50 Best American Restaurants in Rochester

“We hosted a brunch in their private space, planned from out of town. Wonderful communication throughout the process. Venue was great, food was wonderful, service was very accommodating. Guests were very happy.“

“The best onion rings ever!“

“The seafood perlou is amazing! Service was top notch!“

“Incredible experience at the chefs counter. Attentive service, warm hospitality + thoughtful food.“

“This place is AMAZING. First off the food and service are incredible. But what keeps my family going again and again is the fact that they are SO sweet about medical stuff (being right by Mayo that is HUGE). I can recall several examples of the staff being supportive towards my mom who has been living with end stage cancer for years now. We go EVERY appointment and surgery scheduled in Rochester. In fact - we are going tonight!“

“Fast thinking with taking call in orders from your car ( the number was on their big sign) in the parking lot along with the drive through.“

“The food is freshly made, right in front of you. It’s the best Philly cheesesteak I’ve ever had (Philly Ranch)! The fresh cut fries are never cold or soggy. One of my orders was made online while I was in the PICU with my son. Of course, he woke up when I attempted to lay him down to go across the street to get it when I got the text it was done, so I wasn’t going to be able to pick it up in a timely manner. I called and let them know I was still going to come get my food but it wasn’t going to be right away. They told me just to call when I would be coming and they would make me a whole new meal! 🖤“

“I rarely write reveiws BUT this CULVERS DESERVE A HUGE 5 STARS. YES FISH,COFFEE,CUSTARD WAS INCREDIABLE BUT THE REAL CHERRY ON THE ICING WAS THE AMAZING SERVICE. BEV your smile, going the extra mile in SERVICE MADE OUR DAY!!! THANKYOU SO SO MUCH.“

“great ambiance, excellent service, impressive menu, delicious food“

“Very good lunch. I had the Ahi shareable and French onion soup. Both were very good. There was so much cheese on the soup it was almost hard to eat.

My daughter had grilled cheese and tomato soup. She said that was good also.

Our server was great, I wish I would have his name.

There were 2 groups of parents and kids in there. The kids and the parents sat at separate tables so as you can image no supervision and extremely loud and annoying. Not the restaurants fault at all.

Pricey for lunch, $80 with tip for 2 people. No alcohol either.“

“The Castle is so cool!! I grew up hearing stories about different events taking place here decades ago and it was SO fun being there photographing a wedding!! The staff was super helpful and accommodating. Exploring broadway and nearby streets lead to heaps of photographic ideas! The Castle is an awesome venue!“

“Top notch bar. I consider this the home bar because if I want to watch a game and it's not playing one of the servers, bartenders or anyone else working they will put it on for anyone that asks.

Wheelchair accessibility: Standard size tables near the dart boards“

“Very clean & great service.“

“Our plans for a late dinner and beers fell apart. One of our group called and asked if Newt's (South) could accommodate a group of our size that late on a Tuesday. We arrived to a waiting table with waters & popcorn. Our server, Layne, was quick taking our drink and food orders. The food was amazing, hot, and fast. Thank you for saving our "afters" tonight. We will be back!“

“Very good food, friendly, large portions. Definitely will be going back!

Parking: There is parking in the front and a parking lot to the side. Pretty easy just not sure which spots are for this business.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“I eat lunch here at least weekly and always have the same thing, salmon without seasoning, mashed potatoes and broccoli with a glass of water. Both waitresses (Sam and Tracy) know me as soon as I walk in and get my order started. The manager
(Tom) is always lending a helping hand and has a smile on his face. Love this crew!“

“I loved the brisket hash. The waitress took the time to ask the cook about ingredients to accommodate my food allergies. She remembered my special requests. and they have gluten free toast. Highly reccomend!“

“Food was good, prices are mostly reasonable, service is good, and old fashioned salad bar was excellent. Do not order anything well done as they tend to overcook anyway. My only concern was being seated after walk-ins with an on time reservation.“

“Had such a great dinner here!. Fun trying new foods and great beer. Staff was outstanding.“

“Great local cafe to grab some food with your friends or family. When inside you feel like you are in a small town restaurant and the waitresses know most of the usual customers who are in there. The food is very good and prices are great. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area.“

“1st time in and had a great experience!!! Sky took amazing care of us at the bar, giving tons of great recommendations of what not to miss out on!!! Fun atmosphere, great food and amazing service we would definitely recommend checking it out if you’re in the area!“

“This is the only restaurant that I have worked at that I will ALWAYS come back to. For the atmosphere, live music, the incredible staff (no, not favoring because I worked here, totally different staff), the food is consistent and the drinks- chefs kiss (Ryan is FANTASTIC)! Something about coming here is like coming home, it's very cozy and intimate! A best kept secret of Rochester for sure! I must add that the staff are seemingly genuine and you can tell they enjoy their jobs- not like other restaurants where you get a fake nice.“

“Amazing service with tasty food! Everyone is so nice and welcoming and they have a large menu of all great food! I genuinely recommend eating here!“

“Excellent service. First time trying and they asked questions and made suggestions to be sure I got the best sandwich. Next visit I plan to try the Wings!“

“We got there at 11:00am and Mary was the hostess...she was so wonderful in a very stressful time...they were packed and she got us seated quick...my wife uses a walker !!! Great experience !“

