50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mahtomedi

“We love QC Pizza - Their Big Dill pizza is one of our favorites!“

“The pizza was good. I'm not a fan of thin crust pizza, but this was about the only pizza option near the AIRBNB my family stayed at in Mahtomedi. The website is not as detailed as it could be. But the pizza itself was good. Had an abundance of toppings and stayed hot during the short drive back to the housing rental.“

“We just had the most amazing cheesesteaks! If you want the real east coast south Philly cheesesteak....you must go here!“

“We had a party of 16 at short notice who needed to be accommodated and we were very well attended to. Little Oven Staff knocked it out of the park! Thank you all!“

“Probably my favorite pizza in the cities right now, love their lunch special. Owner is a great guy, always very appreciative.“

“Nice of you to help Josh feed the homeless mission very honorable ❤️“

“Delicious, fresh, hand made pizza. We love patronizing this local establishment. We'll definitely be back!“

“Excellent pizza and cheesesteak sandwiches! Kids loved it as well! Food was ready quickly and staff was very friendly. My faves are the Spicy Tono, South Philly and Truffle Fries. Everything was delicious!“

“Great People and Amazing Pizza...Highly Recommended“

“Great pizza that my whole family loves served by some awesome staff! Thank you!“

“It's been a long time since I've had pizza this good. I highly recommend the Eastside Pizza.“

“I just ate here for lunch amazing pizza ? do not pass this spot up thinking it’s another pizza shop it’s not. Real Authentic people and pizza don’t miss the chance to taste how simple pizza can be, top 3 pizza places in this state if you ask me!“

“We brought my dad to Ronnally’s for his 91st birthday today, and we couldn’t have been happier with the entire experience! The service and food were amazing! We had lasagna, pizza, and mac and cheese, and every single dish was delicious. The owner, Diana, made us feel so welcomed throughout the entire visit, and both she and her whole staff made my dad’s birthday one of his best. 🤗 We will absolutely be going back the next time we’re in Woodbury!“

“I almost order a pizza from Dominos (med pan 3 toppings) total for delivery was $30.75 before tip. Got a lunch and appetizer delivered. $27.00 with tip. AND THIS WIIL TASTES GOOD instead of cardboard with tomato soup on it.“

“The staff is superb. They are friendly, professional and make a warm and inviting atmosphere. The food is fantastic and my young kids always enjoy looking for the cats.“

“Best gluten free pizza!!!!!“

“Bring it to Jacksonville, FL ❤️“

“Good family vibes. Love the updated interior“

“super amazing staff love it here“

“Community staple even if ypu don't agree. Macaluso family has run this place for many up's and down's including inside the family and its still there as the beer flows and the food is good! Will be intereating to see if the next generation can keep it going when they come of age?“

“I love the culture!! Fun stuff always going on as well as opportunities for smaller businesses!!“

“Our first time there on Wednesday night. Service was excellent, Kendra was fantastic. The deviled eggs with shrimp was awesome The six of us all had something different from the scallops to the walleye to the salmon all fantastic. There was also dessert like bread pudding to banana cream pie, also fantastic. Can’t wait till our next dinning experience. It will be real soon!“

“August 29, 2026
Ordered another Gourmet Vegetarian and this one was even better than the first. Outstanding pizza being made at this location .

The pizza was loaded with toppings. Very hearty meal. I customized a vegetarian and it was made as I wanted. Tasted great.“

“Great experience at Duke’s! The staff was friendly, helpful, and made everything easy from start to finish. The service was quick, the atmosphere was welcoming, and everything was handled professionally. You can tell they care about their customers and take pride in what they do. I’d definitely recommend Duke’s to anyone looking for a reliable and positive experience. 5 stars!“

“SUPERB PIZZA EVERY TIME!! Enjoy some amazing pizz, hoagies and the drinks from a crazy fountain drink machine that has just about everything well except beer and wine. 😆 Only place i found FANTA 🍒 CHERRY Go check it out“

“The House Special with geen olives“

“The best“

“This is a take and bake pizza place. They have plenty of options available. Including $10.99 any large pizza on the menu plus a create your own with up to 5 toppings on Tuesdays. They have salads and dessert options.

