. Fresh and flavorful. Only one server. She did an awesome! Give her a raise. Definitely will come again.Parking: Plenty of spots. It's a little dark in the parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Kids had a blast.“

“Fantasy cheesy pizza! Best I’ve had in a long while! Delivery was fast and very courteous. Will definitely order again. Yummy!!!“

“Placed an order over the phone for takeout, went to pick it up and they didn't have any order for me. They verified that I called the right location, no one knows who took my order. But that being said, the kitchen staff got a new order in, I don't think I had to wait even 5 minutes longer than I expected.“

“This Pizza Man has been a staple of mine for as long as I can remember. My Grandparents would order from here when I was such a small child. It's so nice that this place is still open. Nothing else has survived in this strip, but I hope Pizza Man holds out forever. The pizza is so good, the ingredients are very fresh, it's quality you can see and taste. I will say they are a bit more expensive. I know the price of everything is on the rise, but this place has always been on the higher end. But as with most things, you get what you pay for!“

“Amazing product and customer service.“

“Just moved to the neighborhood three weeks ago. We tried Rocco’s and Eastside and was extremely disappointed. So grateful there’s a Carbone’s!!! Omg this pizza is phenomenal no matter which place it is. We love to support local businesses but as far as pizza is concerned, we only be going to Carbone’s. My goodness this is dang good pizza!“

“"Whenever I visit Pizza Man, I'm consistently impressed by the exceptional quality and variety they offer, setting them apart from other locations in the Pizza Man franchise. The owner's hands-on approach and commitment to maintaining high standards truly make a difference. It's evident in every slice that great care and attention to detail are priorities here. Highly recommend for anyone seeking a top-notch pizza experience!"“

“A friend recommended Pezzo for a ladies night out. My first time there. Food, service and servers were great and it was a very busy Home Coming night. I recommend it highly. I’m very thankful for the extra service I got when I needed it.“

“Came for bingo. Food was good. Waitress did as good a job as she could there should have been more help for all the extra people. There were way too many people packed in with all the extra tables set up. I would come again but not during bingo.Wheelchair accessibility: It is ground level with wide enough door. But don't come during busy time you'll have a hard time maneuvering though.“

“*edit: the owner apologized and refunded for the issues. Changed testing to 4 stars for customer serviceOriginal post:Most of the time the food I get from here is pretty good, this last time, I guess the store doesn't even know what they sell. Got Honey Chipotle Boneless wings - with no sauce on them or even on the side, the cheese sticks didn't even get cut, and it looked like someone removed some of the cinnamon pull-aparts before they glazed them. I won't be ordering from here again.“

“Dominos in Willernie is great! Always great service, and we love ordering them at home and at Frigaard’s Bar!“