“The patio could be the location for Lord of the Flies! I enjoyed the Onion Rings appetizer and Fish & Fries. The food was good but I had to cover the food with napkins because there were so many flies. I asked a server to turn up the ceiling fans to blow them away and was told that was the highest speed available. I guess that was the easiest answer because the fan was barely moving. They can do much better.“

“Was there Saturday night to catch up with friends from out of state. Our server Katelyn (sorry if I spelt the name wrong) was absolutely fantastic!! She has the best personality & was always checking in to make sure we were all taken care of! Will definitely be back again soon! Also, the drinks and wings were great!!“

“1st time eating there tonight. Very helpful, very friendly, food was amazing! Definitely going back! Steak chicken rice number 12 i think.“

“Great food today but service was lacking a bit ! She never offered a refill she seemed to keep disappearing for long periods. But other waiter was spot on waiting on his customers.“

“I stopped in here after googling places to eat. I have never been to Rochester, I didn’t know what was good and I wanted simple. After looking thru menus online, I found Brothers and saw they had reubens. I found a place to sit and was immediately met by my server. He was a nice kid and was helpful and courteous. I ordered the Reuben and also a bowl of soup. It wasn’t but 10 minutes later and I had my food. The only little complaint is I was served my soup with my sandwich. I would’ve preferred to have it first. But whatever, it’s not a big deal. My dishes were cleared by another gal because my server was working a big table. Which was nice of her, I thought. And it took a minute to get my check but not a big deal. Everything was very reasonably priced and it was delicious. I’d highly recommend this place to everyone.“

“I would highly recommend this restaurant.The food was great.Nicely priced clean restaurant n people were very friendly.Ya gotta try this place its 💯great place to eat .Ya gotta try it“

“Really good food with kind and friendly service“

“adorable decor, clean and great waitress. Food was great and price was fair.“

“Amazing service with tasty food! Everyone is so nice and welcoming and they have a large menu of all great food! I genuinely recommend eating here!“

“We had such a great time for my son's birthday. The staff were amazing.“

“The Mess hall Grill and Tavern is a great place to eat, drink and have some fun!! From bingo to horse racing. Bands Friday nights and Karaoke Saturday nights!! Fun times to be had by all! Great friendly staff !“

“Food was wonderful and the staff was great. Thank you very much!“

“I would highly recommend this restaurant.The food was great.Nicely priced clean restaurant n people were very friendly.Ya gotta try this place its 💯great place to eat .Ya gotta try it“

“Very tasty food selection and very nice people“

“Our lunch was delicious. We each had a cheeseburger and fries with a jalapeño bacon wonton appetizer. We placed our order outside the restaurant and went in and sat down. We had the place pretty much to ourselves. Lots of TVs. Okay music. We could watch our meal being prepared on a flat top in the kitchen. Everything came out quite quickly. The wonton appetizers were nice and crisp with a maple syrup and like a Freddy's frie sauce with them. ??The cheeseburgers were cooked to order (medium) and were nice and greasy as they should be fried on a flat top. The fries were good, too. It was a Monday at 1 pm. We would go there again.“

“Love Rooster’s ❤️!! Both locations!! Their staff is friendly, knowledgeable and happy to be there! Family orientated during the day and main meal times. Then later at around 9/10pm the music is turned up, ppl are dancing, playing pool, darts, gambling, drinks are flowing ppl are just having a great time! They have a fun crew and they work together to provide the best, more efficient customer service as possible!! Stop in!! They are open every night until 1am 🙂“

“We are staying at St. Mary's and I ordered the Hot Ham and cheese deluxe and kiddos cheeseburger with a side of two shakes!!! let me tell the food was simply amazing nice big portions and the shakes were just the right consistency and so tasty!!!! We did use door dash for the delivery!! A++++“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

We’re loving our partnership with Tap House West End! This isn’t just your average spot—think chic vibes, expertly crafted cocktails, and elevated bar bites that taste as good as they look. Every delivery is a little touch of sophistication, and it’s a pleasure to bring their carefully curated menu to our customers.

The team behind Tap House West End is as classy and professional as their space, making every order seamless and enjoyable. If you’re looking amazing vibes delivered right to your door - call us and we got you. We are so honored to be partner with this amazing crew!

—The Waiter Express Team✨“

“Nestled inside the Hy-Vee Market, this very friendly and accomodating grill offers breakfast, lunch and dinner along with a selection of beverages. After a couple of visits, you feel like a regular when they greet you by name. Always a wonderful place for an awesome breakfast!“

“Food was wonderful and everone was so friendly!Shout out to all the wait staff who talked to me more than my date did! 😊“

“Great service and atmosphere. The candied bacon Lucy was quite possibly the best burger I’ve ever had. Please add it to your permanent menu!! The rest of my family agrees!“

“The food is good, the service has been great, and the price is good.“

“The food is good, the service has been great, and the price is good.“

“This is the best Bdubs in Rochester! The food is always great and the trivia is fun! I just won a month of free wings yesterday from it! Oh! If you ever see a cool guy with long dyed hair named Dusty, make sure to ask to be sat at his table. He will always make you feel special, and he loves to chat. He's the main reason we keep coming!!“

“Food is amazing with great presentation! Will definitely return here.“