Dietary restrictions: They have non Dairy, keto,and gluten-free options.“

“5 Star!!! The dill pickle pizza was AMAZING! The perfect combination of dill pickle flavor, light creamy sauce, and delicious melted cheese. Every bite was packed with flavor! The Owner was so kind and went above and beyond to make sure we had the best experience! We will definitely be going back and supporting this great new restaurant.“

“My new favorite Pickle Pizza, add Canadian Bacon, you won't regret it!“

“Great place. Great tap beer selection and the food is outstanding!“

“A friend recommended Pezzo for a ladies night out. My first time there. Food, service and servers were great and it was a very busy Home Coming night. I recommend it highly. I’m very thankful for the extra service I got when I needed it.“

“The wings are great! Went for a event and the server was not happy I went to the bar. Helpers were rude about areas you could walk in because they were busy. My husband was also given a lecture because he had a gift he was given in a pizza box that was not their's. Hopefully this is not the norm and folks just were having a bad day because those wings are worth going back for.“

“Best pizza around!!! Savory sauce, and the crust is great!!! Great service and the delivery people are soooo nice!!!!!!“

“My mom and I stopped in for lunch. I ordered the lunch ribs. They were some of the biggest ribs I have ever had. Lots of meat and so good! The sides had alot of flavor and everything was fresh. My toddler even approved! I would definitely go back!“

“I've picked up a few orders from the restaurant lately and dined in last night. It is always great to see the staff genuinely having a great time at work while treating others like they're part of the family lakes again and we love it and will come back!“

“Thank you for fantastic service on a large last minute order...and correcting it when I messed up! I appreciate you! Definitely will order again. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“I've never had as good a aclzone anywhere as Sarpino's makes, at least the ones at the Oakdale, MN location. They are such a great blend of flavors and seasonings; the ingredients are always fresh and the crust is buttery and crispy, not overwhelmingly bready. The crust compliments rather than buries the abundant fillings. And they're ginormous - I get minimum of two meals out of one. And they're delivered hot and almost always within or sooner than the estimated delivery time (which is free- no need for Door Dash). Can't say enough good things about this Sarpinos! I never thought I liked calzones til I tried one of theirs.“

“My 4 year old had so much fun in the arcade!“

“Surprised there is never a line here for ice cream!! It’s a much better deal than cup and cone around the block and better ice cream! Kids size is $3.75 and HUGE, definitely can split with 2 people! Staff are friendly!
Atmosphere is lacking but kinda a hole in the wall vibe.“

“good pizza, ok customer service. Delivery was bad they didn't keep the pizza flat and the toppings run off the side again.“

“Ordered pizza for my sons 3rd birthday. Arrived early and they were very nice, everything we needed was given to me. Pizza was great. Ordered a Caesar salad and it came with olive and tomatoes. I’m not complaining because I like both but just curious if this is the norm. Never have been given a Caesar salad with tomatoes and black olives. Over all would def order from them again. Staff was wonderful. Food was equally wonderful.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We stopped here recently, and when we found out that the deli opened, just had to order lunch. I mean they have a really cool menu with fried chicken, pizza and gyros of course. Trying the gyro burger really hit the spot, especially with everything that goes on a regular gyro, but with a lettuce and tomato added to give it that burger kick. So worth going back to again sometime soon.“

“This is the best Pizza Hut in the area. Carry out is always on time and they always make our pizza the way we ordered it and better. We only go to this location for pizza. Usually do carry out but when we have dined in the experience is just as good.“

“The bar tender, Donna May (sp?) is an incredible wealth of information about what to do around town and all aspects of the Stillwater community. We learned more in 15 minutes of talking with her than any brochure or travel blog. It’s cash only but they have an atm. Highly recommend!“

“Fantasy cheesy pizza! Best I’ve had in a long while! Delivery was fast and very courteous. Will definitely order again. Yummy!!!“

“good people good food highly recommend“

“We enjoy Papa Muphy's pizza. They have great crust, and a good amount of ingredients. Nothing like a fresh baked pizza right out of your own oven! I order ahead, and pick it up on my way home from work. :-) We order extra so we have leftovers we can heat up in the air frier.“

“Dominos in Willernie is great! Always great service, and we love ordering them at home and at Frigaard’s Bar!“